ipl-logo

Analysis Of Anthony Carnevale's Essay 'College Is Still Worth It'

730 Words3 Pages

In our modern society, College is a key to success. As a result, people with college degrees tend to receive more respect than people without college degrees. In Anthony P. Carnevale’s essay, “College is still worth it”, published in January of 2011, Carnevale argues that the official Bureau of Labor (BLS) data is not correct. This is because the income data show that employers pay workers with college degrees a remuneration inducement. As specified by Carnevale, it would be illogical if the education associated with the college degree were not upscale for the job. The actual earnings of the college graduates are not tracked to determine the demand for higher education. He explains how this argument about the “Bureau of Labor Statistics …show more content…

He structures his essay to make a valid argument. The formation of his essay is a preview of what will be discussed in detail. He begins his argument from an economic perspective, pointing out that the national Bureau of Labor Statistics data is incorrect because it under-predict demand for college educations. He shows his audience that the BLS predictions do not come close to what actually happened in the economy. For an example, the Bureau undercounted the number of postsecondary educated workers by about 17 million in the year of 2006. In 2008, the Bureau undercounted the number of postsecondary educated workers roughly by 22 million people. Carnevale adds his opinion on how to reconcile the BLS projections with real life, “is to assert that the Bureau’s projections reflect the number of college degrees employers actually require, not the actual numbers of college educated workers they decide to hire” (Carnevale 370). This statement help show his opinion is backed up by …show more content…

Some people blame colleges and advise students to skip college. They question the value of college because of the funds needed to pursue a postsecondary education. Carnevale states that skipping college is bad advice. He convinces his audience that a dim job market combined with advance technology is only adding the demand for more skilled and educated workers. Most employers like to see those with postsecondary education as the most capable of adapting to new economic realities. These employers are willing to pay for citizens with college degrees. Carnevale introduces higher pay to college graduates. As a result, jobs that do not require a college degree will pay postsecondary educated workers more money than high school graduates. Carnevale explains a college degree usually leads to higher income and adding new college graduates will stop the rise of income inequality. It is clear to the readers that college graduates have the biggest advantage to thrive in a competitive

Show More
Related
1013 Words | 5 Pages

Their statement supports the author and his case by supplying extra facts about college graduates not having a job right after so they resort to a lower paying job where college may not be required. Continuously, Rose talks about the basics such as reading, writing, and simple math as a being “cognitively rich” (1041). Using a logical approach, he set an example for why blue collar workers are just as intelligent as white-collar workers by saying

Read More
835 Words | 4 Pages

In an essay that appeared on InsideHigherEd.com titled, “On ‘Real Education’”, South Dakota Board of Regents executive director Robert T. Perry writes about the need for more people to graduate from a community college or a university. Through the use of facts and statistics from agencies like the U.S. Department of Labor and the National Center for Higher Education, and his own credibility, Perry shows that there is a significant need for more college degrees. He states that a higher education will help the individual's standard of living as well as the American economy. In support of his position, Perry makes references to a book written by Charles Murray called Real Education, stating that “his pessimistic view of people’s ability to learn ignores...the real pressures the American economy is facing” (670). Obtaining a college degree can

Read More
1540 Words | 7 Pages

In the article, “Should Everyone Go to College,” authors, Stephanie Owen and Isabel Sawhill’s, published by the Brookings Institution, discusses the benefits of a college education. The article begins by mentioning the arguments related to the requirement of having a college degree while entering the middle class in the United States. Having a college degree reminds people that higher education is the best advancement humans can make to allow them to make more money in their lifetimes, rather than if they just had a high school education. A fact that does not get much attention is not all college graduates, or college degrees, are equal. Even though Owen and Sawhill focus, in general, alternative career paths may result in equally lucrative

Read More
1124 Words | 5 Pages

Some of the considerations about education have changed when we compare those considerations by looking closely at the qualifications of the blue-collar workers and students. Two writers looked at different generations, and one of them focused on the experiences of the blue-collar workers; however, the other writer looked at considerations from another perspective by paying attention to statistics. While in “Blue-Collar Brilliance,” Mike Rose claims that college is not necessary in “Are Too Many People Going to College,” Charles Murray believes college is somehow necessary; however, both Rose and Murray agree on how we value knowledge and how we measure intelligence. First of all, although Rose believes that college is not necessary, Murray claims that

Read More
910 Words | 4 Pages

In his essay, "College isn't for Everyone. Let's Stop Pretending It Is," Michael Petrilli uses the title of his article to clearly state the opinion that college is simply not for everyone. He supports this opinion on the statistically low college graduation rate of lower income students. He links this low rate of graduation to poor performance in high school, which leaves students unready for college upon completion of twelfth grade. On the job technical training is presented as a viable alternative to college, where a skill can be obtained to provide a career.

Read More
1204 Words | 5 Pages

The authors use the data very effectively as they use charts and graphs to help back up the information they have presented in the text. Accurate data not only back up their points, it is used to persuade the student to maybe choose a different route for schooling. The authors break down the number of earnings for bachelor degrees, and high school diplomas from the age of 22 to 64. The data is effectively presented through a chart comparing the data showing that the people who graduate with a bachelor’s degree end up with “$12,000 dollars more than high school graduates.” (Sawhill & Owen, 2015).

Read More
900 Words | 4 Pages

Recently, many have begun to attack and degrade higher education in the United States. In the book How College Works, authors Daniel Chambliss and Christopher Takacs claim, “As state support has eroded, and as more students attend college in an increasingly desperate attempt to find viable jobs, the price to students of attending an institution of higher education has gone up, especially at more selective institutions” (172). So is college even worth it? Caroline Bird’s excerpt from her book Case Against College “Where College Fails Us” is an adequately written article that agrees with those who question whether college is a good investment. Bird argues that although some students would benefit from college and succeed, many fall short, wasting

Read More
752 Words | 4 Pages

The authors gathered research from the Hamilton Project and also created graphs to provide the reader with the facts and statistics they need to make their own decision whether they should go to college or not. When the provided data is considered, it’s hard to see why someone wouldn’t choose to attend college and earn a degree. The authors were successful in achieving the goal of getting their point across by simply stating hard undisputed facts on earnings which is why this is a good example of logos in the authors’

Read More
623 Words | 3 Pages

As opposed to much of the past, most jobs today require at least a small amount of higher education, and the work field is increasingly competitive. This need for further education allows colleges to raise tuition costs, as most people have no choice but to pay the fees to have a career. Colleges are also spending more money trying to compete in rankings. Despite all this spending, the article states that “America has only the 15th-largest proportion of young people with a university

Read More
1309 Words | 6 Pages

Education – An investment and stewardship Benjamin Franklin once said, “An investment in knowledge pays the best interest”. However, in today, some people opine that college education is a worthless investment and waste of time. Against this opinion, law professor, Rodney K. Smith, in his USA Today essay in December, 2011, “Yes, A College Education Is Worth The Costs,” analyzes the importance of education in providing people with job and benefits. His first goal is to raise awareness of the correlation between the educational attainment and income as well as unemployment rate.

Read More
2054 Words | 9 Pages

What does it mean to be a college graduate and do they really care about your career? In this essay, “We Send Too Many Students To College (2011)”, Marty Nemko’s, asserts, that colleges are a business as well as students are a cost item. Nemko supports his claim by illustrating authoritative quotes with the nationwide survey conducted by UCLA researchers. Nemko’s purpose points out the way colleges misinform high school students who are seeking a degree where sometimes employment is difficult to acquire, in order to collect billions of tax dollars with minimal accountability.

Read More
482 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion, the author is stating that all the statistics should be laid out for the student and left up to them to decide if they are interested in pursuing college. In sum, then, the issue is whether college is worth the time or money. Though I concede that college is pricey and can consume a lot of your time, my view is that college is the best option after high school. Writers of article “Should Everyone go to college” suggest three main reasons as to why high school students should think twice before attending college.

Read More
1022 Words | 5 Pages

In Rotherham’s article he says “According to the Bureau of labor Statistics, in 2010, the median weekly earnings for someone with some college but no degree were $712, compared to $1,038 for a college graduate. ”the evidence provided clearly shows that getting a higher education and investing time and money into getting a college degree can result in earning more financially for people to support themselves and their families. The opposing side of this argument might say that “even though begin a college graduate, and having a degree can lead to finding well paying jobs. Graduates are often left drowning in

Read More
1197 Words | 5 Pages

Is College Worth the Cost? Life’s success is achieved in different ways. (Director, n.d.) A lot of television programs and magazines instills the idea in us that being successful means; having a fulfilling career, having a lot of money and being powerful. Most religious and spiritual organizations, in contrast, claim that success means being at peace with God and finding spiritual happiness.

Read More
728 Words | 3 Pages

There is a positive correlation between higher levels of education and higher earnings for all racial/ethnic groups and for both men and women. Furthermore, college graduates are more likely than others to enjoy employer-provided health insurance and pension benefits (Baum & Ma, 2007; Pacarella & Terenzini, 2005). To illustrate this point, compare the average earnings of individuals with a bachelor degree relative to the average earnings of individuals with a high school diploma, expressed as a percentage, it is reasonably clear that the premium to bachelor’s degree has increased in the past twentieth century (Boesel & Fredland, 1999; Bound & Johnson, 1992; Freeman, 1994; Grogger & Eide, 1995; Katz & Murphy, 1992; Levy & Murnane, 1992; Murphy and Welch, 1992; Pencavel, 1991). In 1971, both male and female bachelor’s degree holders had an average annual earnings advantage (adjusted for inflation) of 48.5 percent over those who only hold a high school diploma (Pacarella & Terenzini, 2005). The typical bachelor’s degree recipient in 2007 can be expected to earn about 61 percent more than the typical high school graduate (Baum & Ma,

Read More

More about Analysis Of Anthony Carnevale's Essay 'College Is Still Worth It'

Open Document