ipl-logo

A Critical Analysis Of Bacon's 'Declaration And Remonstrance'

1423 Words6 Pages

Critical Analysis: “Declaration and Remonstrance” Preceding the events unfolded in Nathaniel Bacon’s Rebellion, William Berkeley released a strong statement, Declaration and Remonstrance, in the hopes of persuading the public to not start a revolt. In this essay, I compare the contradicting points of both Nathaniel Bacon’s Bacon’s Manifesto and William Berkeley’s Declaration and Remonstrance with a focus on how Berkeley thoroughly combats arguments made by Bacon. The 1670s proved to be a critical time for colonial America; tensions with Native Indians were beginning to boil, the British Empire was being heavily criticized by the colony’s citizens (Hollitz 25), and William Berkeley, governor of Virginia, was under fear of a revolt of indentured servants brought upon by his cousin, Nathaniel Bacon. Although Berkeley and Bacon were bonded by family, there is no denying that they also happened to be avowed enemies of each other: the crown against the rebellion. Berkeley and Bacon both had drastically opposing points of opinion; while Berkeley was loyal to the crown and a firm believer in order, Bacon demonstrated great resentment toward the crown which he campaigned and fought against it (Hollitz 26). The opposing viewpoints of these men are just the …show more content…

Berkeley immediately begins his statement with a strong use of ethos, stating “Now my friends I have lived amongst you four and thirty years as uncorrupt and diligent as ever [a] governor was,” (qtd. Hollitz 30). This quote brings a substantial wave of confidence and safety to the reader with the governor making the point that during all of his years ruling he has never been proven or accused as corrupt. Immediately establishing credibility is a significant part of Berkeley’s statement that Bacon’s Manifesto was

Show More
Related
205 Words | 1 Pages

On 22 April 1677 Charles II’s commissioners, Sir John Berry, Colonel Herbert Jeffreys and Francis Moryson, visited the colony’s governor, Sir William Berkeley, and his wife, Frances, at Green Spring House. The three men had been sent to Virginia with a large armed force to suppress Bacon’s Rebellion and discover its causes by hearing the people’s grievances. The commissioners’ purpose was to bid farewell to the governor, whom the king had summoned to England. Colonel Jeffreys, who commanded the English troops, was designated to replace Berkeley during the latter’s absence. However, Berkeley was old and frail and unlikely to return to the colonyOn 22 April 1677 Charles II’s commissioners, Sir John Berry, Colonel Herbert Jeffreys and Francis

Read More
1872 Words | 8 Pages

Yes, because Nathaniel Bacon was a distant cousin to Berkeley’s wife, which means that it would have been in Governor William Berkeley’s interests to appoint Nathaniel Bacon to a high position, in order to make his wife happy. It

Read More
422 Words | 2 Pages

In this document Bacon declares himself General by the consent of the people and asserts that Governor Sir William Berkeley and his supporters have used their power to commit crimes against the people of Virginia and the English Crown. The document cites eight grievances related to unjust taxes, inadequate protection from the Indians, and government corruption. Bacon calls for the immediate surrender or capture of Berkeley and 23

Read More
231 Words | 1 Pages

He might also have been trying to defend Bacon by pointing out Lady Berkeley’s

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

After it was distributed in the colonies, “the speech was burned in public by the soldiers…” (McCullough, p. 68). The colonists responded with defiance in the face of the massive British Empire. These men and women were “determined to shake off all connections with a state so unjust” (McCullough, p. 68). McCullough’s excellent use of proper organization brings clarity and understanding to his

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

Bacon’s Rebellion is well known to students of colonial America, although no-one has succeeded in writing a convincing account of it. The first question historians asked was who was responsible for the widespread anarchy that followed the breakdown of government authority in the colony between 1676 and 1677. One historian attributes the rebellion to Nathaniel Bacon, and describes Governor Berkeley as a man doing his best to implement sensible policies. Another sees the Rebellion as prefiguring the American Revolution, with Bacon as an early George Washington, already defying British authority.

Read More
1345 Words | 6 Pages

Berkeley was having to face a real rebel, in the state of desperation, he told Nathaniel Bacon that if he gave himself up, he could face trial in England. However, the House of Burgesses disagreed and said that Nathaniel Bacon had to beg to the Governor, Berkeley himself, for forgiveness. Nathaniel Bacon was then elected into the House of Burgesses by some landowners. For the reason of that election he went to a assembly in June 1676, which marks history because of what he did on this historic day. (McCulley, 1987)

Read More
880 Words | 4 Pages

This led to Bacon’s Rebellion, a gang of impoverished and landless former servants attacked the capital of the colony and plundered the homes of the wealthy. Both colonies constituted a successful form of government; however, both governments were carried out in dissimilar ways. The establishment of two primitive English colonies, Jamestown and Massachusetts Bay Colony had many homogeneous attributes and differences. Both had an adequate relationship with the Native Americans that deteriorated and

Read More
246 Words | 1 Pages

Many of the reasons the American colonies believed they were justified in their rebellion from England lay in trade and taxes. When George III inherited the throne at the end of the Seven Years’ War England’s debt had risen to 145 million pounds and his chief minister believed that the American colonies needed to help shoulder the debt. (Nash, et al., 2007. , p. 134) In attempting to collect these taxes from the colonies to relieve the mounting debt Parliament passed a range of acts, which led to discontent among the colonists as many of them restricted trade, their political maneuverability and left many believing they infringed upon their “right to be taxed only by their own consent.”

Read More
1225 Words | 5 Pages

Benjamin Franklin and His Enemies Summary Robert Middlekauff starts off by introducing Benjamin Franklin as a well-mannered and civic-minded individual who is loved by everyone. Of course, Benjamin Franklin was a little bit reserved when it came to strangers, but that never stopped people from growing fond of him. His good heart and spirit lead him to amazing people like Margaret Stevenson (Polly), John Adams, William Strahan, and Thomas Jefferson to name a few. Besides from having a well-liked personality Robert Middlekauff also reveals that Benjamin Franklin was a curious man who came equipped with an outstanding resumé.

Read More
989 Words | 4 Pages

The result of the Bacon’s Rebellion made a establishment of hierarchies based on class, but hidden by race. The Bacon’s Rebellion had to do with the environment because there was a significant deal of social mobility, but this gave the colonist anxiety. The colonists faced lack of stability and an uncertain future, plus a chance of social mobility. Therefore, this became a conflict as individuals fought for nature's

Read More
1850 Words | 8 Pages

Chapter 3 Outline: • 3.1 The Protestant Reformation Produces Puritanism • 3.2 The Pilgrims End Their Pilgrimage at Plymouth • 3.3 The Bay Colony Bible Commonwealth • 3.4 Building the Bay Colony • 3.5 Trouble in the Bible Commonwealth • 3.6 The Rhode Island “Sewer” • 3.7 New England Spreads Out • 3.8 Puritans Versus Indians • 3.9 Seeds of Colonial Unity and Independence • 3.10 Andros Promotes the First American Revolution • 3.11 Old Netherlanders at New Netherlanders • 3.12 Friction with English and Swedish Neighbors • 3.13 Dutch Residues in New York • 3.14 Penn’s Holy Experiment in Pennsylvania • 3.15 Quaker Pennsylvania and Its Neighbors • 3.16 The Middle Way in the Middle Colonies   3.1 The Protestant Reformation Produces Puritanism

Read More
1413 Words | 6 Pages

Darwin and Bacon (The Analysis of the Concurrences between Darwin and Bacon) The anomaly that is the Earth works in strange ways, while failing to balance on one foot all one has to do is place one finger on the wall and you are safe from crashing to the ground. This phenomenon seems to suggest that all things are connected; however there is a delicate balance to be maintained. Charles Darwin’s theory of natural selection proposes that there is a balance that allows for the life on Earth to maintain the equilibrium of evolution. On the other hand, Francis Bacon composed an idea of the levels of the mind called the four idols which obstructed the path for scientific reasoning and observation.

Read More
592 Words | 3 Pages

King Philips War and Bacon’s Rebellion were two pivotal points in early American history. Ironically, they both shared many similarities between them. There are three main points of discussion in comparison of the two conflicts: 1) why the fighting started, 2) what they were fighting over, and finally 3) who they were fighting against. Each of these conflicts resulted in tragic loss of many lives of settlers and Indians and caused even more tension between the English and the Native Americans.

Read More
1050 Words | 5 Pages

The arrival of the first Europeans in the Americas is dramatically captured through the many writers who attempted to communicate what they saw, experienced and felt. What is more, the very purposes of their treacherous travel and colonization are clearly seen in their writings; whether it is poetry, history or sermons. Of the many literary pieces available today, William Bradford and John Winthrop’s writings, even though vary because the first is a historical account and the second is a sermon, stand out as presenting a clear trust in God, the rules that would govern them and the reason they have arrived in the Americas. First of all, William Bradford provides an in-depth look into the first moment when the Puritans arrived in the Americas. In fact, he chronicles the hardships they face on their way to Plymouth, yet he includes God’s provision every step of the way.

Read More

More about A Critical Analysis Of Bacon's 'Declaration And Remonstrance'

Related Topics

Open Document