ipl-logo

Analysis Of Cycles Of Sameness And Difference In LGBT Social Movements

1040 Words5 Pages

In observing “Cycles of Sameness and Difference in LGBT Social Movements" by Amin Ghaziani, Verta Taylor, and Amy Stone, it is clear that this work is different in the fact that the entire paper itself acts a literature review. The article focuses on the similarities and differences between movements and observes prior literature that attempts to explain why these similarities and differences exist and better understand the history and reasoning behind both LGBT and social movements in general. Rather than conducting individual research, Ghaziani and other’s article attempts to explain how and why the history of LGBT movements happened in the way it did. Furthermore, the work is structured according to the three movements it attempts to explain: …show more content…

This is namely in the fact that most literature reviews do not take up the entirety of the work. We also see that there is not much original data present in the work. Rather, the work pieces together theories, ideas, and trends from work within the same field with a focus on LGBT rights. In doing so, the article attempts to create a cohesive and chronological telling of LGBT movements, including the subcultures within the movement and the other social movements occurring at the same time, such as the feminist movement. In observing other articles within the Annual Review of Sociology, we see that this is actually not uncommon, however. For example, “Social Structure, Adversity, Toxic Stress, and Intergenerational Poverty: An Early Childhood Model” by Craig A. McEwen and Bruce S. McEwen is very similar in structure, reviewing other’s literature and connecting theories and models in order to explain how, why, and if these phenomena …show more content…

A Queer Dilemma” by Joshua Gamson. Published in Social Problems, this work has been cited 974 times according to Google Scholar and focuses on the self-destructive nature of identity movements, such as the LGBT movement. Ghaziani’s previous work, The Dividends of Dissent: How Conflict and Culture Work in Lesbian and Gay Marches on Washington, is also heavily emphasized. Unlike Gamson’s work, Ghaziani’s is an independently standing book, which might explain why it is emphasized so heavily. However, outside of “Cycles of Sameness and Difference in LGBT Social Movements,” it is not as heavily cited as Gamson’s with only 124 citations according to Google Scholar. Lastly, we also see Tina Fetner’s How the Religious Right Shaped Lesbian and Gay Activism emphasized and, yet again, it is an independently standing book that is less heavily cited than Gamson’s work with 285 citations according to Google Scholar yet again. In observing all cited works, important sociology journals appears to be Social Problems, Social Theory, and just sociology books in general. Since Cycles of Sameness and Difference in LGBT Social Movements is published in Annual Review of Sociology, one of the top sociology journals, these publications don’t seem to hold the same amount of weight, yet they are important

Show More
Related
173 Words | 1 Pages

In his article ‘Movements before Stonewall need to be remembered, too’, Adam Dupuis discusses the fact that while the Stonewall Uprising was an important event in LGBT history, the events before it should not be dismissed as lesser. The author emphasizes the Annual Reminders, seminal protests which took place in Philadelphia every Fourth of July from 1965 to 1969. Not only were the Annual Reminders the first sustained LGBT demonstrations, but they were the first gay rights protests to have members from multiple cities, with forty activists from Washington, D.C., New York, and Pennsylvania participating. However, these events were discontinued upon the occurrence of the Stonewall Riot in 1969, when the organizers of the Reminders made the decision

Read More
1707 Words | 7 Pages

These efforts were rewarded in the sense that because lesbians were seen as having done a “good work” Homophobic fears began to subside within the ranks of women. Lesbians gained I respect they had not enjoyed before as heterosexual activist chain to appreciate their arguments and saw for themselves how lesbian baiting have been used to stifle the female self-assertion. Because of the growing women's movement in the early 1970s Congress was forced to passed more legislation for women's rights than ever before or since. Document 13 illustrates

Read More
1270 Words | 6 Pages

"The word is out. Christopher Street shall be liberated. The gays have had it with oppression. " The Stonewall riots were arguably the most important event in US, LGBT (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender) history. There might be some people you have heard of like Marsha P Johnson that rioted at Stonewall for a significant amount of time and helped lead the revolution.

Read More
380 Words | 2 Pages

However, she also mentions how this was primarily the “white women’s movement” for sexuality and how it convinced her that lesbian sexuality was naturally different than heterosexual sexuality (Moraga, 393). This white women’s movement was problematic in that it excluded non-white, non-middle class women. Another relation between political activism and eroticism was between radical feminism and lesbianism. Moraga mentions how “radical feminism” viewed lesbianism as a political response to male sexual aggression (Moraga, 395). The Civil Rights Movement was a key moment that exemplifies the link between political activism and spirituality.

Read More
1396 Words | 6 Pages

The riots at the Stonewall Inn served as a catalyst for the LGBT rights movement. This movement then went on to make strides in the acceptance and equality of the LGBT community. After Stonewall, people came to the realization that it was successful because they were loud and unyielding about what they wanted (Dudley 243). As a result, the LGBT community began planning events such as marches and pride parades to communicate their goals, and these demonstrations eventually evolved into the LGBT rights movement. From the Stonewall riots to present day there have been many achievements made by LGBT community, one of these achievements being equality.

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

While women have the right to vote, they are still harassed and discriminated against. The rights to their own bodies are still given and taken away by men. Similarly, while people are allowed to be openly gay without being immediately put in jail, they are still bullied and murdered for their sexual identity. Both of these cases illustrate the continued fight for “genuine equality.” In summary, while the cases aim to protect 2 different groups of people, they have similar outcomes and both are a part of ongoing

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

To elaborate, on June 26, 2015, the US supreme court made gay marriage legal in all 50 states. As a state that is strongly fixed on both individualistic and more specifically, traditionalistic values, the platform of these political cultures in Texas were challenged through means of media. A culture that is based on traditional values strives away from changes and is resistant to accepting new laws, such as the legalization of same sex marriage. However, pop culture and widespread media shared amongst the citizens of the state of Texas, opened and shaped the debate over this issue. In fact, “scholars agree that the news media have become more attentive to and supportive of lesbian and gay rights over time.”

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

When debating the legalization of same sex marriage, religious reasoning and accusations of bigotry often provoke obstinance. Instead of reiterating those arguments, William J. Bennett, a prominent cultural conservative, former secretary of education, and author of The Book of Virtues, focuses on societal effects in his op-ed article, “Against Gay Marriage.” Though Bennett’s piece conveys partiality, it also attempts to discuss this issue scrupulously to ensure readers will consider his argument and perhaps accept his implications. While some of Bennett’s word choices convey tolerance of the gay community, his rhetoric incites readers to accept that preserving society requires marginalizing homosexuals.

Read More
1265 Words | 6 Pages

While many Americans hold a general knowledge of GLBTQ history, a significant chunk of this history is still missing from the public, and even academia’s knowledge. The span of time from 1890 to 1940 saw a wealth of gay activity go unrecognized in favor of the dominant “progress narrative” which, instead, remembers only a linear progression of gay history. This linear progression posits that the fight for gay rights didn’t exist until a rather recent point in time, and rights were only given, and never taken away after this point. The idea of a linear timeline doesn’t allow for any fluctuation in the liberties held by gay people, but George Chauncey attacks this idea in his book Gay New York Gender, Urban Culture, and the Making of the Gay

Read More
1429 Words | 6 Pages

The Vietnam War, which included violence and tragedy, the outbreaks of sustained public violence and assassinations, the Black Panther Party, the rise of Women's suffrage, and the introduction of birth control pills caused “homosexual liberation and struck against anti-homosexual prejudice” appeared. From the LGBTQ+ community, there was a massive increase in pop culture and social activism, the sexual liberation movement as well as the AIDs epidemic, causing an extreme social change. A group called GLF, Gay Liberation Front had an intellectual and political excitement during this time. GLF organized Sunday night meetings and was able to publish in the newspaper Come Out!, which became highly influential for the LGBT community. The GLF started the Gay Activists Alliance, GAA, which mainly focused on achieving civil rights for gay people.

Read More
671 Words | 3 Pages

The Stonewall Riots are said to mark the beginning of the modern LGBT rights movement, and it was largely initiated by transgender women of color. Over the next few decades, legislation would be enacted to aid the cause for equality. By 1977, trans athletes could play on the teams of their gender identities, and by 1993 anti-discrimination laws were extended to transpeople in Minnesota. In the 21st century alone, transpeople were getting invited to the White House, playing in college sports, and serving as judges, all without having to hide who they were (“Milestones in the American Transgender Movement”). Hardships are still all too common, unfortunately, but much progress has been made nonetheless, and the fight continues to this

Read More
822 Words | 4 Pages

The feminist movement and the gay rights movement are two communities that have been fighting for their rights for a long time and are similar in many ways, yet different in many others. While they are both social movements, the feminist movement’s main focus is on women’s rights, while the gay rights movement’s main focus is on gay rights. Similar to each other or not, the two movements could (and do) benefit from each other. Both women and gay people have faced discrimination due to being seen as lesser in the eyes of society. However, the reasons for this discrimination they face/have faced are very different.

Read More
1849 Words | 8 Pages

In being seen as different and as challenging a societal norm, they are often ostracized and discriminated against. Therefore, in an investigation into the higher rate of suicide among LGBTQ youth, people should not look to them for the cause, but to themselves and their stigmatization of the LGBTQ youths because people perceive them as “different from

Read More
902 Words | 4 Pages

The Civil Rights Movement gained traction around the 1950s, paving the way for many other oppressed groups. These groups fought for different rights, but they still had a similar struggle to the original movement. One of these groups is the Gay Rights Movement. The comparison between the black civil rights movement and the gay civil rights movement is “typically a sensitive subject, even among liberals” (Williams). Some people believe that it is unfair to compare a fight for marriage to a fight to gain equality in every aspect.

Read More
1612 Words | 7 Pages

People once used to enslaved people and abused people who simply had different skin tones; they were not conceived as human under the law. Now as history has shown us, that wasn’t justice. In every civil rights conflict we are only able to recognize the just point of view years after the fact and when the next conflict comes along we are blind once again. (Amanda) As I’m writing down this paper we are repeating history once in for all. LGBT communities are just HUMANS who are

Read More

More about Analysis Of Cycles Of Sameness And Difference In LGBT Social Movements

Related Topics

Open Document