ipl-logo

What Are The Ethical Implications Of The Milgram Experiment

654 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Stanford prison experiment critique

Analyzing Psychological Experiments
• Milgram experiments.
The major takeaway from the Milgram experiments was how many people were willing to comply simply due to the inherent desire to listen to authority regardless of the individual’s gender or background (Davidson, 2022). Even though these people were aware that innocent people were being caused pain by their actions, these participants still shocked the learner just because they were instructed to by authority.
• Stanford prison experiment.
The major takeaway from the Stanford prison experiment was how behavior is determined by the situation from a base of person to person. The guards lost sight of reality and treated the inmates poorly. The guards who did not engage in the mistreatment …show more content…

He told the learners that they were participating in a learning and memory experiment(Davidson,2022). The ethical implications of the Stanford experiment denied the participants any ability to withdraw from the experiment. Three was a lack of regard for safety. Zimbardo displayed a lack of ethics which then led to the unethical treatment of the inmates. It shines a light on the ability to tap into one’s dark-sided nature under authoritarian circumstances (Lurigio,2023).
Implications of the Person-Situation Debate
• Trait-based stability
An example of behaviors that highlight trait-based stability in the workplace or school would be an individual who always goes above and beyond in their school work. They are inclined to always have their task completed on time and be very meticulous at work later in their career.
• Personality states
An example of a behavior that highlights the personality state of being conscientious at school is a person dancing at prom. The person may be overwhelmed and overwhelmed with thinking about how to dance and feel anxiety-ridden. If this same individual was thinking of what sort of dance moves to whip out in a positive mindset this may showcase a display of being an …show more content…

I still agree with that sentiment. Traits are on a continuum, they change as we age in life. As we grow older we experience life differently and are exposed to things we have never done before. When we become open to spontaneous moments such as those or meeting new people we tap into other extroverted parts of ourselves. We have underlying personality traits that stay stagnant but for the most part, people will change over time. By characterizing a person in one simplistic way we’re unable to give them the benefit of the doubt. Humans are too versatile to be bound to be the same thing their whole

Show More
Related
406 Words | 2 Pages

The Stanford prison experiment was led by Philip Zimbardo with the purpose of studying the psychological effects of being a prisoner and a prison guard. The participants of the research study were male college students. Once selected, a coin toss determined which males would be prisoners and prison guards. The experiment took place at Stanford University, where a mock prison was crafted. Zimbardo acted as the warden or superintendent of the mock prison.

Read More
315 Words | 2 Pages

Title (psychology #7) In the Abu Ghraib Torture and the Milgram experiment even though they had different reasoning behind it, the same concept is behind it. The obedience to authority people tend to have is either to obey or disobey authority and do what they think is right. In both this situation many people decided to obey authority and break their morals.

Read More
444 Words | 2 Pages

The Stanford Prison Experiment (SPE) had a main goal to find out how much of an influence a specific setting location could have on how individuals behave. The experiment took place in 1971 and many psychologists used as a reference to analyze people’s mind under certain circumstance. Young individuals were given the roles of prisoner and guard in prison-like setting located at the Psychology department Stanford University. I strongly believe that this experiment was ethically wrong and did not surprise me at all, since the participant in the study were not fully aware of how dangerous the experiment could turn. Furthermore, the guards were acting like real inmate’s officers

Read More
751 Words | 4 Pages

In summary, the purpose of the Stanford Prison Experiment was supposed to demonstrate that powerful situational forces, much like Abu Ghraib, could over-ride individual dispositions and choices, leading good people to do bad things simply because of the role they found themselves

Read More
1262 Words | 6 Pages

The CivilWarLand is a family-oriented theme park close to closing as the gangs have been vandalizing and creating problems for the park owner Mr.Alsuga. Mr.Alsuga is determined to keep the park open, using the narrator and other characters to do his dirty work regardless of the consequences. In "The Perils of Obedience," Stanley Milgram conducts an experiment to test how far people are willing to bend their morals and go against their own conscience to appease the authority figure, in this case, the Experimenter. Milgram's hypothesis was proven wrong as the majority of people would go against their conscience and appease the authority figure despite the harm they were doing to the learner. Milgram's experiment demonstrated that people would go to extreme lengths to obey a superior, regardless of the consequences.

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

This experiment was conducted in Stanford University by Dr. Zimbardo. During this two week long session, Dr. Zimbardo had several volunteers agree to act as prisoners and as prison guards. The prisoners were told to wait in their houses while the guards were to set up the mock prison, a tactic used by Dr. Zimbardo to make them fit into their roles more. The official police apprehended the students assigned to the role of prisoner from their homes, took mug shots, fingerprinted them, and gave them dirty prison uniforms. The guards were given clean guard uniforms, sunglasses, and billy clubs borrowed from the police.

Read More
1509 Words | 7 Pages

When the Milgram obedience experiments were being conducted the core of the experiments were all based on the false impression that an electrical shock would be administered to another individual at the push of a button with an incorrect answer, when in fact they weren’t. If the Milgram experiments were not based on lies and each participant did in fact administer a shock to another individual in response to a wrong answer, I feel that the results would have been the same with no alternative result. The reason for this would be because from the very beginning of the experiment the participants already believed that they would be actually administering an electrical shock. The participant’s reactions and concerns before, during and even after the experiments were all real with their true feelings and thoughts about their participation of either walking away from the experiment or completing the experiment. If the participants were to know that the electric shocks they were administering were not real, then the whole purpose of the experiment would have been useless and unnecessary.

Read More
599 Words | 3 Pages

Stanford Prison Experiment Philip Zimbardo questioned, “What happens when you put good people in an evil place? Does humanity win over evil, or does evil triumph?” (Zimbardo, 1971) In 1971 a psychologist named Philip Zimbardo conducted an experiment on the effects prison has on young males with the help of his colleague Stanley Milgram. They wanted to find out if the reports of brutality from guards was due to the way guards treated prisoners or the prison environment.

Read More
329 Words | 2 Pages

Daniel, This is a sound post you made this week. For the first question in your forum answering you went into detail and explained the idea why the prison experiment was ethical in your judgement and opinion. After going through what you typed I agreed myself with what you had to say for it. These students gave full consent to be prisoners, or the possibility to be guards, for an experiment that required them to be in a simulated prison environment for Dr. Zimbardo’s psychological study. The prisoners were pushed to their mental breaking point, in which I too saw was necessary for the experiment to be conducted effectively, and when need be they students were given a pardon.

Read More
496 Words | 2 Pages

It challenged the prevailing belief at the time that individuals' actions were solely a result of their dispositional factors. This notion was debunked as the experiment demonstrated how ordinary individuals, placed in a particular environment, can exhibit drastic changes in behavior. These findings had significant implications, prompting further research into the power dynamics within various social contexts. However, the Stanford Prison Experiment also triggered concern regarding its ethical implications.

Read More
950 Words | 4 Pages

While arguably one of the defining psychological studies of the 20th Century, the research was not without flaws. Almost immediately the study became a subject for debate amongst psychologists who argued that the research was both ethically flawed and its lack of diversity meant it could not be generalized. Ethically, a significant critique of the experiment is that the participants actually believed they were administering serious harm to a real person, completely unaware that the learner was in fact acting. Although Milgram argued that the illusion was a necessary part of the experiment to study the participants’ reaction, they were exposed to a highly stressful situation. Many were visibly distraught throughout the duration of the test

Read More
936 Words | 4 Pages

Stanford Prison Experiment The "good" guards may have succumbed to the pressure of conforming to the roles and expectations associated with being a guard. The simulated prison environment created a social dynamic where the guards were expected to assert authority and maintain control. The "good" guards may have felt compelled to align their behavior with the prevailing norms and expectations, even if it meant following the orders of the tough or bad guards. The guards' behavior in the Stanford Prison Experiment could have been influenced by a diffusion of responsibility. When individuals are part of a group or system, they may feel less personally accountable for their actions, believing that others share the responsibility.

Read More
290 Words | 2 Pages

A virus is considered non- living but shows two things of living, they are made up of protein and genetic material. Viruses are very small, they can be seen with a microscope, and invade living cells. Since viruses don’t consist of cells, they have to depend on a host cell to help them make copies of their selves. When a virus enters a cell it uses that cells ATP to replicate.

Read More
284 Words | 2 Pages

One of the most infamous experiments conducted in the history of psychology was the Stanford Prison Experiment. The main objective of this experiment was to see what effects would occur when a psychological experiment into human nature was performed. As I read through the material provided, I noticed that my thoughts on the matter were similar to many; that it was a complete failure as a scientific research project. However, his findings did provide us with something much more important that is still being talked about today; insight into human psychology and social behavior.

Read More
981 Words | 4 Pages

The Milgram experiment was conducted to analyze obedience to authority figures. The experiment was conducted on men from varying ages and varying levels of education. The participants were told that they would be teaching other participants to memorize a pair of words. They believed that this was an experiment that was being conducted to measure the effect that punishment has on learning, because of this they were told they had to electric shock the learner every time that they answered a question wrong. The experiment then sought out to measure with what willingness the participants obeyed the authority figure, even when they were instructed to commit actions which they seemed uncomfortable with.

Read More

More about What Are The Ethical Implications Of The Milgram Experiment

Related Topics

Open Document