ipl-logo

West Side Story Comparative Essay

2767 Words12 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Violence in cinema and tv essay

Anna Ryan Professor Craig Friend HI 345 (001) April 14, 2023 West Side Story: 1961 and 2021 Comparison Though there are sixty years of separation between the two films, West Side Story (1961) and West Side Story (2021), both of these films highlight societal shifts and problems. These films share several similarities, such as basic storylines, music, and themes, however, the new film provides a deeper emphasis on the change in societal awareness of issues such as cross-culture communities, prejudice, language barriers, and the effects of poverty on American youths. The screenwriters for West Side Story (1961) were Ernest Lehman, Arthur Laurents, and Jerome Robbins, and it was directed by Robert Wise and Jerome Robbins. Robbins was a founding …show more content…

Due to the restrictions on film and violence prior to the film being made, it was controversial to portray violence on the screen. It is films such as Alfred Hitchcock’s Psycho (1960) that pushed the boundaries of violence in film. However, in West Side Story (1961), the violence is more theatrical than realistic. Within the “brawl” scenes, there is limited blood, and close-up shots of real physical altercations. The movement of the actors are swift, fluid, and appear to be a choreographed dance rather than a physical fight. After W.W. Charters’ 1933 study of motion pictures to be used to teach society a sense of morality, films before West Side Story (1961) were hesitant to portray extreme, realistic violence. While the violence in this film seems tame in today’s standards, it was new for films of this time, and having Riff and Bernardo die on screen was pushing the limit of violence. Movies at this time did not want to encourage violence in real life, therefore violent scenes had to be strategic about blood and realistic fighting. West Side Story (2021) maintains a theatrical nature to the violence, however, there is more blood, particularly more vivid blood on characters’ faces throughout the brawling scenes. The violent fighting within each movie is a result of pure hatred between the Jets and the Sharks, and is fueled by the territorial mission of the …show more content…

Throughout West Side Story (1961), there is less Spanish included than in West Side Story (2021). The first film does not give a holistic view of the issues Puerto Rican’s faced in America, such as the racism they endured and the language barrier. This depiction of Puerto Ricans living in America is not accurate because a true representation of their struggles would have been controversial and upsetting to the American audience of the time. The film did not show the conflicts to the fullest extent because it would have painted America in a negative light. However, West Side Story (2021) reveals realistic interactions the Puerto Ricans would have had during this time. For example, in the breakfast scene with Anita, Maria, and Bernardo, Anita keeps reinforcing the conversation to be in English, because people like the Jets and the police would not tolerate Spanish. This reveals a struggle that was not included in the first film, as the Puerto Ricans were forced into American culture and English-only environments. Another example is when Anita goes to the drugstore to give “Doc” a message, and one of the Jets says “go back to where you came from.” This intolerance of the Puerto Rican population was not thoroughly displayed in the first film, again, to appease the

Show More
Related
1348 Words | 6 Pages

In Caballero, Gonzalez & Raleigh belittle the image and abilities of the non-white Mexican worker (peon). By using the narrator to reinforce the negative stereotypes regarding

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

In Judith Ortiz Cofer’s poem, “On the Island I Have Seen” she provides a glimpse of what life in Puerto Rico is like from a unique perspective. She was born in Puerto Rico, but growing up she moved back and forth between Puerto Rico and America. In an interview she shared: “But I think culture is very complex. You could say that I’m Puerto Rican by birth. I certainly enjoy and appreciate my heritage, and have used a lot of my culture for my art and incorporated it into my life” (Kevane and Herdia, 753).

Read More
999 Words | 4 Pages

The Bronze Screen introduced both positive and negative portrayals of Latinas and Latinos in film. While there are plenty of positive Latino roles in films, Latinos and Latinas should be included in more positive roles because the negative roles Latinos have in films cause negative stereotypes. Positive and negative representations of Latinos in films has always fluctuated throughout history, however the more negative ones seem to always overpower the good ones. The film, “The Bronze Screen”, gave many examples of the negative roles Latinos played in films throughout film history. Early films included Latino actors, however they did not always have a lead role or even a positive one.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

Even if the Mexican students assimilated through the Americanization classes, like the student Roberto, they were academically profiled as deficient and non-white and casted away to the “New School” based on their race and not on their academic fall backs. Borrowing the words from Ofelia Garcia, “The Spanish language (and bilingualism) in the United States have become markers of being nonwhite, of being out of place, thus minoritizing the position of U.S. Latinos and excluding them” (Garcia, 2009). Anglos in this community were creating a visible divide by using Spanish language as a marker of “otherness” and framing racial stereotypes to this linguistic

Read More
440 Words | 2 Pages

In this article, Author Gloria Anzaldua writes about growing up in America as a Mexican-American and the struggles that she faced due to the language barrier. Gloria claims that she grew up around a variety of different forms of both Spanish and English, “Standard English, working class/slang English, standard Spanish, Standard Mexican Spanish, and North Mexican Spanish dialect”, are just a few. The language spoken, or combinations of the languages correlate with where the Hispanic person was originally from and where in the U.S. they are now, for example, “Chicano Spanish” is spoken in Texas, New Mexico, Arizona and California. Another focus of this article is how Gloria would be punished in school for speaking in her native tongue and then at home by her for not speaking English properly. Gloria also felt the university she attended made the Hispanics take two speech classes, “in order to get rid of our accents”, she claims.

Read More
1193 Words | 5 Pages

I chose this film because it showed how hard the union workers and families worked in fighting racial injustices, and because it inspired myself to move forward with strong ideologies and pride. 2. Stereotyping in mass media was an important concern of Chicana/o media activists because it imprinted a demeaning label by only casting Chicana/o actors with "minor roles: villains, sidekicks, temptresses, where their main function is to provide the protagonists, typically a handsome white

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

A student watching the film can feel the true emotions of the characters because they, themselves, may have faced discrimination or loss in their lives. The characters in the film, no matter their race, are all victims of discrimination. Sal, a white Italian, is betrayed in a black community. While Raheem is killed by police officers. The setting of the film is in an urban part of Brooklyn, New York.

Read More
137 Words | 1 Pages

The only reason this occurred was because World War I was beginning. The U.S. government needed troops to send down to defend the Panama Canal and they felt that whites weren’t suited to fight in tropical climates. Instead they labeled puerto rican citizens as “immunes” due to them being

Read More
969 Words | 4 Pages

Cofer begins her essay by reliving an interaction she had with an Irishman on a trip to London, where the man re-enacted “María” from West Side Story. It was Cofer’s Hispanic appearance which led to the incident and the extra attention caused her to feel like an “island”. She felt out of place and insists that the same situation would not have likely occurred

Read More
1273 Words | 6 Pages

These words by poets Aurora and Rosario Morales, Puerto Rican Americans, reveal the struggle of the average Puerto Rican. For example, most islanders do not fully understand who they are or how to present themselves when someone asks, “What is your family’s ancestry like?” or, “Where does Puerto Rico get its unique culture?” These questions spark the idea of a questioning identity. This is because the island of Puerto Rico was formed with the help of many different cultures. Are the people of this island African?

Read More
1841 Words | 8 Pages

MAJOR ESSAY The West Side Story is popular for adapting the classic romantic tragedy, "Romeo and Juliet" (Anonymous). On the other hand, Porgy and Bess is an opera with regard black residents in South Carolina. Basically, this film is based on the history of race in America. Since these two films involve different plot, this paper will discuss how these stories differ or what they have in common.

Read More
507 Words | 3 Pages

“Hollywood, too, did its part, portraying fighting units whose members, representing various regional, ethnic, and religious backgrounds, put aside group loyalties and prejudices for the

Read More
222 Words | 1 Pages

As a Puerto Rican citizen, I do not fit in to that part of our history very much. In the late 1800’s, Puerto Rico was not a U.S. territory; instead, it formed part of the Spanish empire. It wasn’t until the end of the Spanish-American war that Puerto Rico became a U.S. property. Even then (after being conquered by the U.S. in the year 1900), the common American belief was that Puerto Ricans weren’t inherently equal any more than they thought that blacks were racially equal to whites. Rather, because the American public wouldn’t consent to treating Puerto Ricans as equals or granting them citizenship, the U.S. had trouble keeping the island as an imperial possession.

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

The Rhetorical Analysis of “The Myth of the Latin Woman” There are many examples of incidents happened because of cultural differences. Some of them are short, single events, while other follow a person or social group for decades. Professor Judith Cortiz Cofer describes the second example in her essay The Myth of the Latin Woman that was originally published in Glamour in 1992. The author focused on the stereotypical view of Latin women from the perspective of the personal experience as a Puerto Rican girl and woman in the USA. Cofer based her essay on examples from her own life and observations of the problem in a broader sense.

Read More
561 Words | 3 Pages

Javeon Lane Mrs. Hughes ALA 8 4 May 2016 Terribly Tragic Story Far too much death can be caused over something as trivial as a city block. West Side Story, released in 1961, starts in the middle of a conflict between an American gang known as the Jets and a Puerto Rican gang known as the Sharks. Tony, previous leader of the Jets, falls in love with a Shark girl named Maria. Riff, leader of the Jets, and Bernardo, leader of the Sharks, plan a large gang fight in an attempt to win control over the city block.

Read More

More about West Side Story Comparative Essay

Related Topics

Open Document