ipl-logo

What's Wrong With Animal Rights By Vicki Hearne

952 Words4 Pages

Imagine a world where the silent cries of suffering animals echo louder than our indifference. In her essay “What’s Wrong with Animal Rights,” Vicki Hearne probes into the neglect of animal well-being, a topic often overlooked by society. This paper will explore the significance of communication in forging meaningful human-animal relationships, evaluate the efficiency of current animal welfare laws, advocate for an ethical approach to animal responsibilities, and present successful instances of animal care. In her essay, “What’s Wrong with Animal Rights?” Hearne contends that animals possess intelligence surpassing human comprehension, advocating for mutual understanding and respect in our interactions with them. She also challenges conventional …show more content…

These deficiencies contribute to the continued suffering and neglect experienced by countless animals, underscoring the need for comprehensive reform in animal welfare legislation and enforcement practices. Hearne advocates for an ethical approach towards animals, promoting a deep appreciation and respect for their worth and dignity (Hearne). Most humans uphold moral and ethical values in their interactions with one another, demonstrating respect and appreciation for fellow beings. It is widely acknowledged that animals experience a range of emotions similar to those felt by humans, underscoring the importance of treating them with compassion and empathy. Despite animals’ inability to reciprocate human gestures in the same manner, they deserve to be afforded dignity and consideration. However, various practices such as trophy hunting and animal testing prove the pervasive mistreatment and exploitation of animals for human benefit. While some argue that animal testing is necessary for human safety, this justification is

Show More
Related
248 Words | 1 Pages

In the op-ed piece “A Change of Heart about Animals”, Jeremy Rifkin emphasizes the similarities between humans and animals by providing results on scientific research studies to illustrate that humans should be more empathetic towards animals. In addition, he further explains how research results have changed the ways humans perceived animals and indicates solutions that were taken by other countries and organizations to help improve and protect animal rights. Rifkin provides examples that demonstrate animals have emotions, conceptual abilities, self awareness, and a sense of individualism just like humans. For example, Pigs crave for affection and get depressed easily when isolated, two birds Betty and Abel have tool making skills, Koko

Read More
2055 Words | 9 Pages

Although Jeremy Rifkin, Bob stevens, and Lois Frazier have all written about their view on animals and how they are treated globally, but when bringing in animal rights groups like ASPCA and PETA, different bias and tactics are newly introduced. Of all the articles, Jeremy Rifkin uses the most credible sources such as lab studies and examples. In the article “A Change of Heart about Animals” Rifkin uses sources such as Purdue University and the European union when talking about situations. One situation he writes about is how pigs need social activity so the pigs are not “lacking mental and physical stimuli [which] hand result in deterioration of health”.

Read More
864 Words | 4 Pages

According to Jeremy Rifkin’s article, “A Change of Heart About Animals,” research has shown that animals are more similar to humans than originally believed. Through the many studies provided, Rifkin claims the need to provide better treatment towards animals. While animals deserve and could benefit from a more humane treatment than what is currently provided, they may not necessarily require a human-like lifestyle simply because of their similarities to humans.

Read More
886 Words | 4 Pages

Michael Pollan brings to our attention the arguments that relate to the treatment of animals. He begins his essay with examples talking about how pigs are seen as nothing more than meat and how dogs get their own birthday and Christmas presents. Here he questions how certain animals receive different attitudes from us and makes us think about how each animal has a different fate. Pollan wants us to question ourselves and to look at animals from another perspective and see if they deserve more equality or if we need to have a different attitude towards them all together. These arguments are very effective in that they make us question of whether or not our attitude towards certain animals are different because of how they are used or in our eyes some are just more important than others.

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Currently people are treating animals with disrespect by abusing , eating , and slaughtering them. In his article “ A Change of about Animals,” Rifkin points out that “ they feel pain , suffer , and experience stress , affection , excitement and even love--- and these findings are changing how we view animals.” In the article “ A Change of Heart about animals,” Rifkin points out that “ they feel pain , suffer , and experience stress , affection , excitement and even love--- and these findings are changing how we view

Read More
526 Words | 3 Pages

In Jeremy Rifkin’s article, “A Change of Heart about Animals”, proves his statement that many of our fellow creatures also “feel pain, suffer and experience stress, affection, excitement and even love..”. I agree that animals share similar feelings as us, and I believe that they should be treated in a way that they can feel comfortable and care in their surroundings. Just because animals may not be completely the same as us, that should not give the right to a human to mistreat and abuse of an animal’s life. Animals can be well treated and cared for without giving them the right to be treated as a human.

Read More
862 Words | 4 Pages

Many Americans blindly believe that animals deserve the same rights as humans, but little do they know about the differences between the welfare of animals and the rights of animals. In the article A Change of Heart about Animals, Jeremy Rifkin cleverly uses certain negative words in order to convince the readers that animals need to be given same rights as humans, and if not more. Research has shown that non-human animals have the ability to “feel pain, suffer and experience stress, affection, excitement and even love” (Rifkin 33). Animals may be able to feel emotions, however this does not necessarily mean that they are able to understand what having rights mean. While humans must accept their moral responsibility to properly care for animals,

Read More
1092 Words | 5 Pages

However when successful, animal testing can have many benefits for humans and animals. This author does not address the other side of the argument and has some biased statements which can lead to polarization in the United

Read More
554 Words | 3 Pages

Since entitlements, freedoms and rights are all affixed, we can then look more closely at the differences between animals, humans and their independent abilities to obtain justices and compassion. Overall, compassion between humans and animals is contrasted due to the vast differences in the species and their understanding of their rights and entitlements for both themselves and each

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

Issues in Society: The Dichotomy of Animal Rights Using animals for our gain is no new prospect; although we’ve elaborated it and made it far more complex throughout our millennia in this, “our” world. Yet, we’ve become delusional, the relationships have only been beneficial for us, and we’ve led ourselves to believe that we are the ‘crème de la crème’ of our little rock floating in space. We forget that animals have been ruling this Earth for hundreds of millions of years, and we are the intruders, albeit the only ones who can make a difference on this planet, for better or worse. It does seem, however, that we’ve opted for the latter, and we’ve enslaved those who share the world with us. It becomes necessary today that we stand for them.

Read More
1461 Words | 6 Pages

Singer and Scruton both present arguments about the position that animals hold in our moral sphere. Singer presents the argument that animals ought to be fully integrated into our moral community and treated equally to humans. Scruton makes a moral distinction between humans and animals, and believes that we are justified in domesticating and eating them. I agree with Scruton’s point that humans should be treated uniquely from animals and that humans do have something morally distinct about them. However, it is important to understand that animals do have the capacity to suffer and we should not exploit them strictly because we find their meat appetizing.

Read More
1016 Words | 5 Pages

We use animals for many purposes it can be for breeding, recreational activities, therapy or as service animals but one of the main reasons for forming human animal bond is to create companionship. Unfortunately this use may result in abuse or exploitation of animals. The critical issues regarding human animal bond are: • Viewing animals as humans rather than recognizing and understanding the need and normal behaviour of the animal, consequently it leads to:  Negligence in the sense that you do not provide adequately the needs of the animal in terms of nutrition which can result in malnutrition or overfeeding your animal which results in obesity of the animal and other health problems.

Read More
784 Words | 4 Pages

I’m here today to talk about a controversial issue that has been around for a period of time, animal testing. Animal testing using animals in experiments with different chemical substances in everything from medical to cosmetic to determine their safety as well as effectiveness . It’s a problem that has existed since the 3rd and 4th centuries BCE with its merciless methods and painful ways of abusing animals for human demands, but now it’s time for it to stop. Our technology has developed significantly since; therefore, such medieval methods of torturing animals are no longer necessary. Researches have shown that each year, over 100 million animals are tortured and killed in American laboratories alone, including dogs, cats and more; this shows how far out of hand animal testing have gotten.

Read More
783 Words | 4 Pages

“Humanity’s true moral test, its fundamental test...consists of its attitude toward those who are at its mercy; animals”. This quote by Milan Kundera summarizes the idea that animals and their well being are constantly being placed in the hands of humans. The relationship between animals and humans is often times abused and not taken seriously. Too many people forget how common and prevalent animal abuse is, even in our own community. Poor treatment of pets should be a pet peeve to everyone because it affects their health, it affects their emotional state, and it is a self chosen responsibility.

Read More
1800 Words | 8 Pages

Animals don’t have the intelligence as high as human beings because of their brain structure. Therefore, it is impossible for them to know humans’ feeling and care about us. It is not the animal’s fault. Animals should not be penalized and killed for our food just because of their inability to care about people. The mental state of animals is similar to the people who have serious intellectual disability.

Read More

More about What's Wrong With Animal Rights By Vicki Hearne

Open Document