ipl-logo

A False Legacy: Exposing John Smith's Lies About Pocahontas

1822 Words8 Pages

Andie Koontz
Stalets
College Prep English 3
24 January 2023

A False Legacy: Exposing John Smith's Lies about Pocahontas In a melodramatic novel by Susan Donnell simply titled Pocahontas, a passage says “[Pocahontas] wanted to devour [John Smith] with love. Her body acted as if it was no longer a part of the woman she knew… She felt as if she were part of the man whose body gave her such joy, as if his skin were hers, as if their hearts were one. At other times she felt she would swoon with the deliciousness of her captivity” (qtd. in Paul 121) Despite the author’s claims of being a direct descendant, this could not be further from the truth. The book, supposedly, was based on history, but it serves only to twist the narrative of Pocahontas …show more content…

The natives brought food to the colonists, with Pocahontas accompanying them at times due to her status as a token of goodwill, but it was not in secret nor was she ever alone (Schilling par. 19). The reason is simple; at that age, she would still be watched carefully, similar to how she certainly was during the alleged ceremony (Schilling par. 20). She would never have adequate time alone with Smith to tell him about the Chief’s plan to murder him in such detail. While Wahunsenaca was disapproving of Smith’s violent actions towards other tribes, even going so far as to say that he “[had] not treated any of my werowances as well as [John Smith], yet [Smith is} the worst werowance I have!” he never intended on killing him at any point in time, according to the descendants of the tribe (Schilling par. …show more content…

The colonists wanted the natives to convert to Christianity and their way of life; unfortunately during the summer, sexual assault that the settlers blamed on the native’s more revealing garments was commonplace (Paul 97). This escalated to the degree where mothers volunteered themselves instead of allowing their children to be subjected to the assault (Paul 97). Within the tribe, sexual assault was expressly forbidden and an act of immeasurable atrocity, and was dealt with gravely (Schilling par. 42). Pocahontas had been raised on this mentality her entire life. This often involved banishment from the tribe. However, this was not an option when the colonists had weapons far beyond the tribe’s capabilities. The Powhatan weapons were effective against other tribes, but it was near impossible to rival an arsenal of guns without some of your

Show More
Related

Pocahontas And The Powhatan Dilemma Analysis

517 Words | 3 Pages

Now we have all heard about the story of Pocahontas, unfortunately many of the stories we were told growing up are not completely true. Camilla Townsend, the author of “Pocahontas and the Powhatan Dilemma”, intends to inform its readers about the evolution of the many lies written and told by the Englishmen regarding their relationships with the Native America peoples that many of us have heard about today. However, Townsend has ineffectively given her readers information about the whole truth to the stories she has written about the many relationships of the English and Native Americans. Firstly, although Townsend claims to have done her research on the topic by reading all the documents written from this time period and beyond, she leaves

Read More

Jamestown Women's Role In Early America

1734 Words | 7 Pages

He stated that Pocahontas was, "the instrument to preserve this colony from death, famine, and utter confusion.” He was stating that without Pocahontas’s help the colony would have surely parishes and starved to death because of their lack of knowledge of the new land. However, soon later John Smith was captured by Powhatan for venturing too far into his territory. He was going to be killed, when Pocahontas rushed in at the last minute and begged her father not to kill him, saying that if he died she would have to die too. This seemingly small act could have just been her trying to save her English friend, but it is largely speculated that this was actually a ploy to try and control the relationship between his tribe and the English.

Read More

Pocahontas And The Powhatan Dilemma Sparknotes

872 Words | 4 Pages

The author goes on to debate what Pocahontas actually felt in her relationship with John Smith and how she most likely did not reciprocate the feelings he claimed she had. This may be new information to the reader and provides historical difference of the real Pocahontas from the Hollywood version while strengthening Townsend’s argument. Also, the author does not use challenging language in her own writing. She keeps her own wording basic as to give the readers a break from the difficultness of the old language. Another positive aspect of this book is the notes section and the preface.

Read More

Similarities Between Harriet Jacobs And Frederick Douglass

579 Words | 3 Pages

As a woman, Harriet Jacobs faced unique challenges in the slave society. She was forced to endure sexual abuse from her owner and struggled to protect her children from the same abuse. This experience is clear in her narrative, which focuses mainly on the sexual misuse of female slaves. She writes with passion, using her own experiences to gain the attention of free women in the North (Jacobs).

Read More

Summary Of Pocahontas And The Powhatan Dilemma

1011 Words | 5 Pages

Very rarely did she state that something was true or accurate, almost always she kept things real and said that it was possible, or could 've happened. With the very little information the world actually has on Pocahontas, it is hard to know exactly how she felt. Many times the book states that she did not really write things down. Much of the information that was included in this book is from many of the Englishmen’s writings, journals, diaries, etc. Some of the information is even hear-say.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Jamestown And Adam Smith

504 Words | 3 Pages

Smith was a very selfish person. The Natives brought him over to the fire and fed Smith their food, and as the Natives took Smith thinks the Natives saw his

Read More

The Foundations And Stigmas Of Jamestown

1384 Words | 6 Pages

The three articles that are being discussed in this review are three about the foundations and stigmas of Jamestown. The First one is Capt. John Smith, Pocahontas and a Clash of Cultures: A case for the Ethnohistorical Perspective, by Author Michael J. Puglisi. Puglisi article is about the Natives at the time of Jamestown, and rather than being just victims, and passive bystanders to the Europeans, a new theory sees the Natives as direct participants with their own political agendas. The second work is The Civic Solution to the Crises of English Colonization, 1609-1625, by Andrew Fitzmaurice, who is Chief Executive Officer at

Read More

Historical Dilemmas In The Iroquois Constitution

683 Words | 3 Pages

Human history talks about how people were so stereotypical and how they had to eat raw corn and how they exchanged grains of food to either make peace amongst each other or for just common trade. They also embroiled about the mistreatment of the women in those days of the many tribes around the world showing that those who mistreated the women did it with so much injustice and weren’t punish themselves for such cruel thing to do to women. The Iroquois tribe did indeed think differently in the whole mistreatment business they believed that women had equal say, power to the men of the tribe and that they shouldn’t be treated as if they were in the appearance of invisibility . They were also said to have been indigenous people at that time of year because if you really think about all the Native tribes in the history of the world they characterize them as indigenous. Along with most of the world the Natives also did have a leader that would say what goes and do what’s best for his people.

Read More

Colonists And Native Americans In Chief Pontiac's Speech At Detroit

773 Words | 4 Pages

Her writings also depict how little of value she placed in Native American people and their culture. In her culture, anything that defied her way of life or religion was of lesser value. Her story offers an insight to a female, puritan perspective on the Native Americans. One section of the narrative showed that she acknowledged that the Indians had their own civilization and culture based on their clothing, but it was a civilization of savages. Mary Rowlandson’s narrative is an important piece of literature at the time as it offers a greater understanding of her society at the time, and their deeply troubling relationship to and perceptions of the

Read More

Compare And Contrast Bradford And John Smith

601 Words | 3 Pages

Smith referred Native Americans to savages, and paints negative pictures of them at their feasts, because he saw that the Native Americans killed the English newcomers that were trying to cross the Native Americans tribes to get to wherever their destination was. Smith met a young girl named Pocahontas when natives took him to Werowocomoco for the King to kill him, and Pocahontas laid herself on Smith and wrapped her arm around his head to save him from death. Pocahontas and Smith had a argument when they later met again, about him not getting in not writing her back. Smith looked down on Native Americans even though they were the reason for the colonies surviving. Bradford had many interactions with Native Americans throughout this journey.

Read More

Address To John Smith Analysis

835 Words | 4 Pages

Most likely, one has heard about the story of Pocahontas and John Smith. However, John Smith was not as loving and kind as he was portrayed. In the letter Address to Captain Smith, the speaker, Chief Powhatan, Pocahontas’ father, takes a condescending tone and addresses to the English settlers, especially John Smith, how the chief’s generous hospitality has not been appreciated. Literary devices such as rhetorical questions, antithesis, and repetition, diction, and pathos and ethos are exercised by Chief Powhatan to address his purpose and produce it as impactful as fully possible.

Read More

What Was The Difference Between Sojourner Truth And Mary Rowlandson

1656 Words | 7 Pages

Mary Rowlandson lived during Colonial America when tensions with Native Americans were at the highest. According to her narrative she said “The occasion (as I thought) of their moving at this time was the English army, it being near and following them... Being very faint I asked my mistress to give me one spoonful of the meal, but she would not give me a taste.” During this time, the natives were being followed the English army and they were running low on food. Mary was not prioritized because she was just a captive.

Read More

Martin Luther King And Cesar Chavez's Argument Against Abortion

991 Words | 4 Pages

“I cannot understand anti-abortion arguments that centre on the sanctity of life. As a species we've fairly comprehensively demonstrated that we don't believe in the sanctity of life. The shrugging acceptance of war, famine, epidemic, pain and life-long poverty shows us that, whatever we tell ourselves, we've made only the most feeble of efforts to really treat human life as sacred.” - Caitlin Moran Abortion does what contraception does not necessarily do: it works. Let the abortion be as it is, it is the mother’s body and she can abort it as she wishes.

Read More

A True Relation Summary

372 Words | 2 Pages

And whispers started, neighbors telling neighbors how Smith said the new people were kind and hospitable to him. How Smith said the new people treated him to their delicacies and provided him with provisions on his journeys. How Smith said the new people were respectful, helpful, and friendly. Smith writes about Chief Powhatan of the Powhatan Nation, "He kindly welcomed me with such good words and great platters of sundry victuals, assuring me his friendship and my Liberty in four days... Having all the kindness he could devise, sought to content me, he sent me home with four men: one that usually carried my gown and knapsack after me, two loaded with bread, and one to accompany me."

Read More

Mary Rowlandson A Narrative Of The Captivity Analysis

1544 Words | 7 Pages

“A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mary Rowlandson”: The Influence of Intercultural Contact on Puritan Beliefs “A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson” by Mary Rowlandson gives a first person perspective into the circumstances of captivity and cultural interaction and an insight to Rowlandson 's attitude towards the Indians, both before and after she was held captive. Rowlandson displays a change in her perception of "civilized" and "savage", in spite of the fact that her overall world view does not alter. It should be covered below that in the following Essay, since the author and the narrator are the same person, will not be individually distinguished. For one thing, Mary Rowlandson provides all the conventions typical of a Puritan perspective.

Read More

More about A False Legacy: Exposing John Smith's Lies About Pocahontas

Related Topics

Open Document