ipl-logo

What Defines A Good Person In The Count Of Monte Cristo

413 Words2 Pages

What defines a good person? This question has been debated for generations, and Aristotle's philosophy suggests that a virtuous and good person derives happiness and pleasure from their virtuous actions. However, being a good person is not just about one's actions but also the qualities they possess. In the film The Shawshank Redemption (1994), Andy Dufresne better represents what a good person should be than Edmond Dantes in The Count Of Monte Cristo (2002). To begin, the situations of Andy and Edmond should be examined. Andy was the Vice President of an American bank in Portland, Maine, and Edmond was the First Mate of his merchant ship, La Pharoan. Both were good, upstanding citizens of their societies, but their responses to their corresponding …show more content…

Andy maintained his moral compass even in the face of extreme adversity, refusing to give in to corruption or violence. Edmond's moral compass was distorted by his thirst for revenge, and he went to great lengths to achieve it, even harming innocent people. This shows that Andy's sense of morality is stronger than Edmond's and makes him a better person overall. Furthermore, Andy displayed resilience in the face of adversity. Although he had been wrongly convicted and was serving a life sentence, he refused to let his circumstances define him, instead focusing on improving himself and the lives of those around him. In contrast, Edmond's quest for revenge consumed him, and he became so focused on it that he lost sight of everything else. In conclusion, a good person is defined by a combination of qualities such as generosity, morality, and resilience. Andy Dufresne from The Shawshank Redemption represents these qualities much better than Edmond Dantes from The Count of Monte Cristo. Andy's unwavering sense of morality, selflessness, and resilience in the face of adversity are qualities that make him a truly good person. In contrast, Edmond's pursuit of revenge ultimately led him down a path of moral decay and corruption. It is clear that a good person is not defined by their circumstances or their actions alone, but rather by the qualities they exhibit in the face of

Show More
Related
1569 Words | 7 Pages

Louie and Andy are very similar, they were innocent people. Louie was simply caught in a raft and turned into a prisoner to be beaten, and Andy was a man framed for a violent crime against his wife and her lover. They were both punished and dealt with many hardships throughout their lives. Andy however, managed to escape from the prison, and while he did he also brought down the people who had crossed him. Louie had no chance of escaping and yet in a way he got back at the people who crossed him.

Read More
726 Words | 3 Pages

He is a good person because a criminal wouldn’t want to feel, and look like a good person. He cares for others and feels like a good person because he didn’t do anything. Also, Steve saw the pictures of Mr. Nesbit in court. Nesbit was the store owner who was killed. The author wrote, “‘The picture of Mr. Nesbitt scares me.

Read More
461 Words | 2 Pages

Since Melinda thought Andy was pleasant at first she believed him enough to be distant from everyone else with him, she never again has the capacity with that with any other individual. Melinda's sentiments toward Andy are abhor over the way that she can't act naturally any longer and feels lost over the way that he simply utilized her. ”I just want to sleep. The whole point of not talking about it, of silencing the memory, is to make it go away. It won't.

Read More
552 Words | 3 Pages

One of the most common setbacks for the show was showing common sins such as lying and stealing occasionally. In the words of John Melhorn, the pastor of Faith Brethren in Christ Church, “The heroes often resort to lying or deceit or some other "sin," yet we are to admire them. After all, they are the hero.” Throughout the years it is a truly fabulous show that is still “craved” and “needed”, with it’s marvelous perseverance that has had viewers hooked on trying to figure out “What will happen to ‘Andy’ next?”. Nowadays as generations are growing up, less and less of the population know about the show and the context at which it is talking in.

Read More
787 Words | 4 Pages

He is a well-liked figurehead among the community due to his level-headed approach to law enforcement. Andy has a calm and quiet life at home, enjoying fishing and nights on his front porch with his aunt and housekeeper, Aunt Bee. However, he does face some issues with his son that call for disciplinary action, as well as dealing with his aunt’s disastrous romantic life. The “I love Lucy” show and “The Andy Griffith Show” have a few similarities that can be compared to each other.

Read More
1344 Words | 6 Pages

Eventually, Red got out on parole, and it was the hope that Andy brought to Shawshank that kept him going on the outside. In this story, Andy was the most hopeful person in Shawshank, but he was also sensible towards the notion of risk and reward. Despite being a

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

It is the smallest of actions which create the most hope. Andy, being one of the very few sources of hope for those in Shawshank. He was clearly more optimistic than the rest and he was a lot smarter too. It was when Andy locked himself in a room and turned the music of Mozart on. He then turned on the speakers which projected all throughout the prison.

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

These sisters beat up the ones only that fought back and Andy always fought back because he felt that not resisting is a much worse. Also, he figured that they will stop at some point. Andy gains protection from the sisters because he helped the guards and the warden with their finance papers. This quote has a deep meaning and it is the major lesson of the novella. Andy says to Red, "Remember that hope is a good thing, Red, maybe the best of things, and no good thing ever dies."

Read More
710 Words | 3 Pages

The Royals had a negative reputation with the public, but would not give up this image for the sake of Laura. From the reader's perspective, he was irresponsible due to wanting to juggle a peaceful and violent life. Andy lived a violent life joining the Royals but wanted to live a peaceful life with Laura. His irresponsibility is shown by Andy deciding to become a Royal rather than live to his true self alongside Laura. Through this story, Andy goes through a difficult predicament and reflects on his circumstances.

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

What is the definition of a good person? The view of a good person changes as time goes on. However, the Odyssey is still the foundation of human morality. The Odyssey, created by Homer, is an ancient telling of a man named Odysseus and his journey home from the Trojan War. The morals found in the Odyssey show readers the benefit of being able to view situations from multiple points of view.

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

In Ancient Rome, the Romans had their own Roman Republic. The Roman republic reasonably met the common good. The way they did this was that they didn’t fully meet the common good in all areas, but in other areas they did. In public service I would give the Ancient Romans an A. One of the greatest achievements in ancient time was the waterway.

Read More
1720 Words | 7 Pages

This is easier to identify with a character who has their faults than the one who is positively driven by all their intents and purposes. One of their tenets and objectives is one of unimpeachable integrity. Conclusively, he recognized as a sympathetic character in the story, who is

Read More
533 Words | 3 Pages

What is the measure of a good person? Is it his heroic ways, or perhaps his personality? A virtuous person can be defined in many ways. Characteristic such as being honest can up a person's reputation. Being respectable plays a big role

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

From this, we learn that it is important to be ourselves and not have labels define you we are. It also teaches us that we have to be careful of labels and not to associate with bad influences such as gangs, because they are what people will see you as. Instead, we must avoid labels and develop our own character. There are several events in this story that demonstrate this theme. For example, Andy meets the couple, Freddie and Angela, who refused to help him because they saw he was a gang member.

Read More
751 Words | 4 Pages

Towards the end of the book, Andy and his family get to see the true colours of the Duvitch family. When Mr Duvitch “remarked that since Andy and Tom caught the fish, he’d feel better if we all shared them” during dinner, Andy and his family felt that this was a generous and kind thing to do. Just like the saying “Don’t judge a book by it’s cover” Andy and his family learn to not judge someone based on their

Read More

More about What Defines A Good Person In The Count Of Monte Cristo

Related Topics

Open Document