ipl-logo

What Are The Effects Of Bias In Forensic Professionals

2071 Words9 Pages

Problem Statement: What are the effects of bias in Forensics and how can Forensic Professionals combat this issue?

What is Bias:

The issue of bias in forensic science is a crucial one for the field of forensics to address. Bias is defined as the action of supporting or opposing a particular person or thing in an unfair way (“Bias”). The topic is important to the forensic field because it has been known to greatly impact the accuracy and reliability of results produced by forensic professionals. If a forensic analyst holds biases, either knowingly or unknowingly, it can influence various results such as influence DNA mixture interpretations, fingerprint comparisons, toxicology, and other forensic science judgements (Dror et al. 1). By understanding …show more content…

These types include (but are not limited to) confirmation bias, contextual bias, and implicit bias. Confirmation bias refers to the favoring of information that confirms existing beliefs and perceptions, while ignoring information that contradicts one’s opinions (https://cpdonline.co.uk/knowledge-base/safeguarding/types-of-bias/). This form of bias could influence a forensic professional to focus on data that may confirm their own beliefs about a person or evidence within a case creating misjustice in forensic processes. Secondly, there is contextual bias which refers to an unconscious bias of external influences that may affect how information is perceived. In forensics, this can be exhibited through preconceived notions concerning specific attributes about a person, even though the attributes should have little impact on the forensic process itself. An example of contextual bias is exhibited in a study determining how forensic professionals analyze immunoassay tests for opiate-type drugs. The study discusses how throughout multiple trials of this experiment, professionals were shown to be biased in their choice of tests based on the age of the individual in the case study. The study allowed …show more content…

Other factors that may have influenced the students’ judgement were the race of the victim whom the sample belonged to, as well as the manner in which the victim passed away.
The results of this study also may illustrate examples of implicit bias which suggests that people unconsciously attribute certain qualities to certain social groups (https://cpdonline.co.uk/knowledge-base/safeguarding/types-of-bias/). It is seemingly easier to stereotype groups of people and classify them with certain behaviors. This practice makes it easier to assume a person of a given race, gender, social class, or other classified group will almost always exhibit certain characteristics. In forensics, this thought process can affect how a professional conducts standard forensic procedures.
Impact of

Show More
Related
690 Words | 3 Pages

However, the way the glass evidence at the crime scene was documented, collected, and preserved absolutely would have had an impact on the examination results at the lab. The glass evidence was mishandled as it was reportedly transferred from an envelope to a plastic bag during the investigation, which could have resulted in further loss or contamination of the evidence. Overall, the mishandling of significant evidence compromised the reliability and admissibility in court. Again, this example of mishandling of evidence posed as another contention point within the case and resulted in much

Read More
1603 Words | 7 Pages

Those that are within my own knowledge I confirm to be true. The opinions I have expressed represent my true and complete professional opinions on the matters to which they refer.” On top of this any Forensic tests that Dr Wilson carried out must be documented in a form that is understandable. Another qualified expert must supervise these tests and their qualifications must be also listed. The report that is complied may need ot changed at a later date this might be because of new evidence coming to light or because of questioning that has taken place in the court

Read More
852 Words | 4 Pages

In 1996, Peter Neufeld the cofounder of the Innocence Project remarked that there is no rational as why crime laboratories, which habitually make decisions that have life and death outcome for an indicted individual, should be less managed than a clinical laboratory operating alike tests. In addition to this The NAS Report commented on the lack of standards for lab management and administration. For example, it argues that ‘There is no uniformity in the certification of forensic practitioners, or in the accreditation of crime laboratories. Indeed, most jurisdictions do not require forensic practitioners to be certified, and most forensic science disciplines have no mandatory certification programs. Moreover, accreditation of crime laboratories is not required in most jurisdictions.

Read More
986 Words | 4 Pages

In this paper I will be comparing contrasting two various aspects of forensic sciences used, and talking about the different tactics used to identify suspects; as well as the contrasts between the two methods. The man I will be talking about is John Wayne Gacy. The two methods I will be going over are, Finger print DNA and Forensic toxicology. These two are very similar, but made substantial differences in the evidence in his case. John Wayne Gacy was a murderer from Chicago, Illinois.

Read More
1737 Words | 7 Pages

The possible biases in jury decision-making will be discussed, including those related to having a celebrity on trial. In addition, this paper will examine the taboo nature of sexual assault cases, the problems that often arise in such cases, and the psychological toll on the victim. One issue with this case is the prosecution’s lack forensic evidence. In a “he said, she said” case that lacks the evidence that jurors expect in order to make their decision, it comes down to whether they believe the defendant or the prosecution. When DNA is not available, other types of physical evidence are examined (LaPorte, G., Nguyen, M., Schwarting, D., Scott, F., Waltke, H., Weiss, D., 2017).

Read More
1990 Words | 8 Pages

We know that DNA testing is giving hope to the hopeless in prison. Margret Berger (2006) comments, “Even though the number of inmates released as a consequence of DNA testing is minuscule in contrast to the two million persons incarcerated in the United States, the DNA exonerations have had an enormous impact on the fundamental assumptions about the American criminal justice system and how it operates.” Changes like the desirability of the death penalty, the growing concerns on how forensic laboratories operate alongside the increasing interest in forensic science overall. For instance, as the number of exonerations continues to rise, the number of people being placed on death row is decreasing thanks to Supreme Court rulings that juveniles under the age of 18 and the mentally ill cannot be sentenced to death. The death penalty is overall losing its appeal to society, not just because of the DNA testing, but people become aware of the wrongful convictions of other crimes as well.

Read More
380 Words | 2 Pages

African Americans in particular are victims of automatic prejudice the most. I think this was the case in Tamir’s case. As the text states, automatic, implicit prejudice can have life or death consequences in some situations (Myers, 2015, p. 249). In Payne’s study, a gun was quickly recognized and tools were mistaken for guns when associated with African American faces (Myers, 2015, p. 249).

Read More
2295 Words | 10 Pages

The impact of Tim’s case was also felt on a national and even international level, as it shed light on the importance of using accurate and scientific evidence in the legal system and the need to reform the criminal justice system to prevent wrongful convictions. Tim’s story has inspired many other cases to be re-opened and re-examined, leading to the exoneration of several other innocent individuals. Overall, the case of Tim Cole has had a profound impact on the criminal justice system and has helped to bring about important changes in the use of DNA

Read More
1502 Words | 7 Pages

On the other hand, discrepancies or weaknesses in the forensic analysis may raise reasonable doubt and favor the defendant (Bolton-King, 2016). Conclusion: Reliability and validity are critical considerations in forensic firearm examination, influencing the accuracy and credibility of forensic evidence presented in legal proceedings. Despite its importance, the field of forensic firearm identification has faced criticism regarding its scientific foundation. Skeptics argue that traditional methods lack the rigor and standardization necessary to be considered truly scientific. However, dismissing forensic firearm examination entirely would not only disregard its historical significance but also deprive the legal system of a valuable tool in investigating firearm-related crimes.

Read More
301 Words | 2 Pages

Due to DNA testing now available many cases of wrongful conviction have led them to be exonerated, by a confession from the actual perpetrator or other convincing evidence of innocence that wasn’t available at trail. For a DNA profile to be made they must first find evidence in form of blood, saliva, skin tissue, hair and semen that was recovered from a crime

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

Every day forensic investigators use tactics just like the ones that were discussed throughout the paper. It’s more than just looking for an admission of guilt, and interrogating potential suspects until they

Read More
488 Words | 2 Pages

One of the most accurate methods of connecting a suspect with a crime is through the use of DNA analysis. Even if no fingerprints are left behind at a robbery, for instance, a single strand of hair or skin cell from the thief can be used to positively identify a suspect. Conversely, if a suspect’s DNA does not match samples procured from a crime scene, the use of so-called “genetic fingerprinting” can exonerate, or clear, them. Concern over the issue of wrongful convictions, coupled with a sense of greater trust in DNA analysis over other, more conventional methods of prosecution, such as eyewitness testimony, has led some to call for mandatory DNA testing before any person begins serving a sentence for a serious crime, as well as

Read More
508 Words | 3 Pages

Gurleen Sekhon Essay Submission Number Two Many individuals trust in their reasoning to insist in making logical and justified decisions. In court cases; however, individual reasoning can be less logical or justified due to belief bias and confirmation bias. These two patterns, belief bias and confirmation bias, affects every individuals’ abilities to adapt and alter their beliefs according to newly acquired knowledge and face evidence. These patterns state that we tend to accept evidence or information that confirms what we already know.

Read More
1223 Words | 5 Pages

15 “The Innocence Project’s groundbreaking use of DNA technology to free innocent people has provided irrefutable proof that wrongful convictions are not isolated or rare events but instead from systemic defects” (Innocence Project). 16 There have been 337 DNA exonerations in the United States. Of the exonerees, the average age at the time of their wrongful convictions was 26.5. 17 The leading causes of wrongful convictions are eyewitness misidentification testimony, invalidated or improper forensic science, false confessions and incriminating statements, and informants.

Read More
2482 Words | 10 Pages

The former being defined as the evidence collected in order to convict or rule out suspects, and the latter being defined as the way the investigators developed the investigation and how it evolved throughout the ensuing years. In order to evaluate these two different subjects, one needs to examine the similarities and differences between this investigation and theories about how investigation of this type develop, the nuances of this investigation not able to be explained by theory, investigatory elements that

Read More

More about What Are The Effects Of Bias In Forensic Professionals

Related Topics

Open Document