ipl-logo

Analysis Of Stephanie Hanes Little Girls Or Little Women? The Disney Princess Effect

570 Words3 Pages

In the article, “Little Girls or Little Women? The Disney Princess Effect” originally published on October 3, 2011 from the Christian Science Monitor, author Stephanie Hanes persuades parents that social media and advertisements are the reasons behind their daughter's wanting to mature too soon. Hanes shapes her argument by using logos and pathos techniques, and using considerate organization of the information. Throughout the article, Hanes makes it evident that the audience of intent is the parents of young girls by referring to other sources such as Disney Princess Recovery: Bringing Sexy Back for a Full Refund, a blog by Mary Finucane, Cinderella Ate My Daughter, a book by Peggy Orenstein, and "What's Wrong With Cinderella?", an essay in New York Times, also by Orenstein. The authors of these sources are mothers sharing their attempts to steer their daughters away from Disney Princesses because of the negative effect it brings on their maturing. Along with this, Hanes mentions Diane Levins, an early childhood specialists at Wheelock College in Boston by saying near the end of the article, "Parents' involvement is key, but they don't have to act alone. Over the past few years, a growing group of advocacy organizations have formed to help fight against marketing pressure and sexualization" (515). By this, she gives off a …show more content…

After researching, Finucane created Disney Princess Recovery: Bringing Sexy Back for a Full Refund, a blog to "reclaim her daughter's awareness after it was hijacked by Disney Princesses" (Finucane). By using a story that portrays the loss of creative energy and interests in young girls, a feeling of sadness and benevolence is created. Furthermore, Hanes uses these feelings to convince parents that there is an adverse influence from Disney Princesses and the

Show More
Related
323 Words | 2 Pages

In "Little Girls or Little Women? The Disney Princess Effect", Stephanie Hanes makes the argument that Disney princesses and modern day media influence young girls in negative ways. Hanes suggests that sexualization is everywhere including cartoons. She points out that any detail such as Ms. Piggy showing cleavage, leads girls to assume that doing so is okay and natural. Furthermore, Hanes asserts that allowing girls to see themselves as sex objects is a contributor to depression, eating disorders, and many other health problems for young girls.

Read More
1378 Words | 6 Pages

There are a variety of facts used in Hollandsworth’s article; however there are a select few that he makes good use of for his argument. Hollandsworth states that $4 billion is annually spent on Disney Princess retail; he uses this fact to claim that girls who wanted to be like princesses did beauty

Read More
712 Words | 3 Pages

The media is a very powerful tool that reaches all ages and can impact how a person views him/herself. These patterns can impact the role models for young girls by misrepresenting the characters (Gill). Disney heroines should be idols for young girls (Gill). The media should not make women feel inferior, instead the media should focus on independent women and how success is not determined by the man they

Read More
532 Words | 3 Pages

In 2011, Peggy Orenstein published Cinderella Ate My Daughter to examine how princess culture impacted girlhood. “What Makes Girls Girls?” is a chapter in this book that delves into the implications of sexual difference and whether or not it is rooted in biology. By studying various research projects conducted by professionals, Orenstein discovers that, ultimately, a child’s environment plays a key role in behavior. To pose the question of whether the concept of gender is inherent, Orenstein references several examples that have sparked a considerable amount of discussion about how a child’s gender expression is molded by upbringing.

Read More
692 Words | 3 Pages

We live in a society where everywhere we look we are presented with a form of media that is trying to influence us in some way, whether it is to buy a product, support a cause, or make a change to our way of thinking. Stephanie Hanes uses this in her article about Mary Finucane’s look on how Disney princesses are a negative influence on little girls. In her article she uses logos, pathos and audience to support her poor arguement on Finucane’s point of view. Hanes uses logos by going over how Finucane came to the conclusion that her three year old daughter became a victim in this cyberbullying society. While she provides the reader with several facts and supports her main idea with a variety of expert opinions the argument is poorly written.

Read More
1343 Words | 6 Pages

However, the later Disney films have gradually attempted to break away from this stereotype resulting in stronger female characters like Ariel, Mulan, and Elsa among others. Keeping this transition in mind, this paper uses semiotic analysis of four popular Disney films, namely, Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs (1937), The Little Mermaid (1989) and Mulan (1998) to depict the influence of societies ' changing perceptions of women on the portrayal of Disney princesses. These films taking into account the earliest film and certain popular characters that have represented a shift from being the coy damsel in distress to a woman who plays an active role in determining her own destiny. The portrayal of the Disney princess has changed in accordance with the development of women in society over time (1937 to 2013) from demure and traditional to

Read More
582 Words | 3 Pages

Logos creates a sense of urgency in the reader’s head that they need to monitor their child’s behavior. One of the credible sources Hanes uses is from a University of Central Florida poll, which found that, “50 percent of 3-6 year old girls worry they’re fat” (*). Hanes argues this statistic could be stemmed from the Disney Princesses image. The princesses have a particular shape and size that has created a standard for body image. The author uses these facts to show her audience that if parents continue to allow their children to view these images, their child will desire to be just like the Disney Princesses.

Read More
1002 Words | 5 Pages

Growing up as a little girl, surrounded by Barbie Dolls, dresses, and piggy-tails, sparked my interest in becoming a princess. I grew up an only child, without any older sisters to teach me how to apply make-up correctly or braid my hair for me. I learned everything by myself, using the auspicious approach of trial and error. After entering middle school, I quickly realized my archetypical goal was not exactly realistic. Although dismayed, I was not discouraged, nor were my interests in cosmetics altered.

Read More
805 Words | 4 Pages

Disney is a multibillion-dollar company who has released dozens of box office hits. Many people attribute this to Disney’s renown but two authors interpret Disney’s success as a matter of psychology. Bruno Bettelheim author of “‘Cinderella’: A Story of Sibling Rivalry and Oedipal Conflicts” and Maria Konnikova author of “How ‘Frozen’ Took Over the World” describe and explain Disney’s success as a deep relation to the psyche of children. While both authors address Disney’s success in the movie industry as a matter of psychology, Bettelheim explains through a Freudian lens using core Freudian psychological concepts such as Oedipus complex while Konnikova describes Disney’s success using statistical evidence and psychological studies pertaining directly to Frozen and its viewers.

Read More
1751 Words | 8 Pages

The timeless tale of glamourized abuse, Perrault’s “The Little Glass Slipper” from 1697, more commonly known as the 1950 Disney classic, “Cinderella.” Lieberman claims that the formation of a child’s ‘psycho-sexual identity’ may be negatively impacted by the representation of female and male behaviour in media. “The Little Glass Slipper” follows the story of a kind and gentle Cinderella whose widowed father married a haughty woman with two daughters. Cinderella is mistreated by her stepmother and stepsisters repeatedly, and her father is never mentioned again in the tale. Her only solace is her godmother, who supports her throughout the fairy tale.

Read More
174 Words | 1 Pages

She defines "the Disney Princess Effect" as something that little girls perceived through watching Disney princess movies. These movies make girls want to be sexy, not feminine. How is that happening? What's so sexy about a princess? I mean I get the whole damsel and distress part, but I thought we have overcome that concept with the stats the author wrote to prove her point.

Read More
956 Words | 4 Pages

In her essay, “Representation of Disney princesses in the media”, Isabelle further infers that the media misrepresents Disney princesses by failing to celebrate their feminine and masculine qualities.

Read More
1285 Words | 6 Pages

Walt Disney has been making girls think that in order to be beautiful you have to be the perfect shape and size. (Shortridge). Some people believe that the Disney Princesses are great role models for children because Mulan teaches us to never give up on the strengths we have just because we are girls, Belle teaches us to never judge a book by its cover, and Pocahontas shows us real princesses are strong leaders. On the other hand, some individuals feel that Disney Princesses are bad role models because of their unrealistic body appearance, telling girls every marriage ends with a happily ever after when you get married at a young age, and saying every girl needs a man in order to be happy. Both sides have valid points but in reality everyone

Read More
524 Words | 3 Pages

Amanda Putnam’s essay, “Mean Ladies: Transgendered Villains in Disney Films”, is a compelling piece on gender portrayal and views in Disney films. Putnam opened the essay with a personal anecdote about her daughter. Her daughter wanted a Disney movie without a “mean lady”, as in most Disney films the villains are scary, evil women. The real life evidence strengthened her claim that children are noticing the characterization of female villains in Disney films. The antidote was brought fill circle when she referred back to her daughter in the final paragraphs of her essay.

Read More
1330 Words | 6 Pages

The Disney princess movies had a great deal of influence on many young girls watching princesses represent what royalty looked like. The princesses are always beautiful, polite and seeking the love of their Prince Charming. This plays a strong role in perpetuating the idea that being a princess means seeking only love from a man, and a man who contains all the stereotypical masculine qualities; handsome, powerful and rich. For example, in The Little Mermaid, Ariel had to give up who she was in order to win over the affection of her prince charming. She traded in her voice in order to have real legs and near Prince Eric.

Read More

More about Analysis Of Stephanie Hanes Little Girls Or Little Women? The Disney Princess Effect

Related Topics

Open Document