ipl-logo

Andrea Tone's Argument Analysis

613 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Debate over birth control

Andrea Tones essay on female consumers and contraceptives in the early 1930s until the 1940s is very interesting. The way she puts her argument together is by explaining the history of contraceptives and going back in forth between the span of around 10 years in order to highlight certain regulations, laws, and prominent events of a certain year. Her main point is evident from the beginning but with the help of mostly evidence and explanations, it is very informative and raises many inquiring thoughts and questions of what really went down pertaining to women and the birth control options they were given during that era. It was not easy for women to find healthy and safe reproductive controls, especially if you did not have access to clinics …show more content…

The advertisement says how using Lysol’s feminine hygiene product will free a women from her marital fear of getting pregnant when she doesn’t want to. The message in this advertisement is not only about birth control but also targeting women through pathos and mentioning words like “fear” and “unhappiness”. It is a tactic used to push profit into their company knowing that women really wanted to find reliable contraceptives. Like Andrea stated, they are capitalizing off the fact that women during this time period really did not want to have big families due to economic hardships. Her main argument of this essay is that it was not easy for woman to obtain effective birth control methods due to the fact that manufacturers persuaded them through false advertisement and facts. Effective contraceptives were considered a luxury but companies decided to sell “feminine hygiene” with the underlying promise of birth control, where the underlying part made it legal. Manufacturers even went as far as making female sellers wear nurse outfits in order to get women buying the contraceptives to trust them. The industry ultimately shaped and controlled the birth control developments in the U.S. Commercialization profited on the fact that birth control was in high demand and found an abundance of ways to get women to buy them, even though some of the ways were not

Show More
Related
1367 Words | 6 Pages

In America and The Pill: A History of Promise, Peril, and Liberation, Elaine May Tyler examined the history of birth control in the United States. May traced the pill's conception and evolution the United States through to the twenty-first century. The book consisted of an introduction, seven chapters, and a conclusion. May approached the topic in the context of influence of suffragist and reformer Margaret Sanger's advocacy originating in the late Progressive Era and Cold War American ideology, through to the emerging movements of the sexual revolution and the feminist movement, including acknowledging political, religious, racial, socio-economic, and gender bias factors.

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

Elaine Tyler May delivers a concise historical retrospective and critical analysis of the development, evolution, and impact of the birth control pill from the 1950s to present day. In her book, America and the Pill, examines the relationship of the pill to the feminist movement, scientific advances, cultural implications, domestic and international politics, and the sexual revolution. May argues cogently that the mythical assumptions and expectations of the birth control pill were too high, in which the pill would be a solution to global poverty, serve as a magical elixir for marriages to the extent it would decline the divorce rate, end out-of-wedlock pregnancies, control population growth, or the pill would generate sexual pandemonium and ruin families. May claims the real impact of the pill—it’s as a tool of empowerment for women, in which it allows them to control their own fertility and lives. May effectively transitioned between subjects, the chapters of America and the Pill are organized thematically, in

Read More
355 Words | 2 Pages

Quotation: “It was the modern word’s signature to etch economic dominance and political supremacy into a radical cultural design. It was also its signature to hide the social relations that were brewing supremacy and conflict behind a semblance of “race things.” (Silverblatt, 3) Argument: Here, Irene Silverblatt is arguing that, like all colonial powers, the Inquisition of Peru racialized certain groups, in this case the Native Americans. She argues that the foundation of colonial empire is racial segregation where the people who are conquered were treated as inferior human beings. They purposely created unequal groups where the Africans and their descendant were reserved for slavery and had to give up their way of life.

Read More
534 Words | 3 Pages

Taylor Hurst Kaiser AP Lang 11 November 2015 Analysis of Margaret Sanger’s Speech on Birth Control Margaret Sanger, an American birth control activist, made an announcement titled “The Children’s Era,’ at the first national birth-control conference in March of 1925. In this speech, Sanger attempts to influence her ideas and beliefs on the importance of birth control and contraceptives to the health of society’s women. She also vividly explains how controlled childbearing would apply to children who would eventually be born.

Read More
67 Words | 1 Pages

Nora Rodriguez is ahero because she helps immigrants with their immigration paper work. The article states that "a honduran women runs a business helping central americans with thier immagration paper work. Also she is a hero because she spoke up for the people about thier injusties. The article says that "she has gone from simply providing a support service to demmanding change regarding the injustes and discrimination.

Read More
1586 Words | 7 Pages

In the 1910s, Sanger became an advocate for birth control. As the years went on, Margaret Sanger became associated with the term of birth control and even later, eugenics. In the 1920s, she gave a speech entitled “The Morality of Birth Control”. In the speech, she addressed why birth control should be legal and why women deserve

Read More
343 Words | 2 Pages

The author’s argument was to inform the public on how Margaret Sanger argues that women today are still enslaved by childbearing and abstinent couple due to the lack of misrepresentation of the Birth Control movement. The author tends to elaborate some of Margaret’s reasons of the birth control movement which was the limiting the size of families who were have extremely large families. The message is explicit because it informs the public on Margaret’s argument of women’s right to birth control as women constantly wrote her about their problems. The author get the message across by listing reasons and arguing her point of view of why the birth control movement was best for women on how it could limit and prevent a decrease in families and abstinent

Read More
925 Words | 4 Pages

The first article presented only the author’s point of view and refused to say the words “birth-control” or even “contraceptives.” Sadly, it only focused on how “evil” the people were who were sending out the literature, not how these women, many of whom were likely married, simply did not want any more children and needed medication and information on how to prevent pregnancy. The second article, however, addressed the issue with a more factual approach. It seemed to accept the idea that women have the right to birth control and sex education, even if the author only discussed married people. These articles are evidence of how, in one hundred years, the nation can change its entire stance on an issue.

Read More
1227 Words | 5 Pages

Birth control hasn’t always been legal for women in the United States. In 1873 the Comstock Act passing prohibiting advertisements, information, and distribution of birth control. This act also allowed the postal service to confiscate any information or birth control sold through the mail. Margaret Sanger made it her life’s work to make information about birth control and birth control itself available to women in the United States. Margaret Sanger was a nurse on the Lower East Side of New York City and decided to get involved in the Birth Control Movement in 1912 after she watched a woman die as a result of a self-induced abortion.

Read More
330 Words | 2 Pages

In the 1920s, birth control was a very significant issue that led to the controversial debate between Winter Russell and Margaret Sanger. Most people believed that Planned Parenthood caused the decline of population in human race. Many viewed it harmful to human being’s welfare. Sanger’s debate about birth control was to stand for the entitlement of women to access birth control. Today in our society, birth control plays a big role in our lives.

Read More
782 Words | 4 Pages

In this paper, I will focus on Bonnie Steinbock’s claim on whether or not we should give equal moral consideration to species outside our own species group. I will first determine what moral concern means, according to Peter singer, and explain how he views the human treatment of animals. I will then outline Steinbock’s argument against Singer’s position and explain how her criticism is part of a much broader issue: that is moral concern. I will finally make my argument against Steinbock as well as address any issues she could possibly raise against my argument. Peter Singer believed that all species, whether it be human or non-human, deserve equal consideration of interests and quality of life.

Read More
460 Words | 2 Pages

Contraceptives geared towards females were only allowed distribution with a prescription from a physician. With a prescription comes a hefty price, so on top of everything else, most couples were not able to afford means of birth

Read More
281 Words | 2 Pages

The suggestion that Andrea’s friend gave Andrea is not an effective way for Andrea to reduce her anger. Pounding a pillow is not a way to control anger. Andrea cannot pound her way out of anger (Markman). This is an ineffective way because hitting the pillow will build up anger against Andrea’s boyfriend. It will be a good thing if Andrea reduces her anger because anger can harm people.

Read More
1165 Words | 5 Pages

“In Europe 1960, the average total fertility rate was 2.6, and hormonal contraception was non-existent. Forty years later, the TFR was 1.4 and almost 18% of all women of reproductive age living in a marital or consensual union were using hormonal contraception” (“Overpopulation”). Contraception reduces family sizes which allow a great proportion of resources to be handed to each child. This can improve opportunities for nutrition, healthcare, and education (“Overpopulation”). “Contraception empowers women by giving them reproductive control.

Read More
2126 Words | 9 Pages

In 1960, the first birth control pill was put on the market. This was the first time a woman’s reproductive health was in her own control. Ever since the 1900’s women have been fighting for the right to their own reproductive rights (“The Fight for Reproductive Rights”). With the upcoming presidential election the right to obtain birth control and other contraceptives for women could be jeopardized, and taken out of the control of the woman. Thus, the history of birth control, the statistics of how it affects today’s society, why women should have the ability to obtain it easily, and how if outlawed it would not only hurt women, but also the economy are all important topics in the women’s rights movement and very relevant in modern day society.

Read More

More about Andrea Tone's Argument Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document