ipl-logo

Argumentative Essay On Women In Combat Advantages And Disadvantages

1081 Words5 Pages

“Instead of seeing my strengths and how I could contribute, he only saw my gender.” - Major Mary Hegar. Major Mary Hegar, an Air National Guard search and rescue helicopter pilot fell victim to gender inequality. Mary Hegar was supervised during a mission in Afghanistan in 2007 because they did not think she could carry her own weight in an evasion situation if they were shot down by their enemies. Women’s position in armed forces is not a recent phenomenon, but an erstwhile issue that invades modern societies today. Men tend to overlook the abilities women posses to protect their alter egos as more women step into male dominated fields. A number of opposed arguments have been given as to why women shouldn’t participate in combat that range from, women’s health disadvantages, physical limitations, and the risk of potential rape. Each of these arguments will be discussed and revealed to be essentially flawed. The same opportunities in regards to combat should be given to those women who prefer to wear dogtags and boots, rather than pearls and sensible shoes to work. Thus indicating that it would be …show more content…

In other words, they may not be true for every woman. Therefore, despite the allegations that perceive women unfit, it is cruel to keep all women from combat. Health disadvantages, physical limitations, and rape predictions are arguments that men perceive as valid to protect their self-esteem. Every individual whether they be a female, a male, gay, a transgender, etc. still deserve the same opportunities. We no longer live in a society that restricts women to participate in activities that were once perceived as male-dominated. Thus indicating that it would inhumane to use the traditional image women are associated with, rather than judging them off of the basis of their abilities and physical

Show More
Related
901 Words | 4 Pages

In the United States, women weren’t allowed to join the military until the beginning of the twentieth century. This law, however, didn’t stop northerner Deborah Sampson. Like a modern era Mulan, Sampson dressed up as a man in the continental army during the Revolutionary War. Deborah Sampson showed perseverance, bravery, and a disregard for gender norms as she fought alongside unsuspecting men for over two years, earning herself a rightful place in the history books that has yet to be properly represented. Deborah Sampson was born into a poor family in the southeastern part of Massachusetts and worked as an indentured servant for 12 years as she grew up.

Read More
1265 Words | 6 Pages

With the women’s rights movement and the end of the draft the pentagon was compelled to review the status of women in the military. (Moore) The Army committee had recommendations to separate the women’s corps to increase the specialties offered to women. The Army committee also pushed opening ROTC and military academies to women and also changed the law that required automatic discharge if a woman became pregnant. It was after these recommendations were followed that women could serve in 430 of the 467 military specialties, but they could not command any unit that had a combat mission.

Read More
215 Words | 1 Pages

In the feature article “All Guts, No Glory”, I agree with the author Molly M. Ginty, that women participating in combat. If I was in the military some of the things that might affect me would be probably because of my gender. First, women would not be put into battle because people think women cannot handle the work or bloodshed. They think women are better off bring a nurse for helping men in battle if they get injured. Second, they think women in combat would be a distraction.

Read More
850 Words | 4 Pages

Due to this over exaggeration, men are not able to create their own identity, which leads to serious gender and behavioral issues. This forced environment leads to women having to act differently as well because many people feel that “women are not held to the same standards as men” (Nicolas) Nicolas shows that the military environment affects women as well as men and forces genders to act in different ways. Gender is not universal but the military forces gender roles to be blown out of proportion. Women are not held to the same standards as men, which in our day and age should be unheard of. Nicolas’ piece extends the point that Myers makes about the military environment and genders.

Read More
1209 Words | 5 Pages

Women are viewed as fragile and delicate, but strong enough to keep a house clean, kids in line and a happy husband. Women are expected to be stay at home moms and depend on their husbands for everything while having no opinions of their own. However, there are women who have overlooked those expectations and proved that women are capable of doing anything. Deborah Sampson and Elizabeth Van Lew are just two women who have helped break the norms of women’s roles in society. Sampson’s impressive braveness and loyalty to fight for her country against all odds have proved that women are capable to endure harsh horrors.

Read More
933 Words | 4 Pages

The targeted audience is young women who aspire to help their troops and break away from the stereotypical roles of women during that era. In this analysis, the topic of femininity and Rosie the Riveter will be applied and compared to “Woman’s Place in the War”; as well as other elements such as colors, lines, emotional and logical

Read More
925 Words | 4 Pages

“Those involved in recruiting women for war work in the civilian labour market also sought to allay fears that women doing jobs formerly performed by men were not upsetting the basic gender order. For instance, it was argued that women’s “natural” endowments of “dexterity, patience and keen eyesight” made them eminently suitable for the “deft-fingered” precision work required at various stages of aircraft, gun and ammunition manufacture, especially in electronics and optics.” (3 specialists) Around the world it was common that women were considered less worthy and capable than men. However, the fact that the Canadian government was letting women join the military in what had been considered a manly job meant only for strong brave men.

Read More
1798 Words | 8 Pages

According to her the only way to end war is unmaking masculinity. She further adds that this kind of change is already in process through the men who oppose and say no to combat and transform their lives into a new kind of humanity. But the work of Kathleen Barry also has some shortcomings like: - In reality it is very difficult to separate combat ethic from the military’s time immemorial emphasis on face-to-face killing.

Read More
788 Words | 4 Pages

The women of the early 20th century showed that they have the ability to be productive in the work place and fight for the greater good of the United States of America. In modern times women have started joining combat roles in the military and increasing in demographical size in the military. This has shown that women are striving to be more equal to men in all aspects of modern life. By showing they can fight in wars and hold their own against our nations enemies they can and will be seen as equals. The public celebration of women’s history in the United States began in 1978.

Read More
1406 Words | 6 Pages

During the Second World War, after many of the men left to join the battle overseas, women were once again given the task of running the nation, and in order to do so they took over traditionally ‘masculine’ jobs, such as working in munitions bunkers, and on farms. By doing so, women were able to keep the economy running, which helped pay for war efforts and even provided the nation with more jobs. Contrary to WWI, women were now encouraged to take on more jobs directly related to the ongoing war. For instance, on the home front, an approximation of 35 000 women were working in munitions factories, making the artillery for the soldiers. Not to mention, for the first time in Canadian history, new positions in the military such as Women’s Royal Canadian Naval Service (WRENS) and the Women Division (WD) in The Royal Canadian Air Force (RCAF) were created so that women were able to contribute more towards the war efforts.

Read More
885 Words | 4 Pages

Women were well suited for providing nourishment and necessities for the army due to their skills obtained by their accustomed housework. “...the American army often recruited the many female camp followers to fill these jobs” (Brooks 2013, para. 17). They had slowly began to achieve recognition in society, especially war. It was then, that woman had begun to silently “protest” on having the same equal opportunity as men. During the war, women created a role for themselves to side amongst the male soldiers: a secret soldier.

Read More
297 Words | 2 Pages

(Hamilton 258). The mortals do not see the women as strong and brave enough to reach for the weapons to fight because they just reach for the trinkets and shiny things. Men stereotype women as weak people who do not have the ability or desire to fight, even though some women want to help in the war. When women want to fight in the war, no notice

Read More
597 Words | 3 Pages

I think women should be added to the draft. Women have been proven to be just as capable as men in the military, equal rights include equal responsibility, and by having the most talented people in our military regardless of gender we can fight and win wars in the most intelligent and efficient way. Adding women to the draft is a great way to support and protect the American dream. People fear that woman wouldn’t be able to handle the physical conditions of serving on the front lines, however women have been in the military since the late 18th century. Furthermore those who couldn’t handle it could be sent home the same way a man would be.

Read More
2060 Words | 9 Pages

Even though men are usually stronger than women, Women can have strength to serve in combat. But now other countries are allowing women in combat, Women are becoming stronger. Their just doing this so they can prove women are equal, and are as equal to men. Some countries do this so other countries join in with them. Women have the strength, and are as equal to men as men are to women.

Read More
1396 Words | 6 Pages

The gender role in military as women categorized and stereotyped by men has never been easy. Military does not require muscular or gender power for leadership in combat or command positions. Some men believe that women in command will weaken the military tradition or military in context. The gender role of “women” and “soldiers” proved to many that is uncontested in World War I and II when women served as auxiliaries. Women have a long history of service in the military.

Read More

More about Argumentative Essay On Women In Combat Advantages And Disadvantages

Related Topics

Open Document