ipl-logo

Trudeau's Constitution Document Analysis

560 Words3 Pages

In 1982, Canada had almost gained its long awaited goal of complete independence from Britain. However, the British still had control over their most important document; the Constitution. By 1982, Trudeau believed that he had achieved enough goals as Prime Minister in order to convince the British to sign over the Constitution to Canada. This would be an extremely controversial and beneficial agreement for Canada, as they would have the power to govern themselves completely without being ordered by other parties. However, many Canadian leaders tried and failed in the past to patriate the Constitution, and trying to do so would be a huge political risk. Despite the strong benefits that would come from patriating the Constitution, 8 out of the …show more content…

First of all, the federal government was now able to deal with language and other rights issues more effectively. Since Canada now had control over the constitution, the federal government was now able to ease tensions created by French and English relations. Moreover, the Charter of Rights and Freedoms was entrenched in the Constitution. This meant that it was firmly established in Canadian law, and that it would be extremely hard for it to be removed or changed in any significant way. Likewise, the rights of Aboriginals were entrenched in the Constitution. This would mark the first time that this occurred, and would also ease previous tensions that flared up between the federal government and the Aboriginals. In addition, women were not entrenched in the Constitution. This meant that they were not guaranteed the rights and freedoms included in the Charter, enraging women across Canada. Finally, had its historical veto power removed by the other premiers of Canada. As a result of this, Quebec was now not able to change the outcome of federal issues alone. However, many Quebecers saw it as a betrayal, and this sparked new separatist movements that were previously non-existent. Thus, the Constitution that Canada fought so hard to patriate for had a variety of drastically important

Show More
Related

Max Farrand The Constitution And The Pros Of The Confederation Summary

934 Words | 4 Pages

In his article “The Federal Constitution and the Defects of The Confederation”, Max Farrand delves back into the 1700s in order to examine the creation of the Constitution and even moreso the reasons behind its inception. The Constitutional Convention was a very interesting event that has always had some historical mystery and even some common ignorance around what happened at the convention. As a way to inform the people reading this articles of the intentions of the convention, Farrand formulates his thesis around this idea of how and why the Constitution was made. On the first page of his article, he states, “That the Constitution was framed because of the defects in the Articles of Confederation is universally accepted, but it does not

Read More

Pontiacs War: A Document Analysis

1810 Words | 8 Pages

When the Pontiacs war came to an end, the British found that they had to do much more in order to fulfill the needs of the French Canadians. As had been mentioned earlier, there are those Canadians who had close relations with the French at the time that the latter had seceded and left the land in the jurisdiction of the British. In order to satisfy this population, the British came up with the Quebec act of 1774. This document contained among other things, the parts of the French civil law that would remain place. Additionally, the document allowed for the extension of Quebec’s boundaries, which would now extend to the south of the Ohio River.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Canadian Confederation

1397 Words | 6 Pages

the British North America Act, 1867 (BNA Act), that legally created the Dominion of Canada was, in effect, Canada’s fifth constitution. The three constitutions immediately preceding the BNA Act established essential elements of liberal democracy, but the BNA Act was the first in which the novel and creative elements were designed by the colonists themselves, not their imperial masters (Russel, p. 115). The previous four constitutions of Canada was designed by Britain they had some influence towards it but the British North America Act 1867 (BNA Act) Was designed by the Canadians so it brought about like a feeling of independence to Canadians and it was the first steps to complete

Read More

How Did The Treaty Of New France Change The Land Of Canada

997 Words | 4 Pages

Many years ago, French and British explorers found land that they claimed and fought for, through time they turned this land into Canada. This country began named New France, ruled by the French people, then as British North America, ruled by the British people. The French and the British had frequently fought over power, but this is what ended up shaping the provinces and territories in Canada. Events that impacted Canada were the Treaty of Utrecht in 1713 , then the Treaty of Paris in 1763, the Forming of Upper Canada in 1791, and the Act of the Union in 1849, when a responsible government was formed and Canada became one. The land of Canada began with an unsteady system, and ended with responsible government, having a democracy and giving

Read More

Canada's Road Was Evolutionary Not Revolutionary

685 Words | 3 Pages

“Canada’s road was evolutionary, not revolutionary.” To what extent do you agree with this question? The road to Canada’s independence was evolutionary due to changes and factors such as the formation of the new country, the new leading government and it was mostly made of negotiations to find what will best fit the new country. After the English took over New France, at that time called Lower Canada.

Read More

Effects Of Post Ww1 On Canada

1085 Words | 5 Pages

Women were able to have their voice heard and have the power to choose the fate of their country through voting. They were also able to divorce for the same reasons as men with no judgement. This was a result of passing the Federal Divorce Law in 1925. In addition to political power, women also gained access to new job opportunities. This changed the social environment of Canada and also made women more respected.

Read More

How Was The Act Of Union A Positive Step Towards Peace For Canada

3614 Words | 15 Pages

Timothy Chua Candidate Number: Word Count: 3,076  Abstract: To what extent was the Act of Union a positive step towards peace for Canada? The essay introduces a very fresh British North America outlining some causes of the mass immigrants coming in, mentioning Loyalists, and Pioneers arriving from Europe.

Read More

Rise Of Nationalism In Quebec During The 1980s

987 Words | 4 Pages

For example, when the Parti Québécois leader René Lévesque proposed a sovereignty-association with Canada, which would enable Quebec to have political independence however they would have close economic ties with Canada in 1980, a separation seemed possible (Archibald, 2016). The referendum for a consensus on the sovereignty-association, held in May of 1980, resulted in a 60 percent rejection and thus the sovereignty-association between Quebec and Canada was not carried out (Hudon, 2013). Although the sovereignty-association referendum had ultimately failed, the Parti Québécois were re-elected in 1981, indicating that separatism itself had not yet died in the province and thus, the threat of Quebec’s independence was still very present (Stein, 2006). Quebec also isolated themselves from Canada when they had disagreed with the patriated and new Constitution in 1981, as their government felt that they were still not equal in comparison to the other provinces (Gall, 2006). All things considered, Quebec’s possible freedom from Canada became a real possibility in the 1980s and the threat of separatism was a key factor in the change of Quebec

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Canadian Charter

1212 Words | 5 Pages

The Charter is the center to which all Canadian rights circle around. It is what allows Canadians to freely express themselves. The Charter protects the rights and freedoms of every single individual in Canada. However, the Charter is especially large and covers many topics and so it tends to conflict itself. Seen in the case of speaking rights where, freely speaking about a topic can to lead to hate speech which can be a criminal offence.

Read More

Controversy: The Great Flag Debate Of 1964

1118 Words | 5 Pages

The language and regional conflicts within Canada, gave the flag dispute added weight. It grew more general concerns about cultural rights, particularly those involving Quebec and the rest of the nation. In addition, the Canadian Parliament developed into a highly heated political topic. The Progressive Conservative Party, led by John Diefenbaker, passionately opposed the change of a new flag, while the Liberal Party, led by Prime Minister Lester B. Pearson, strongly supported it. Political parties became divided as a result of the argument, which resulted in a big political disagreement that affected the general public's opinion of the government and caused them to side with the party they favored.

Read More

Pierre Trudeau Federalism

1515 Words | 7 Pages

Institutional and historical analysis often portray the motives of governments, especially in the cases of Quebec separatism and Aboriginal mistreatment. History describes attempts at compromise to rectify the problems by altering political institutions to provide more autonomy to the provinces, witness in various accords and the methods described previously. However, in regards to Aboriginals a historical relationship of exploitation and eradication sheds on the systemic issues that Aboriginals cope with and the institutions that caused them. As scholars of Canadian politics, it is important to consider historical and institutional analyses when looking at any issue, as it reveals the underlying motives of actors in regards to the cleavages that comprise a state.

Read More

Comparing The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

623 Words | 3 Pages

A constitution is unique to each country as it states the fundamental principles according to which a country or state is governed and considers most important. Most constitutions include principles of the state, fundamental rights of each individual that cannot be denied and the methodology of the government. The Canadian constitution was finalized in 1982 ending the BNA act and the Egyptian constitution of 2014 was modified from the constitution of 1971. Canada’s constitution prioritizes individual rights and freedoms and is evident in the 12 headings. The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms is integrated into Canada’s constitution and outlines the rights and freedoms regarding the individual.

Read More

Canadian Senate Reform

1844 Words | 8 Pages

A constitutional amendment is a very tricky task to accomplish and is not something most Prime Ministers wish to take on. Not only that, but the political parties in Canada have different views on what reform is best for the country, few of them are favored by seven provinces. While under the leadership of conservative Prime Minister Harper his government attempted to submit two Senate reform proposals to Parliament without getting constitutional amendments. His first proposal never became law due to being refused by the then liberal dominated Senate while his second proposal Bill C-7, the Senate Reform Act, was also refused due to needing a constitutional amendment to implement it. (The Canadian Encyclopedia, Senate)

Read More

The Benefits Of The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

1219 Words | 5 Pages

Before the Charter, many people may argue that Canada was a free and democratic country. Canadians had the freedom of expression, equality and the principles of fundamental justice. What changed with the creation of the Charter was that rights and freedoms were given constitutional status, and judges were given the power to strike down laws that infringed on them. In 1982, most Canadians agreed that the introduction of the Charter was going to monumental. But on the contrary, over 30 years later, numerous laws have been struck down by interpretation of the charter and remedial techniques that have been developed by courts.

Read More

Waltz's Theory Of Neorealism

1036 Words | 5 Pages

Why do many neorealists liken states in the international system to firms in a capitalist market?  How valid is that analogy? Neorealism has emerged as a contemporary theory that attempts to explain the interaction of states on an international level. Oftentimes neorealists compare states in the international system and firms in a capitalist market. There are a number of factors that can be described as similarities or differences between the two and for the sake of brevity, only a few will be discussed below.

Read More

More about Trudeau's Constitution Document Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document