ipl-logo

To Kill A Mockingbird Compare And Contrast Essay

865 Words4 Pages

The Book is Always Better An immersive story, appealing characters, significant themes. Some may say Harper Lee’s To Kill a Mockingbird is a life-changing story. But does the film have the same effect? The story is about two siblings, Jem and Scout Finch, who live in a quiet county known as Maycomb county during the 1930’s. The two siblings encounter many issues in Maycomb and dig into the secrets and problems of the town. The novel is written by Harper Lee and the film adaptation is directed by Robert Mulligan. In the Film To Kill a Mockingbird, many plots, characters, story changers, and themes were not in the film
Miss Maudie’s house burning down is a major look into Miss Maudie’s personality and also a big part in the story overall. …show more content…

Dubose, Aunt Alexandra was not in the film at all. Aunt Alexandra is the sister of Atticus Finch who believes he is not raising his children properly. Aunt Alexandra moves in with Jem, Scout, Calpurnia, and Atticus around chapter thirteen and stays with them from then on. Aunt Alexandra is very important when it comes to Scout’s lady life. Calpurnia is still seen as the mother figure for Jem and Scout in the story, she still teaches Scout and helps her become more proper. ‘ “Stay with us Jean Louise” ‘She said. This was a part of her campaign to teach me to be a lady” Yes, Calpurnia does teach Scout to be more kind but Aunt Alexandra helped so much for the short period of time she was there. On top of that, Atticus and Aunt Alexandra have disputes whether to let go of Calpurnia or not. Aunt Alexandra wanted her fired because she moved in but Atticus disagreed. Also, while Aunt Alexandra is living in the Finch Household she reminds Jem and Scout to think like their father, Atticus. Strangely enough , Aunt Alexandra was not a character in the film. Aunt Alexandra could have changed Scout’s personality in the story and she could have changed the daily life in the Finch household. Many people question what the filmmakers were thinking when forgetting such an impactful character like Aunt Alexandra. It is hard to overlook Aunt Alexandra and her contribution to the

Show More
Related

Differences Between To Kill A Mockingbird Book And Movie

474 Words | 2 Pages

Finally, Aunt Alexandra wasn't into the movie. It would have been important for her to be in the movie. This is because she was a women role model for Scout and if she was there it would have shown that Scout still didn't like girly clothes.

Read More

To Kill A Mockingbird Calpurnia Quotes

1128 Words | 5 Pages

Aunt Alexandra on the other hand, is not a good mother figure. First of all she does not get along with Atticus’s side of the Finch’s. This is supported when Aunt Alexandra is very rude and blunt with Scout and Jem, who are still little children. She also likes to tell Atticus that he is parenting wrong, and tries to get Scout to change the way she acts. The second reason I do not think that Aunt Alexandra would be a good mother figure is that she does not let the family be themselves.

Read More

King Treville Dialectical Journal

652 Words | 3 Pages

Porthos wasn 't sure how he was meant to feel. He thought that once he knew his father 's identity he 'd be at peace. But as he rode away from the Marquis de Belgard 's estate, Porthos felt as if he would never rest. There was a part of him that wished he had never found out about Belgard. And another part of him couldn 't help but wish de Foix was his father, as he had first thought.

Read More

To Kill A Mockingbird Calpurnia Quotes

2105 Words | 9 Pages

Some readers may debate that Scout's Aunt Alexandra’s influences has a stronger effect on her, but those people might not take into account all of the negative effects she had on Scouts mentality. " Aunt Alexandra was fanatical on the subject of my attire. I could not possibly hope to be a lady if I wore breeches; when I said I could do nothing in a dress, she said I wasn't supposed to be doing things that required pants. Aunt Alexandra's vision of my deportment involved playing with small stoves, tea sets, and wearing the Add-A-Pearl necklace she gave me when I was born; furthermore, I should be a ray of sunshine in my father's lonely life" (Lee 81). Aunt Alexandra constantly wanted Scout to be something she was not simply to fit into the typical southern woman mold.

Read More

Dialectical Journal For To Kill A Mockingbird

811 Words | 4 Pages

(Lee 134)” Calpurnia is a great mother figure, in my opinion Aunt Alexandra is only a good mother figure. She came to live with the Finch’s to help Atticus for when Scout starts growing into a woman. Aunt Alexandra says, “ We decided that it would be best for you to have some feminine influence. (Lee 170)”

Read More

The Importance Of Atticus In Harper Lee's To Kill A Mockingbird

916 Words | 4 Pages

Aunt Alexandra is a conservative woman who is conscious of propriety and class. So she wanted Jem and Scout to live in a certain way especially Scout, She was worried Scout was too much of a tomboy. Aunt Alexandra was also concerned that Atticus was too careless in his parenting. He allowed his kids to do whatever they wanted. She was also concerned that Calpurnia had too much say and authority over the lives of the children with the absence of their mother.

Read More

Theme Of Labelling In To Kill A Mockingbird

940 Words | 4 Pages

Unable to satisfy this center in her lower mindset, Aunt Alexandra accepts Scout for who she is and achieves a higher or growth mindset. By giving Scout the same overalls that Aunt Alexandra has once hated, Aunt Alexandra displays that she is satisfied with Scout and is not constantly trying to change her into a person who she is not. After Atticus tells the family about Tom Robinson’s death, “Aunt Alexandra [sits] down in Calpurnia’s chair and [puts] her hands to her face” (ch.24; 236). Instead of creating a separation between

Read More

How Did Aunt Alexandra Change The Story Of To Kill A Mockingbird

1038 Words | 5 Pages

Even though Aunt Alexandra plays a major role in this plot, she was actually removed completely from the movie all together. There were conflicts between Atticus and Aunt Alexandra, which provided many examples of themes in the story. She showed more prejudice toward the people, which was not included in the movie. Also, Calpurnia took on a move of a female model toward Jem and Scout in the movie, since Aunt Alexandra was non-existent. Although Aunt Alexandra was vital in the novel, Calpurnia was the prominent one in raising and teaching both Jem and

Read More

How Does Scout Change In To Kill A Mockingbird

589 Words | 3 Pages

Their Aunt Alexandra moves in, and she plays a big role in Scouts gender. Aunt Alexandra is an example of a perfect southern woman, and we see this by the way she is dressed when she comes to the Finch house, on page 128, wearing “protective garments that pinched her waist, and suggest that Aunt Alexandra was once an hourglass figure.” An important role of a southern lady is to maintain the families reputation, which she does by telling Scout that she must act more mature and more like a lady. The image of the perfect southern woman goes against what Scout sees herself as, making things hard for

Read More

To Kill A Mockingbird: Comparing Literature And Film

692 Words | 3 Pages

In the movie they didn’t add Aunt Alexandra thus, making Scout less of a lady. Aunt Alexandra brought drama and some tension in the book. Along with Aunt Alexandra, you forgot Francis and Uncle Jack. Uncle Jack was a funny character that would have played a good part in the movie with Christmas gift of airsoft guns, and yelling to Miss Maudie. Francis would have made an annoying character that would be made fun of, and that nobody would like, but would have some purpose.

Read More

To Kill A Mockingbird Comparison Essay

806 Words | 4 Pages

No more than two years after the book, To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee was published, the movie version was released. Sparking much controversy, people argued whether the book communicated the storyline the best or whether the movie summed everything up, although it is apparent that the novel is better. This is because the characters, setting, and plot are drawn out in an easy-to-understand yet exquisite tale, rather than the movie, which skipped over plot, storyline, and was overall confusing. The characters develop the story.

Read More

What Is Aunt Alexandra's Transformation In To Kill A Mockingbird

1577 Words | 7 Pages

In the book To Kill a Mockingbird, by Harper Lee, you can see the character of Aunt Alexandra developing throughout the whole of the book from being presented as cold and harsh to more caring and showing how she has a softer feel. It may not be evident at first, but as you read and look closely at her character's actions you may just understand how evident these changes may be. In this essay, we will discuss this along with how her character compares and interacts with Scout and Jem along with how they react to her doing these things and how it affects them, from when she's first introduced to the end of the story when she's last mentioned. When you first meet her character, it’s at Finch’s Landing for Christmas (which takes place in chapter

Read More

Compare And Contrast Essay On To Kill A Mockingbird

463 Words | 2 Pages

The movie To Kill A Mockingbird directed by Robert Mulligan, is a great movie based off the book To Kill A Mockingbird written by Harper Lee. The movie portrays the story of Scout Finch and her family in the 1930’s while Scouts father (Atticus Finch) is defending a negro (Tom Robinson) in a court case. This story takes in Maycomb, Alabama during a very racist time. The beginning of the story starts with Atticus being asked to represent Tom in court for his accusations of rape against Mayella Ewell. Throughout the story Scout and her brother Jim cause all kinds right of mischief but become very interested in their father's court case.

Read More

Individuality In To Kill A Mockingbird

670 Words | 3 Pages

Aunt Alexandra because of her idea that everybody is supposed to be a precise way she is trying to fit Scout into the role of a lady. This role Aunt Alexandra is seeking to fit Scout into is the role that she fits into and the other women in Maycomb fit into. When she does this she loses her individuality and becomes part of the bigger mindset that is Maycomb. Aunt Alexandra is focused on Scout throughout the book. Scout was thinking about Francis at this time.

Read More

Examples Of Feminism In To Kill A Mockingbird

1829 Words | 8 Pages

Aunt Alexandra comes into the Finch household to work with Calpurnia, the black housekeeper, “...and is persuaded that Atticus and Calpurnia are raising Scout to be unladylike” (Shaffer). Aunt Alexandra and her brother Atticus were raised to adhere to traditional Southern gender expectations. Following their childhood, Atticus began living a more progressive life defending a black man and allowing his daughter, Scout, to be a tomboy. When Aunt Alexandra joins the family, she uses the opportunity to try to teach

Read More

More about To Kill A Mockingbird Compare And Contrast Essay

Related Topics

Open Document