ipl-logo

Uniformitarianism Vs Catastrophism

1121 Words5 Pages

I. Introduction It is a tale as old as time. How old is our Earth and how has it come to be the Earth we see today? The paradigms centered around this debate involve those of uniformitarianism and catastrophism. Uniformitarianism maintains that the Earth and the things in it came to be slowly, over a long period of time; whereas, catastrophism indicates that large-scale catastrophes shaped the Earth. Catastrophism spawned into the belief of one catastrophic event, namely, Noah’s Flood, which is the view on which I will focus. To that end, this paper will explore these two long-held viewpoints.
II. Old-Earth Secular View Uniformitarianism dates back to the 1830 's and is based on the methodology of Charles Lyell 's Principles of …show more content…

Amidst the controversy, the two altering views usually divide people on a religious basis and separate believers from non-believers. Therefore, those with a young-earth view adhere to ideas concerning uniformitarianism such as that held by Henry Morris (n.d), “It is pure assumption that one can only interpret all the data from the unobserved past within a naturalistic, uniformitarian model.” Holding an opposite view, uniformitarianists would customarily never see the Earth as being young. However, as of late, there is “an increasing acceptance today of the role of rare, large-scale events” (Leddra, 2010) for modern uniformitarianism …show more content…

Both uniformitarianism and catastrophism attempt to explain the geological features found on the Earth’s surface and the age of the Earth. For this explanation, both use research of geological theories such as those of sedimentation and continental drift. Much of the commonalities of geological features and the age of the earth rely on the rules of relative dating (Ross, Faulkner, Gollmer, & Whitmore, 2015)(text 153), on which both views agree. Relative dating is based on three principle laws; the law of original horizontality, the law of superposition, and the law of lateral continuity. By agreeing on these three laws, both uniformitarianists and catastrophists use these means to determine geological age and events (Ross et al.,

Show More
Related
441 Words | 2 Pages

The idea of catastrophism or “consecutive creations”, is the theory that changes earth’s crust geological history from sudden violent and unusual events. Catastrophism is the idea that Earth has been affected in the past by sudden, short-lived, violent events, possibly worldwide in space. This view holds that the present is the key to the past, and that all things continue as they were from the beginning of the

Read More
794 Words | 4 Pages

Since the dawn of humankind, historians are trying to piece out the gaps in history and explain how we got here based on the events of the past. Surprisingly, historian David Christian, author of This Fleeting World, summed up the astonishments and confusions of humanity in 113 pages. This short book, about world history, tells us about the prequel of the Universe (first 14 billion years of the earth without humans) to the modern era in history (how we are today). David’s goal is to provide an easy understanding of world history for students. What to expect in this enticing book?

Read More
1258 Words | 6 Pages

The case of the collision of Cajamarca brings forth to light the differences between Old World and New World societies. Our human ancestors from the beginning survive as hunters-gatherers but that change 10,000 years ago as the Holocene period sought to shift into food production. It was a new lifestyle, one that began with the rise of the Natufian culture. In lecture 10, it stated that, “Natufians were foragers who lived by hunting and gathering, but they had settled down and lived in particular locations” (Love, 10). The Natufian culture has been linked to have trade networks, however, cultivation evidence was found in Levant.

Read More
1145 Words | 5 Pages

An ancient Earth supports Darwin's theory while a younger Earth supports the religious version of creation. At the time of Charles Darwin, Bishop Ussher of the 17th century and most people believed the Earth to be 6,000 years old. (http://www.csicop.org/sb/show/darwinism_and_the_age_of_earth/).

Read More
247 Words | 1 Pages

In response to Lynn White’s “The Historical Roots of Our Ecological Crisis” Thomas Sieger Derr provided a response saying that White’s claims against Christianity were not as solid as he thought. Derr tries to disprove White’s statements by explaining how they are wrong. Many things in Derr’s argument are logical and disprove the claim that Christianity is to blame for our ecological crisis. In the end of an excerpt from Derr’s “Religion’s Responsibility for the Ecological Crisis: An Argument Run Amok” he makes the comparison between White’s argument and the inventor of fire to blame for all of the world’s arsonists.

Read More
801 Words | 4 Pages

Totaliarism is a system in which individuals govern without the support of the people tightly control over peoples lives and do not allow any opposing viewpoints. For an example Adolf Hitler and Joseph Stalin were both the leaders of a totalitarian government during world war two. Both had complete and total control over there countries by silence any type of opposing view. Even though both individuals were leaders in Totalitarian government, it was not the purest form of a totalitarian system because both couldn’t entirely remove all the critics for the government. In the Totaltarism system the government would have three features.

Read More
604 Words | 3 Pages

Henry Wadsworth Longfellow is a well known American Poet who wrote “The Jewish Cemetery at Newport”. The poem can be seen as music like, but it stills has a historical background. The cemetery he writes about can be found in Newport, Rhode Island; which is a small seaside town. According to William E. Cain in American Literature “During the Colonial period, Jews, encouraged by the relative religious tolerance afforded to them in Rhode Island, settled in the area of Newport, which is also home to the oldest continually operating synagogue in the United States”(Cain, pg. 718). This makes sense as to why there would be a cemetery specifically for Jews in the town.

Read More
840 Words | 4 Pages

Without outside intervention, there is no tale to tell; in other words, there is only the Nothingness that has always remained a possibility in man’s encounter with the Universe. Unlike the preposterous pulp-fiction worlds of Mars and Venus created by Edgar Rice Burroughs, for example, where an energetic evolutionary force has created an elaborate hierarchy of intelligent beasts and beings, Clarke and Kubrick looked to outside intervention to spur the slow, steady state of terrestrial change. If the

Read More
750 Words | 3 Pages

(Steffen et al., 2011; Lewis and Maslin, 2015). There have even been numerous calls to recognise this influence by renaming the most geological epoch in humans’ honour”

Read More
789 Words | 4 Pages

“The Ground That Opened Its Mouth: The Ground’s Response to Human Violence in Genesis 4”, written by Duke University’s Mari Jorstad, is a scholarly article that covers the idea that the ground and the early humans did indeed have a connection. Furthermore, Dr. Jorstad’s thesis appears to be that the ground is responsive to God’s will, and thus opposes human rebellion and brutality. In other words, the ground reflects God’s will and this often times clashes with humans and their behavior. Dr. Jorstad, in her article, discusses examples that exemplify her point from the Book of Genesis, specifically in relation to Cain, Adam and Noah. To start, Dr. Jorstad establishes that herself, as well as many other scholars, have interpreted the ground as its own being when talking about early Genesis stories.

Read More
991 Words | 4 Pages

Around 4000 BCE, environment conditions finally settled into the pattern we see today (Origin myths, 37). In the Epic of Gilgamesh, Ea, the cleverest of the gods, warned Utnapishtim that the gods would be sending the great flood to wipe out humankind. Utnapishtim then builds a boat to save as many people as he can and every living creature. After seven days, Utnapishtim released a dove and raven to find dry land. The Great Flood story is very similar all around the world, as we can find similar stories in West Asia, South Asia, and China

Read More
1657 Words | 7 Pages

The more realistic lense is what Purdy calls “the ecological view” (8) in which everything is interrelated and works together, whether it be in nature or a part of industrialized society. This is the vision that the Anthropocene is leaning towards because no one in my generation or generations younger than me is being taught to see nature as a right. Returning to Louv’s argument on whether taking a walk in nature is a right or a

Read More
1057 Words | 5 Pages

“What has been distilled from the experience of hundreds of generations should not be dismissed because it cannot be submitted to scientific test” (geosc,

Read More
1027 Words | 5 Pages

Chorley said “Whenever anyone mentions theory to a geomorphologist, he instinctively reaches for his soil auger” (R.J Chorley 1978). Physical geographers are viewed as always being out in the field doing their own research and not sitting

Read More
1432 Words | 6 Pages

The Earth is a beautiful place, there is no doubt about that. Now the future is questionable due to all the manufacturing and oil drilling we’ve done. However, not only those actions are to blame, we have all played our part. Humans have created a new world, the Anthropocene. The Anthropocene is defined as the idea that we have entered a new epoch in Earth’s geological history.

Read More

More about Uniformitarianism Vs Catastrophism

Related Topics

Open Document