ipl-logo

An Inclusive View In Alan Goldman's 'Plain Sex'

653 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Gender identity analysis essay

An inclusive view? A counterintuitive mean-end analysis argument? A counterintuitive article? In “Plain Sex”, Alan Goldman ironically taking a liberal point of view actually holds a conservative view to defining sex as contingent to the intent of fulfilling sexual desire. To prove his point, Goldman refers to a “means-end analysis of sex” using three main arguments; reproduction, expression of love and communication. I criticize Goldman for being too inclusive in defining sex, I will outline that Goldman’s means-end analysis of sex are counteractive to his argument. First, I will argue that reproduction is not guaranteed when doing the sexual acts of kissing, sodomy or fellation, in all three cases, humans are unable to reproduce. Second, expression …show more content…

For instance, what about petting my dog to express communication of friendship, here my intent is touch not for sexual desire. Goldman validates the touching of babies and sexual sports by saying that those are for the bodily function of exercising and attachment. But what about in the case of my cat? Viewing sex in this narrow view accounts non-sexual acts as sexual. In contrast to Woodhead’s view, viewing sex as a wider context such as between children, family friends and community. Also, Zukerman and manning: sex and religion: an introduction, while there exist many plurality of sex, there also exist many interpretations of sex within religious traditions. Goldman does not limit sex acts to “the venereal act” like Aquinas does, but includes any physical contact so long as it’s committed with the intent of fulfilling sexual desire. Goldman’s view is too inclusive. Moreover, while Goldman defines sex as the mere desire for sexual contact, he negates the idea of emotionless sex. This is referring to his second principle of communicative love. If he defines sex as similar to the act of the basic desire to eat or exercise, following that logic, there are no emotions in those actions and sex can be no more communicative than other acts and need not be communicative and since sex as love doesn’t account for emotionless sex. He therefore claims sex can not be defined as a means to an

Show More
Related
653 Words | 3 Pages

Chris, despite being a young man just out of college, chooses the path of celibacy, a shocking move to most Americans, as Krakauer explains: “We Americans are titillated by sex, obsessed by it, horrified by it. When an apparently healthy person, especially a healthy young man, elects to forgo the enticements of the flesh, it shocks us... Suspicions are aroused.” (Krakauer 66). American society, while not an immoral one, is not one that shies away from sexuality, as most Americans are not immune to sexual desire and find it shocking that one could reject such desires.

Read More
492 Words | 2 Pages

Other readings have discussed the history of sexuality—A history of Latina/o Sexualities. Throughout history, women were supposed to be passive. Women were there to please the man and ofter were viewed as the inferior. Sex was viewed as something that was essential only for reproduction; it was only to be pleasurable during a marriage and through very strict guidelines set by the church. This is still an influential way which women are being treated today.

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

These laws, then, uphold old notions of chastity and virginity, while providing a weapon against men from social groups we do not like. They also deprive women in their mid and late teens of choice under the guise of protecting that choice. The highly “patriarchal and paternalistic” law is what Delgado sees an area for further revue. With the lack of women being charged for such crimes, he questions things such as pressured intercourse and sexual love involving two consenting individuals.

Read More
994 Words | 4 Pages

Anne McClintock wrote her essay “Gonad the Barbarian and the Venus Flytrap: Portraying the female and male orgasm” to examine pornography and how it has changed throughout history and its effects on how women perform as sexual beings. McClintock focuses on the various roles of pornography such as its emphasis on voyeurism, pleasure, and the male ego. She wants her readers to know that women are still not represented in pornography to satisfy their own desires, but they are there to cater to men and their subconscious. I will analyze how McClintock argues that due to the history of sexism towards women, the roles that men and women have in pornography are inherently different because of the societal belief that women are only seen as objects of sexual desire and are solely there to satisfy the male audience.

Read More
1972 Words | 8 Pages

One man on a journey to find the lost treasure of Broken Heirs. Neil Gibbs is going to cross the deepest part of the South Pacific Ocean, cross treacherous rapids, climb steep mountains infested with man-eating creatures, and cannibals after him. What he did to infuriate them, is a secret only to be revealed in this tale of life or death. Neil Gibbs was on an ordinary exploration trip to search for the treasure of a Broken Heirs, a treasure worth billions of dollars and is millions of years old. He was determined to be the first explorer to find it, but he had competition, Aria Steele.

Read More
675 Words | 3 Pages

(Krakauer 66) The author explains that even though in today's world, especially in America, people are not comfortable with the idea of sexual things. However, he explains it that actually portrays how it is today. It is a topic that most people don't want to discuss or mention something into this only except for when there is some story or drama. It then entices us Americans and we want to look into it more and more.

Read More
352 Words | 2 Pages

According to Grimke’s document, “sex does not give to

Read More
1332 Words | 6 Pages

The hookup culture has taken an arguably new form that wasn’t seen before, which is that casual sex is now the norm (Wade 49). This new form occurs when American’s shifted out of the Victorian Era and

Read More
1425 Words | 6 Pages

This minimal criterion, according to Goldman, is both necessary and sufficient to qualify normal desire as sexual. The mentioned above “repression argument” is grounded on a critics of the paradigms of ‘morality’, ‘naturalness’ and ‘normality’. They distort the concept of sex per se by ascribing external goals to it, such as reproduction, expression of love or other communicative intentions. These judgments and biases are allegedly intrinsic to sex itself, but they can only be justified through arguments non-related to the sphere of sexual desire.

Read More
1046 Words | 5 Pages

He portrays how the criterion of penetration as a distinction between masturbation and sexual acts fails the rational analysis. Other modified definitions of masturbation also run into trouble. He finally concludes, after giving many modifications of the original common sense definition of masturbation, that in truth most of our sexual acts are in essence masturbatory. He disagrees with some other philosophers like Goldman who think that masturbation is not even a sexual activity. He also illustrates that the claim that masturbation is sexual perversion is logically not sound.

Read More
986 Words | 4 Pages

There are lots of sexual acts of which society does or has disapproved (adultery) but are not considered perversions. He offers examples to the elucidate his position. Voyeurism, exhibitionism, sadism and masochism are, according to Nagel, incomplete forms of communication. Nagel also talks about homosexuality, and settles that using this quarrel one can hardly call homosexuality perverse, since two persons of the same sex can certainly have complete communication (Nagel, 16). Though in this way he emphasizes his prior declarations about fetishism, bestiality, and sex with more than one pair of partners.

Read More
1831 Words | 8 Pages

The tone that was build up in the beginning was formal and made it seem like having sex without any pleasure is a beautiful act because the poet uses images like “beautiful dancers” and “ice skaters” who “glide”. This kind of confuses the reader, but this aspect of the poem means that even if there is no love between the two people, the act of sex is a beautiful thing in general. To the poet sex feels like “beautiful dancers” and “ice skaters” who “glide”.   “How do they do it, the ones who make love without love? Beautiful as dancers, gliding over each other like ice-skaters over the ice, fingers hooked inside each other's bodies, faces red as steak, wine, wet as the children at birth whose

Read More
1886 Words | 8 Pages

The title of the book “Virgins” communicates more than the first sexual act. It depicts the inability to make personal decisions without basing off other people’s opinions and beliefs. The story is an analysis of the progression of two females and their interaction with men. Though different, each girl has a different perception of sexual anatomy and hence Evans is able to communicate his message that virginity or sexuality is something that is a sole decision of someone despite whether they have had vaginal sex or not. Throughout the story, Erica is unsure with men.

Read More
1385 Words | 6 Pages

Moreover, this restriction on expressing sexuality encourages passive behavior amongst women. In addition, linking a woman’s ethics to her body reinforces the double standard related to sexuality between men and women. Ultimately, being sexual is “stigmatized in women, but encouraged in men” (Heldman, Part 2). This double standard, combined with the expectations of passivity, reinforces the concept of rape culture. Women are expected to refrain from sex in order to embody purity and thus, are defined by what they do not do.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

He talked about how the experts began examining sexuality in a scientific manner in order to learn the “truth” of sex. He dismissed the notion that sex was a repressed topic to talk about in the 17th, 18th, 19th and early 20th centuries. He said that in fact, it was during this time that people started talking more about sex. He argued that this hypothesis of not

Read More

More about An Inclusive View In Alan Goldman's 'Plain Sex'

Related Topics

Open Document