ipl-logo

Analysis Of William Deresiewicz's Essay

708 Words3 Pages

In William Deresiewicz’s essay, “The Disadvantages of n Elite Education”, Deresiewicz begins by developing a social scenario that he had with a plumber in his kitchen. Here he explores the first disadvantage of an elite education which he describes as being unable to talk with people who aren't like you, referring to those who didn't attend an Ivy League school. Supporting his statement, Deresiewicz goes on to explain that Elite schools strive to achieve a strong diversity, but only in ethnicity and race and not economic class. As an example, he uses Al Gore and John Kerry, both of whom went to Harvard and Yale respectively. Going along with terrible social ability with non Ivy League alumni, Deresiewicz also claims that his education taught him that those who didn’t attend Ivy League education are below him and not good enough to talk to, no matter their ethnicity, race, or class. Deresiewicz’s second disadvantage to …show more content…

He is frustrated that elite students are supposed to be the smartest and brightest kids around in an academic sense, however they aren't going above and beyond the homework to become intellectuals. Instead, the schools are molding the students into only being able to answer the little questions in life and how to think as a lawyer or doctor. The students that Ivy League’s accept are already trained to do what it takes for the A rather than think outside the main idea. Deresiewicz points out that there are students at middle class universities that are just as smart as Yale and Harvard students, but never pushed to get the grades in high school. They are the thinkers rather than the doers and they will be the ones who end up being the strong intellectuals while the elite educated graduates will become the next Al Gore and John Kerry. As Deresiewicz puts it “She will have many achievements but little experience, great success but no

Show More
Related
270 Words | 2 Pages

In the poem “ Thinking for Berky”, written by William Stafford, the speaker argues that people in the society are so careless and do not understand for people who are not lucky like them, being able to born in a wealthy family with good relationships. The author started out with the setting of the author lying in bed thinking about a girl named Berky and her deaths. He pointing out different forces that lead to her death like her abusive parents, poor family situation, and lastly, people who can’t sympathize with Berky and criticize her for her situations/environments. The speaker also pointed out that there are people out there who can’t think for others and just live their life, thinking that it is Berky fault for living a life like that.

Read More
493 Words | 2 Pages

Leonid Fridman characterizes the typical American mindset this makes the text easily understood and relatable for the readers. Because the problem at hand is mainly geared toward Americans he brings up the fact that, “In most industrialized nations, not least of all of our economic rivals in East Asia, a kid who studies hard is lauded and held up as an example to other students.” He is showing the reader that in other countries they praise the children for their academic efforts unlike the US that use derogatory language like “nerd” and “geek” when referring to the academically achieving people. He also compares the jobs of individuals from other countries to show the divide between the American mindset and the mindset around the world. Fridman states “In many parts of the world university professorships are the most prestigious and materially rewarding positions but not in America…” Friedman says this so the readers are aware of the rift between America and other countries of the world especially their view of intellectual

Read More
783 Words | 4 Pages

He suggests that an academic institution like Harvard even has discrimination against nerds with “anti-intellectualism rampant.” The atmosphere leads the readers to his argument that America will not survive if nerds are not seen positively and in his opinion the U.S. is the only country with this sole

Read More
1737 Words | 7 Pages

Clearly emphasizing the role of excelling in the traditional educational standard to being considered “elite”. Those standards, like fluency in English and mastery in mathematics, are not inclusive of all people that have different talents. Despite Davidson’s acknowledgement

Read More
457 Words | 2 Pages

“America Needs its Nerds” Analysis Leonid Fridman’s use of irony, the rhetorical triangle, and rhetorical questions in his article “America Needs its Nerds” develops his argument that American society should be more accepting of intellectuals. His tone is critical of society’s values, which is seen through his use of phrases such as, “there is something very wrong with the system of values,” (1). Through his reference to Harvard University, a “prestigious academic institution” (11), he demonstrates that society tends to look down upon intellectuals by revealing that many students are “ashamed to admit” (13) the amount of time they spend on their studies. The fact that even at Harvard, a school known for its focus on intellectualism, students still perpetuate the anti-intellectualism stereotype shows the extent of the problem with the values of America’s current society.

Read More
904 Words | 4 Pages

William Henry wrote, “In Defense of Elitism”, he argues that colleges are letting too many students in, and that some of the students that are in college do not really deserve to be there. He thinks that the reason for the dumbed down education system is because of letting in too many students that do not need to attend college. In “America Skips School”, by Benjamin Barber, he believes that the teachers of todays generation blame kids for the fall of

Read More
826 Words | 4 Pages

Although race appears to be the source of these inequalities, it should be noted that other factors contribute as well. For instance, if a black child came from a high class family, he could afford to attend Morris High. Likewise, a white child from a low class family might only have the option of attending a school in East St. Louis. Through Kozol’s Savage Inequalities: Children in America’s Schools, it can be observed that children like those at Morris High are taught about racial inequalities, but are not taught to recognize white privilege. In addition, they seem to only be passionate about issues that have potential to benefit them personally.

Read More
1147 Words | 5 Pages

The growing gap between the upper class and the lower class has been expensive. In “Biographies of Hegemony”, Karen Ho looks into the prevalent ideology named “culture of smartness” and explores the close tie between some of America’s most powerful and prestigious universities and Wall Street firms. Joseph Stiglitz, the author of “Rent Seeking and the Making of an Unequal Society”, is concerned about

Read More
1109 Words | 5 Pages

Generally speaking, American elites have access to the finer elements of society. More importantly, social clubs reinforce class dynamics and limit class mobility. Because those belonging to social clubs and institutions are generally members of the upper class, networking, befriending, and communicating only occurs within class lines, making it impossible for less fortunate individuals to transcend class boundaries. This sort of class division in American culture is generational, explaining the dominance of white, affluent males in social clubs - time has favored these demographics and there do not exist many chances for the economic less fortunate to overcome historical

Read More
1501 Words | 7 Pages

Graff says street smarts offer more life skills than the education provided in school. In other words, you can be smart without being highly educated because knowledge goes beyond academics. He grew up thinking he was anti-intellectual because his writing skills were not great about the topics he’s expected to write in school. Graff describes how sports helped him excel in academics and discover his hidden intellectualism. He believes ‘’Making students’ nonacademic interests of an object study is useful, the, for getting students’ attention and overcoming their boredom and alienation, but this tactic won’t in itself necessarily move them close to an rigorous treatment of those interests.’’

Read More
635 Words | 3 Pages

He discusses two points while discussing hierarchy that convince the audience to believe that what he speaks about is the truth. He does tell “The most useful subjects for work are at the top within this hierarchy.” He mentions how children were conditioned to believe that those activities will not get them a job in the future and turned away from activities they enjoy. He specifies this when he says, “If you think of it, the whole system of public education around the world is a protracted process of university entrance.” Many students with different talents get rejected by the university because the talent they had was ignored in the school.

Read More
869 Words | 4 Pages

He uses this pattern of logic in this piece by observing that every American college is most likely going to defend and state that a college education is one of the most important achievement in a person’s lifetime. A college education will help them earn more economically, it will help them become an informed citizen, and to be more curious about the world through knowledge. However, Delbanco also makes a point by saying that the college education system will only improve if it is fair toward all different kinds of people. The argument is convincing how college still matter, but it will only truly be the best once it throws away all of the discrimination and includes anyone who seeks to pursue an education. Delbanco shows that the arguments are convincing but have failed to consider how discrimination in democracy still

Read More
953 Words | 4 Pages

As for the executive elite school, it emphasized the development of the students’ analytical intellectual abilities. Students were encouraged to reason through a problem, and to produce work that was of top academic quality. Overall, the “hidden curriculum” of school work causes students to

Read More
698 Words | 3 Pages

To conclude this analyzation of Mike Rose’s essay “Blue Collar Brilliance” and Gerald Graff’s essay “Hidden Intellectualism”, Mike Rose’s essay was more effective. He gave readers examples of real life scenarios to validate his point. He used rhetorical tools that would help the more academic successful audience. He also connected with the audience labeled as “Blue Collars”, with stories from his mother and uncle

Read More
143 Words | 1 Pages

For example, in her analysis of Isak Dinesen’s “The Blank Page” Susan Gubar adopts the metaphor of “the blank page” to stress how women’s history silenced by the patriarchy can be subversive. “The Blank Page” is narrated on a wedding night where the stained sheets of princesses are displayed with their names to prove their virginity. Among these stained sheets is a plain white sheet with a nameless plate. “Dinesen’s blank page,” writes Gubar, “becomes radically subversive, the result of one woman’s deficiency which must have cost either her life or her honor [is] Not a sign of innocence or purity or passivity, this blank page is a mysterious but potent act of resistance” (89). The blank page shows the silence of women but it proves female resistance

Read More

More about Analysis Of William Deresiewicz's Essay

Related Topics

Open Document