ipl-logo

Analyzing Walker Percy's Another Message In The Bottle

435 Words2 Pages

What causes a book to be filed under the bad book category? In Walker Percy's essay, Another Message in the Bottle, he very boldly states that bad books always lie. According to Percy, a book that lies about the human condition, does not fit, and does not give pleasure is a bad book. If bad books always lie, why don't all authors just write about truthful things. Sometimes an author will lie about the human condition because they believe it will make the story more interesting. However, in Percy's eyes, if the book lies about the human condition, the reader will not be able to connect as well as they had hoped when they picked up the book. Although it is true that the reader probably will not connect as well, I do not believe that this one …show more content…

Percy believes that "a good [book] is like a good table. The parts have to fit; it has to work, that is, sit foursquare and at the right level" (59). Therefore, if a book does not connect directly with itself, the book is definitely a bad book. The last reason a book would be categorized as a bad book is if it does not give pleasure to its reader. However, even if a book does give pleasure, that does not guarantee that the book would be good. Percy states that "even when a bad book gives its own sort of pleasure, either a pastime of diversion and adventurism, or the titillation of voyeurism, it leaves a sour taste in the mouth" (59). Therefore, if a book lies about the human condition and it does not fit together but gives pleasure, the book is definitely still a bad book. In Percy's opinion a book that lies, does not make sense, and does not give pleasure is a bad book. I do believe that this is correct, but Percy says that bad books always lie. This, however, is not always true. I believe that in most ways he is correct and that his essay is a good description on what categorizes a book as a bad

Show More
Related
120 Words | 1 Pages

Percy’s experiences align with the Hero’s Journey because of these three reasons. First, separation happens to Percy for a while. I know this because in the book it says that he has ADHD and dyslexia so that is what makes him separated from the rest of society. Then, the call to adventure happens. I know this because there is a danger that starts them on their journey and the danger is the monsters that come for them.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

he Scarlet Pimpernel is a mystery novel by Baroness Emmuska Orczy that teaches the consequences of having too much pride as well as the fact that people wear masks to cover up who they really are. The author took human nature into account when writing this book because she made the characters realistic in the way that they have flaws. One of these common flaws that the characters shared was the fact that they all wore masks. Percy is the main character in this novel and when you read about him, you get the impression that he's pretty stupid.

Read More
630 Words | 3 Pages

In the novel The Scarlet Pimpernel by Baroness Orczy, the main character, Marguerite, has many epiphanies that change her life immensely. When the novel commences, Marguerite believes that her husband, Sir Percy, does not love her, and she only feels “good-humored contempt” towards him (99). By the end of the novel, Marguerite realizes that Sir Percy still loves her, and their love is rekindled. Sir Percy also has an epiphany that greatly affects his life. For most of the novel, Sir Percy kept his alter ego from Marguerite because he did not fully trust her. After Marguerite finds out the truth about his life, he has an epiphany and realizes that he should have trusted her all along.

Read More
600 Words | 3 Pages

While the majority of the Fahrenheit 451 population focuses on the cons of books, of this “quality” and substance they contain, a small few still appreciate the pros of this content. By

Read More
717 Words | 3 Pages

There is at least 300 books banned a year for foul language, but don’t you think that an invasion of the authors freedom of press and an invasion of children 's first amendment as well? So I think that books should not be banned. I have three main idea the first on is that the books can be about history and they have some language back then that was fine but is not fine today. The second reason is that libraries should be able to hold all types of books but have an age restricted area. The last reason is that it will get rid of children’s first amendment, and the authors first right as well.

Read More
434 Words | 2 Pages

Im reading percy jackson the lightning theif. This is a book about a normal kid named Percy that is a half blood so he has to go to a camp because he wasn't actually normal. So it starts out as a guy named Percy. He has a tough time at school and at home, at home his step dad

Read More
926 Words | 4 Pages

William Alexander Percy captured a realistic view of life as he saw fit, while major changes began to fall upon the Southern realm surrounding him. In the authors, William Percy, writing, Lanterns on the Levee, Percy manages to capture life in the Mississippi Delta, not only in his hometown of Greenville, Mississippi, but also in the surrounding areas of the south. William Percy demonstrates the contrast of two different periods in Southern history, the declining aristocratic 1800’s and the mid 1990’s. William Percy shared his most influential ideas in his work, Lanterns on the Levee, discussing the social relations along class and racial lines, political control and authority culture, and the art of living well during the transitions of the

Read More
682 Words | 3 Pages

Novels flourish a persons imagination and present advances in their independent knowledge. Ray Bradbury’s novel Fahrenheit 451 displays a society deprived of novels, leading Montag to the realization of affects novels have on people. Montag fought for what he believed in, the right to read and learn from numerous novels, containing various topics ranging from innocent child books to vulgarity stricken novels. “The School Library versus the School Board: An Exploration of the Book Banning Trend of the 1980s” contains several arguments Montag would agree with, such as, “Even when a book contains language that is not appropriate for everyday use or describes unsavory ideas or feelings, the ability of the book to have a positive impact on the reader or provoke discussion or awareness is not necessarily diminished.” This quote symbolizes the positive viewpoints an “objectable book” most definitely possesses.

Read More
1111 Words | 5 Pages

To some people it is not. Some teachers say that the book is challenging for students. Now, this novel may be difficult for students, but that is how students learn new information. If students weren’t to have read harder pieces of literature all throughout their schooling career, they would stay at the same level of reading for most of their life. The reason why students should read more challenging novels are because they learn new things, and they could also learn how to act in a certain situation based on the type of challenging story they read.

Read More
1293 Words | 6 Pages

The Dangers of Book Banning The practice of challenging or banning books has long been a strategy used to label reading materials as offensive on moral, religious, or political, grounds. Books are being banned for containing offensive materials. It is argued that people can become influenced by detrimental ideas. The First Amendment expresses that citizens have the right to freedom of speech and freedom of the press.

Read More
797 Words | 4 Pages

This was an honor for Percy which brought a great honor into Percy’s life. But, it also brought more danger into into Percy’s life like being attacked by many monsters including people like the kindly

Read More
1333 Words | 6 Pages

Throughout “The Lightning Thief” by Rick Riordan, the main character Percy Jackson grows in many ways. Through application of Joseph Campbell’s Hero Cycle, Percy’s development as a leader over the course of “The Lightning Thief” can be analyzed (Campbell). Percy is born into the hero’s cycle at his natural birth and his call to adventure is the attack by Mrs. Dodds. Percy crosses the threshold, when he leaves Montauk with his mother and Grover and the first trial testing his leadership is on the bus with the furies. Trials exemplifying Percy’s growth include: the furies, Medusa, the Saint Louis Arch, the “Waterland” Waterpark, the Lotus Hotel, Crusty’s Waterbed Palace, and Hades and the Underworld.

Read More
419 Words | 2 Pages

An epilogue is more than a body count. This idea is written by T.S. Garp a fictional writer that was dreamed up by John Irving. John, in stating this, isn't just coming up with a nice sounding quote for Garp to say that will gain him more interest; he already had too much of that. On the contrary, he was actually using this statement as a warning to the world, the people that are reading, and more importantly a message that would have been life saving, for multiple people, for Garp himself to hear.

Read More
815 Words | 4 Pages

A book is a loaded gun in the house next door. Burn it” (Bradbury 55). In the fictional universe Bradbury has created, books have become a weapon and are seen as dangerous. Why? Because the well-read man has more knowledge and is smarter about the way the world works.

Read More
515 Words | 3 Pages

Neil Gaiman once wrote, “some books exist between covers that are perfectly people-shaped” (Gaiman xvi). The idea that books can be defined as the sharing of thoughts and information between people reveals a deeper meaning in Ray Bradbury’s Fahrenheit 451. In Fahrenheit 451, the protagonist faces a society in which books are censored and, thus, burned. This, according to his definition, means that if books become banned, certain connections between people will, too, be destroyed. Ray Bradbury reveals the theme (the importance of books) through the protagonist’s dynamic character, which comes as a result from his conflicts with society.

Read More

More about Analyzing Walker Percy's Another Message In The Bottle

Related Topics

Open Document