ipl-logo

Analysis Of Emily Murphy's Case: A Defining Moment For Canada

1526 Words7 Pages

The Persons Case, a Defining Moment for Canada.

Madeleine Balfour

History 111
Dr. Denis Dubord
May 26, 2017

In 2015, the Prime Minister of Canada announced a gender balanced cabinet in which half of its members were women. However, it was not until the Emily Murphy and the Famous Five won the Persons Case, a mere 88 years ago, that women were legally considered people. In the mid to late 19th century, political, and public life was largely run by men at the provincial and municipal levels. The societal and political atmosphere for women was severely limited; women were expected to be homemakers and were frowned upon for working outside of the home if they were married1. They could …show more content…

She campaigned for the protection of women and children, who, in the late 19th century and early 20th century, had meager protection under the law2. In 1916, Murphy was, arguably, the catalyst for the Persons Case with her involvement in a trial in which women were accused of prostitution. This trial was attended by Murphy and other women but they were rejected on the basis that women were not welcome at the tribunal. Murphy appealed to Charles Wilson Cross, the Attorney General of Alberta, by saying “if the evidence is not fit for mixed company, then the government must set up a court presided by women, to try other women1.” Unexpectedly, the Attorney General agreed and appointed her as the Police Magistrate of the Court of Edmonton1. Regardless of her appointment, she was met with heated resistance by her male peers. Her first case was challenged by the defence lawyer claiming she was not a person under the British North America Act of 1867 3. This was due to ambiguous and gendered language in Section 24 of the British North America Act of 1867. The BNA act of 1867, also known as the Constitution Act, were a collection of policies in the Constitution of Canada. Section 24 stated that only “qualified persons” could be appointed to the Canadian Senate5. While Murphy’s sentence as magistrate was upheld by the Supreme Court of Alberta, she became inspired to campaign …show more content…

Uglow, Frances Hinton, and Maggy Hendry. 4th ed. Macmillan Publishers Ltd, 2005 3) Valerie Knowles, First Person: A Biography of Cairine Wilson Canada'as First Woman Senator. Louiseville: Dundurn Press Ltd., 1988. 4)Robert J. Sharpe, Patricia I. McMahon Persons Case: The Origins and Legacy of the Fight for Legal Personhood. Toronto: Univ of Toronto Press, 2007, 1-206 5) Michael Dorland and Maurice René. Charland, Law, rhetoric and irony in the formation of Canadian civil culture (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 2002), 218. 6) Vivien Hughes. "How the Famous Five in Canada Won Personhood for Women." London Journal of Canadian Studies 17 (2002): 60-70. Accessed May 20, 2017. Canadian High Comission. 7)"The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council Decisions." Henrietta Muir Edwards and others (Appeal No. 121 of 1928) v The Attorney General of Canada (Canada) [1929] UKPC 86 (18 October 1929). Accessed May 25, 2017.

Show More
Related
846 Words | 4 Pages

Certainly, the case exposed the underhanded method of tax evasion as a means in which to punish Desmond for violating the invisible cods of conduct in the private sector venue of the Roseland Theater. The legal judgment of owing “one cent” for a tax violation was the ultimate decision of the court. This “echo” of the Jim Crow laws defines the underlying resistance to desegregation in Nova Scotia, which made an impact on the social consciousness of the people. The judgment of the courts in relation to the purchase of a ticket, which would eventually galvanize the Civil Rights Movement in Canada. These factors define the sentencing of the Desmond case as another means in which a racially motivated legal institution would lay the foundations for Civil Rights actions against these underhanded methods of legal enforcement of racism in

Read More
2747 Words | 11 Pages

Additionally, Trudeau then was tasked with attempting to negotiate a settlement with the reluctant premiers, which argues that Trudeau's strategic maneuvers and the premiers' unyielding resistance reflect the clash between centralizing and decentralizing forces within Canada's political landscape. The disagreement over the language rights made the settlement process far more complicated than expected. The amending formula and the provisions on language rights became central points of contention, reflecting the deeply entrenched regional divisions and divergent views on federalism and individual rights. Trudeau was very passionate about his version of the Charter, and Graham argues that Trudeau used his abilities and background in his longstanding commitment to human rights and democratic freedoms, shaped by his experiences as a student and his efforts to combat oppression and discrimination in Quebec in the 1940s to push for said

Read More
1760 Words | 8 Pages

Howell, Colin. " Richard, Maurice 'Rocket' (1921-2000). " Oxford Companion to Canadian History (2006): 544-.

Read More
939 Words | 4 Pages

Jamshaid Goraya Ms. Grossi NBE 3U Monday, March 20th, 2023 The Fight for Equality Comparison There are many ways in which the spoken word “Poet Calls out Justin Trudeau on Indigenous Rights” and the video “Wab Kinew 500 years in 2 minutes” differ in their tone. The spoken word “Poet Calls out Justin Trudeau on Indigenous Rights” is about a woman whose ancestral land is about to get flooded. Whereas the video “Wab Kinew 500 years in 2 minutes” is about a person who tells the audience about the history of the Indigenous people and the Queen's promise to the Cree of Bounty and Benevolence. Although “Poet Calls out Justin Trudeau on Indigenous rights” by Helen Knott and Wab Kinew 500 years in 2 minutes by Wab Kinew are different in terms of tone,

Read More
2494 Words | 10 Pages

Obscure People of the American Revolution We have all heard of George Washington, Thomas Jefferson, and Benjamin Franklin. These are the most studied, the most documented people of the American Revolution and a few of our country’s Founding Fathers. These are the famous people that everyone refers to when they are either reciting a quote or making a reference to the American Revolution or our Founding Fathers. We all know that these well documented individuals were well educated in the finest schools and that their families had the wealth to accomplish anything they wished.

Read More
1784 Words | 8 Pages

In the 2015 book, Notorious RBG: The Life and Times of Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Irin Carmon and Shana Knizhnik evaluate the significant role Ginsburg has had to United States policy on equality and women’s rights. The authors of Notorious RBG, present the structured internal initiative and personal influences of Ginsburg, that contributed to her life-long achievement in academics and scholarly enlightenment. Carmon and Knizhnik describe how Ginsburg juggled her professional aspirations and family life while continuing to present the legal world with arguments that aided in shifting popular opinion about female equality compared to males in our society. In Notorious RBG, Ginsburg’s meticulous and tireless devotion to cases for the Women’s Project

Read More
613 Words | 3 Pages

William Lyon Mackenzie King stands as a towering figure in Canadian history, his legacy intertwined with the very fabric of the nation's identity. Throughout his remarkable tenure as Prime Minister, spanning over two decades, King navigated Canada through the turbulent waters of the 20th century, leaving an indelible mark on its social, economic, and political landscape. This essay delves into the life and achievements of Mackenzie King, exploring his historic significance and enduring impact on Canadian history. Early Life and Education Born in Kitchener, Ontario, in 1874, Mackenzie King was immersed in a family steeped in political activism and civic engagement. His grandfather, William Lyon Mackenzie, was a prominent figure in Canadian history,

Read More
709 Words | 3 Pages

Finally, Canada was stronger because of America’s Sweetheart, Mary Pickford. The above groups and individual were able to inspire and make change, which made our country all the stronger. The Famous Five are a group that made Canada stronger. In 1914, Nellie McClung staged a “mock parliament” that turned the tables and asked why men would not be allowed to vote.

Read More
5443 Words | 22 Pages

The nineteenth century saw the emergence of the Metis leader Louis Riel, one of, if not Canada’s most controversial and contentious public figures. Since the hanging of Riel for treason in 1885, his legacy and reputation has been under continuous scrutiny and invented and reinvented to suit the political, ideological and philosophical agendas of historians, Political Scientists, politicians, policy makers, ethnic groups and the majority of Canadian Citizens. The depictions and perceptions of this leader by Canadians are various, opposite and contradictory to one another, which could be assessed from titles that are given to him: a traitor to the Confederation of Canada, a ‘Father of Confederation,’ a Catholic Martyr, a rebel, a prophet, a madman,

Read More
975 Words | 4 Pages

This investigation will explore the question: To what extent was the degree of threat posed by a Japanese-Americans during the Second World War equivalent to the treatment they received from the US government? The 1930s - 1940s will be the focus of this investigation, to allow for an analysis of transcript evidence Roosevelt received before making the decision, as well as the political and public pressure that fueled up the decision. 1) The first source evaluated is a memorandum to the President from Attorney General Francis Biddle in February 17, 1942. The origin of this source is valuable because it was written directly from Francis Biddle; who was appointed to a number of important governmental roles, thus would have connections and had

Read More
1059 Words | 5 Pages

If dialogue theory is nothing more than a thin cover for judicial supremacy, than how should Canada model the relationship between the legislature and the judiciary? The answer lies in coordinate interpretation. Coordinate interpretation envisions that every branch that interacts with the Charter (the judiciary, the executive, and the legislative) will have equal responsibilities in upholding and advancing the values in the Charter (Slattery, 1987, 707). Under coordinate interpretation, the executive and the legislative branches would have “first order” duties, which means they would be expected to scrutinize legislation that they intend to pass in order to ensure Charter compliance; likewise, they also have a duty to scrutinize legislation

Read More
827 Words | 4 Pages

For example, Gian Singh was one of them, and how he spent countless hours in court trying to prove a point and make sure that the Sikh community of Canada is safe and is not stereotyped for other people's mistakes or certain people that did something wrong. Each person that supports and helps Gian Singh shows the courage of the human spirit, and their struggles shed light on the larger systemic issues that have plagued Canadian society for

Read More
734 Words | 3 Pages

General Info: - 19th century= Canadian women organizing to change place in society= equality - The women 's movement = demanded justice. achieved some equality for Canadian women in legal and political ways. - Canadian woman tried to change society for better - Fought for their rights - Previous to WW1: low paying jobs for women - Ended careers once married - National council of women formed in 1893. Helped improved public health, immigrants, factory workers - In 1919 eleven women in Ontario became lawyers - In 1927 first woman engineer graduated U of T Voting/ political: - 1893- national council of women was founded - By 1900- throughout Canada, municipal voting privileges for propertied woman were general - 1918- council contributed to

Read More
1219 Words | 5 Pages

Before the Charter, many people may argue that Canada was a free and democratic country. Canadians had the freedom of expression, equality and the principles of fundamental justice. What changed with the creation of the Charter was that rights and freedoms were given constitutional status, and judges were given the power to strike down laws that infringed on them. In 1982, most Canadians agreed that the introduction of the Charter was going to monumental. But on the contrary, over 30 years later, numerous laws have been struck down by interpretation of the charter and remedial techniques that have been developed by courts.

Read More
173 Words | 1 Pages

Dorothy Smith is a Canadian Social Anthropologist. She was born in North Allerton, Yorkshire England in 1926. Before attending the London School of Economics (LSE) for her undergraduate, Dorothy Smith had various jobs such as secretarial work. In 1955, Dorothy Smith graduated LSE with a B.Sc.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Emily Murphy's Case: A Defining Moment For Canada

Related Topics

Open Document