INTRODUCTION Through the story of coming of a Japanese car making firm Assan Motors to the American town of Hadleyville, Ron Howard’s movie Gung Ho beautifully portrays how businesses are affected when people from different cultures come together to work as a team. Hunt Stevenson, played by Keaston, entices Assan Motors to Hadleyville where he is offered the position of ‘employee liaison in the joint venture. But soon, internal conflicts begin as both the Japanese and the Americans had very different styles of operation, which were mainly due to the differences in their cultural values. HOFSTEDE DIMENSIONS OF NATIONAL CULTURE To better understand this, I will use Hofstede Dimensions of National Culture to examine the various facets of cultural …show more content…
INDIVIDUALISM VERSUS COLLECTIVISM This dimension helps in measuring the tendency of people to integrate with the larger groups. The movie very comically compares the Collectivistic culture of Japan with the Individualistic values of American society. On the first day of the venture, Kazihiro in his address to the American workers says that “We must build spirit…. We must be a team, one, with one purpose only. Everyone thinking only of the company.” To build this spirit, he makes all the workers exercise together which is mocked by the American workers. It was only when Stevenson began doing calisthenics that the workers joined him doing their own exercise rather than following the Japanese procedure. Thus, from the very outset of the merger, American individualism and Japanese collectivism have been at loggerheads In another instance, one of the American workers named Willie is shown upset for being docked for taking the afternoon off to be with his son who was having his tonsils removed. When Stevenson tries to reconcile with Kazihiro by clarifying that, “The guy just lives for his kids”, Kazihiro replies, “But work …show more content…
MASCULINITY VERSUS FEMININITY Japanese culture has been shown to have a highly masculine orientation with high penchant for perfectionism and workaholism. American culture, though on a lower scale in Hofstede’s masculinity index as compared to Japanese, still places a high value on personal achievements. The Japanese and American masculinity orientations have been poignantly showcased at the end of the movie, Gung Ho when the workers realize that they are falling short of the 15,000 production goal. To try to meet the goal, the American workers decide they can take some shortcuts and Keaton’s character says, “Now on these last few, we might need to cut a few corners. Just little things, like…engines” When Japanese management inspects the last vehicles and finds them to be far less perfect from the way then had expected they decide to fire the workers. Another instance of Masculinity in Japanese culture becomes evident when Audrey and Stevenson go to Kazihiro’s home for dinner. After the meal, when Kazihiro wanted to discuss business and wanted Audrey to leave, she stays. Instead she says, “Well actually I’m kind of interested in what’s going on at the plant. Nobody minds if I stay,
The author of this article is Robert Jensen. He is a journalist professor at the University of Texas at Austin. Jensen’s writing and teaching focus on interrogating power structures of race and gender. He also wrote and published The End of Masculinity; therefore this is a topic that he feels really strongly about. Jensen first published the article “The High Cost of Manliness” to argue for an end to the conception of manliness.
This is a situation that corporations and managers use as an example of how cultures can affect profits, convey the wrong message, and create hostility toward a community. Managers working in foreign and domestic locations, are to consider the effects and backlash from opposing cultures in todays digital
The articles in this essay will give three different insights on how American culture is perceived based on observations and first hand experiences. Jennifer Price used the trend of the pink flamingo to describe a time of new and vibrant change that has shaped its culture to be strong and optimistic. Richard Rodriguez gives his first hand experience of being a part of two different cultures to give a comparison between totally opposite places with their own traditions and customs. Finally, Scott Sanders presents his belief of ideas are more important to the American people than the places which they live in. All of these writers all give substantial information of their viewpoints which combined makes up the identity of American culture.
One of the most basic aspects of life is work and having a job. It is usually a requirement for a stable life and of utmost importance to people. Richard Nixon’s “Address to the Nation on Labor Day” highlights the work ethic as “ingrained in the American character”. He explains that the competitive spirit is central to the character and takes another name as work ethic (Nixon). Work’s importance is also expressed through the cultural icon of Rosie the Riveter.
Anna Martin Play Marathon Paper: All The Way Hist Lit 4 29 April 2016 The Good, the Bad, and the Dirty: Power and Politics in All The Way The play All The Way by Robert Schenkkan is reminiscent of documentary style theatre, particularly the monologues of Anna Deavere Smith, because both sources take dialogue from previously recorded transcripts: Smith from interviews she conducted with members of Crown Heights, Brooklyn for her one person play Fires in the Mirror, and Schenkkan from samplings of recorded dialogue straight from phone calls made by President Lyndon Johnson.
3.2 The Individualism and Collectivism Reflected in The Joy Luck Club Individualism - collectivism, according to Hofstede statistics, China 's index is 20, while the United States is 91. It is clear that Chinese culture is attributed to the collectivist culture, and American culture is attributed to the individualistic culture. Individualism people tend to care about themselves and small families, more respect for a person 's values, dignity and power. Individualist children learn to think from the perspective of “I”. Outspoken is honest man 's performance.
In Robert Jensen’s article “The High Cost of Manliness”, he states that the idea of masculinity is a bad thing and they should get rid of it. This article debates on the common stereotypes of men, as he states: “That dominant conception of masculinity in U.S. Culture is easily summarized: Men are assumed to be naturally competitive and aggressive, and being a real man is therefore marked by the struggle for control, conquest, and domination” (par. 4). Nonetheless, there are some traits that men and woman share, such as, caring, compassion, and tenderness. These traits often depend on the situation, since a man cannot always be this way, whereas, a woman is often expected to have these traits.
The first is personal achievement. This is shown when the parents are proud of Bud’s success in the science fair and when the dad is invited into the “Chamber of Commerce”. Individualism is sort of resented in their society because any individuality would go against the balance of their society. For example, the citizens hated the art created by Bill. The other side of individualism is the hard work of a person which is exemplified by the idea of the “American dream” portrayed in the movie.
He helped his coworkers with their work. By hammering away in the early morning. John Henry has the strength. But in despair sets in the coworkers when the railroad sends a steam hammer to replace the crew and burns the contract. John Henry purposes a challenge: man against machine.
Advocate individualism in the American film through personal struggle, self-reliance, pioneering, enterprising, to achieve the "American dream". Despise or ignore the individualism, may lead to dislocation of the behavior or the opposite result. The United States is in the European immigrants as the main body established on the basis of, as a result, American culture are built on the basis of European culture. It inherits the European traditional culture, which also includes the European spirit of individualism and heroism.
For example, consumers are becoming more similar in terms of lifestyles, income, aspirations and education. In order to clarify my statement, I would like to apply Hofstede’s dimensions of national culture. Masculinity and femininity is one of the Hofstede’s dimensions. The dominant values of masculine culture are achievement and success while dominant values in feminine cultures are caring for quality of life and others. The country that possesses the most masculine culture is Japan, which scores 95 (Geert and Mariake de, 2002).
1) What are the cultural dimensions Hofstede proposes? Please include a definition of each and how is each one rated? The Cultural dimensions Hofstede proposes are four dimensions that represent elements of common structure in the cultural systems of the countries. They are based on four very fundamental issues in human societies to which every society should find its answers.
Masculinity versus femininity This dimension doesn’t correlate directly with gender roles or behaviours. Instead this is more orientated towards specific traits that Hofstede has defined as masculine and low masculine (femininity). A high masculine culture is characterized by focusing on money, possessions, and traditional family values. Feminine cultures are said to be relationship oriented, focused on quality of life, and failing is generally more accepted. This is best describe by the commonly used phrase “Americans live to work, while Europeans work to live.
Criticism: Lazonick (1993) took up the challenge with porter regarding the issues of rivalry, issues regarding rivalry alone cannot pressure firm to produce more innovative products. When a firms faces too many issues from their competitors, they may rather choose to imitate their competitors’ products than innovate products at their own risk. When foreign competitors come up to take challenges with firms, firms would rather choose to be cooperative the business with their current competitors to prevent decline of products. Porter’s diamond framework concept most of the time focuses on the home based market due to competitiveness of a national business system is usually derive from their home based market (Porter, 1990). Single diamond framework
Culture is comprise of religion values ,economy ,languages ,class ,material items ,social institutions ,customs ,manners ,education, policies and attitudes (Czinkota & Ronkainen ,1993).Kirkman and Shapiro (2001) described that cultural diversity affect the management styles .He stated that managers with different cultural backgrounds showed different behavior, attitudes, beliefs and basic values. Moveoneinc (2013) stated that culture has prodigious impact over the management style. For example, in Japanese firms almost all employees are participating in the process of decision making. But in the society of America, only top management is involved in the decision making of important and vital matters. In the same way, reward systems are designed on individual performance in western countries and America whereas individual performance has less significance in Japanese firms.