ipl-logo

Are The Similarities Between The Book Of Joshua And The Epic Of Gilgamesh

703 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Mesopotamian and hebrew civilizations

Operation 1. Conceptualize 1. Question: How could Joshua and the Israelites conquer the entire land of Canaan in a short time as depicted in the Book of Joshua, considering the actual size and complexity of the region? 2. Issue: The Genesis flood narrative seems to have similarities with the Epic of Gilgamesh, an ancient Mesopotamian poem. How could two different cultures have such similar stories? 3. Question: Why does God seem to allow, or even command, violence and warfare in the Old Testament, such as in the books of Joshua and Judges, when He is depicted as a God of love and mercy in other parts of the Bible? 4. Issue: The use of differing names for God (Elohim, Yahweh, Adonai, etc.) throughout the Old Testament may suggest multiple authors …show more content…

Contributing factors The first issue arose while comparing the timeline and the geographical locations mentioned in the Book of Joshua with historical and archaeological records. The rapid and complete conquest seemed incongruent with the size and complexity of the region. The second issue came up when studying ancient Near Eastern literature and noticing striking parallels between the Genesis flood story and the Epic of Gilgamesh. This led to questions about the origins and interconnections of these narratives. The third issue emerged from the seeming inconsistency in God's character as depicted in the Old Testament. God's involvement in warfare and violence seemed at odds with His portrayal as a loving and merciful deity. The fourth issue was noticed while observing the different names and characterizations of God in various books of the Old Testament, raising questions about the process of its compilation and its authorship. The fifth issue was identified while comparing the Old Testament's cosmology with modern scientific understandings of the universe. The biblical texts often depict a geocentric cosmology, which seems to contradict current scientific consensus. Operation 3. Analyze (Question …show more content…

Literal interpretation may suggest God's endorsement of violence, whereas metaphorical or symbolic interpretation may perceive these passages as a symbolic representation of the spiritual struggle between good and evil (Collins, 2004). The theme of divine justice and holiness, prevalent throughout the Old Testament, offers another perspective. God's commands for violence may be interpreted as His judgement on the wickedness and idolatry of certain nations (Wright, 2006). This understanding does not contradict God's love and mercy but instead underscores His commitment to justice and intolerance of evil. The concept of progressive revelation, suggesting that God's nature and will were revealed gradually over time, may also help reconcile this issue. The Old Testament provides a partial revelation of God's character, with His love and mercy becoming more evident in the New Testament (Fee & Stuart,

Show More
Related
498 Words | 2 Pages

In comparison, of The Epic of Gilgamesh to The Song of Roland, time and cultural aspects show the similarities of power from distant years. The Epic of Gilgamesh, was created

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

In the story of “ Noah and the Flood”, the flood wiped out the entire earth and lasted for 40 days and 40 nights. In “The Story of the Flood” in The Epic of Gilgamesh, the flood also wiped out the entire earth but only lasted for 6 days and 6 nights, causing a different effect than the flood of the ark did. As god wipes out the earth in The Epic of Gilgamesh, he explains how “‘[he] has brought them forth’” and has the power to destroy them just as easily (42). Both gods believed that they have created their people and they have disowned them, but both believed so for different reasons. Moses, who wrote the bible for the Hebrews which was then called Genesis, believed that the people have truly been disobedient and wants to create a more peaceful culture.

Read More
1045 Words | 5 Pages

If you have read Gilgamesh the Hero and Genesis 6-9:19, you would think the two passages are pretty similar to each other, maybe even almost the same exact thing. But when we dive deeper into each passage of writing, you start to see that Gilgamesh the Hero to Genesis 6-9:17 are very different from each other. Even though their similarities will also be expressed in this essay, these stories are not as similar as you may think because of the Gods’ motivation for sending a flood, and how Noah and Utnapistim were warned about the incoming flood. The Gods’ in both stories were upset with the way their creation, which was humanity, turned out to be.

Read More
306 Words | 2 Pages

The similarities that this version shares with The Flood described in Genesis is that the reason behind the flood are both punishments to humanity due to wickedness and sin. The individual in both these stories who are Utnapishtim and Noah are both forewarn by the disaster and act out of righteous to give life for all another chance. These characters also both dock on a mountain after the flood and use birds as a test to find more land. The biggest difference is that in Epic of Gilgamesh the storm only lasts 6 days while in The Flood it is said to have lasted between 40 days to a year. I am sure there are many viewpoints that have transformed these stories throughout the years because we have no evidence of these events.

Read More
1949 Words | 8 Pages

I did not expect to come across another account of a different culture or religion with the same big picture as the story of Noah and the flood. In the beginning, I was not troubled because the important details of the story which hold great value were different. Also, I knew that Genesis was an oral tradition passed down for many of years before it was written down. I automatically assumed that the Epic of Gilgamesh was just a spin-off of the story of the flood; however, I realized the Epic of Gilgamesh is older than Genesis. This changed my opinion of the story because it if anything Genesis, the book of the bible that many Christians base their theology upon, has the possibility of being a spin-off of the polytheistic Epic of Gilgamesh.

Read More
1476 Words | 6 Pages

In this essay, I will be talking about The Epic of Gilgamesh as well as the great flood that is mentioned in the Bible. Both stories were written and passed down orally through generations and have often been compared with many similarities as well as differences that I will discuss and contrast. More specifically, the first few books of the Bible, including Genesis is where the Bible flood story is found, which was said to be written by Moses. The Epic of Gilgamesh is the story about a king by the name of Gilgamesh, who uses his power in a negative way in his kingdom. The gods decide upon giving Gilgamesh a friend, who will tame his character and therefore, produce a more ethical king to rule over the city of Uruk.

Read More
1352 Words | 6 Pages

Anna O’Tool Professor Volger World Literature 1 14 June 2023 The Epic of Gilgamesh vs. The Hebrew Bible “Where did we come from”. A question as old as time, pun intended. Humans have been asking this from the very beginning, and we know this because of the texts that they wrote. Thousands and thousands of writings have been created to attempt to answer it, but a few stick out.

Read More
271 Words | 2 Pages

The Epic of Gilgamesh and the story in Genesis are very alike and different at the same time. The Epic of Gilgamesh is an epic poem from ancient Mesopotamia and Genesis is the first book of the Bible. Even though they both come from different writers they both have a man that was told by a divine power to save mankind from a flood. Both of these men in both of these stories were rewarded by being able to continue living after the flood. In both The Epic of Gilgamesh and the story in Genesis they both have a horrible flood that was sent by the divine to wipe out everything on earth and similar events that happened but some other smaller details are different in each story.

Read More
1580 Words | 7 Pages

This model of God is shown to have characteristics such as a human-like personality, emotions, a physical form, and extreme power. There are many occasions within the Hebrew Bible where God’s extreme power is shown, including instances such as wiping out an entire population, destroying cities, and even ordering Abraham to sacrifice his own son. This divine intervention shows the difference between the God of Old’s physical form and his Godly, mythical form in which he creates and alters the world to his image. In addition, this model of God is also seen as a fabled and legendary being, with a few certain individuals shown to have directly spoken with

Read More
214 Words | 1 Pages

When it comes to religion in Mesopotamia, the Epic of Gilgamesh shows a similar presentation of what the Greek and Roman authors would write a thousand years later. Being a polytheistic society, the gods were attached to natural phenomena and occurrences. Ishtar, as stated before, is the goddess of love and war; Ea, the god of water and the arts; Shamash, the god of the sun and his wife; the goddess of the moon. The Gilgamesh Epic compares to the Homeric epics.

Read More
701 Words | 3 Pages

Throughout the Book of Genesis, God makes several connections between his creations, such as with Noah. As mentioned before, the Lord spoke to Noah in a vision, and said to Noah, “... The end of all flesh is come before me; for the earth is filled with violence through them; and behold, I will destroy them with the earth... (Gen. 6.13).” In the Epic of Gilgamesh, the main character, Gilgamesh prays for the protection by the Sun God, Shamash, to kill Humbaba, which states “Here I present myself, Shamash, to lift up my hands in entreaty That my life may be spared; bring me again to the ramparts of Uruk: Give me your protection. I will give you homage.”

Read More
765 Words | 4 Pages

“Extinction is the rule. Survival is the exception (Carl Sargon)”. According to The Epic of Gilgamesh and Genesis, unprecedented floods occurred in the stories. The exception fell on the kind men, Utnapishtim and Noah: they survived the powerful event of destruction. However, in the same theme of the stories, there are sources of similarity and differences.

Read More
1132 Words | 5 Pages

Any casual reader has to be impressed that there are these points of similarity between these two. On the same token, the reader has to be impressed with the fact that there are some conspicuous and obvious differences. In the Gilgamesh epic, the author has the gods that are squabbling. They are infections, jealous, and immoral. In contrast, there is a great, holy dignity in the bible that brings this judgment to bear.

Read More
1326 Words | 6 Pages

Adam and Eve, Cain and Able, Abram and Lot, the apostle Paul/Saul-all are just a few instances where the battle continues through Biblical times. Again, we see the battle between the evil and good throughout Greek mythology. After Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon killed their father, they

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

Although the Epic of Gilgamesh and the Biblical book of Genesis both tell of a worldwide flood which nearly annihilates mankind, each account has several additional similarities as well as distinct differences that include the reason of the elimination of humanity, the occupants of the ark, and the duration of the flood. One begins to find parallels in the narrations within the first few sentences. The Biblical God is infuriated by the wickedness of mankind, while the Babylonian gods are annoyed by the lack of sleep due to the growing population of raucous humans. In either case, the supreme being, or beings, of the tales come to the same conclusion: to extinguish the human race.

Read More

More about Are The Similarities Between The Book Of Joshua And The Epic Of Gilgamesh

Open Document