ipl-logo

Washington Vs Glucksberg Case Study

509 Words3 Pages

Brynne DeRosier

Washington v. Glucksberg

The Supreme Court case between the state of Washington and Dr. Harold Glucksberg,

considering the decision to prohibit physician-assisted suicide, took place in 1997. Dr. Harold

Glucksberg and four other physicians decided to challenge the state of Washington 's ban on

physician-assisted suicide. The state of Washington had labeled it a crime to promote suicide

attempts by those who "knowingly cause or aid another person to attempt suicide."

Glucksberg claimed that Washington 's ban was unconstitutional. Following a District Court

ruling in favor of Glucksberg and other petitioners, the Ninth Circuit confirmed and the

Supreme Court granted the state of Washington certiorari.

The Supreme Court Case of …show more content…

Washington chose to enforce the ban as it is

rationally related to a state interest, therefore related to the exercise of its police powers.

In my opinion, Washington 's ban on physician assisted-suicide did not violate the

Fourteenth Amendment 's Due Process Clause. Analyzing the guarantees of the Due Process

Clause, the Court focused on two main aspects: the protection of our nation 's objective

fundamental, historically rooted, rights and liberties; and the cautious definition of what

constitutes a due process liberty interest. The Court held that the right to assisted suicide is

not a fundamental liberty interest protected by the Due Process Clause since its practice has

been, and continues to be, offensive to our national traditions and practices. Moreover,

employing a rationality test, the Court held that Washington 's ban was rationally related to the

state 's legitimate interest in protecting medical ethics, shielding disabled and terminally ill

people from prejudice which might encourage them to end their lives, and, above

Show More
Related

Griswold Vs Connecticut Case Study

212 Words | 1 Pages

Griswold V. Connecticut 381 U.S. 479 (1965) Facts: The two appellants Griswold and Buxton were both arrested and charged under the Connecticut Comstock Act of 1879. They both violated this act by providing information and medical advice to married persons on means of preventing conception. They were both found guilty of aiding clients and were fined 100 dollars each.

Read More

Supreme Court Case Brief: Washington V. Glucksberg

726 Words | 3 Pages

The district court found that the Washington law violated both the Due Process Clause and Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment, and the court of appeals affirmed. The United States Supreme Court granted certiorari. 4. Issue Three terminal ill patients and four doctors brought forth a case challenging Washington State’s position on assisted suicide.

Read More

Case Study: Nestle V. South Carolina

239 Words | 1 Pages

The court granted Nestles request for transfer of the action to the United States District Court for the District of South Carolina. Reason : The court pointed out that the plaintiff resides in South Carolina, her daughters injuries occurred there and her medical treatment was there and continues to be there therefore making South Carolina the appropriate place for the litigation to proceed. A court should not be required to expend resources on cases that have little relationship to the district

Read More

Federalist No. 78 Analysis

671 Words | 3 Pages

Since the establishment of the United States Supreme Court in 1789 the role and function of the court has varied depending on the need of the country. There are several different schools of thought when it comes to the purpose and the function that the Supreme Court should take, ranging from strictly ruling on constitutional matters up to weighing in on national policy cases. To evaluate what role the court actually takes, one must examine both the institutional function as well as the political function. Alexander Hamilton’s Federalist No. 78 has been considered one of the most influential pieces of work in the field, as it lays the ground work of what he believed was the role of the court.

Read More

Tina Carter Case

950 Words | 4 Pages

The Criminal Code forbids helping a person commit suicide. The case of Carter v Canada is important in this aspect because it considers whether the Charter of Rights and Freedoms allows a right to physician-assisted death. The court was required to balance the autonomy and dignity of terminally-ill adults with the need to protect the vulnerable from being induced to commit suicide in a moment of weakness. The British Columbia Supreme Court decided that prohibiting physician-assisted death for adults who are competent, informed and seriously ill violates their section 7 Charter right to “life, liberty, and security of the person” if they have no possibility of

Read More

Mapp Vs Ohio Case Study

1872 Words | 8 Pages

56. Webster v. Reproductive Health Services (1989): The Court upheld Missouri restrictions on abortions that “public employees and public facilities were not to be used in performing or assisting abortions unnecessary to save the mother 's life; encouragement and counseling to have abortions was prohibited; and physicians were to perform viability tests upon women in their twentieth (or more) week of pregnancy.” It was a fractured decision that seemed to contradict Roe v. Wade but the court decided to not revisit any parts of Roe v. Wade after this case. The Missouri restrictions did not violate the right to privacy or the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.

Read More

Attorney General Ashcroft Case Study

495 Words | 2 Pages

In the Baxter v. Montana case, the Plaintiffs ' statement was that the right to assisted death is based on three of the explicit rights in the Montana Constitution; equal protection, personal dignity, and individual privacy. The right to privacy and equal protection are also in the U.S. Constitution, therefore, Mr. Baxter should be able to do as he pleases in the privacy of his own home. The state denying Baxter these natural rights, brings up more issues besides the right to die. More importantly, it was also clear that throughout the case Mr. Baxter was diagnosed with lymphocytic leukemia and was terminally ill. The District Court of the First Judicial District agreed and held that a competent, terminally ill patient has a right to die with dignity and appealed the case.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Fourth Amendment

459 Words | 2 Pages

The Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution provides, the ultimate goal of this provision is to protect people’s right of privacy and freedom from arbitrary governmental intrusions. And being searched. Good Thing

Read More

Vacco Vs Quill

695 Words | 3 Pages

The Equal Protection Clause under the fourteenth amendment of the U.S. constitution states that “No state shall deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws.” This clause is utilized upon arguing for allowing assisted suicide due to the fact that “New York permits a competent person to refuse life sustaining medical treatment, and because the refusal of such treatment is ‘essentially the same thing’ as a physician assisted suicide…” (Vacco v Quill, p. 423). As previously stated, both refusing medical treatment that could keep you from death, or prolong the process, and assisted suicide are being drawn by comparison to make the claim or argument that both cases should be treated equally under the Equal Protection

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Oregon's Death With Dignity Law

1554 Words | 7 Pages

This poll also found that 56 percent of Americans believe that physician assisted suicide is a morally acceptable act regardless of its legality, and only 37 percent believe it is morally wrong. Additionally, 62 percent of adults agree that a person has a moral right to suicide” (Ralph A Capone). Other states including Oregon, that have passed death-with-dignity laws include Vermont, California, Colorado and Washington. There is a death with dignity bill that is slated to go before the Maine Legislature in support of physician assisted suicide.

Read More

Washington State Case Study Essay

567 Words | 3 Pages

To fill the open positions, Washington State in the Pacific North West has been identified as a potential manufacturing location. In making the decision, four major workforce demographic factors were considered. They are, the state’s job market and available labor force, leading business sectors in the state, cost of living, and work-life balance for employees. These factors were considered based on the future needs of the organization as well as the needs of our employees.

Read More

The Death With Dignity Act (DWDA)

1311 Words | 6 Pages

The Death with Dignity Act (DWDA), which allows terminally-ill patients to request physician-assisted suicide, was first introduced in Oregon in 1997. The basic premise of the law is that terminally ill patients, with no outside help, should be able to choose the right to end their life. Since then a few more states have the DWDA or an similar law in their state; an ongoing debate is going on to make the act legal across the nation. The Death with Dignity act allows the individual’s request to die to be acknowledged by the state. Though various of groups and people have spoken against this act, Oregon, with close to two decades of experience with the law, has shown that it can work well even when faced with backlash from the public because

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

852 Words | 4 Pages

Physician assisted suicide should not be considered murder in the United States because it is

Read More

Argumentative Essay: The Death With Dignity Act

1838 Words | 8 Pages

In a close victory, fifty-one percent of the voters voted yes and forty-nine percent opposed the Death with Dignity Act. However, the law was delayed for several years due to an injunction by District Judge Hogan who had ruled that the Oregon Death with Dignity Act violated the U.S. Constitution’s Equal Protection clause (Legal). The ruling was immediately appealed to the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and in 1996 the ban was ruled unconstitutional by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. In two related cases at that time, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that assisted suicide was not a Constitutional right, but also that the issue would be best addressed in the “laboratory of the states” which are free to prohibit or legalize physician assisted dying. In 1997, the Oregon Legislative Assembly put Measure 51 on the ballot in an effort to repeal the Death with Dignity Act.

Read More

Thesis Statement For Physician Assisted Suicide

522 Words | 3 Pages

The Right to Die 1) Introduction a) Thesis statement: Physician assisted suicide offers patients a choice of getting out of their pain and misery, presents a way to help those who are already dead mentally because of how much a disease has taken over them, proves to be a great option in many states its legal in, and puts the family at ease knowing their love one is out of pain. i) The use of physician assisted death is used in many different countries and some states. ii) Many people who chose this option are fighting a terminal illness.

Read More

More about Washington Vs Glucksberg Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document