ipl-logo

No God But God Analysis

1211 Words5 Pages

Based upon your own assessment of the movie "The Message" and your reading of No God but God, write a cogent essay on Diversity in pre-Islamic Mecca and Medina.
Pre Islamic Mecca and Medina was known to be very diverse with people coming together from different races, nationalities, religions, and genders to form a varied community. It is interesting how a desert area known for its barren and uniform landscape created such a richly diverse community. From the movie The Message by Mustapha Akkad, and the book No God but God by Reza Aslan we can see that this diversity in the desert was mainly due to the presence of the Kaba, a universal sanctuary where Gods of many religions resided, and the proximity of Mecca and Medina to the red sea that made them ideal resting grounds for travelers. In this essay, I will analyze the level of diversity and its effect on pre-Islamic Mecca and Medina using the movie The Message and the book No God but God.
It is clear from both sources we viewed in class that pre-Islamic Mecca and Medina had great religious diversity. In his book No God but God, Reza Aslan claims that “In all, there are said to be three hundred sixty idols housed in and around the Kaba, representing every god recognized in the Arabian Peninsula.” Therefore people from all over Arabia congregated in this area to worship their gods. This image is clearly presented in the movie The Message where we see the many different gods being worshipped around the Kaba like the god Hubel

Show More
Related

  • Spread Of Islam Dbq Analysis

    769 Words  | 4 Pages

    The lucrative location of the beginnings of Islam lead many merchants to trade while spreading the culture. Mecca, Islam’s headquarters, was in the crossroads of the world and in a perfect location for trade, which led to the spread of the culture. In a map created

    Read More

  • Apush Dbq The Spread Of Islam

    442 Words  | 2 Pages

    To conclude, military was the main reason for the spread of Islam. Between vast Muslim rule, The Pact, and the Muslims victory at the battle of Yarmouk, it is clear that the military set the pace for Islam’s rapid development and growth. In doing this Islam had overruled the majority of the middle east by

    Read More

  • Why Did Islam Spread So Quickly Dbq

    618 Words  | 3 Pages

    First, it was at the crossroads of the lucrative caravan trade.” This shows that since Mecca was such an important trade stop, many people from all over the area would pass through. Document A also states, “Two empires, Persia and the Byzantine Empire, shown on the map are in relation to Arabia because they surround it.” This

    Read More

  • The Grammar Of God Summary

    1847 Words  | 8 Pages

    Aviya Kushner, the author of The Grammar of God, was raised in an Orthodox Jewish family where not only was Hebrew her first language and language studied/spoken it school, moreover, it went beyond simply speaking it in home and class, rather, her family culture was vested in discussing, reveling in, and questioning the grammar, meaning, and overall language of the ancient Hebrew text: The Bible. When Kushner came across an English translation of the Bible for the first time, she writes about how she did not seem to recognize the thing she loved dearly. This jolting surprise in a Graduate school course led her on the path to write this book that examines the role of language, translation, and what it all means. The heart of the book seeks to

    Read More

  • Africa In The Post-Classical Era

    807 Words  | 4 Pages

    In North Africa the Berber merchants were one of the major groups that traded with Sub-Saharan West Africa through the Trans-Saharan trade routes. The Berber merchants played an essential part in dispersing the Islam and its traditions into Sub-Saharan West Africa since they frequently used the Sahara to trade. When Islam made its way into Sub-Saharan West Africa, it was absorbed into their society but unlike in other societies, Islam merged with the existing animistic culture. A majority of the Sub-Saharan West African population didn’t convert to Islam but remained animistic. The people who converted were merchants and elite rulers.

    Read More

  • Explain Why Did Islam Spread So Quickly Dbq

    512 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Document A, it states,” By the middle of the 6th century… Mecca was … prosperous and important.” Mecca is prosperous and important meaning that people would trade there often and people may travel the routes and spread the religion and since it was important, people went there tremendously so people would trade religions and praise Islam. Plus in Document C, it shows that Islam spread in the vast region through Muhammad followers. Muhammad had many followers which meant that he had a variety of people teaching Islam.

    Read More

  • Elie's Belief In God Analysis

    451 Words  | 2 Pages

    Milos Kulina Elie’s faith towards God changes a lot as the story goes on. In the beginning of the work, his faith in God is complete. In chapter one when asked why he prays to God, he says, “Why did I pray? ... Why did I live?

    Read More

  • Why College Matters To God Analysis

    639 Words  | 3 Pages

    Why College Matters to God In the introductory chapter of Why College Matters to God, the author focused on what a worldview is and why it is important in a Christian college setting. According to the author, “A worldview is a framework of ideas, values, and beliefs about the basic makeup of the world.” One point made was that worldviews are more about actions, not just beliefs.

    Read More

  • Mansa Musa Dbq

    284 Words  | 2 Pages

    There are 5 pillars of Islam, one being a Hajj to Mecca, that Muslims take part in to prove that they are good Muslims. Mansa Musa went on a Hajj for his religion, but he had other intentions for participating in this journey. Mansa Musa was a very wealthy leader of Mali who decided to go on this pilgrimage to Mecca to complete one of the 5 pillars of Islam, and he gave some of his gold to people who lived in the cities along the way where salt was abundant and gold was very valuable. Mansa Musa went to Mecca for his religion, but had other motivating factors. Mansa Musa could have gone through Timbuktu, but instead he decided to go the longer route, through Taghaza and Walata.

    Read More

  • Malcolm X Central Idea Analysis

    495 Words  | 2 Pages

    When he arrives in Mecca he is astounded to find that there are people of all races and colors here that are not being discriminatory towards each other and throughout the rest of his journey he begins to see the true face of Islam and sees the error in Elijah Muhammad’s teachings. This affects the central idea of integration vs separation since he saw that it is completely possible for white people and black people to coincide, they just need to actually respect each other and not judge based on the other one’s

    Read More

  • Dbq The Spread Of Islam

    635 Words  | 3 Pages

    (Document D) Muhammad’s changing of the ghazu made Arabs reach further out of the Muslim territories into Persia, Byzantium, and beyond. The Arabs were able to defeat the Persians and Byzantines so easily because for decades the two countries had been in series of wars.(Document D) The Arabs continued to maul countries in their path, and because of this, the Ummah (Muslim Community) continued to grow. Mecca (held Arabia’s holiest Pagan shrine) was an important trading center before Muhammad was born.

    Read More

  • Jesus And Muhammad Parallel Lives Summary

    969 Words  | 4 Pages

    This book portrays Jesus and Muhammad, two powerful religious leaders, and compares and contrasts various aspects of each of their lives and religions. In his book, Peters explains how two leaders with different faiths and beliefs can be similar in various aspects of life. In his book, Peters offers the first printed extremely in-depth

    Read More

  • West Africa Compare And Contrast Essay

    947 Words  | 4 Pages

    The societies of West Africa, Europe, and North America exhibited similarities and differences in their religious beliefs, values, and government systems. These contrasts and similarities were further made apparent during European expansion across the Atlantic and the subsequent new cross cultural interactions that were created. One way in which the societies of West Africa, Europe, and North America diverged was in their belief systems. Unlike Europe and North America, West Africa gradually adopted Islam in addition to its traditional religions. Islam diffused through the trans-Saharan trade with North Africa and by the 1200’s was assimilated into the Mali and Songhai Empire.

    Read More

  • Comparing The Hebrew Bible And The Ifa-Yoruba Tradition

    1132 Words  | 5 Pages

    They differ significantly in many ways, including the ideas of monotheism versus polytheism, mythical versus historical contexts, and the role and significance of the figures in their respective traditions, even though they have some common themes, such as the belief in divine creation and the significance of cosmic order. Oduduwa's legendary origins and symbolic significance in Yoruba culture are highlighted in the Ifa-Yoruba Tradition birth narrative, whereas Muhammad's historical significance as the last prophet and the influence of his teachings on the growth of Islam are highlighted in the account of his life. By exploring and appreciating the richness and diversity of these narratives, we can foster a greater understanding and appreciation for the complexities of different religious traditions and promote interfaith dialogue and

    Read More

  • The Gods Must Be Crazy Analysis

    1028 Words  | 5 Pages

    The film “The Gods Must Be Crazy” shows the difference between the culture of the Bushmen and modern society through the interactions between socialized members of each of the cultures. The differences can be noticed in the characters’ actions, values, views, etc. The film shows the differences between human cultures, as well as the ethnocentrism. The bushmen culture is basically of simplicity and contentment.

    Read More

More about No God But God Analysis

Open Document