ipl-logo

Ambiguous Morality In Billy Budd

956 Words4 Pages

The Conflict Between Individuality and Society: An Analysis of Ambiguous Morality in Billy Budd, Sailor Capital punishment and mandatory military service, two major political issues that are still debated to this day. Both, at their core, boil down to one question. Are the rights of an individual worth less than the survival of a society? Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor follows Billy Budd, a young and naïve sailor during his impressment aboard the Bellipotent, a British warship manned by Captain Vere, during the Napoleonic Wars. Billy Budd is taken from the aptly named merchant ship the Rights-of-Man and dropped into the brutal reality of life in the British Navy. While he manages his situation well, he attracts the ill intentions of …show more content…

The story begins with Billy being taken from the Rights-of-Man, an obvious symbol for his individual rights, to the Bellipotent, where he has no rights of his own. In his newfound military service, he is subjected to grueling labour and harsh conditions, which he takes in stride. The day after he boards the warship Billy sees for the first time the brutal subjugation of one of his fellow sailors in the form of a public lashing. This convinces Billy to shoot straight henceforth, for “[w]hen Billy saw the culprit's naked back under the scourge gridironed with red welts, and worse; when he marked the dire expression on the liberated man's face...Billy was horrified. He resolved that never...would he make himself liable to such a visitation...” His hard work for fear of further dehumanization, earns him the respect of his senior sailors, and the jealousy and attention of Claggart, yet another symbol for power suppressing identity. Claggart serves as an metaphorical extension of power, manifesting society’s repression of the individual, while Billy Budd represents individualism in itself. In conclusion, Billy Budd’s sense of self is stripped from him, and although he reacts to his bondage with conviction and work ethic in attempts to lay low, his actions only serve to make him more conspicuous to Claggart, fueling his resentment towards

Show More
Related
1684 Words | 7 Pages

As students, one usually sees a positive view on what life was like back then. Usually, one fails to realize that perhaps these pilgrims, or puritans who sailed across the Atlantic, were more complex than the simpleton title the standard textbooks give them. Thus, one is able to realize that there are perspectives from both sides of the spectrum. As Vowell composes her book, she gives a witty outlook on the governing of John Winthrop in the Massachusetts Bay Colony, and how his puritan ideals affected the society around them. One thing that The Wordy Shipmates does suggest to the reader is how one must not take things for face value.

Read More
2075 Words | 9 Pages

From the beginning few pages of Rogers’ The Press Gang, the thesis and theme of the book is made abundantly clear; coerced, forceful, and even violent impressment of ordinary British male citizens for the service of the British Navy in Great Britain during the 18th century and 19th century was a very real challenge to every day life. In fact, according to Rogers “the rough way in which press gangs recruited for the Royal Navy has long been commemorated in print and ballad, supplemented in the press by often harrowing accounts of the affrays that ensued” (Rogers, p. 17.) It is clear to see that the cultural and societal ramifications as well as national opinion of impressment are what The Press Gang aims to explain throughout the book. Opening

Read More
176 Words | 1 Pages

By analyzing this quote, we see the people who actually fight in the war, like Billy and the Americans, are in bad shape; while the dignify and strong ones, who want to fight, like the Englishmen, are held in prison. This is the opposite of what we think it should be like in a war. Here, we see Billy as an ill man, who has to fight, contradicts the English soldiers

Read More
1035 Words | 5 Pages

He makes many mistakes along the way and displays many emotional struggles. Despite his struggles, he continues to believe that eventually the

Read More
433 Words | 2 Pages

Mr. Unlucky How did a guy get a metal bar shot through his brain and skull but still survive? Is he superhuman? No, he is Phineus Gage. Some would say he is lucky, but the effects made him unlucky. But here is where everything went wrong.

Read More
175 Words | 1 Pages

Moral Courage Have you ever been afraid to do what’s right? Well, there was a man who risked it all to do so. The concept of right or wrong varies from person to person. We all have our own unique individual mindsets that enable us to embody our thoughts into reality. Nonetheless, in the newspaper “The Man In The Water” by Roger Rosenblatt, the literary elements setting and conflict showed moral courage.

Read More
1078 Words | 5 Pages

Authors of classic American literature often utilize a character’s development to establish a worldview or opinion. In The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn and The Great Gatsby, Mark Twain and F. Scott Fitzgerald use their narrators, Huck Finn and Nick Carraway, to suggest an argument about American society. Seeking adventure, both characters embark on a journey, but their encounters with society leave them appalled. While they each have personal motives for abandoning their past, both end up interacting with different cultures that lead them to a similar decision about society and their futures. Ultimately, they stray from the dominant culture in order to escape the influence of society.

Read More
1106 Words | 5 Pages

Soldiers were not viewed as brave men risking their lives, and the war was seen as an unnecessary event. This type of mentality is seen in the novel with the perceptions of the soldiers. The narrator expresses the view of the time period when he states, “They were soldiers’ coats. Billy was the only one who had a coat from a dead civilian” (82). The meaning behind this is very crucial because it establishes a definite division between soldiers and civilians.

Read More
396 Words | 2 Pages

In the novel Billy Budd by Herman Melville, Captain Vere portrays a morally ambiguous character, and plays a very pivotal role. Vere isn't necessarily the villain throughout the novel, but isn't the good guy either. He kills Billy to prevent a mutiny and also persuades the court he calls into agreeing with the death sentence, but also is the captain of a ship and helps the ship run smoothly. When in a tough situation, Vere tends to fumble which shows common human nature.

Read More
1479 Words | 6 Pages

By using ambiguous language, Herman Melville’s Billy Budd, Sailor explains homosexuality and the issues the group had in society. It can be assumed that at least three of the Bellipotent’s crew were homosexual and other members of the crew knew this as well. Through the time period there was constant fear and persecution of homosexuals which led to the crewmen being silent in their justice just as homosexuals were silenced in their prosecutions by others. By using historical aspects, Melville has hidden under everyone’s nose the implications of homosexuality on the ship. Captain Vere is seen as a scholarly figure who keeps to himself until the end of the novella where he is forced into the conflict of a potential mutiny brewing.

Read More
771 Words | 4 Pages

This story indicates how easily one can be manipulated and jaded through experience. He is also a

Read More
389 Words | 2 Pages

Have you ever written a book and had a dilemma on how to end it? We all agree that Herman Melville ended the book with the death of Billy Budd. But some believe that Herman Melville should have ended the book with the escape or salvation of Billy Budd. I think Melville made the best choice in ending the book with the death of Billy Budd for three reasons: It would turn it from a good book to an excellent book, It would make the book realistic,and it sets an example of the law being enforced.

Read More
1141 Words | 5 Pages

Individuals often say that the right way may not necessarily be the popular way, but standing up for the right thing, despite it being frowned upon, will be the true test of one’s moral character. This relates to the moral growth that Huck Finn experiences throughout his journey. Mark Twain’s controversial novel, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn, can be said to be a compelling story about how one individual, Huck Finn, goes against society’s ideals. Huck’s moral development can be said to be based primarily on those around him, especially Jim. Many instances also influence Huck’s morals, particularly during the raft journey that will change his beliefs and morals.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

He knows he is under scrutiny and is willing to forgo his entire past because of his misdeed. This displays his lack of true feeling and friendship, as well as obvious

Read More
154 Words | 1 Pages

A Brief Summation of Billy Budd Historical Setting/Context Set in 1797 during the Napoleonic Wars, shortly after the notorious Nore Mutiny in the British fleet. Main Characters Billy Budd (Protagonist) - Budd’s role as the “The Handsome Sailor” is his most important quality which leads to most of his trouble. He is quite a simple man that makes his confusion of situations throughout the story prominent.

Read More

More about Ambiguous Morality In Billy Budd

Related Topics

Open Document