ipl-logo

What Is The Creation And Examination Of A Metaphorical City

1727 Words7 Pages

When considering how to define justice, the creation and examination of a metaphorical city is certainly not the first method that comes to mind. It’s probably not even in the top ten. In Reeve’s Eight Essential Dialogues, Socrates demonstrates the creation and examination of said city. Not only are readers introduced to Socrates, but they get to observe the reactions and arguments from his audience at the time. His extended metaphor of the city tends to create obscurity, requires a lot of clarification, and leaves much to be desired. Socrates’ use of the city metaphor is so extended and convoluted that overall, it tends to confuse the readers rather than providing the intended clarity.
The city metaphor is a product entirely of Socrates himself. …show more content…

On multiple occasions they require clarification or an elaboration from Socrates. It is not just on concepts they are unable understand, but they often disagree with him or require a whole additional metaphor in order to understand the comparison Socrates is attempting to make. In one instance Socrates makes a statement regarding courage in the city and it makes very little sense, so Glaucon informs Socrates that he did “not completely understand what [he] said” and asks if Socrates would “mind repeating it?” (429c). Of course, Socrates furthers the explanation for Glaucon, but it takes an additional thirty-seven lines and a metaphor about dying wool for Glaucon to understand and accept this definition. All of that seems excessive, especially just to define courage in the city. Originally, Glaucon was not just confused, but he didn’t understand at all. Meaning the concept that Socrates was arguing is so far out of the scope of any normal person’s thoughts that Glaucon could not even manage to grasp what he meant. This is not the only time that one of the members of Socrates’ audience has felt they needed clarification in regard to the city. It happens multiple times throughout the metaphor. Several times in each book those listening to Socrates ask questions or ask him to explain himself more thoroughly. Socrates’ city does not evoke clarity at all, at least not if it is to be judged by the audience’s reaction to his

Show More
Related
1118 Words | 5 Pages

Socrates compares the relationship between a citizen and a city to that of a child and a parent. Athens has nurtured Socrates in body and mind, given him an ideal environment to raise his own children in, to give him a platform to exhort people to be virtuous (Crito, 51a). As any child benefits from the protections and provisions of a parent, he must also obey the parent when it requires something of him. So, Socrates considers it his civic duty to obey Athens wishes since he has benefited from his citizenship. Socrates reaches a conclusion that defies a common-sense understanding of

Read More
1220 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout the debate, Socrates seizes his knowledge of rhetoric and uses it against Gorgias. His understanding of rhetorical appeals and devices allows him to conspire a plan to trap Gorgias in his own contradictions. Through the use of Ethos, Logos, and Pathos, Socrates adequately

Read More
1556 Words | 7 Pages

The people were conditioned to whole the city in high admiration, above family. Socrates was no exception, he believed in this as

Read More
806 Words | 4 Pages

In this play the Socrates here doesn't sound like the Socrates from the Apology or the real life Socrates. The real Socrates doesn't actually teach per say, he teaches in a way that makes you yourself use your brain. He makes you question everything and understand things based on your own perception. The writer of this play clearly felt as if Socrates was a major problem in his society for allowing people to actually try to think outside of the box and ask questions. He most likely enjoyed the fact that everyone were robots and all thought alike and believed in the same thing because it brought no need to bring out discussion.

Read More
1193 Words | 5 Pages

Due to Socrates accommodating his concerns with the crowd by capitalizing on their curiosity, which conserves the contemplation of the audience, thus establishes excitement towards their behalf. This puts Gorgias in a scrutiny, as he must now vigilantly respond in order to deter questioning, and pique by the viewers; more so probable attendees of his teachings. The factors leading to this discussion have led to further expressive tones of consensus among many participants engaged in the conversation. As demonstrated by Socrates exhibiting superlative measures of deciphering for he jumps into the meanings of concepts much more sharply than Gorgias does (As portrayed, he keeps Gorgias and everyone on their toes pondering what he recites). Gorgias, on the other hand, ensures his place into the consultation by presenting elegant acts of control and faith as he presents his case in a more robust

Read More
1116 Words | 5 Pages

He also states this definition is applicable “in war and in every other situation.” (195a2) showing his attempt to provide an answer that is a universal rather than a particular. At first glance, this appears to advance our understanding of courage as it seems too be applicable in all situations. This seems to be the common element found in all acts of bravery. However, while providing the correct form of answer to Socrates question, it does not capture courage as a whole.

Read More
718 Words | 3 Pages

(Crito.49b). He believes the city raised him like a child from birth so retaliating is the same as striking your parents down. (Crito,50e). Socrates believes your country should be honored more than your parents or ancestors and by not doing so is not godly. Turning your back on your country is doing the wrong thing, so to escape is

Read More
961 Words | 4 Pages

In the Apology Socrates defends himself against the charges brought against him by his prosecutor Meletus in two ways. In the first way Socrates describes his method and

Read More
233 Words | 1 Pages

He starts his interrogation with those that are believed to have the greatest reputation and wisdom and visits with the politicians, poets, and craftsmen. Socrates tells the court that the politicians are not wise, hence he is in a room full of politicians and there supporters He concludes that he is wiser than these politicians even

Read More
1382 Words | 6 Pages

Socrates believes that justice benefits the just, but also benefits the city (other people) too. He is faced with a seemingly simple choice, escape Athens or remain in prison and be sentenced to death. Socrates’ central argument against escaping his circumstances is twofold. First, Socrates argues that “one must never do wrong.” (49b)

Read More
1421 Words | 6 Pages

Brian Diaz Professor Siddiqui Philosophy 1 20 January 2018 Second Paper: Conceptual Reconstruction (Crito, Meno, Phaedo) The dialogue of the Crito, by Plato, recounts the last days of Socrates ' life. In the dialogue Socrates ' old friend, Crito, proposes that Socrates escape from Athenian prison. Crito is a wealthy man from outside of town, a student of Socrates, and an old friend.

Read More
965 Words | 4 Pages

S12:Socrates then at the end of the chapter and talks about an analogy he created involucrate a human who is just and the city he defines both and explains them and what they do and the functionality they consist of individually. C12: The author still uses this step to show justice in the city and all he does is compare it to an analogy between man and

Read More
1355 Words | 6 Pages

In his discussion over how the citizens should be educated and how to control their knowledge, the question of the ethical and realistic expectations of the city. However, the problem, or downfall, of Plato’s city is its foundation. A foundation of lies. Plato’s web of lies, falsehoods and manipulation make the entire city

Read More
1687 Words | 7 Pages

Throughout Book II and Book III, Socrates argues repeatedly for the censorship of art, music, and stories. However, this censorship seems to be only in effect over the guardians rather than the general population. The commencement of the conversation about education and censorship illustrates this point with Socrates asking, “but how are we to bring [the guardians] up and educate [them]” (376c). Here, Socrates sets up the discussion that follows to be one pertaining to the education of the guardian class of Kallipolis specifically and not the rest of the population. Socrates expresses that, “[they] want the guardians of [their] city to think that it’s shameful to be easily provoked into hating one another,” so they, “mustn’t allow any stories about gods warring, fighting, or plotting against one another” (378b-c).

Read More
943 Words | 4 Pages

In Book IV of Plato’s Republic, Socrates and his peers come to the conclusion that a city is going to need people who have an understanding of what justice should be. Socrates at the end of Book IV can make the difference between individual, political, and social justice. He knows that individual and political justice is so much in common because they both weigh in heavy on truth, honor, and appetitive soul. That appetitive soul is an element that helps the secure the just community with love and support.

Read More

More about What Is The Creation And Examination Of A Metaphorical City

Related Topics

Open Document