ipl-logo

Virginia State Board Of Pharmacy V Us Consumer Council Case Study

1014 Words5 Pages

Virginia State Board of Pharmacy v. Virginia Citizens Consumer Council, Inc., 425 U.S. 748 (1976)

Topic: Authority of the United States Supreme Court to question the lawfulness of the Virginia State Board of Pharmacy statute under the First and Fourteenth Amendments.

Relevant Facts: Consumers of prescription drugs brought suit against the Virginia State Board of Pharmacy (Appellant) challenging a Virginia statute that prohibited every licensed pharmacist to advertise prescription drug prices. According to Va. Code Ann. 54-524.35 (1974) statute, a licensed pharmacist in Virginia was guilty of unprofessional conduct if he “publishes, advertises or promotes directly or indirectly, in any manner whatsoever, any amount, price, fee, premium discount, rebate or credit terms…for any drugs which may be dispensed only by prescription.” The Virginia State Citizens Consumer Council (Appellee) claimed that the statute violated the First and Fourteenth Amendments of the Constitution. A Three-Judge panel of the United States District Court ruled that portion …show more content…

Whether the appellees as receivers of information have a constitutional right to obtain commercial facts, including the price of prescription drugs, under the protection of the First Amendment?

2. Whether commercial speech, including the advertisement of prescription drug prices, is wholly outside the protections of the First Amendment because its sole purpose is a commercial transaction?

Brief Answers:

1. Yes. The First Amendment protects all parts of communication: its source and recipients. Therefore, Virginia consumers are entitled to have free access to the flow of commercial information regarding the prescription medicines.

2. No. Although the advertisements of prescription medicines prices have a purely economic purpose, they can also promote valuable information for consumers. As a result, the First Amendment protects this commercial information.

Court’s Reasoning (Mr. Justice Blackmun for 7-1

Show More
Related

Charles Sell Case Summary

209 Words | 1 Pages

The petitioner’s original bond was revoked after evidence that he was intimidating the witness and after the petitioner screamed and shouted racial slurs at the magistrate judge as well as spit on his face. This behavior furthered supported that Charles Sell was suffering from a delusional disorder. The district court concluded that the decision to involuntarily medicate Charles Sell to restore his health and competence is constitutional. The courts also concluded that the drugs administered must not have any negative effects. They also stated that drugs used were medically appropriate for Charles Sell and it gave him the right to due process and protected his fifth and sixth amendment right to a fair trial.

Read More

Summary Of The Controversial Court Case Of Ogden Vs. Gibbons

576 Words | 3 Pages

This court case focused on the Commerce Clause in Article

Read More

Summary: The Case Of Abbott Laboratories V. Portland Retail Druggists 1979

840 Words | 4 Pages

In the case of Abbott Laboratories v. Portland Retail Druggists, the respondent brought an antitrust action against Abbott Laboratories claiming that they had violated the Robinson-Patman Act. The pharmaceutical manufacturers had sold drugs to not-for-profit hospitals at lower prices then to the commercial pharmacies (Showalter, pg 452). The Robinson-Patman Act of 1936, which was an amendment to the Clayton Antitrust Act (Elfand, n.d.), had made it unlawful to discriminate by placing a pricing difference between buyers of similar goods, when “the effect of such discrimination may be substantially to lessen competition” (Abbott Laboratories v. Portland Retail Druggists, 1976). As the petitioners, Abbott Laboratories claimed that the price

Read More

Difference Between First And 14th Amendment

318 Words | 2 Pages

The act established that companies could not use treasury money to support or dissent someone’s political campaign, and the case decided whether are not this law was against the first and fourteenth amendment . The outcome of the case decided that this law was in fact not against the first or fourteenth amendment because companies could not be regarding as people and therefore did not reserve the same kinds of rights and liberties, such as freedom of speech or equal protection under the law . In the case of McConnell v. Federal Election Committee, the BCRA of 2002 was brought into question and whether or not Congress had the right to limit companies spending of money towards political campaigns, even if it was considered to be soft money and

Read More

Stronecrest: A Case Study Of Eating Disorders

98 Words | 1 Pages

The consumer was able to see the doctor and therapist. The consumer did have a psych eval and was prescribe cogentin for the side effect from the shot he was given at BCA Stronecrest. The consumer was not given any other prescription and was advise to continue to take clonazepam as prescribed. The consumer was not very cooperative with his therapist unable to stay focus on the questions and he became angry and irritable. The writer was able to clam him down to finish his treatment and crisis plan.

Read More

Case Study: Keller V. NCAA Football

1297 Words | 6 Pages

Is EA protected under the First Amendment with regards to the anti-SLAPP motion? Decision: The Appellate Court upheld the decision of the District Court, with one dissenting judge, and concluded that EA was in fact not protected under the First Amendment and in turn denied their anti-SLAPP motion. The court found that EA had no defense after failing to meet the requirements of the “transformative use” test, the Rogers test, the “public interest” test, and the public affairs exemption that they claimed to be protected under. The defendant/appellate, EA was responsible for any

Read More

Us Canadian Magazine Dispute Case Study

886 Words | 4 Pages

6. If you were the Canadian government, trying to protect the domestic magazine market, what kind of criteria would you establish to distinguish between a split-run and a domestic magazine? In order to distinguish between a split-run and a domestic magazine, I would treat them as what I will identified as “fair trading law”. The tax imposed on split run magazines would be higher than the local magazines but in a very little amount, as the split-run magazines also contains little part of my country’s contents.

Read More

Morse V. Morse's First Amendment Rights

276 Words | 2 Pages

I. Issue: Morse vs. Frederick, 2002; Frederick, a high school senior, hung a banner saying: “Bong Hits 4 Jesus” at a school supervised activity. Morse, the principal, suspended him for 10 days saying the banner promoted illegal drug use to those attending the school supervised activity. Frederick sued Morse saying his First Amendment rights were violated. Issue: Does the First Amendment allow public school to prohibit students from displaying banners with messages promoting use of illegal drugs at school supervised activities? II.

Read More

Commerce Clause In Supreme Court Cases

1737 Words | 7 Pages

The Commerce Clause refers to Article 1, Section 8, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution, this clause endows Congress with the power to regulate commerce within the states. The application and intention of this clause has created great debate in American Constitutional law since its inception. Supreme Court cases such as Gibbons V. Ogden (1824), Champion V. Ames (1903), Wickard V. Filburn (1942) and The United States V. Morrison (2000) have all dealt with and set legal precedent in regard to the clause. However the implementation of the clause had never had been so widely scrutinized or debated than The United States V. Lopez (1995). The Supreme Court mishandled the decision regarding the implementation of the Commerce Clause in the case

Read More

Utilization Management Case Study

1010 Words | 5 Pages

Many doctors are experiencing difficulty getting insurers to authorize several prescriptions. Overly Restrictive Step Therapy Programs. Often insurers require the patients try a series of alternative treatments that are cheaper before agreeing to pay for the one prescribed by the doctor. Overly Expansive Formulary Exclusions. The article provides the example of CVS, who has doubled its list of treatments excluded from its formulary in the past three years.

Read More

Arguments Against Big Pharma

1087 Words | 5 Pages

However, they should not be allowed to target the consumers themselves on television, only though physicians. This would drastically reduce over prescribing and patients being prescribed drugs they do not need. By banning drug and narcotic advertising, this would infringe the corporation’s rights to free speech. This has been one of the top argument for why legislation should not be passed, as seen in the lawsuit by Arimin against the FDA. This is a very strong argument as it has constitutional backing.

Read More

Arthur Murray And Vokes Case

432 Words | 2 Pages

O’keefe took the time and effort to drive out to the dealer, but legally there had been no binding agreement made. The advertisement was merely an invitation to negotiate, and not a definite statement to agree upon. Price tags, in store windows, and advertisements are often placed to bring in customers. Once the

Read More

POM Wonderful Case Study

811 Words | 4 Pages

The case that I will be talking about today is the case of POM Wonderful LLC vs Coca-Cola Company in which POM Wonderful felt that Coca-Cola was using false advertising to promote its own drink to sell to customers. POM Wonderful makes its own fruits to be used in their fruit chooses and they sell a drink that is made of 100 percent fruit juices with 85 percent being pomegranate juice and the other 15 percent blueberry juice. Coca-Cola also make a juice drink through the Minute Maid division of their company with the label saying pomegranate blueberry in giant letters. The Coca-Cola juice is made with only 0.3 percent of pomegranate juice and 0.2 percent of blueberry juice along with 0.1 percent of raspberry juice and 99.4 percent of a combination of apple and grape juices. The focus of the complaint was that the Coca-Cola juice label had the words pomegranate and blueberry in all capital letters and then underneath that the words got smaller and explained that it was a “flavored blend of 5 juices” and that it was made “from concentrate with added ingredients” (Cheeseman).

Read More

Porter's Five Forces In The Pharmacy Industry

1156 Words | 5 Pages

Logistically, creating an independent pharmacy is relatively simple: requirements include only a professional who dispenses prescription drugs, a small store which faces the street, and a license. The scale of Walgreens and CVS that many consumers choose their pharmacy based on positional convenience, however, the existence of these smaller local pharmacies is unlikely to become a competitive threat. Bargaining power of Suppliers (Moderate): Clearly, many prescription

Read More

Essay On American Consumerism

630 Words | 3 Pages

Supreme Court ruled in 1942 that states could regulate commercial speech at will. But in 1976, the Court granted constitutional protection to commercial speech. Corporations have used this new right of speech to proliferate advertising into nearly every nook and cranny of life” (Ruskin, 488). Starting with advertisements to elementary students to high school students about newest foods, drinks, miscellaneous items that they were told they needed. To product placement on children’s television and books, companies spending billions of dollars on children advertisement alone.

Read More

More about Virginia State Board Of Pharmacy V Us Consumer Council Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document