ipl-logo

What Is Cockburn's Argument Against The Vikings?

384 Words2 Pages
One such contradiction to this theory is Patrick Cockburn, who believes the Viking “atrocities were the equivalent of those carried out by SS divisions invading Poland 75 years ago”. Throughout his argument, Cockburn is incredibly biased towards the Anglo-Saxons, using emotive language such as, “the Anglo-Saxons fought back heroically”, which colours his entire argument. He believes “terrified accounts of what happened were set aside by experts as biased”. However, he doesn’t state that it isn’t wise to not consider bias when using sources, especially when a significant element of utilising a source is to consider the bias. Evidence for Cockburn’s argument is that the Vikings “killed in a sickenly gruesome Viking ritual known as the ‘blood-eagle’”,
Show More
Related
570 Words | 3 Pages

There are finds where parts of skull are actually hacked off and arm bones hacked into multiple parts. This clearly constitutes an evidence of some conflict for dominance in the region. Of course, it is impossible to determine at this time, if the fight happened between the local people and the Scandinavian group or between two rival leaders and their followers, however, it is significant indication that struggle for power and dominance took place outside the established borders of Scandinavia. There have been even attempts to link this find to the famous King Ingvar from Inglingasaga, (Heimskringla) although it is, of course, impossible to prove or disprove such hypothesis. In any case, it indicates the presence of significant military force of well-equipped men in the region.

Read More
279 Words | 2 Pages

Tacitus, a historian living during time of the 5 Good Emperors possesses a balanced view on the Germanic people, however in the 4th Century, as a historian, Marcellinus views them as savage barbarians, finally in the 5th Century, Priscus, a diplomatic envoy, views the Germanic people as civilized. Although he was “delighted by gifts from neighboring tribes”, Tacitus also thought them to be barbarians after he experiences that “they wear skins of wild beasts.” Considering the peaceful and flourishing time period that Tacitus lives in, he lacks any natural reasons to fear the Germanic people, eventually he comes to the conclusion that these “barbarians” are quite civilized. Around the 4th century when the Huns actively attack the Western Roman Empire, the historian Marcellinus states that the Huns along with the Germanic tribes have “no home or law or settled manner” and he views them to be “quite abnormally savage.” The rather un-forgiving vibe Marcellinus puts off is due to the stressful, desperate, and instable time period that he writes in, ultimately viewing them as ruthless barbarians.

Read More
90 Words | 1 Pages

Vinh, you did an excellent job explaining the events and the impact of Missouri crisis. I like how you mentioned John Tallmadge, he forbids the further introduction of slavery into Missouri and declaring that all children born of slave parents should be free upon reaching the age of twenty-five. I also like how you mentioned Vesey 's Rebellion into the argument because it supported your argument really well. And I did not see many people using Vesey 's Rebellion on their arguments, so I was really impressed how informative your argument is!

Read More
603 Words | 3 Pages

To What Extent Can the Vikings Be Considered More Than Just Raiders? The Vikings were a civilisation from Scandinavia that lived between the 8th and 11th centuries. Over time, the Vikings have gained a reputation as being bloodthirsty savages. But exactly how much of the stereotypes are true?

Read More
1641 Words | 7 Pages

Eyewitness to History’s “The Vikings Discover America, ca. 1000” lacks the features of a rigorously checked academic source, resulting in missing facts, diminished accuracy and other academic transgressions. The article skimps on historical detail, suggesting disinterest in the “unexciting” facts. As such, the article uses inappropriate terms that are often anachronistic and biased, pandering towards the enjoyment of the audience. The article is also missing key structural details, demonstrating its lack of authority.

Read More
966 Words | 4 Pages

In support Quora.com states, “Columbus paved the way for permanent colonization & exploitation of the Americas. The Vikings didn't have the same kind of lasting

Read More
1049 Words | 5 Pages

Fans who raise questions of race on forums are often cautious, understanding that their ways of reading the text are not ‘correct’ according to the majority of the fan community and anticipate negative responses. Dismissive, and even angry responses, often crafted along the lines of “This is fiction, you’re taking it too seriously”, downplays the importance of racial representation and their individual responses to the whiteness of Westeros. Lastly, similar to minimization, fans use the Monochrome Middle Ages argument, an ides that Europe in the Middle Ages was purely white, to defend

Read More
126 Words | 1 Pages

The Cardigans want to advertise commercials on clothes that are too revealing The Cardigans want to have their commercials on WBLAH television station but WBLAH does not to air the commercial. WBLAH have children watching their station they feel that have commercials with clothes too revealing would not be good for the children to watch. The Cardigans feel that WBLAH is violated their freedom of speech under the 1st Amendment. WBLAH disagree they do not commercials not suitable for children. The Cardigans believe that WBLAH is going by the old law that does not allow commercial are not suitable for children.

Read More
936 Words | 4 Pages

Answering the question ‘When did St. Patrick die? ’ is of crucial importance in understanding the way in which Early Medieval History works. The debate over the potential death date of St. Patrick shows that (for this period at least) there is no such thing as a historical fact for an Historian to rely on. When studying any period in History, there is a heavy reliance on sources. However, with the Medieval period, there are question marks surrounding the reliability of the sources.

Read More
139 Words | 1 Pages

Beowulf is a classic story of good versus evil. Beowulf defeats the bad and dies a hero, a story that is very satisfying to many. Although Beowulf was written thousands of years ago, it relates strongly to today’s society. Modern-day movies, soap operas, television shows, have advanced in many ways but still contain some of the same story lines as Beowulf. In addition, it portrays violence such as in the world of social media today.

Read More
960 Words | 4 Pages

Barbarians have always been associated with terms like merciless and ravages. Throughout the ages they have been described as cruel beasts who’s only task is to destroy everything in their way. In Ibn Fadlan’s account of the Viking Rus, we are exposed to a point of view that we’ve never seen before. Ibn Fadlan goes to the barbarian Northmen and asked them several questions about their way of life, which further helped to reveal the honest efforts of the Barbarians. Even so, when reading his views, historians can’t be one hundred percent right that all this may be true information.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

The legend begins with an intricate history of the Danes’ leadership, showing the high regard the Anglo-Saxons had for their rulers. One of the kings, Shield Sheafson was a “scourge of many tribes” and “a wrecker of

Read More
618 Words | 3 Pages

When history is reviewed there is commonly a culture gap between the reader and the time period. These gaps in time create difficulties when historians attempt to fully comprehend an event due to changes in culture, religion, morals...etc. When contrasting two ancient civilizations such as the Romans and the Germanic peoples, these differences can create certain bias. Similar to the early American settlers and the Native Americans, it is important to remain impartial to either civilization and realize history tends to be written by the conqueror. There is an insufficient amount of information we have on early Germanic civilization due to the lack of written text.

Read More
1626 Words | 7 Pages

When a novel or novella from an author is first released to the public, there is a slight chance of fame for that book or author. However, what happens to those who create not just a book but also a legacy? These are the creators of sub-genres, worlds, great literary works, and legacies that inspire fans. This is what Tolkien was to many; he was the father of epic fantasy. Even though he may have struggled through his youth and older years, he surpassed other authors by creating numerous characters and stories that the world would know and remember.

Read More
821 Words | 4 Pages

The epic poem “Beowulf”, translated by Burton Raffel, focuses on a hero by the name of Beowulf who goes on a quest to rescue King Hrothgar and his people from an egregious monster by the name of Grendel. This Anglo-Saxon tale gives insight into the values and beliefs of the people from whom the story originated. Their war-centered ideology and views on loyalty and courage were the principles that the Anglo-Saxon culture was founded upon. While warfare was a focal point in their lifestyle, it was far from a savage, barbaric state of fighting. Honor and prestige were bestowed upon those who died during battle and selflessness for fellow warriors was a fundamental belief.

Read More

More about What Is Cockburn's Argument Against The Vikings?

Related Topics

Open Document