ipl-logo

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

738 Words3 Pages

1.The US-Canadian magazine dispute arose due to the strong desire to protect the Canadian culture. Throughout history, Canada showed a strong sense of its identity and how different it is. We can see that in its preservative attitudes towards foreign cultures, especially towards the US culture. Being a bordering country to the US and the fact that the two countries have a lot in common has made the Canadian government has been worrying about the infiltration of some aspects of the US culture through the importation and exportation of goods and products, especially cultural ones such as books, films, TV shows, etc. However, some argue that this dispute and movement of the Canadian government is not completely driven by the protection of the Canadian culture, they contend that it is also a matter of market competitiveness and that what has …show more content…

This has led Canada to make strict decisions such as applying tariffs on such products. Also, according to international trading laws, governments must treat foreign and domestic corporations identically. With that in mind, if a Canadian company would do the same, I mean publishing a split-run in the US that doesn’t contain enough US content, the latter will impose extra taxes against the Canadian magazine. So, the Canadian Government felt that it has the same right to do so.

3.I think Canadian government has already made it clear that domestic magazines play an important role at showing, deepening, and fortifying the Canadian culture in citizens. This is what made the dominance of US and foreign magazines an important issue for Canada that has to be dealt with. Given that 90% of the Canadian population is concentrated in the border region, US borders, the issue is even more serious. This dispute is driven by the fear that US culture may dominate the Canadian one after decades of attempting to keep its

Show More
Related
689 Words | 3 Pages

Charter Case Analysis Censorship: Little Sisters vs. Canada Little Sisters vs. Canada was a case that involved a bookstore in Vancouver that serves to mainly gay and lesbian clients. Little Sisters fought against the unfair, discriminatory treatment from Canada Customs. For years, Canada Customs had repeatedly confiscated books and magazines being shipped to Little Sisters from the United States because they deemed them “obscene”. The items were often seized, detained and then prohibited although they had previously been approved for shipment to either Little Sisters or other bookstores and many “obscene” pieces could be found in the Public Library.

Read More
644 Words | 3 Pages

In short, using key genres and examples from the Canadian film canon, I will argue that Canada does not possess a single 'identity ', but a multitude of radically different ones, each individual filmmaker viewing our country through the cracked lens of

Read More
385 Words | 2 Pages

The myths of the RCMP are strengthen by the Heritage Minutes film and Daniel Francis’s argument. Throughout both the Heritage Minutes films, the RCMP represented and protected the Canadian national identity. In the Sam Steele Heritage Minute film, it shows the RCMP solving the problem with the American with compromise, not violence; Sam Steel also demonstrated subtle approach in protecting Canadian values and national identity from the influence of the American - gambling gear and gun (Sam Steele). In this example, Sam Steele enforced gun and gambling control since Canada national identity is reflected through compromise and is not reflected by the strong use of guns and gambling (American influence and national identity). The RCMP solves all

Read More
1626 Words | 7 Pages

Canada’s economy has undergone continuous changes throughout the years. Many of these developments include newly established acts, economical, and political reforms; the core of what has shaped the country into what it is today. More prominently, since the 1950s, Canada’s identity as a nation is stronger and more defined due to many of these growths. One can clearly see this from the following examples; the welfare state, the St. Lawrence Seaway, and NAFTA.

Read More
766 Words | 4 Pages

Essentially the Canadian Radio-Television and Telecommunication Commission (CRTC), “an independently constituted regulatory agency(armstrong)”, enforced a regulation for broadcasters to devote a big portion of their airtime to canadian programming. There are two main reasons

Read More
222 Words | 1 Pages

The Creative Canada framework is a government policy initiative aimed at promoting the growth of the cultural industries and digital media in Canada. The framework, introduced in 2017, outlines key objectives and strategies to support Canadian artists and creators, increase access to Canadian content, and promote cultural diversity in Canada and around the world. However, the impact of the Creative Canada framework on different groups, For example, film and television, performing arts, media, etc., but here we will focus on Cultural Industries, Digital Media, and Indigenous Peoples. This essay will provide an overview of the Creative Canada framework, including its history, goals, and impact on various stakeholders. We will conduct a literature

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

In the 20th century it was apparent that huge changes occurred in the world. In Canada, there were many ups and downs that contributed to how the present was shaped. Both of the world wars were terrible, but fate had brought these battles to diminish the economically poor times. After the second World War, Canada’s identity was shaping into the one we see today. The war changed Canada in various aspects, such as how Canada was part of a cause to support other countries in need of help, how the economy was advancing, and Canada’s part in peacekeeping missions across the world.

Read More
1074 Words | 5 Pages

Ideological Differences: Exploring the Division Between English and French Canadians in the 20th Century Though Canada’s English and French populations are united under one nation, the two groups have always had contradicting beliefs and viewpoints-creating a sense of division between the two. Numerous instances throughout the 20th century showcase their differences, and how they impacted French English relations as a whole. The inherent ideological differences between English and French Canadians made the 20th century a time of heightened tensions, as evidenced by instances such as; the Conscription Crisis, the Quiet Revolution, and the Meech Lake Accord. Tensions between the two first arose during the Conscription Crisis of 1917.

Read More
424 Words | 2 Pages

Media has an impacting effect on today’s Canadian’s, creating a deceptive view that plays to others self-esteem. Therefore, leading to the question about how the government is going to vow to address these concerns. Current society is highly affected by the media, including the influence of media on children in Canada. Furthermore, children ages 2-11 spend about 30 hours a week watching television (Boyse & Bushman 2010). So basically 4.5 hours of quality television per day.

Read More
514 Words | 3 Pages

The colonial experience and nation building process for Canada is extremely similar to the United States’. Canada and the United States have similar national identities, such as high immigration rates, sharing a British cultural heritage, and aspects of their government. The resemblance between the two countries nation building processes are strong, and only differ in the way of the mindset and mentality of each situation described. From the start, immigration had been a large factor for each country. Both countries allowed and encouraged immigration to their territory.

Read More
801 Words | 4 Pages

To what extent do you think the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture? I think a huge part of the motivation was to protect Canadian culture. A lot of times with these issues, the only way to solve them is with economic related solutions. That doesn’t always mean their motivation was purely economic.

Read More
830 Words | 4 Pages

To what extent do you think the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture? If we should stay to official documentation, we have to conclude that the U.S.-Canadian magazine dispute was motivated by genuine desires to protect Canadian culture. In fact, Canadian Government declared that the magazine industry is “an important touchstone of Canadian National Identity" and indicated it as the only Canadian national press (The LEVIN Institute, n.d., p. 17). Considerations about the diffusion and the popularity of Canadian magazines, or the preferences of Canadian people are inappropriate when the purpose is to preserve tradition and culture. Of course, people have the right to choose what to read,

Read More
1639 Words | 7 Pages

Globalization is a many-faceted process which has benefits and repercussions in many areas. It has led to great developments through exchanges of ideas and technologies and has also caused deep conflicts within and among nations in different ways. While often conflicts arise economically, politically, or in the realm of intellectual rights, these are easier to understand and resolve than the varied and nuanced conflicts that arise between Globalization and Culture. Due to a long history of such conflicts, sometimes groups or governments take it upon themselves to initiate preventative measures in order to reduce the risk of damage or loss of cultural identity. One specific example of this preventative action began almost 100 years ago as Canada started issuing a tax on foreign produced magazines in the

Read More
1033 Words | 5 Pages

The events in American history have also affected Canada from a political perspective, which lead to the Democracy that is present today. Another way the U.S. has affected Canada is from a military perspective because Americans are quick to jump to war and Canada has had to help control them which lead to them being peacekeepers. The United States helped mold the Canadian identity by being both a threat and support to the nation; this will continue into the 21st century but Canada will keep it’s unique identity. A country 's culture can be seen as interchangeable with identity; in Canada there is evidence of American culture everywhere.

Read More
737 Words | 3 Pages

Environment Change: A Rhetorical Analysis on Rush Limbaugh’s “The Environmental Mindset”. In Rush Limbaugh’s “The environmental mindset”, Limbaugh introduces us to a very conservative view on environment change and how we have little to no effect on our climate(Limbaugh). In Rush’s article, he writes in a way to persuade people such as right wing conservatives, upper-middle class caucasian males, and politicians that can reinforce his notions. He solely relies on logos throughout the article, using no other credible sources other than himself with ethos and scarcely appealing to emotions in pathos.

Read More

More about Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document