ipl-logo

Youth Justice System

906 Words4 Pages

am writing to you about a serious concerns I have with regard to the Youth Justice Act in Bill C-10 and Canada 's obligations to protect the rights of children. This bill would have a number of negative impacts to our legal system.
This Bill is very important for The Justice for children with respect to the protection of children. Without having a full assessment of the proposed changes in the Youth Justice System for compliance with our international obligations. Canada risks taking a serious step backward on children 's rights.
Fundamentally, the Youth Justice System needs to be drastically different than the adult system, especially with regards to section 9.2.6 Application of adult sentences to young persons. This section highlights …show more content…

I recognize in certain circumstances the use of mandatory minimum sentences is just, but the expanded use of mandatory minimum sentences should not be addressed in this bill. This could potentially lead to disproportionate sentences which would increase the number of trials. As this would increase the waiting time the courts would have to convince each individual. The proposed amendments will re-frame judicial discretion in favour of a punitive choice that may not be in the young person 's best interests. The re-framing will result in increased levels of youth incarceration in Canada which could lead to an increase in crime. Therefore, creating a “revolving door” whereby the criminal justice system spins out more criminals. Young people will become more entrenched in criminal activity. The bill would increase the frequency and severity of young person’s having negative interactions with the justice system. An example of this is the United States where one can see the effects of a misguided approach to youth justice. In the United States, where severe sentencing occurs, the US should be the safest country in the world. In texis,…. ( add more here) hree-strikes” laws, perhaps the best-known example …show more content…

Courts have acknowledged the negative effect of naming a young person a criminal. We should look for opportunities to decriminalize youth rather than label them. We should give the children success of rehabilitation approaches, the maintenance of judicial discretion is of paramount importance. Legislative choices that seek to constrain judicial discretion should at least be questioned. The proposed amendments to the Youth Criminal Justice Act in the Bill would limit a judge’s ability to fulfill his/her function in the justice system. The expansion of options to sentence a young person to prison, or publish their name and label him/her a criminal, articulates a clear legislative preference to deal with our youth through punitive

Show More
Related

Christopher Lee Simmons Essay

1302 Words | 6 Pages

Director of Justice Reform and the MacArthur Foundation, as well as Christopher Simmons advocate Laurie Garduque reminiscences on the disregard for criminal juveniles during that time: “As concern about increasing juvenile crime peaked, we were alarmed at the wave of harsh juvenile justice reform sweeping the country that blurred lines between adults and juveniles… Existing research did not address the legal implications of adolescent developmental immaturity with respect to competency, culpability, and capacity for change” (“Roper v. Simmons Ten Years Later”). A similar sentiment was shared with Columbia Law School professor Elizabeth Scott, who recalled the conditions for criminal youth in the early 1990’s, asserting that “...attitudes about juvenile crime became more punitive, and it was clear that lawmakers weren’t focusing on developmental differences between teens and adults or how immaturity might contribute to juvenile offending” (“Roper v. Simmons Ten Years Later”). There are a myriad of scary commonalities between these anecdotes, such as the legal disregard for youths despite their underdeveloped brains. There are many factors that make adolescent minds susceptible to committing crimes.

Read More

Strengths And Weaknesses Of Bill C-10 In Canada

1644 Words | 7 Pages

Bill C-10 was introduced by the Minister of Justice on the 20th of September 2011. Bill C-10 is also called the Safe Streets and Communities Act but many believe the title is very misleading. The purpose of this Act is to provide Justice for Victims of Terrorism, Amend the State Immunity Act, the Criminal Code, the Controlled Drugs and Substances Act, the Corrections and Conditional Release Act, the Youth Criminal Justice Act, the Immigration and Refugee Protection Act and Other Acts. This essay will analyze issues that affect the criminal code and provide the strengths and weaknesses of the Bill, and will also provide justification on why or why not the Bill is favouring for Canada to deal with crime and the judicial process.

Read More

Analysis Of The People V. Smith Case

856 Words | 4 Pages

After some time, most courts have taken the stance that the juvenile record of an individual can be thought about by a judge while considering a proper punishment for a now adult offender. “When, however, a juvenile offender appears in court again as an adult, his juvenile offense record may be considered in imposing sentence” (Elrod & Ryder,

Read More

Compare And Contrast State V. Booker

2129 Words | 9 Pages

The Supreme Court’s approach to the constitutionality of an automatic life sentence for juvenile homicide offenders focused on youth charged as juveniles while failing to acknowledge the modern trend to transfer juveniles to adult court for prosecution, resulting in a failure to incorporate protections for juveniles sentenced in adult court. Part II of this comment will review the history of case law concerning sentencing of juvenile offenders. Part III will evaluate the details and holding in Booker. Part IV will evaluate the Court’s reasoning in Booker. Part V will suggest how the Court may further protect juveniles in the justice

Read More

Sentencing Children As Adults By Lawrence Gorski

820 Words | 4 Pages

Anthony S. Tomasso Professor Rodriguez ENG-101 12 APR 2023 The Struggle Between Juvenile and Adult When we as a society picture what age group is the most innocent and precious, we typically agree on children. When a child commits a serious crime such as: rape, murder, armed robbery, many teeter between sentencing that child as an adult rather than a child. In this essay, “Sentencing Children as Adults” by Terence Gorski (2001) discusses the difference in the Juvenile Justice system and how detrimental it is to not place the juvenile child in that system.

Read More

Youth Justice With Integrity Analysis

134 Words | 1 Pages

The literature that has been reviewed directly incorporates the principles set out in Goldson and Muncie “Youth Justice with Integrity”. The analysis of the current justice model attempts to maximize diversion by providing more offences available for extrajudicial measures and the use of measures for re-offenders. Additionally, it is argued that the de-politicization of the youth justice model will help the integrity by providing effective programs and services that will address the social needs of specific individuals within the available resources in the community. The programs and services that are being used are effective, but there are areas of improvement for greater prevention strategies which will hold a person more accountable for

Read More

Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA)

771 Words | 4 Pages

The YCJA was said to solve the political need striking a balance between two contradicting objectives, protecting society from predatory youth, and the desire to avoid unnecessarily criminalizing minor offenders (Tanner, 2012). To accomplish these objectives the Act would follow the principles of accountability and proportionality, youth who commit serious or violent crimes will be punished as harshly as they should be, and minor offenses will be dealt with diversionary measures, such as EJMs (“Emergence of Juvenile Justice Systems”, March 15, 2017). For instance, EJMs that were commonly used included, police and Crown issued warnings, referrals to community programs, counselling, and educational programs, these measures are to avoid needlessly criminalizing youth who have only committed minor

Read More

Youth Criminal Justice Act Essay

1064 Words | 5 Pages

While the effectiviness of the YCJA is a subject of an ongoing debate some people argue that the act is not effectivivley dealing with children who are inviovled in criminal activitity. One commmon criticisism of the YCJA is that it is too leininant on young offenders. For example some people beelive that the act places too much emapapshis on rehibiblatation and reintegration and not enough on punishment. They Argue that this approach does not hold young offenders accountable for their actions and does not deter them from from engaging in in criminal behaviour in the furtutre.

Read More

Judging Juveniles By Aaron Kupchik Summary

816 Words | 4 Pages

Research has shown that transferring adolescents from juvenile court to criminal court increases the recidivism rate. Thus, exposing minors to adult treatment increases crime. Generally, juvenile detention facilities are equip for rehabilitation, offering programs to aid reformation. Society does not hold youth to the same maturity level of an adult. Furthermore, juveniles are not afforded the same rights as adults (e.g. smoking, drinking, voting) because we understand their inability to make responsible decisions.

Read More

Juveniles Tried As Adults

506 Words | 3 Pages

We have seen today in society of how crime rates have been rampant and how statistics show that most of the crimes were being made by minors. I believe that when most of them look at the bottom of these young offenders come disproportionately from impoverished single-parent homes that are located in the neighbourhoods desinvertido and have high rates of learning disabilities, mental health, and substance abuse and problems with the help of the system of juvenile justice that can make a great return on a successful transition to adulthood. Their ages ranged from 20 and under, most are under fifteen years of age. Juveniles tried as adults must assume the same consequences as any other criminal and are subject to state prisons with inmates much higher and that have probably committed crimes much more tortuous then you could ever have. These minors between the ages of nine to twenty according to the offence committed or of the number of times that are prosecuted and believe that it is immutable.

Read More

Juvenile Rehabilitation In Adult Prisons

636 Words | 3 Pages

Juveniles in prison face increased violence and sexual abuse, and are at much higher risks of committing suicide than juveniles in juvenile prisons. In addition, the number of released prisoners that turn back to crime is much higher for those that were juveniles in adult prisons. Juveniles will face the consequences of their actions in juvenile prisons, but will also be given a second chance to change their lives through rehabilitation. It is time to stop failing this nation’s juveniles and build a system that benefits not only these children, but society as a whole through the end of a vicious criminal

Read More

YCJA Pros And Cons

412 Words | 2 Pages

The YCJA, Youth Criminal Justice Act is a federal law was proposed in 2002 and came into effect on April 1 in 2003. The main purpose of this act is to separate youth offenders aging from 12 to 17 from the adults and immaculately protect the right of youth offenders to the maximum and provide rehabilitation and reintegration for them, because the rights of youth offender outweigh the safety of the public. In addition, a particularly successful policy is the rehabilitation and reintegration of youth offenders, this policy is clearly illustrated by the Medicine Hat case. An essential policy of the YCJA is the rehabilitation and the reintegration of youth offenders, this policy provides assistance for youth offenders to realize the crucial mistake they’ve made in the

Read More

Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults In Criminal Court?

1979 Words | 8 Pages

In today’s world there are countless crimes committed every single day. “In 2015, there were 1.42 million total arrests, at a rate of 3,641 arrests per 100,000 residents” (State of California, Department of Justice). Grown adults are not the only people being arrested every year, there are also juveniles, children, being arrested every day. One topic of controversy today is whether or not juveniles who commit these crimes should be tried as adults in criminal court. There are many differences between the justice system for adults and the justice system for juveniles.

Read More

Juvenile Crime Annotated Bibliography

1043 Words | 5 Pages

Annotated bibliography Childress, S. (2016, June 2). More States Consider Raising the Age for Juvenile Crime. Retrieved from PBS: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/frontline/article/more-states-consider-raising-the-age-for-juvenile-crime/ More states are considering to raising the age for juvenile crimes before being tried as adult because young offender's mental capacity. The idea is to cut the cost of incarcerate young offender in adult prison and ensure offenders to receive proper education and specialized care to change their behavior. Putting children in adult prison does not deter crime.

Read More

Juveniles Should Not Be Treated The Same As Adults Essay

760 Words | 4 Pages

Can you imagine waking up behind closed walls and bars? Waking up to see your inmate who is a 45-year-old bank robber and you are a 14-year-old minor who made a big mistake. This is why minors who have committed crimes should not be treated the same as adults. Some reasons are because the consequences given to minors in adult court would impact a minor’s life in a negative way. If a minor is tried through a juvenile court, they have a greater chance of rehabilitation.

Read More

More about Youth Justice System

Related Topics

Open Document