ipl-logo

A Comparison Of Trauma In Maus And The Best We Could Do

1823 Words8 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Essay reliving trauma memory

We Could Do in Representing Trauma and Educating Against Repetition

Maus by Art Spiegelman and The Best We Could Do by Thi Bui are two graphic novels that provide poignant insights into the experience of trauma, both on a personal and a collective level. While the two stories differ in their specific contexts and historical backgrounds, they share common themes that illustrate the complexity and long-lasting effects of trauma. This paper will outline three points that both Maus and The Best We Could Do address in their portrayal of trauma. Firstly, both novels depict the ways in which trauma can be inherited across generations. In Maus, Art Spiegelman grapples with the traumatic legacy of his father's experiences during the Holocaust, which …show more content…

Secondly, both novels highlight the ways in which trauma can fracture and reshape identity. Spiegelman's father struggles with his Jewish identity in the aftermath of the Holocaust, while Art himself grapples with the legacy of his father's trauma and the weight of his family history. Similarly, in The Best We Could Do, Thi Bui's experiences of displacement and cultural dislocation shape her sense of self and her relationship with her family and her Vietnamese heritage. Through their narratives, both authors illustrate the complex ways in which trauma can shape and reshape identity and the ongoing process of coming to terms with one's own history and legacy. Finally, both novels emphasize the importance of memory and storytelling in the process of healing from trauma and why this should be integrated into education. Spiegelman uses the graphic novel format to weave together his father's personal story with broader historical events, creating a multifaceted portrait of trauma and survival. In The Best We Could Do, Bui uses images and text to convey the complexity of her family's experiences and to …show more content…

One of the most significant ways in which Maus conveys generational trauma is through the portrayal of Vladek's experiences during the war and how it has affected his modern day behavior. The novel depicts the atrocities of the Holocaust in a powerful and visceral way, showing the reader the horrors that Vladek and other survivors were forced to endure. Generational trauma involves a range of traumatic experiences, such as starvation, isolation, and other harrowing encounters. In Maus, Vladek endures unimaginable hardships, including going for days without food, water, or sleep. The Germans subjected him and others to forced labor, incessant killing, and brutal treatment, reducing Vladek to a state of mere survival rather than truly living. By conveying these aspects, the novel highlights the ongoing impact of trauma and how it can continue to affect individuals long after the

Show More
Related
697 Words | 3 Pages

The focus of this paper is the core concept that traumatic events may cause changes in one’s family life, reminders the traumatic experience, and other adversities in relation to the trauma. Amarika, an 18-month-old girl, was with her mother in the park when a stray bullet from gang violence hit Makisha, Her mother. This initial event caused many changes in Amarika’s life. Makisha had complications from surgery and had to stay in the hospital for an extended period of time. When Makisha was to return home, the family also faced the distress of her rehabilitation.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

The circumstances in which these characters find themselves may make it difficult for readers to emotionally engage with their stories, as the horrors of the Holocaust are a heavy topic. Additionally, the choices and sacrifices these characters make may cause uncomfortable questions and feelings, challenging readers to confront their own values and

Read More
1083 Words | 5 Pages

Throughout history, humans have encountered adversity and challenges in big and small ways. The Holocaust is one of the most horrible cases of persecution and oppression in the history of the world. In this essay, we’ll see how Maus by Art Spielgman and Often a Minute by Magdalena Klein explore the Holocaust. Maus is a graphic novel about Vladek, a survivor of the Holocaust, and his story. On the other hand, Often a Minute is a poem about the injustices of the Holocaust.

Read More
1626 Words | 7 Pages

By using such heavy emotions, both authors were able to articulate their experiences with the Holocaust and those around them. The two authors also successfully managed to capture an audience that appeals outside of the works timeframe. With an event as memorable as the Holocaust, it’s not difficult to focus plenty of attention on the event, but both authors managed to appeal to people who could not possibly have any real insight on the happenings of the Holocaust. The

Read More
872 Words | 4 Pages

Ultimately, these two vignettes both highlight how trauma can be an inescapable burden that some have to carry for decades before being able to work through

Read More
739 Words | 3 Pages

Tim O’Brien’s book “The Things They Carried” has many stories of people's different experiences with war. The three stories (“The Man I Killed”, “Ambush” and “Good Form”) all have the same way of writing that makes it clear to the reader how they know the emotions of the narrator's trauma. How they communicate those types of emotion, and how the people around them reassure them. Susan Farrell gave some of her opinions off of it that she put into a review.

Read More
1305 Words | 6 Pages

The lasting impact of trauma is powerfully demonstrated in Jesse Thistle’s memoir, From the Ashes, highlighting how he navigated through

Read More
1108 Words | 5 Pages

Instead of the traditional and mainstream verbal memoir, David Small chose to confine into an autobiological memoir, Stitches: A Memoir, with a comic medium that details the darkest periods of his childhood as a prelude to healing. Small demonstrates the rough parts of his past that shaped his life and the relationships between himself and his dysfunctional family by encoding these moments into vividly drawn emotions and sensations. Small experienced traumatic things both physical and psychological, yet despite this, he was able to work through it. This way of using graphic text was David’s take on using illustrations as an outlet to deal with traumatic experiences.

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brien displays Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) to a reader who is not familiar with what it is perfectly because of the many different perspectives and examples he gives in his stories. National Geographic started a program where war veterans could create a mask to show their experiences after the war. This is such an important program because it helps soldiers express themselves in a way that they can not do so with words, and it also spreads awareness to anybody who wants to look at the masks. Many of these masks happen to relate to the themes of different stories in The Things They Carried, both the stories and the masks are a great way to understand someone

Read More
1504 Words | 7 Pages

The novel focuses on coping with the death and horror of war. It also speaks volumes about the true nature of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) and the never-ending struggle of dealing with it. In the

Read More
1196 Words | 5 Pages

Despite the brave front that Vladek has put in the years following the war, his story remains to be a tale of suffering, agony, and death. The story of Vladek’s survival during the Holocaust is the central aspect of the novel,

Read More
1314 Words | 6 Pages

Dario Robison Mrs.Burns Pre-Ap ELA ll 06 January 2023 We, humans, have the amazing ability to retain experiences in our minds creating memories, and whether these memories are positive or negative, we learn from them. However, sometimes we have experiences that affect us in such a distressing way that they form trauma. These traumatic experiences can change how we look at things, including people, situations, and experiences. And even though it may have happened far in the past, it will stick with us for a long time into the future. We learn about how trauma affects people in the novel “The Joy Luck Club”.

Read More
649 Words | 3 Pages

Spiegelman also address the issue of post memory, and how it effected his family and his life. He also was very truthful in the way he told the story, it seemed as though he did not leave a single piece out. All in all, they way Spiegelman captures the tone of the story, along with its writing style successfully tells his father’s

Read More
1068 Words | 5 Pages

The Holocaust, death, and sexual identity are three very deep and profound subjects, and the comic medium helps bring these topics to life. No longer is the comic the silly humor on the back of your newspaper. Before comics used to be a form of cheap, low-class art. Spiegelman and Bechdel show that comics are even more complex than the most sophisticated high-class art. The graphic novel is a powerful literary weapon that helps authors explain the complicated and subtle nuances that are crucial to the greater story.

Read More
1240 Words | 5 Pages

Exploring Survivor's Guilt Throughout Art Spiegelman’s Novel Maus The Holocaust was a dark chapter in human history, and its aftermath continues to affect generations to this day. In the graphic novel Maus by Art Spiegelman, we are presented with a powerful and unique account of this tragedy, told through the eyes of a survivor and his son. Among the many themes explored in the graphic novel, one that stands out most is survivor's guilt. This intense emotion is not solely limited to those who lived through the Holocaust, but is also experienced by their children.

Read More

More about A Comparison Of Trauma In Maus And The Best We Could Do

Related Topics

Open Document