ipl-logo

To What Extent Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero

549 Words3 Pages

Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero?

Andrew Carnegie was seen as an influential leader, but was he a hero? Andrew Carnegie was born on November 1835 in Dunfermline, Scotland in the attic of his family's cottage. The three characteristics of a hero are courage, integrity, and concern for others. Andrew Carnegie was a hero in these three areas of his life: wealth, community, and his ambitious state of mind.

The first area in which Andrew Carnegie was he started as a blue collar worker and worked his way up the ‘workforce ladder’. When Andrew was just twelve years old he started working at a textile mill 12 hours a day for only $1.20 a week just so his family could eat and have shelter. Once he was sixteen Andrew was famous for being able to decode dot-dot dash-dash messages (morse code) and was paid $4.00 a week. In 1872 Andrew met Henry Bessemer, the creator of the steel mill, Andrew decided to adopt Bessemer's idea and bring the steel mill to the United States. This would be Called the J. Edgar Thomson Works (Pre-DBQ). This evidence helps explain why Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he had the courage to work hard to get to where he was at the nearing end of his life. …show more content…

Andrew Carnegie's company Carnegie Steel Company spread across Pittsburgh Pennsylvania to transport goods from city to city (Doc 5). In 1900 Andrew Carnegie made the large amount of $23,000,000, therefore, his daily wage would be about $92,000 (Doc 7). This evidence helps explain why Andrew Carnegie was a hero because when he started the steel mill he gained integrity and trust among the American

Show More
Related
823 Words | 4 Pages

He also built up many cities out of steel; but Andrew Carnegie was more of a Robber Baron. Carnegie horribly mistreated his workers by giving them very long days and very low pay. Carnegie steel was a very rich company but Carnegie couldn’t even give his workers and average pay. Also, Carnegie was a not brave at all, while his company was not going well, instead of working to make it better, he camped out in Scotland and let his chairman Henry Frick do all the work. All in all, Carnegie was more a Robber Baron more than a Captain of

Read More
742 Words | 3 Pages

He was hired to manage the railroad up to a supervisor to the age of 24 making $8.00 a week, and he made $1,500 a year. Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man for a lot of different reasons. He was making more than an average 24 year old. What made Carnegie wealthy was in his steel industry. Carnegie was selling his steel in his own company.

Read More
654 Words | 3 Pages

That made him one of the richest men. But what did he do with all the money he was making? The real question is, was Carnegie a hero? A hero is someone who does outstanding achievements. There were three reasons Andrew Carnegie was a hero he always gave back, he didn't just leave his money with his family, and brought beauty to a castle in Scotland.

Read More
610 Words | 3 Pages

Andrew Carnegie isn’t a hero because he only does things for money to in the end make a name for himself. Andrew Carnegie was a selfish man. He didn’t like competetition and he didn’t like losing or giving money away unless it benefitted him. Carnegie allegedly grew up poor and by the age of 12 went to work to help out his family. Carnegie worked 12 hours a day and got payed $1.20 a week, later he taught himself morse code and got payed $4 a week ( because he got promoted to telegraph operator.)

Read More
572 Words | 3 Pages

Was Andrew Carnegie a hero? Did he’s new ideas, business and donations made him a hero? At that time most of the biggest and most profitable business were controlled by 3 important gentlemen, one of them was Andrew Carnegie who controlled the steel production in all America, being the steel production his monopoly, but also, he was one if not the biggest philanthropist in that time. So, does these matter for be a hero? Was him a hero?

Read More
418 Words | 2 Pages

He then started his first job, having his career take off he earned more than $100,000 in the middle of his life. Was Carnegie a hero or a villain? Andrew was a hero in business and philanthropy, but not with labor in many eyes. Carnegie was an American hero in the eyes of people who did not face the challenges of his labor. Workers at Andrew’s industry earned no more than $1.90 while he received over one-hundred thousand dollars.(Doc 7)

Read More
838 Words | 4 Pages

“No Man of business drew more attention that the king of steel, Andrew Carnegie” (Background Essay). Andrew Carnegie grew up in Dunfermline, Scotland and immigrated along with his family to the United States in the 1800s. He worked his way up from being a poor immigrant to working with people such as Rockefellers and JP Morgan. He became one the most famous industrialist who led the expansion of the steel industry.

Read More
415 Words | 2 Pages

Many philanthropists around the world are viewed as heroes, so why should Andrew Carnegia be viewed any differently? Andrew Carnegie was a poor boy from Scotland, until his parents moved thier family to America. He is the prime example of a rags to riches story for this time period. Eventually, Carnegie became the leader of the steel industry in America. His most heroic attribute had to have been the funds he put into philanthropy, and continues to put into charities.

Read More
467 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion, Andrew Carnegie should be deemed as a hero. Sure, he did some things that people frowned upon. But, he also accomplished things that made his communities education better and stronger, but he made his community all around better. To do this, he did things such as provide local libraries for people and students, He claimed that it was disgraceful to die a rich man and give money away to your children, also his total giving overall was 350,695,653 dollars. Carnegie should be seen as a hero because of his good deeds, and providing of libraries to better the community’s education.

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

Carnegie was noticed at the age of seventeen, he began work for the Pennsylvania Railroad co. throughout the seven years of working for the railroad he became the supervisor of the western division. Working in the railroad industry taught Carnegie multiple tactics for business which he would later use in the steel industry. This evidence helps explain why andrew carnegie was not a hero,but he was intelligent and a hardworking man. But being a hard worker does not make him a hero because every hard worker would be a hero

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was a hero in some people 's eyes , not so much in others . That’s why everyone has their own opinion. In this essay you will read one reason someone might think he’s a hero , and two reasons why he is not a hero for the rest of the people. What that means is that this paper mostly leans on that Andrew Carnegie is not a hero and you will read why . Andrew Carnegie was a very wealthy man.

Read More
338 Words | 2 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was one of the most famous and wealthiest American industrialist during the Industrial Age. He was a robber baron who made a fortune in the steel industry and applied vertical integration to his business. Carnegie contradicted his views as a robber baron because he supported, but destroyed many unions. This made many of his views unethical.

Read More
676 Words | 3 Pages

A "hero" is considered to be courageous and to have noble qualities and achievements, but over time, the "hero" definition changes to be something else. The view of a "hero" now has become one of wealth. Andrew Carnegie was a man of wealth and was a hero during the second Industrial Revolution, as well as a well-known great philanthropist. Due to his achievements in helping people, many have considered him to be a hero, while others view him as only benefiting himself. Andrew Carnegie was born in Scotland, where his family was not the wealthiest and had difficulty maintaining a standard of living.

Read More
602 Words | 3 Pages

Andrew Carnegie was a hero because he was selfless. In the “Carnegie’s philanthropy chart” it states “The Carnegie corporation… is currently giving out about $100,000,000 a year, most of it to education.” I can make this claim because I know that Carnegie corporation gives a large amount of money to help the community and promote education. This shows us that instead of keeping his money to himself he was kind and generous enough to give it away, to help others. Overall Carnegie showed he was selfless and became a

Read More
454 Words | 2 Pages

Carnegie was not a hero, because a hero does a deed selflessly, but he thought a lot about himself. 184,400,000 dollars was spent on big-name corporations and associations that would honor him by naming a meaningful belonging after him (Doc C). Carnegie was a man who wanted to feed his ego but should have donated money to help the community, not make himself known.     Andrew Carnegie was not a true hero. Many may say, going from rags to riches makes Carnegie a hero.

Read More

More about To What Extent Was Andrew Carnegie A Hero

Related Topics

Open Document