Analyzing Todd May's 'Immortal'

270 Words2 Pages
In regards to immortality, Todd May argues that it would be an undesirable experience. He argues that immortality would eventually cause everyone to be the same because everyone would have the time to experience the same things. In this paper, I will show that May’s argument is invalid, and that immortality would not cause everyone to become the same person. To begin, May comes to this conclusion after reading “The Immortal” by Jorge Luis Borges. In “The Immortal” Borges tells the tale of Joseph Cartaphilus, a leader of a military force in Berenice. One night he discovers a bleeding man and goes to help him. Upon reaching him the man asks where the river is at, thinking he was referring to the Nile Joseph points him in the right direction,