ipl-logo

Why Is Macduff's Statement Of Being A Man Is More Meaningful Than Macbeth

623 Words3 Pages

Prompt: Whose statement of being a man is better Macduff’s or Macbeth’s?

Thesis Statement: From my perspective, Macduff’s statement of being a man is more righteous and meaningful then Macbeth’s statement.

Imagine the world where everything has been taken away from you. Would you enjoy your new life or would you do whatever it takes to get everything back? In the play Macbeth, there are three witches that help guide Macbeth to where he is now. In “Act IV Scene I”, the witches warn Macbeth about Macduff and how he is trying to dethrone him. Macbeth thinks the solution of this is to slaughter all of Macduff’s family. This leads to Macduff now wanting to fight Macbeth and avenging his family. Macbeth's definition of being a man is doing whatever it takes to get what he wants. Macduff’s definition of being a man is getting justice for his family. From my perspective, Macduff’s statement of being a man is more righteous and meaningful than the Macbeth’s statement. …show more content…

He discloses to Malcolm that he can cry and sob like a young lady yet rather he wields his sword in the face of Macbeth and run his sword through him (Act IV Lines "246-248"). When you hear that your family is butchered you would separate and cry. It's alright to cry since it's what every single person do, everybody has feelings yet what you do with those feelings. Macduff comprehended what he needed to do which since crying and sobbing is weak which is the reason his meaning of being a man is more grounded than Macbeth's. Rather Macduff would rather face and murder Macbeth is in the face this is not quite the same as Macbeth's murder that was considered as masculine. Macbeth's murder was done oblivious while the King was sleeping, this is the reason I consider Macduff significance of being a man considerably more

Show More
Related

Why Does Macduff Want To Die

435 Words | 2 Pages

(8-10). This quote can show the reader how bad Macduff wants revenge and hopes for Macbeth to die. Macduff then goes on to say that he can kill Macbeth because of the fact he was born different and not technically from

Read More

Examples Of Power Hungry Macbeth

1234 Words | 5 Pages

In the end, everyone looks to Macduff to slay Macbeth, since he is the only one that

Read More

What Role Does Power Guilt Play In Macbeth

810 Words | 4 Pages

Macbeth states that he is not born from a woman like the witches said in one of the prophecies rather he is ripped out of her mother 's womb. Macduff made a decision to do the right thing which was to fight for his country and for Malcolm to be king. Macbeth’s decision to murder changed his whole way of life negatively. With that being said, what goes around does come around.

Read More

Macbeth Unchecked Quotes

864 Words | 4 Pages

He states, “The castle of Macduff I will surprise Seize upon Fife; give to the edge o' the sword His wife, his babes, and all unfortunate souls” (4.1.150-152). At this point Macbeth is out of control and is killing anybody he suspects, showing that he is clearly paranoid and delusional. Once Macduff finds out his family is killed he decides to finally kill

Read More

Macbeth Manhood Quotes Analysis

632 Words | 3 Pages

Manhood is defined as the state or period of being a man rather than a child. The whole Macbeth play is surrounded by manhood. Macbeth was always trying to prove his manhood he always wanted to be the man and the boss of everything and everyone. He made it so difficult for other people to show their manhood and most of the ones that expressed their manhood were killed. Macbeth was the definition of a “man” wanting to control everyone all the time from the citizens of Scotland to his wife, I believe that in that time period it was so common for men to be controlling and bossy and Macbeth always tried to show that there was no one like him and he was not scared to demonstrate how far he could go to let everyone know that he was the boss, he was willing to kill.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Macbeth And Lady Macduff

450 Words | 2 Pages

To compare and contrast the roles of Lady Macbeth in the play, giving close consideration to their relationship their husbands. In the play ‘Macbeth’ we notice that the roles of Lady Macbeth and Lady Macduff are very different. The contrast between these two ladies, is especially noted by each woman’s loyalties and manner of death. These two women, as similar as they were, also had dissimilarities that are far more striking.   Although Lady Macduff and Lady Macbeth each had the ability to influence their family, they used this influence in entirely different ways.

Read More

Infernal Denizens Vs Macbeth

948 Words | 4 Pages

Macduff, a thane, was called to go to a party at the Macbeth’s house but choose not to attend. Then, Macduff goes to England to speak with one of Duncan’s sons. Because of these actions, Macbeth believed that Macduff committed treason. While Macduff is the guilty party, Macbeth has Macduff’s children and wife slain because of his suspicions. All these killings, based on the actions and dialogue from the play, can be classified as different forms of treachery.

Read More

Integrity And Responsibility In Shakespeare's Macbeth

661 Words | 3 Pages

Integrity can be defined as being honest and having strong morals. Being able to balance one’s own integrity and professional responsibility is what determines how successful they will be. If someone’s personal integrity and professional responsibility aren’t balanced, they will interfere with or hinder the other. Ultimately, a person is successful if they can balance their personal integrity and professional responsibility.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Macbeth And Macduff

427 Words | 2 Pages

When Macduff is aware of what Macbeth did, Macduff goes and finds Macbeth and a battle between them commences. Macduff once again proves to be the true hero of

Read More

The Role Of Masculinity In Macbeth And Today

1015 Words | 5 Pages

One of the apparitions warns Macbeth of Macduff. Macbeth kills Macduff’s family in order to lure Macduff to him. While Macduff is searching for Macbeth, he refuses to kill Macbeth's servants because they “Are hired to bear their staves: either thou, Macbeth, / Or else [his] sword with unbattered edge / [He shall] sheathe again undeeded”(Act 5.6.18-20). Shakespeare shows the progression of the meaning of masculinity by contradicting the stereotype of violence that many people had during the 1600’s.

Read More

Theme Of Ambition And Greed In Macbeth

569 Words | 3 Pages

Macduff went to England to find Malcolm, King Duncan’s son, who fled Scotland so he would not be killed like his father. Macbeth no longer considers Macduff loyal to him and becomes apprehensive. Macbeth consorts with the murderers again to kill Macduff’s family, “give to the edge o’ the sword his wife, babes, and all unfortunate souls that trace him in his line” (Act 4, Scene 1). When a messenger comes to deliver the news to Macduff, he becomes sad but Malcolm tells him “… Let grief convert to anger…” (Act 4, Scene 3).

Read More

Gender And Gender Roles In Shakespeare's Macbeth

998 Words | 4 Pages

(IV. III. 260). He wants Macduff to understand that he has to do his deed like a man. It can fail if he back out of his plan at the last moment or he might get hurt himself but the person he is after [Macbeth]. Macduff response showed he took that sentence as a challenge or

Read More

What Are Gender Roles In Macbeth

764 Words | 4 Pages

Line 224). Macduff talks about his manliness and to avenge the murder of his family. Doesn’t have to do with Lady Macbeth, but has to do with the manliness of

Read More

Effects Of Cruelty In Macbeth

1446 Words | 6 Pages

In addition, this shows how much Macbeth has changed through the course of the play. In the beginning of the play, Macbeth was hesitant about killing Duncan and felt extremely guilty after doing so. However, after deciding to kill Macduff’s family, Macbeth doesn’t feel hesitant regarding his decision and doesn’t feel guilty at all. This act of cruelty is ironic because originally this act is committed in order for Macbeth to maintain his power, but instead, it is the final straw that causes his death and downfall. Overall,

Read More

Comparing Leadership In Shakespeare's Macbeth 'And Beowulf'

849 Words | 4 Pages

In Shakespeare’s Macbeth, the protagonist is Macbeth. Macbeth is described at first as a mighty, courageous warrior devoted to King Duncan. However, Macbeth realizes his importance and evil enters his mind, corrupting his motives. While in the poem, Beowulf, the protagonist, Beowulf, is also portrayed as mighty, courageous warrior, but is devoted to King Hrothgar.

Read More

More about Why Is Macduff's Statement Of Being A Man Is More Meaningful Than Macbeth

Related Topics

Open Document