ipl-logo

Xhonneux Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit

1264 Words6 Pages

Xhonneux, L. "The Classic Coming Out Novel: Unacknowledged Challenges to the Heterosexual Mainstream." College Literature, vol. 39 no. 1, 2012, pp. 94-118. Project MUSE, doi:10.1353/lit.2012.0005. Xhonneux argues within her article that Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit does not primarily focus on the protagonist’s sexuality. Instead, the author believes that the novel does not follow a chronological sequence in order to present the reader different sides of Jeanette. For example, Xhonneux points out that when Jeanette was a young child, her train of thought wonders simultaneously as she begins to make new connections with everything around her. As the story progresses, Jeanette’s mind begins to mature. This can be seen, as Xhonneux states, a …show more content…

The author states “Winterson deconstructs Jeanette’s received ideology and demonstrates the ways in which self and reality are narrative” (Reisman 11). She compares the events that occur and the fairytales and states that they allude to Jeanette’s subconscious desires. For example, in one of the fairy tales, a prince searches for the perfect woman and stops at nothing to marry her. Like the prince, as Reisman points out, Jeanette is in search of a ‘perfect’ partner she wishes to be with. Like the fairy tale, she believes she found her perfect princess, Melanie, however, she becomes upset when she realizes Melanie was not a suited partner. Both have great similarities despite the vast differences in time era and the reality of each situation. The author later states that the stories are spaces in which Jeanette’s ‘inner power are stored’. This allows the character to define her true self through negotiation and soul searching, for example, when Jeanette leaves her evangelical home to reflect upon herself. I agree with Reisman’s interpretation of the fairytales and Jeanette’s reality. It is interesting how she believes that each fairy tale gives Jeanette powers. This journal source will help give a better interpretation of the relations between the fairytales and Jeanette’s

Show More
Related
1457 Words | 6 Pages

Landon West Miss Sibbach AP English III 12 December, 2014 Our Eyes Are Watching Oprah In the novel Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston, the author, incorporates details and literary devices that enhance the story and theme of the novel. Oprah did not display these key elements in her film. The relationships and character traits of the characters undergo a change in the movie to suit Oprah’s desires.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

(115-116). This sedate tone is a clear craft move by the author. She specifically makes Jeannie seem resigned and about to give up. Denials of small, everyday, opportunities like this can have a damaging impact on one’s mental health and can create an inferiority complex. For example, Jeanne starts blaming herself and her race for everything that happens to her.

Read More
1291 Words | 6 Pages

When she was moving from house to house she always had to be the bigger person to help her family and her siblings, nothing was easy for her but she learned how to manage finances and how to keep her family afloat. For most of her young years, she had to mentor her siblings and be that strong role model that shaped her siblings into the adults they turned out to be. Jeanette also had to face her past in many ways throughout her life and find ways to move past the painful memories and difficult traumas. She also realized as she got older that her parents were not even close to other children's parents and that with each day that went by her parents were failing her.

Read More
521 Words | 3 Pages

Jeanette grows up living and being pushed around by her parents. Understanding her perspective of her childhood helps us compare that not all children are raised the same. She grew up poor and on the run from whatever trouble her dad got them into. She did not grow up rich or middle class. The lesson taken away from their story if that not all parents' methods of raising their children are easy or reasonable, but not know the do's and don'ts on the wrong and rights or feeding

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Jeanette “was the most successful of [the pack], the one furthest removed from her origins” (232). Because of her progress, she differed from the epigraph, not reacting as negatively to the new environment as the rest of the pack. For example, most of the wolves cringed at the new smells they experienced, but “Jeanette smiled and pretended like she couldn’t smell a thing” (232). This has both a literal and figurative meaning in the text, as it represents how well Jeanette was able to adapt in most circumstances, not just to new smells. However, there were times when even Jeanette suffered the trials described in the epigraph.

Read More
1189 Words | 5 Pages

Through this, she herself had stated she invented parts of the story to fill in the spaces. “I did my best through other sources from the period and place to discover the world they would have seen and the reactions they might have had. What I offer you here is in part of my invention, but held tightly by the voices of the past.” She partially invents aspects of the story for lack of evidence. For example, during the marriage or the original Martin Guerre and Bertrande before he leaves, they are unable to have child for several years.

Read More
448 Words | 2 Pages

“I told him I that I would never lose trust in him, and I promised myself I never would”(76). At this point in the story, Jeannette is the only one who seems to still believe in her father. She looks up to him with a child’s eyes and always wants to be there for him. After failing her everyday, having faith in her father begins to be a struggle for Jeanette, and her tone changes. “If Francie saw the good in her father, maybe I was not a complete fool for believing in mine, or trying to believe in him.

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

They think they can bend the rules and do what they think is necessary. Jeannette is exposed to these understandings, making her the person she grew up to be. Jeanette demonstrates how she struggles with her family throughout numerous portions of the novel: “The Desert,” “Welch,” New York.” These struggles developed and defined who she came to be.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the novel, Jeanette clarifies various occurrences of herself and her kin, fending for themselves, since her

Read More
1788 Words | 8 Pages

As someone who feels as though they are well versed in issues of LGBT discrimination and history, I felt so taken aback by this history of violence and systemic homophobia, and that I wasn’t even fully aware of it’s extent. Feinberg’s writing provided me with a lot of insight relating to current issues and the history of the LGBT movement. The most important thing I think to take away from this novel is to think outside of the binary in terms of gender expression or sexual orientation. Humans are not black and white and neither are their psychological makeups, trying to fit all of humanity into two neat, strict boxes does not work for a vast majority of the population. Realizing that even within the gay and lesbian community pressure to identify as “the man” or “the woman” in a relationship is very real.

Read More
1576 Words | 7 Pages

In her novel Oranges Are not the Only Fruit, Jeanette Winterson describes the conflictual relationship between a profoundly religious adoptive mother and her lesbian daughter, Jeanette. The writer’s decision to give the main character her own name reflects the autobiographical content of the novel, since the story is based on the author’s own life. The first part of the chapter examines how the whole story can be interpreted as a fairy tale, and how the mother’s role profoundly changes according to her attitude towards the heroine-narrator. Secondly, the final reconciliation between the two female characters is analysed. Finally, the reasons for the adoptive mother’s rejection of Jeanette’s lesbian nature are discussed.

Read More
456 Words | 2 Pages

"I Stand Here Ironing" is a powerful and complex short story by Tillie Olsen that explores the challenges faced by women in a patriarchal society. The story centers around a mother reflecting on her relationship with her daughter, Emily, and their difficulties together. Through the mother's voice, the story highlights several feminist themes, including the societal pressures placed on women, the impact of economic and political systems on women's lives, and the importance of solidarity among women. One of the central themes of the story is the role of women in society.

Read More
1831 Words | 8 Pages

Milun: You Forgot about Destiny Many people and even scholars have overlooked destiny being a theme for Marie de France’s work. In which most highlight the idea of love between two lovers. After reading “Milun” by Marie de France, I begin to think about themes that would fit this romantic story, other than the theme of love. Destiny is a major factor in Milun because of the ongoing events that mold the outcome of Milun, the mistress, and their son’s destined future.

Read More
828 Words | 4 Pages

Mallard’s emotional journey. From her initial reluctance to her ultimate freedom, Mrs. Mallard reflects nature’s everchanging beauty. Chopin conducts a symphony of imagery that pieces together the life and death of Louise Mallard. It is evident that Chopin uses Louise Mallard’s story to convey her perception of women and men’s roles during the late 1800’s by showcasing her acceptance of the freedom that could only be gained by a single woman. The descriptions used in Chopin’s work are a marvelous representation of her character’s struggle with inner conflicts.

Read More
3192 Words | 13 Pages

This novel follows the life of a recent college graduate, Marian MacAlpin, through her career and emotional maturation in a somewhat unnatural, if not threatening world. The queer concept of this world is branded by a spectrum of moral viewpoints of gender politics that manifest themselves and surround Marian. The political and cultural values and practices of a male dominated and sex driven society depicted in the novel are so strong that they seem to devour Marian physically and emotionally. She rebels against this cannibalistic, patriarchal society through a comestible mode and the end, reclaims her identity crisis by restoring her relationship with

Read More

More about Xhonneux Oranges Are Not The Only Fruit

Related Topics

Open Document