ipl-logo

Arguments Against Insanity Defense

874 Words4 Pages

Insanity Defense
Imani Batiste
Lee College
Insanity Defense
The insanity defense is described as, “A defense asserted by an accused in a criminal prosecution to avoid liability for the commission of a crime because, at the time of the crime, the person did not appreciate the nature or quality or wrongfulness of the acts” (Encyclopedia, 2005). It was first instituted in late-thirteenth-century England as “Complete Madness” (Encyclopedia, 2005). The defense is based on the belief that people who are ill should be treated for their illness rather than sentenced to prison or death. There are legitimate times when an individual has a serious mental illness that caused their actions because they were not able to process correctly. The insanity defense …show more content…

They believe the convicted need to do hard time for the crime they committed. Supporters of the insanity plea feel that if a criminal has in fact experienced insanity during the commission of a crime they should be able to receive medical care for the mental illness associated with the crime instead of punishment. Both sides agree that there is no sure way to determine if they were really experiencing insanity at the time of the crime
The insanity pleas is not used often. In reality, less than one percent of defendants try to use the insanity plea, and even less are successful (Smith, 2012). Defendants do not usually gain exoneration, and are still required to stand trial when it is used. Most defendants found “not guilty by reason of insanity” are incarcerated in a mental institute. Usually their sentence is longer than if they can been convicted and sent to prison (Smith, 2012).
Overall, the insanity defense is an interesting concept. While implemented to help those who needed it, over the years it has made many question its existence. Yet, it should be understood that it is not an easy plea to use or a slap on the wrist when the defendant is convicted. It is a real punishment for a crime committed by a mentally ill offender that would hopefully be more help than harm for them.

Show More
Related

Insanity Defense Of Andrea Yates

935 Words | 4 Pages

Dr. Mark Nolan, Senior Lecturer at ANU College of Law, says that the NGRI plea “enables defendants to avoid criminal liability and standard criminal punishment” (Nolan 8). The main disagreement with America is the focus whether if the “guilty defendant” pursues to misuse the “Not Guilty by Reason of Insanity” as an alternative to imprisonment or if the criminally accused was at the time of committing the crime “clinically insane” and in need psychotherapy. Therefore, during this discussion of opposing viewpoints concerning the insanity defense being misused or ethical are going to be

Read More

First-Degree Murder Case Summary

707 Words | 3 Pages

Mental illness is necessary to use the insanity defense and

Read More

Soviet Union Dbq

305 Words | 2 Pages

Caroline Foley AP World History Mr. Jameson May 24, 2024 The Soviet Union When an American hears about the Soviet Union the first thought is Joseph Stalin, communism, totalitarianism, and so forth. The Soviet Union was established as a result of the Russian Revolution. This revolution, led by Vladimir Lenin, introduced ideas of Leninism, Marxism, and overall communist ideas that the Soviet Union has become infamous for. Then after the establishment of the Soviet Union, Joseph Stalin came into power.

Read More

What Is Myers III V. State Of Indiana An Example Of Mental Competency?

1528 Words | 7 Pages

In the field of criminal law there is a certain type of criminal defense that comes to the court and has a low success rate. These cases concern the mental capacity of the defendant and if they have enough mental capacity, or are sane enough, to be aware of their crime and consequences of crime. The insanity defense is extremely rare because of how difficult it is for the defense to prove to the court and jury that the defendant did not have the mental capacity to understand what they did wrong and the consequences from it. The case of Myers III v. State of Indiana is one example of criminal responsibility and mental capacity. This case has information that can be connected to the textbook with the insanity defense tests, mental competence

Read More

The Insanity Verdict On Trial By Scott O. Lilienfeld

1669 Words | 7 Pages

What exactly is the insanity defense? In a criminal trial situation the insanity defense is used to explain that the defendant was not responsible for his or her actions at the time the crime was committed due to a mental health illness or a mental handicap. Now you have to think of the reasoning, is this form of defense used as an actual defense for one who irresponsibly committed a crime or as a last resort hoping for an acquittal before a defendant is about to be handed a guilty verdict? Most people being asked would say it is being used for sane people trying to get out of a crime they committed, but I believe the insanity defense is misunderstood by society and should strictly be used for its creation of mentally ill individuals.

Read More

Summary Of Is Guilty Insane Or Not By John White

894 Words | 4 Pages

The insanity plea was created as a compassionate way to help the individuals who would benefit more from a mental institute rather than a prison. White’s position firm and filled with conviction, however it lacks substance and makes the reader question his research. In four states alone there are no verdicts where an individual can plead not guilty by insanity. He directs his argument with the examples of individuals such as David R. Berkowitz, Jim Jones, and Adolph Eichman. David R. Berkowitz was an individual who attempted the insanity plea but was denied that plea and was found guilty and sentenced to six life sentences in prison on

Read More

Use Of The Insanity Plea By Andrea Yates

2597 Words | 11 Pages

During my true crime podcast era, I came across Andrea Yates. Yates was a mother who killed her five young children by drowning them in a bathtub. While listening to this case, it was revealed that the insanity plea, or also known as the insanity defense, was used. It got me thinking about how the plea works and how people would allow this outcome over a jail sentence. The insanity plea is a tough topic to tackle in the world of criminal law.

Read More

Barney Bezerk Case Summary

824 Words | 4 Pages

After this, public outrage surfaced and formed the legal definition of insanity, which evebtually became known as the M’Naghten rule (Koocher & Keith-Spiegel, 2008). A plea of not guilty by reason of insanity claims that due to mental illness, the defendant should not be held morally responsible for the crime. In order to successfully plead the insanity defense, a defendant must not only show that he is mentally ill, but also show that there was a link connecting the mental illness and the criminal offense (Grachek,

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Defense

1562 Words | 7 Pages

Most courts require additional elements to acquit the defendant even if he or she has proven not in control of his or her behavior (“Insanity Defense Pros and Cons”). Other elements include witnesses or the previous medical records of the defendant. Without the prior knowledge of the defendant's mental situation the defense has no back up information or proof. Jurisdictions allowing the defense to still stand will undoubtedly turn down the plea for insanity without those records shared in court. The records need to hold substantial information stating that the defendant was so mentally ill that they did not know right from wrong during the time of the crime or has a disease such as schizophrenia or other causing sporadic mental incapacities in order to prove the burden of proof of beyond a reasonable doubt.

Read More

Examples Of How Fair Is The Insanity Defense

49 Words | 1 Pages

How fair is the “insanity” defense? Davis (2016) argued that the used of the “insanity” defense may be seen by others as unfair to other criminals because of the leniency towards one group of criminals and not others. This can be seen as discrimination towards individuals with mental illness.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Plea

1086 Words | 5 Pages

This was later carried out through twenty-six other states, including the U.S., which created a precedent against the execution of the mentally ill in 1986. Even though the mentally ill cannot be executed, if the person who claimed mental illness is no longer mentally ill he or she can be executed. While the insanity plea proves that some criminals are mentally unstable, it should be used with caution because many convicted criminals abuse it during court cases, imitate being mentally ill during an examination, and are able to avoid the death penalty. Despite that the insanity plea can potentially help someone in defense for a mental illness case, many people can also take advantage of these precedents to alleviate their trials. The public in most insanity plea cases, do not typically agree with the rulings because most criminals use the

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Insanity Defense

1114 Words | 5 Pages

In the American legal system, there is a well known criminal defense strategy called the insanity defense. This plea ultimately claims and acknowledges that the person being tried was involved in the crime but was not, however, in a sound mental state and should therefore be pardoned from their actions. This idea was created in order to provide a defense for the criminals who do not have a sound mind, getting the court to label them as innocent as a result of their insanity. This particular method of defense falls under something called the excuse defense category, which uses an excuse, in this case insanity, to remove the responsibility of one's actions that resulted in the harm of others or the crime committed. In order for this plea to actually

Read More

Insanity Plea Research Paper

102 Words | 1 Pages

The insanity plea is one of the most controversial and problematic defense strategies used in court cases. It becomes so problematical when someone determines the sanity of a person, because where does the line cross from insane and sane. The insanity plea is the least common mechanism that defendants and lawyers use as a plea. Sometimes it is accurate and the defendant is treated properly in a mental institute for awhile; whereas in other cases it is used as “get out of jail free card. ”

Read More

Insanity Plea Pros And Cons

543 Words | 3 Pages

Penal institutions in America are already over packed making it harder for the prison guards to look out for everyone. Mental diseases such as schizophrenia and bipolar disorder can make it hard to control for their thoughts and actions, which results in them committing malicious crimes, such as murder. But, these personas do not know that they are doing something terribly wrong. Because of this, they sometimes end up in prison. But with the insanity plea, the accused have a chance in defending themselves.

Read More

Model Of Insanity Defense

798 Words | 4 Pages

Many people may believe they know about the insanity defense as it has been brought to the public’s eye in many popular trials. For example, the cases of John Hinckley, who attempted to murder President Ronald Reagan, and Andrea Yates, who drowned her five young children, were highly publicized cases where the defendant was found guilty by reason of insanity. While many people may be familiar with these cases or similar ones, the insanity defense is highly misunderstood and disliked. To help judges and juries conclude whether a person is insane, three models have been devised. There is a wide variety of tests from state to state; however, they all typically revolve around one of the three models.

Read More

More about Arguments Against Insanity Defense

Related Topics

Open Document