Growing up, I have always had an interest in geography and thinking about different countries and what makes them the way that they are. I have not been in a geography class since middle school and Human Geography was a class that made me think about things I have never thought of before. The readings of both Kropotkin and Mackinder brought up very interesting points, some that conflict and others that agree. Each author writes in a way that stimulates and makes you think about geography and certain topics in different ways which I find to be very rare in writings from this time period. Discussing Kropotkin’s and Mackinder’s general ideas, points they disagree or agree on, and my own views on the topic will all be discussed in this final paper. …show more content…
Mackinder’s writing seems to take on a much more formal tone as opposed to Kropotkin. One of the first major questions that Mackinder asks about geography itself, is, “Is geography one, or is it several subjects? (Mackinder 156). He brings up the specific point of contrasting physical and political geography. This is an important distinction again from the writings of Kropotkin, in that Kropotkin as discussed geography as it were one all-encompassing subject and discipline. Mackinder’s main point is to propose a definition of geography in which it is a science that functions to trace the interaction between man and society as well as his environment. This is a much more specific definition than what Kropotkin had …show more content…
With this statement, Mackinder makes a claim and says that no rational political geography can function without being built upon the ideas of physical geography. He says the idea of political geography is currently based upon no principles of physical geography and must not be considered a true discipline. This defines the complex and typically unseen relationship between political and physical geography, “Geography is like a tree which early divides into two great branches, whose twigs may none the less be inextricably interwoven.” (Mackinder 159). After Mackinder makes an interesting claim about how the rivalry between physical geographers and geologists are perceived. He claims that the physical geographer has hurt their field by only including the most basic principles of geology. What Mackinder really believes is that a geologist looks at the present to interpret the past, while a physical geographer looks at the past to interpret the present. The views of Mackinder to vary largely when opposed to the views of Kropotkin on what geography is or “ought” to
Regionalist Richard White argues that "[i]t is this sense of historically derived relationships … that is central to the regionalism of the New Western History" (qtd. in Neel 114), defining the West as the result of conquest and the interchanges within the variety of groups and cultures in this specific territory, logically indicating intense struggles and conflicts over possession of land and natural resources. Limerick defines those relationships as a conquest, meaning "the drawing of lines on a map, the definition and allocation of ownership … and the evolution of land from matter to property" (qtd. in Neel 114). Worster concludes by shaping the western identity as a result out of adaption of modes of production.
Carter Short Dixion 10/24/17 CJ 111 Richard Kuklinski Richard Kuklinski is definitely a one of a kid human being. He has no remorse for anything. Through his whole childhood he was abused by his father and mother, as well as his brother. He was beating everyday by his father when he would come home from work.
Warkentin’s text has a very broad overview of the historical background but still is able to explain the fundamentals. It is in the post-war growth sections of both the text that the reader is able to distinguish BC from the other provinces as a powerhouse region. While Bone remained very broad and covered a variety of topics minimally, Warkentin veered to a more specific body of text. Warkentin’s chapter has a more in-depth overview of each sub-region described in the text, allowing for a different viewpoint of the province compared to Bone’s style. While Bone’s text is broader in its subject, it is much simpler put; and is easier to follow along.
#1 - In what ways was geography crucial to the establishment of the small kingdoms and empires we have discussed thus far? Paragraph 1: Throughout all of history, geography has impacted the way small kingdoms and empires have been created. The Phoenicians are impacted by living on the coast and the Persians are impacted by living on the fertile crescent of Mesopotamia.
The physical domain of the country had its counterpart in me. The trails I made led outward into the hills and swamps, but they led inward also. And from the study of things underfoot, and from reading and thinking, came a kind of exploration, myself and the land. In time the two became one in my mind. With the gathering force of an essential thing realizing itself out of early ground, I faced in myself a passionate and tenacious longing— to put away thought forever, and all the trouble it brings, all but the nearest desire, direct and searching.
Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia, 13 Oct. 2017. Web. 2 Nov. 2017. https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=1&ved=0ahUKEwjT2-rMzI7XAhXC8YMKHcRZDjgQFggoMAA&url=https%3A%2F%2Fen.wikipedia.org%2Fwiki%2FGeography_of_Florida&usg=AOvVaw3MBuLBNfYqDMgLgEd0VN06 Geography of Massachusetts/ Wikipedia "Geography of Massachusetts." Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia.
This book is a wonderful that relates the history of the Oregon Trail. Coupled with that history is the experience and personal history of the Rinker Buck who decide to traverse the entire trail in a covered wagon with his brother, Nick. Rinker Buck brings an historical bend to the trail portion. Not only does he give it is history, but Rinker Buck often puts the trail in its unique perspective as a molder of USA and reflection of much of our psyche. Spreading west and expanding ?
In the world there are amazing regions to explore and see. However, we usually don’t see them in person. Writers use the fact that readers may not know anything about their region, but are able to read or experience the region the writers provide. In fact, Twain uses this to his advantages to talk about his home village near the Mississippi River, as well as, Jewett shows us the wilderness in Maine. Jewett and Twain uses regionalism throughout both of their writings, by creating their own types of settings.
b. How do you describe the geography of Asia? Discuss the physical boundaries that separate Asia from Europe and Africa. What were the reasons for the drawing of such boundaries?
Harm de Blij’s Why Geography Matters: More Than Ever explains the necessity of geographic knowledge in today’s society and the need to further expand interactions within the United States and other countries. This novel expands on the economic, cultural, physical, and political geography of our nation. De Blij outlines on the importance of geographic thought by focusing on climate change, terrorism, the rise of states, and development in Africa.. I believe that while geography has proven to make a noticeable difference in the knowledge of our vast world, it will require an extensive amount of effort in order to make geography known.
Geography impacts society, cultures, the economy, politics, and the environment around the world. To dig deeper and know why geography affects a variety of things the definition of this world should be known. Geography is the study of where things are found on Earth’s surface and the reasons for their locations. It is studied everywhere from countries in Asia to cities in The United States, such as Houston, Texas. Houston, Texas is a city of more than 2.3 million people.
In Bill Bryson’s memoir “The Lost Continent”, the writer goes on a trip across the United States to relive his childhood memories with the perspective of an adult. This book documents his observations of the ‘forgotten’ parts of America. While this book did not impact my life in any way, some of the content was thought provoking and insightful. The part’s of the book that affected me most were his personal motivations, reflections upon small towns, and First, Bryson’s motivations were interesting because they made me think about my own inspirations.
In the chapter “Geography Matters”, Thomas C. Foster explains the effect of geography on a story. Geography contributes greatly to themes, symbols, and plot, and most authors prefer to use setting as a general area with a detailed landscape rather than a specific city or landmark. In Cormac McCarthy’s The Road, he does not reveal the actual region of America that the man and boy are traveling in, but describes the mountains and eventual beaches of their path. McCarthy might not have revealed their location because it might ruin the reader’s interpretation of the setting. For example, the pair come across a generic “gap” between mountains and this is a turning point because it confirms the man’s planned path to the south.
In his book Understanding Cultural Geography, Places and Traces (2010), Anderson argues that cultural geography contributes to and affects place. He states that: “cultural life does not take place in a vacuum. ”(1) Instead various "things ideas, practices, and emotions occur within a context" (1). Anderson defines the interest in this context as the study of geography.
Physical geographers apply the positivist approach in trying to understand the physical world. Bennett defines positivism as “a philosophy of meaning, of what you say that something is true, when you offer it as something which others must also accept because it is, according to some allegedly neutral standard true” (2009, 310). In this paper the way in which geographers use the positivist theory to understand the physical world will be discussed along with the advantages and limitations of using this method. There are a host of factors involved in the positivistic approach to physical geography. Physical geography is viewed by many as being hands on work with less theory.