ipl-logo

Under A Cruel Star Sparknotes

1945 Words8 Pages

Following the Holocaust and aftermath of world war II, Heda Kovaly’s Under a Cruel Star provides one woman’s view on communism in Czechoslovakia. In this memoir, the author develops the theme of popular support for communism by explaining the people's thoughts during that time and her own experiences with her husband’s support for communism. She uses the lens of the Czech people, herself, and her husband, Rudolf Margolius, to develop her theme for popular support for communism. Her use of these viewpoints helps explain how the party was able to take over Czechoslovakia after the Holocaust through their persuasive ideals. Kovaly’s memoir has been useful in contributing to our discussions but also has its limits and advantages as a primary source …show more content…

While we often blame the support of communists, especially high-level communists such as Rudolf Margolius, for the violence that is enacted by the Czech communist party, Kovaly explains that they are also just pawns in the Soviet system. She tells us her husband’s reaction to the arrests where he explains his strong support of communism: “I cannot give up my conviction that my ideal is essentially sound and good, just as I cannot explain why it has failed- as it apparently has…If you’re right, if it really is a fraud, then I’ve been an accomplice in a terrible crime. And if I had to believe that, I could not go on living”. This statement shows us how desperate Rudolf really was, as his communist party was showing its true colors as corrupt and unstable. In lectures, we often heard the terrors pushed by the communists, such as totalitarianism, which is the use of political terror to control every aspect of people’s lives and linked nazism and Soviet communism together. Kovaly’s memoir challenges this view by humanizing the communists, especially Rudolf, since we often simply think about the destruction that communists did. Kovaly uses her memoir to portray how her husband stood strong in his beliefs and to challenge our discussion on how all communists were violent and corrupt, causing us to reevaluate our discussions about the theme of popular support for …show more content…

The author uses the points of view of the Czech people, herself, and her husband, Rudolf Margolius, to develop her theme for popular support for communism. Her memoir showcases the horrors of both the Holocaust and communism and contributes to our discussion about popular support for communism. As a primary source, it has both its limits and advantages, especially since it just focuses on one country and one woman’s view. Some of its limits include bias, emotions, and inaccurate information that can take away from the themes of the book and are important to keep in mind. However, there are also some advantages to using a primary source as it can provide foreshadowing and the emotions of the author can emphasize the important events of the book. Overall, while reading any primary source can have some advantages and drawbacks, this memoir contributes to our discussions and helps challenge and enrich our views on the popular support for communism in

Show More
Related
143 Words | 1 Pages

Eli Wiesel's ‘‘Night‘‘ and Martin Niemöller's ‘‘First Came for the Communists‘‘ share common themes of the danger of silence and the importance of standing up against injustice. He describes the horrors he experienced and endured, including the loss of his family, the dehumanization and atrocities of the concentration camps. Throughout his story, Wiesel emphasizes the importance of standing witness and opposing the atrocities he and others have endured.

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

In analysis of Vera Figner’s Memoirs of a Revolutionist, Figner expressed a few political goals that led her to assume violence as the only answer to the economic, political, and social injustices forced upon the peasants, by the government authority and Russian traditions. All of Figner’s energy was spent in effort to achieve these goals at any cost. These goals were to use influential propaganda, to educate the peasants1, and to kill the Tsar. All of which, were used to motivate a peasant uprising, to remove2 the suppressive Tsarist regime and to give birth to democratically3 free institutions4. To justify her violent means, she used her personal belief that there were no other peaceful ways, that they had not tried, to provide liberty and justice for the peasants.5

Read More
619 Words | 3 Pages

Post WWl, Russia was still not industrialized, suffering economically and politically and in no doubt in need of a leader after Lenin’s death. “His successor, Joseph Stalin, a ruthless dictator, seized power and turned Russia into a totalitarian state where the government controls all aspects of private and public life.” Stalin showed these traits by using methods of enforcement, state control of individuals and state control of society. The journey of Stalin begins now.

Read More
1167 Words | 5 Pages

Being thrust into ghetto life as a teenager, Sierakowiak joined the underground resistance movement at a young age like many other Łódź Jews (“Sierakowiak Diary Extract”). He had chronicled his daily experiences in a diary, from political schemes to personal matters: all was covered there (“Sierakowiak Diary Extract”). “The city, abandoned by its institutions and by the police, awaits the imminent arrival of the German army in terror” (Sierakowiak). In this diary, he was free to write about the extremities and wrongdoings of the Nazis with no censorship, being able to show the actual violence committed (“Spiritual Resistance during the Holocaust”). “Some Jews were ordered to stop working, to remove their clothes and stand facing the wall, at which point they were told they'd be shot” (Sierakowiak).

Read More
669 Words | 3 Pages

Two compelling novels going back to the dreadful past during World War II Holocaust, including the death camps with millions prisoners, The Devil's Arithmetic, by compassionate Jane Yolen, and aggressive Peter Fischl’s poem,”The Little Polish Boy Standing With His Arms Up, are analyzed progressively. Both writings have a similar purpose and meaning. Both of the outstanding writings inform about history repeating.

Read More
643 Words | 3 Pages

The author says that perhaps many citizens may be drawn to Communist ideology if the social injustices become more prevalent, and urges the readers to look into the problems of Communist civilizations. This article is an example of how many felt during the Red Scare and Cold War in regards to communism. It shows that people felt a collapse

Read More
1386 Words | 6 Pages

“Under A Cruel Star” despite being an excellent book to read was not credible or believable as compared to Kevin McDermott’s scholarly article. Heda Kovaly depicts popular opinion under Communist dictatorship as being controlled by terror of the government. She states that popular opinion no longer comprised morals or humanity, but instead was uttered by fear and doubts of the consequences of their actions and the domination of the government. This significance of life can be explored and tested against details found in secondary sources. “Under A Cruel Star”, a primary source, provides personal experiences through the political difficulties of Jews while secondary source in Kevin McDermott’s article provides accurate facts of events that

Read More
2191 Words | 9 Pages

The Holocaust is a vicious memory that survivors hold each and everyday. From the tattoos on their arms, to the memories that haunt them, living as a prisoner of the Holocaust was no easy feat. Both books, Night written by Elie Wiesel and Survival in Auschwitz by Primo Levi are memoirs written to show their readers the brutal experience and hardships they had to endure as prisoners of the Holocaust. In this paper, I will use Night by Elie Wiesel and Survival in Auschwitz by Primo Levi to compare and contrast the similarities and differences they both experienced while in concentration camps. The first event I will compare and contrast will be the event in which they are first exposed to Nazi’s and concentrations camps.

Read More
763 Words | 4 Pages

Three people, close friends, inseparable, are gathered together. One wakes up the next morning to find the other two dead. This is Europe’s Jewish population during the Holocaust, an obstacle of the highest order. The Holocaust may seem like it’s in the distant past, but a brief look at Europe’s Jewish population before and after the event makes it abundantly clear that it still matters today. Every day people overcome obstacles, but every Jew, Slav, Romano, homosexual, and disabled person in those ghettos and camps who survived overcame the obstacle to end all obstacles.

Read More
1775 Words | 8 Pages

Let this essay be a reminder to the world that totalitarian ideologies will bring forth catastrophe just as National Socialism did in Nazi Germany. The memoirs of Rudolf Hoss, Death Dealer, is one of the most detailed accounts of a man who was the Commandant of Auschwitz, and is known as one of the greatest mass murderers in history. In the forward Primo Levi wrote to Death Dealer, he stated that even though this autobiography is filled with evil and has no literary quality, it’s one of the most instructive books ever published because it describes a human life exemplary in its way (Hoss, 3). In this essay, I will argue that Primo Levi thought Death Dealer is one of the most instructive books because it seeks to explain how ordinary men

Read More
1530 Words | 7 Pages

Tim Snyder’s “Bloodlands” gives a detailed history of Europe during the reigns of Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin. In “Bloodlands” Snyder’s main point is to describe that although Hitler and Stalin had conflicting goals and viewpoints, their actions directly affected one another and resulted in one of the most horrific time periods in European history. Timothy Snyder is an American author and historian who specializes in the Holocaust and Central and Western Europe. After graduating high school, Snyder received his Bachelor’s degree from Brown University and his Doctorate from Oxford University; Snyder also has held fellowships Paris, Vienna, and Warsaw (Timothy Snyder, 2018).

Read More
1196 Words | 5 Pages

Despite the brave front that Vladek has put in the years following the war, his story remains to be a tale of suffering, agony, and death. The story of Vladek’s survival during the Holocaust is the central aspect of the novel,

Read More
1245 Words | 5 Pages

“The Holocaust is the solution to the Jews final question.” This famously known quote, said by Adolf Hitler, explains the ugly truth behind his so called “well-being”. Dating all the way back to the 1930s, Hitler was first brought to power becoming a dictator and leader of the Nazi party; however, many citizens under his rule did not know that they just set their country up for a major downfall. From 1933 to 1945 society in Germany was “doomed” as many had put it, and full of indifference. Author of Night, witness of the Holocaust, and a human just like anyone else, Elie Wiesel, shared his horrific journey about how he survived through the time of the genocide of Jews.

Read More
2979 Words | 12 Pages

The perceived threat of communist

Read More
1757 Words | 8 Pages

Therefore, despite the horrors of Stalin’s regime, one could argue that the socialist realism paintings could ‘mould the consciousness of the people’ into believing that Stalin was a great and wise leader, a kind and humble man, and the father of all Soviet people, thus reinforcing his cult of personality that tries to portray him in that light. However, while art might have the power to do this, one must not forget about other visual representations of life such as photographs and posters. Their relative power and influence will be discussed later in the

Read More

More about Under A Cruel Star Sparknotes

Related Topics

Open Document