ipl-logo

Agency Against Divine Intervention In The Iliad

1176 Words5 Pages

Agency can be defined as the capacity to act in ways that matter without influence from any outside forces. Characters in The Iliad by Homer struggle with making their own fate with or without the influence of gods and goddesses who can already anticipate their fates for them. One particular instance of the limited scope of agency against divine intervention occurs near the end of Book I, where the character of Achilles juggles his free will, deciding if he should fight and kill Agamemnon for seizing his female slave, Briseis, in exchange for Chryseis, who Agamemnon is keeping captive (The Iliad 1. 241 - 259). Achilles’ patience is tested at this moment in time when he is furious at Agamemnon’s request, but Athene, the gray-eyed goddess, steps in and sets him straight as she promises a better reward and a far better future for Achilles if he doesn’t choose to fight Agamemnon. This interference influences …show more content…

Though mortals in The Iliad possess a great sense of pride in their decision making, divine intervention and will by the various gods and goddesses sways their faculty of agency and influences how they come to terms with their mortality, as in Athene’s interruption of Achille’s monologue.
Achilles is in full rage after Agamemnon makes his request and wants to kill him for infringing on Achilles’ power and pride. Achilles tends to push the limits of his agency and make these threats often, as evidenced in his threat to quit the army and go home because he refused to fight Troy. Like most people, Achilles can’t see the big picture when he’s in a frantic and angry mood. Athene, sent from goddess Hera, comes down and speaks to Achilles, as she is invisible to everyone but him. Athene’s appearance is the first time a god descends and speaks to a mortal in the story and it is clear there is a sense of subservience in her words:

Show More
Related
514 Words | 3 Pages

Response Paper 2 In Achilles speech in book 9 he says he will not help the Achaeans in the fight against Troy. Up until this point, Achilles main reason for not fighting has been that he was mad at Agamemnon for taking away Brises. Although this is still the case, Achilles’ speech in lines 397-413 suggest that he has other reasons for not fighting as well. Achilles has known forever that he is destined to die young, in a glorious battle, and he has good reason to believe that if he fights in this war it will kill him. Achilles is known by now to be very emotional, and, for a demi-god, he has an overwhelming sense of humanity.

Read More
606 Words | 3 Pages

For those who fail to adhere to any form of a decree by the Gods, experiencing heightened free will comes at the cost of suffering some form of punishment. Having adequately warned them of perchance of crossing roads with a dangerous fate, Odysseus had reminded his crew-mates to not harm the Cattle of the Sun; however, his starved crew eventually disregards the prophecies of the Gods and the insistences of Odysseus. Although the crew exercises a form of free-will by choosing to do as they wish, starvation compels their subsequent action, not the Gods. In doing so, they trigger the wrath of Helios and Zeus. Homer highlights the severity of disobeying a divine mandate and develops a destructive and punitive tone with the use of utterly obliterative

Read More
308 Words | 2 Pages

The ancient Greeks believed that the gods were responsible for any unexplained event or fate, expressed in the epic poem, “The Odyssey” written by Homer. As the epic begins, the narrator introduces Odysseus’ predetermined fate, remarking “That year spun out by the gods when he should reach his home”(20). The word “spun” creates an image of the god’s meticulous plot for Odysseus’ life, specifically a human “year”. This demonstrates the god’s capability to meddle on a mortal’s fate. As Athena prepares to enter Ithaca, the narrator displays her godly presence, when “She fastened the supple sandals, ever glowing gold, that wing her over the waves and boundless earth with the rush of gusting winds.

Read More
802 Words | 4 Pages

For example, in “The Odyssey” by Homer. The great goddess Athena helped poor Odysseus when he needed it most. Odysseus was being enslaved on the island of Calypso. Athena told Zeus to tell Hermes to tell Calypso to let Odysseus be free. Athena didn’t have to do that, but she did out of the

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

Long ago lived the greatest hunter named Daniel Boone. Why, he could hunt down the most ferocious and brutal animals. He was talented in both archery and lasso. Everything went his way except his physical trait. He was a midget, short and lightweight.

Read More
1029 Words | 5 Pages

In epic Greek poems, gods have a major influence in the overall storyline and the Odyssey is no exception. The gods and goddesses constantly are appearing sometimes in a disguised form, but all nonetheless crafting the scenes to their accord so that they may offer gratitude for the mortal’s loyalty or to gain revenge for their disloyalty. Not only do they alter events, but people also alter their actions while keeping the appeasement of gods in mind. By paying respect to the gods, the characters express much more than a simple gesture of reverence; instead, it is also a way of showing compassion for something other than themselves. Odysseus strategically exploits his devotion to the gods in various scenes in a way to improve his own character

Read More
1349 Words | 6 Pages

127-128). Thus, this blindness causes the gods to be constantly mistaken as men, and vice versa. “Examples abound, then, to show that the gulf between divine and mortal eidenai reveals itself most clearly in men’s inability to see or recognize the gods.” One example would be, as we have seen previously, Athena disguised as mentor coming to help Telemachus find his father back. In Book 6 of the Odyssey, we find an uncertain Odysseus about the fact that Nausicaa is a goddess or a mortal woman.

Read More
705 Words | 3 Pages

Within the Greek myths and mythos the gods and goddesses, although human, are all powerful and all knowing. Disobeying or angering these mighty beings always leads to a negative outcome. From Athena turning Arachne into a spider for boosting about being better. To Leto sending Apollo and Artemis to kill Niobe’s 12 children for boosting about bearing more children then her. Not even Oedipus in Sophocles’s Oedipus Rex is spared from the gods’ wrath.

Read More
917 Words | 4 Pages

Persuasion is used in a multitude of everyday ways by diverse groups of people- from car salesmen to lawyers proving someone’s innocence and political candidates convincing an entire nation to vote for them. Oftentimes, persuasion must be used used in dire wartime or life-threatening situations, as shown in the Iliad. Master speakers use three distinct methods of rhetoric- ethos, pathos, and logos, in order to accomplish their goal. The Iliad contains a variety of speeches to demonstrate these methods of rhetoric.

Read More
1399 Words | 6 Pages

Firstly, fate plays a large role in Greek Mythology, as it is described as three sisters who “spun out life [on a thread], measured it, and cut it”. So the question that arises from this is if the fate sisters controls everyone’s actions including the gods, was Zeus truly acting out of duty or was it fate that made him do so in the Iliad? As Zeus agreed upon in The Works of Lucian when discussing fate with Cyniscus that the fates control everyone’s actions. If he was acting under the guise of fate, we have to take Zeus’ actions with a grain of salt because he was not in control of his own actions. If fate decreed that Zeus act the way he did, is it truly right to consider him as someone who acts out of duty?

Read More
879 Words | 4 Pages

Homeric Portraiture In The Iliad and The Odyssey, Homer relates of Fate (Moira) rather than Fates (Moirai). In his view, the Fate is a single impersonal power which is basically concerned with the cessation of life. Surprisingly, in The lliad, Homer also mentioned the Fate in plural form, albeit only for once. In Homeric description, the Fate acted independently from the gods and Zeus was the sole god who could control it.

Read More
1570 Words | 7 Pages

Now I must go to look for the destroyer of my great friend. I shall confront the dark dear spirit of death at any hour Zeus and the other gods may wish to make an end (Q 65-68). Here, Achilles shows fearlessness and audacity in his acceptance of death. However, he accepted his fate, to avenge the killer of his friend Patroclus.

Read More
384 Words | 2 Pages

Should destiny intend that he shall see his roof again among his family in his father land, far be that day, and dark the years between. Let him lose all companions, and return under strange sail to bitter days at home. " The theme of divine intervention is shown as Poseidon hinders Odysseus on his way to Ithaca by the curse, which made it years before Odysseus returns home whereas he would have returned in a matter of days, had Aeolus helped Odysseus again, but he didn't because he believed "their voyage has been cursed by the gods" (Homer 16). Homer demonstrates Athena's divine intervention through her providence towards Odysseus. Athena aids Odysseus multiple times throughout The Odyssey, an example of this is when she disguises Odysseus as a beggar in book 17 of The Odyssey to protect him from the suitors.

Read More
394 Words | 2 Pages

Achilles is maddened and appeals to his goddess mother saying, “If I am to die soon, shouldn’t I have what I want?” Feeling only sorrow for her son, Thetis requests Zeus to cause to Greeks to lose until Achilles fights again. Slowly the Greeks are pushed back farther and Agamemnon pleads with Achilles, offering Briseis back. Achilles declines due to his pride and the Trojans come close to burn the Greek ships. Even when a ship was burning, Achilles refused to fight and instead sends out Patroclus.

Read More
1512 Words | 7 Pages

Iliad is recognized as one of the most famous ancient monuments of literature. The full understanding of this epic poem is hardly possible without thorough analysis of its main characters. Among all the episodes of the Trojan War, Homer chooses the moment of Achilles’ wrath and thus creates a poem in which he becomes the central figure. From the Ancient Greeks’ point of view, Achilles represents the ideal of manliness and pure heroism, for he is brave and fights for heroics, not profits. Today, one can agree with this interpretation, yet Achilles is probably the most controversial character because he combines various personality traits and acts in accordance with his ambiguous nature.

Read More

More about Agency Against Divine Intervention In The Iliad

Related Topics

Open Document