ipl-logo

Analysis Of Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?

1504 Words7 Pages

In her paper, “Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?” prominent anthropologist Lina Abu – Lughod critiques the “women’s liberation” argument used to garter American support for the war in the Middle East. This paper is particularly interesting as it discusses the anthropologic implications of one of the events that shaped the 21st century, 9/11. To give context, In October 2001, following the Al-Queda attacks on the World Trade Center which killed 3000 men and women, (Intervention narrative, p.140) US President George W. Bush launched his so-called “War on Terror” and invaded Afghanistan, then occupied by the oppressive Taliban. Despite the invasion presumably being a response to the 9/11 attack, Abu-Lughod tells readers that if one looks farther …show more content…

As explored in Chapter 2 of the course, a symbol is something that stand for something else (book, p.20). Each culture has symbols that hold heavy meanings for them and are an essential part of their learned ways.(book) An example of such symbols, which is mentioned repeatedly throughout Abu-Lughod’s article and is subject of heavy controversy is the Islamic practice of veiling ones body and face. For US citizens, veiling is a symbol of women’s oppression by the Taliban. Whereas on the contrary, for Islamic women veiling is a voluntary act symbolizing modesty, morality, and honor.(quote) There is a hypocrisy in the sense that US citizens advocate for Afghan women to have rights yet seem reluctant to accept that it is Afghan women’s will to veil themselves. This discussion brings us back to ethnocentrism, the belief that one’s culture is better than the others, because Americans assume that Afghan women need to dress themselves in a matter fitting of the West. In their minds, Western culture and clothing are what is right, and cannot accept the possibility that other women would want to dress differently. Yet, as Abu-Lughod perfectly lays it, people wear the appropriate form of dress for their social communities and are guided by socially shared standards, religious beliefs, and moral ideals. (Do Muslim Women Need Saving) The act of veiling is an essential part of Islamic religion, deeply rooted in its cultures. As anthropologists know, culture is adaptive (quote book, p.29) meaning it develops in response to the environment in which individuals live. To understand how the practice of veiling has emerged and evolved, it is essential to look at the Qur’an, the holy book of Islam that Muslims consider the direct word of God. (What is veiling p.22) In the Qur’an, it is explained that in the time of the prophet Mohammed, who through God’s words authored the Qur’an according to Islamic religion, it was

Show More
Related
797 Words | 4 Pages

The presence of Veils in America brought up all types of stereotypes and likewise can be said about woman’s positions at the workplace. - Our culture influences our

Read More
1063 Words | 5 Pages

In Western nations, arguments against the burqa are sometimes stoked by racist and nationalist discourse that demonizes Muslim women who wear it. It is important to understand

Read More
468 Words | 2 Pages

A symbol is a representation of something. A symbol is often a material or object signifying something abstract. In the novel speaks by Laurie Hassle Anderson, the use of symbolism helps the reader better understand the inner working of the main character. Laurie uses mirrors, blood, a Maya Angelo poster, seeds, plants, and trees to help the reader better understand Melinda. Mirrors.

Read More
774 Words | 4 Pages

The first section I will be talking to you about is the act of prohibiting the wearing of burqas in the United States. The second point I will be discussing about is my point of view on the act of prohibiting Syrian and/or Saudi Arabian refugees from entering the United states without presidential approval. The final section I will be discussing to you about is about Immigrants At a camp at Kohat, Pakistan there were two suicide bombers, disguised with burqas, that struck the camp. The attack killed 41 people and injured about 62 people. In another case there were seven Afghan Taliban terrorists who were wearing burqas.

Read More
1715 Words | 7 Pages

Khaled Hosseini’s A Thousand Splendid Suns depicts the conflict in Afghanistan through the lens of the country’s oppressed women. At first glance, the novel appears to be a depiction of the appalling injustice and cruelty endured by women in Afghan society. However, the novel expands on the issue of domestic violence to look at the conflict and injustice in Afghanistan as a whole. While A Thousand Splendid Suns focuses on acts of violence and terror, Hosseini’s message may be far more hopeful than the novel’s grim atmosphere may suggest. By examining the conflicts both within a household and in Afghanistan as a whole, Hosseini suggests that anyone can resist and rise above oppression.

Read More
894 Words | 4 Pages

In 1939, Reza Shah’s unveiling declaration sparked a worldwide debate as to what the veil actually symbolizes. Ever since the beginning of Islam, women throughout the Islamic world have had to adopt the hijab as part of their cultural and religious attire due to various interpretations of the Islamic dress code. In addition, the Koran emphasizes purity in the name of Islam by asking both men and women to be modest when it comes to the way they dress. Furthermore, in his efforts to modernize Iran, Reza Shah failed to satisfy the needs of his people, as he gave women no say in what they could and could not wear in public. This eventually resulted in the division of Iranian women, as there were those who favored the Islamic tradition, and those who supported the regime and its adoption of Western values.

Read More
707 Words | 3 Pages

Jonathan Wert 5/7/17 French History Dr. Blackman Politics of the Veil Politics of the Veil, written by Joan Wallach Scott, is about the 2004 controversial headscarf ban in France. Scott opens with, “This is not a book about French Muslims; it is about the dominant French view of them.” Scott examines the political storm surrounding the French ban on headscarves for girls eighteen or younger in public schools. The book is an easy read, filled with first-hand accounts of the racism felt by Muslim women.

Read More
1669 Words | 7 Pages

The issue of the veil has come to represent the essence of Islam, not only to the West, but also to Muslim Conservatives and Fundamentalists. To some in the West, the veil represents repression and constriction of women’s freedom and choice, limiting their capacity for self-determination. However, some Muslims would argue that women must veil because it is a first step towards restoring true Islam and a defiance against the West Interventionist policies (Lazreg, Why Women Should Not Wear the Veil, pg. 113). Additionally, the idea of freedom as the ultimate value, is a western standard and that for some, piety is more important. Lila Abu-Lughod and Marnia Lazreg have contrasting views on the veiling of Muslim women and the affects it has on their lives.

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

This scene takes place 5 days later to emphasize that the mother is still affected by what happened to her days after the event. In the living room, the news is on and a government official is on the screen stating that women are required to wear the veil. What is ironic is that the government official does include that women have to wear the veil for religious reasons, along with the fact that women must cover themselves so men are not sexually appealed to them. In the original text, the man only talks about the veil protecting women from men. I wanted to add on more to this, to connect it with my historical brief and research about Khomeini.

Read More
793 Words | 4 Pages

“Symbolism is the use of symbols to signify ideas and qualities by giving them symbolic meanings that are different from their literal sense.” Symbols can add a deeper meaning than just an object itself that the author is trying to make. Symbols can also foreshadow what is yet to come. The audience can interpret a symbol in many ways it depends on their experience. In Southside Chicago the Younger family is struggling to have hope as they are always facing society.

Read More
1475 Words | 6 Pages

The French veil ban is thus particularly problematic because it implies that there is an idealized essence of Frenchness that Muslim women must acquiesce to, in order to be functioning and valuable members of French society. This essence of Frenchness is not dissimilar from the essences of citizenship found in other countries - most certainly America encourages “outsiders” to adhere to American “values” and assimilate to American “culture.” However, the French are unique in that their sense of secularism in the public sphere is much more prevalent than in most other Western countries, and no doubt French society is much more secular than American society; as such, Islam’s place in French society is under scrutiny from both cultural and racial

Read More
1034 Words | 5 Pages

Due to the restrictions made by the Iranian government, women were required to cover themselves from head to toe (98), otherwise, men get mad at them. Covering up took away any sort of belonging to their homeland as they were forced to follow rules. The restricted clothing choices took away Marji’s identity, however in her pictures, she always puts herself in a patterned shirt or has patterned bedding. Despite the restrictive rules, and not in the present, this was a way Marji expressed herself during her writing process. Even as a child, the requirement to wear the veil was something Marji questioned (3), along with many of her classmates.

Read More
486 Words | 2 Pages

In my opinion, this is a really interesting topic. I am a Greek Orthodox Christian, and I did not have much knowledge about Muslims. I have seen plenty of times, girls wearing the hijab, but I always thought that their family press them to wear it just because it’s part of their culture. As our textbook, “Religion and Culture” explains, this cloth used to symbolize the loyalty of a woman, “Apparently, this tradition of the wearing of the hijab was associated with upper-class women among the elite in these societies” (Scupin 446). That means that the royal or the upper class women, who did not have to work, used to wear veil in the public to protect themselves from the staring of people, and most specifically of men.

Read More
1539 Words | 7 Pages

This highlights the importance of how these acts of cruelty Mariam and Laila faced; ‘fear of the goat, released in the tiger’s cage’ is what ultimately defines their inner feminist strength, ‘over the years/learned to harden’ which shows that Mariam and Laila’s past indirectly prepares them for The Taliban’s arrival. The Taliban take away the basic rights of Mariam and Laila ‘jewellery is forbidden’, but they fail to do so. Ironically, it is the society itself that gives them the strength and platform to strike back against Rasheed, who is a cruel, male-dominating character who symbolised and reinforced everything the term ‘anti-feminist’ stands

Read More
2077 Words | 9 Pages

A. PREAMBLE The terrorist attack on September 11, 2001 has sparked intense curiosity and interest in the world especially the West to learn and investigate the religion of Islam. The Muslim people are portrayed as violent and barbaric, and Islam as oppressive and antithesis to human rights values. Thus, escalation of public opinion about Islam has encouraged debates and forums, and also stirred demonstrations and movements which have compelled the Muslims to speak out their minds and interpret and recast their texts viz. Quran and Sunnah of prophet Mohammad and even question and challenge the prevailing culture and practices, and domineering structures.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Do Muslim Women Really Need Saving?

Related Topics

Open Document