ipl-logo

Arguments Against Perverted Justice In To Catch A Predator

722 Words3 Pages

Nearly a decade ago thousands of people watched the controversial, ratings-grabbing television series on NBC’s Dateline. “To Catch a Predator” raised serious ethical questions throughout its show time from 2004-2007.
Dateline worked directly with Perverted Justice, an advocacy group that provides decoys to message would-be predators with explicit language to lure them into meeting these young girls and boys. Perverted Justice methods are controversial because the potential predator always has to make the first move. The decoy uses a questionable young looking person and chat with older men. Arguments against Perverted Justice suggest the focus to “catch a predator” should not be embarrassing, rather, the dialogue should ask these older men, …show more content…

The police would not have been there to arrest these men if Dateline NBC never contacted Perverted-Justice. Should NBC be working close with the police and Perverted Justice? The techniques are appropriate for the police to work with Perverted Justice, but not for journalism.
Journalist go undercover for their last resort during an investigation. Ethically, parallel investigations are messy. This article is a case study for journalist’s dilemma that demonstrates how complicated working alongside advocacy agencies and the police. The police want to arrest the pedophiles, journalists want to inform the public about the threat of pedophiles, and Perverted Justice want to expose these potential pedophiles before they attack children.
Another reason why Dateline NBC show “To Catch a Predator” had an ethical dilemma was when the Dateline Camera crew showed up at Prosecutor Louis Conradt Jr.’s home in Terrell, Texas, the police forced their way into the house, and the police found the 56-year-old prosecutor holding a semiautomatic handgun and fired a bullet into his own head. This is very concerning that a television show exposes these “normal” people who have to live with being labeled a “predator” for the rest of their life. This impacts them to the core. Whenever they apply for jobs, confront their friends and family, neighbors, and live everyday in society, they have to be shamed. Journalist

Show More
Related
427 Words | 2 Pages

They shed light on how the prosecution built their case. The authors also explains in detail on how the media and the people fixation on the case could have undermined it. Walker, C., & Filia, M. (2011). The Casey Anthony murder trial: a modern American tragedy.

Read More
259 Words | 2 Pages

The article “On Punishment and Teen Killers” written by Jennifer Jenkins is an article with very weak ethos. The author argues that teens who commit heinous crimes should receive life without the possibility of parole and that the victims rights should be considered. The author is a victim of a crime committed by a teen, her pregnant sister was brutally murdered by a teen gunman who wanted to “see what it felt like to shoot someone” (2). By bringing her sister into the paper the author lowers her credibility because she is emotionally connected to the case and has an obvious biased opinion. This leads to the readers to question her reliability on an unbiased opinion in the article.

Read More
1065 Words | 5 Pages

Modern Day Muckraking “In 1979, Goldschmidt, who as mayor had won national renown for the development of the downtown bus mall and the city 's then-revolutionary light rail, was tapped by President Jimmy Carter to be Secretary of Transportation” (Jaquiss). Neil Goldschmidt was a very successful politician, but he was hiding a very dark secret that the people of Oregon deserved to know. Should the type of person, who raped a 14 year old girl for three years, be considered someone that the people of Oregon look up to? This is just one of the questions Nigel Jaquiss addressed in his article about the affair between Neil Goldschmidt and a 14 year old girl that occurred from 1975-1978 (Jaquiss).

Read More
324 Words | 2 Pages

This story is a typical case of child sexual abuse with a male offender, Jerry Sandusky, who victims were aged between 7 and 13, and who had a close

Read More
2815 Words | 12 Pages

The victim “Jane Doe” claimed that on July 22, 2021, her next door neighbor, Mr. Santillan sexually assaulted her while she was unconscious. The attorneys, judges, audience, and jurors all possessed unique communication patterns. These ultimately impact the decision of whether Mr. Santillan is guilty and showcases the standards of a trial. As a communication student from the University of California, Santa Barbara I was able to decipher these communication

Read More
875 Words | 4 Pages

Natalie Wolfe’s media report on the guilty plea of Rick Thorburn over the murder of his 12-year-old step-daughter Tiahleigh Palmer was published on the 19th of March 2018 on news.com.au under the title ‘Tiahleigh Palmer: Rick Thorburn to plead guilty to schoolgirl’s murder’. This journalist used the news values; betrayal of trust, violence, moral clarity, and simplification in order to gather the attention of the public and engage the reader. The use of these news values is effective in being able to get the attention of and engage the public in this crime. The ‘Betrayal of Trust’ news value is less about the media report and more about the crime itself, though the media does have an impact on how it is portrayed. Natalie writes about the crime in a way that portrays Rick as a guardian that has taken advantage of his duty of care to the victim, Tiahleigh, by murdering her and leaving her body to be found on the edge of a river (Wolfe, 2018).

Read More
310 Words | 2 Pages

Pedophile in Penn State The general argument made by Maia Szalavitz in her work, “Bystander Psychology: Why Some Witnesses to Crime Do Nothing”, is that it is wrong when people view crime, and they do not take action. More specifically, Szalavitz argues that people tend to keep quiet for each other as a conglomerate. She writes, ”Mike Mcqueary… witnessed child rape firsthand in 2002...

Read More
497 Words | 2 Pages

I vividly recall my mother’s astonishment that I, as a 10 year-old, would be glued to the television set. The Casey Anthony case was aired for years, I was fascinated by how the law worked and the new facts that were discovered that threw the case to one side or another; I felt connected to this case because it was in my home state. My mom never grows tired of telling this story, and with every year passing I know she becomes more and more proud of the little girl who admired the men in blue suits on the screen and decided then she wanted to be a lawyer. I remember watching my mom gaze at me with an amazed look in her eye that I have now grown so fond of.

Read More
1461 Words | 6 Pages

Juveniles carry underdeveloped brains that can lead them to do wrong because of their poor judgment and immaturity. The rise in technology does not help with the development of the brain, for juveniles are open to a mass number of websites with information. The judges have to decide from whether the immaturity of the criminal is a factor, whether or not these juveniles meant to commit these crimes, have to take into account how heinous the crime committed was, and also the judge has to give these victims correct justice. The information on these websites is not always truthful, for it became one of the key pieces to “The Slender man Case”. The girls, in this case, Anissa Weier and Morgan Geyser spent most of their time reading about the Slender

Read More
812 Words | 4 Pages

A frustrated community, mislead stories, and a phony mother brought to the courtroom in 2008, as a mother was being charged. Casey Anthony, the mother of Caylee, was accused of being responsible for the disappearance and death of her daughter. Caylee had been missing for weeks, before it was reported. The Casey Anthony case was significant to America because it showed our society the careless actions of one mother through the unreliable stories, falsely made reports and evidence that wasn’t thoroughly investigated. This trial was significant to America because it showed our society the careless actions of a mother, and how her choices got her to where she is today.

Read More
890 Words | 4 Pages

When Eric Harris and Dylan Klebold terrorized Columbine High School nearly twenty years ago, the shooting shocked the nation. However, as the media incorrectly reported- the attack on Columbine High School was not an intended school shooting, but rather an elaborate terror plot with the hopes of killing hundreds of people. It had been decades since terror of this magnitude had occurred on school grounds, and the first one that had occurred in the dawn of mass media. Never before had the media become so up close and personal with the victims, to the point where they were able to talk to the students while the shooting was happening. But with this new sense of power and responsibility to quickly inform the public and develop conclusions, danger

Read More
803 Words | 4 Pages

As a result, in the case of the West Memphis Three law enforcement and the legal system seem so hurried about placing these three teenage boys behind bars even though they didn’t have the right people in prison. They had a created a messy investigation without any evidence leading to the defendants. Also when there is a confession that is false when there is scientific evidence most commonly DNA that definitively establishes the defendant’s innocence (Greene & Heilbrun, 2014, p. 166). The West Memphis Three in 1993 is about the bodies of three young eight-year-old boys - Stevie Branch, Michael Moore, and Christopher Byers – were found bound, mutilated and drowned in a drainage canal in the Robin Hood Hills neighborhood of West Memphis. The detectives used coercive interrogation that was demonstrated in the documentary.

Read More
1423 Words | 6 Pages

Is true crime media ethical? Everyone loves watching true crime stories about serial killers, but do we ever think about the victims and their families while we consume these things? Of course, we do, but not because we are concerned about them and how that show/podcast could affect them, but because they are mentioned in the media we consume. Lately, many fans of true crime have noticed that their obsession with the genre has been a bit concerning.

Read More
2030 Words | 9 Pages

We may find that juveniles are of special cases when charged with a sex crime and their information should be protected and not public

Read More
227 Words | 1 Pages

REPORTER: The reporter/Detective (Kim) called with concerns for the victim, Kierra. According to the reporter, on today (10/26/2015), a Forensic Interview was conducted on the victim. On Thursday, the victim was at school and a topic came up about a church, and the child got very upset. The teacher sent the child to see the counselor (Mrs. Brookes), and the child disclosed that she was sexually abused when she was 6 years old by Vishun Evans, who the victim said was 13 years old at the time of the incident.

Read More

More about Arguments Against Perverted Justice In To Catch A Predator

Related Topics

Open Document