ipl-logo

Arguments Against Proposition 54

1460 Words6 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Healthcare disparities between social classes in america

Proposition 54 was a measure that Californians were asked to vote on in 2003 that sought to prohibit state and local governments from classifying any individual by race, ethnicity, color, or national origin. An excerpt of an argument in favor of this proposition states that California is the most racially and ethnically diverse state, and that it is the wrong for the government to put a label on Californians based on their ethnic background. The thesis of the argument is that the government should stop categorizing its citizens by color and ancestry. The argument's t main premise is that being asked to state one's race is a means for the government to classify, categorize, and divide the people. The article continues on and states that the …show more content…

Although the goal of Proposition 54 is to prevent racism by prohibiting the government from classifying the people, it will ultimately result in the opposite. As I stated earlier, classification systems now today are used for our own benefit in many ways. Classification systems are used to protect us and our rights, benefit us in the fields of medicine and healthcare, and can be used to in fact stop racism. I would vote against Proposition 54, because it were to be passed, it would hinder our safety and rights, hinder the current advancements being made in the fields medicine and healthcare, and further promote …show more content…

Proposition 54 seeks to have an exemption to collecting data on people in medicine and healthcare as well, but similar to law enforcement, healthcare agencies work along with the government in order to keep track with its citizens. With the government now prohibited from collecting data on people, healthcare is now subjected to having a further difficult task on tracking information on its patients. Proposition 54 only exempts "medical research subjects and patients", but not for medical studies concerning the patterns, causes, and effects of health and disease conditions in certain populations. Certain health conditions affect individuals differently depending on their ethnic background. Therefore, certain ethnic groups must experience different forms of treatment, and have different rates of risk behaviors. With these restrictions placed, it would hinder the current progress being made in the fields of medicine and healthcare. Former U.S. Surgeon Dr. David Satcher states that "Without that data we could not even begin on a course toward eliminating disparities in health, we would not be able to measure our success or evaluate our objectives toward eliminated

Show More
Related

Pros And Cons Of Proposition 28

1483 Words | 6 Pages

Proposition 28 was passed on June 5, 2012 through the California initiative process. Proposition 28 was an initiative to amend the California Constitution. The change to the Constitution aims to reduce the amount of time a legislature can remain in the California legislature, but it would increase the total amount of time that a legislator could spend in one house to twelve years in total and it would only affect an legislators elected after June 5, 2012 (“In Depth” 2). The legislator could choose how the twelve years where spent, whether in just the Assembly, just the Senate, or any combination of the two. The legislators would still be subject to the same terms, but just the limits on them would increase.

Read More

Race And Ethnicity Paradigm

1025 Words | 5 Pages

Everyday the future in America looks brighter for the issues dealing with race and identity. Brave souls are not letting racism, class discrimination, or sexism hold them back anymore. Furthermore, the fight for a balanced society that pushes for equality is on the horizon. As we close on an era, based on purely the skin of the person, we need to analyze the impacts of the Ethnicity paradigm and Class paradigm on politics of the 20th century. Race and Ethnicity are used interchangeable in everyday conversation, however; they are not the same.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Proposition 54

841 Words | 4 Pages

Proposition 54, the Public Display of Legislative Bills Initiative, would 1) prohibit California legislators from passing any bill without posting the bill for the public 72 hours beforehand, 2) require that videos of all the state’s public legislative meetings be posted online for twenty years, and 3) allow anyone to record videos of meetings and use them for “any legitimate purpose.” While proponents argue that this initiative is necessary to increase transparency, you should follow the Democratic Party in opposing it because it would unnecessarily slow down the legislative process, discourage bipartisan compromises, and enable misuse of videos in misleading ads. Furthermore, if Proposition 54 fails, you should offer an alternative piece

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Glenn E Martin's One In Three

561 Words | 3 Pages

Glenn E Martin uses multiple rhetorical devices in his article “One in Three” to put forth his argument that the politicians and the government as a whole, use race as a factor in considering how and where a person should live his life. He uses strong, confident language, details, and colloquial, technical diction to convince his readers in believing his argument or at the least understand his point of view. The author uses short, simple words in the article to reach all readers. For example, he says, “ They did a crime and shouldn't get anything for free.”

Read More

Dean Spade's Intersectional Resistance And Law Reform

464 Words | 2 Pages

In “Intersectional Resistance and Law Reform,” Dean Spade proposes that the United States was founded through “racialization…(which) continues to operate under new guises… that produce, manage, and deploy gender categories and sexuality and family norms” (16). More over, these laws and norms tend to maintain the “status quo,” and employ an inherently flawed justice system that is only equipped to address single-axis discrimination issues (5). Thus, the intersectionality movement is largely dismissed by the social and justice systems, as it utilizes “critical intersectional tools… that are often (too) difficult for legal scholars to comprehend” (17). Interstionality’s progress is also impeded by advocates leaving to support single-axis issues. However, Spade warns that this approach is ineffective, as it fails to protect the most marginalized members of society.

Read More

Proposition 57: Argumentative Analysis

2010 Words | 9 Pages

Yes on Proposition 57 When Robert Gonzalez was 17 years old, he was charged as an adult because the public defender said his actions were an”adult-like crime”. Robert Gonzalez was the “wheel-man” during a robbery. The sentenced Mr.Gonzalez got a sentence of 20 years with 4 months. Proposition 57 is mainly for the juveniles that are getting a second chance to go to rehab and to get better. Proposition 57 is trying to get passed because there are too many people that are getting put into prisons for reasons that can be solved another way.

Read More

Mendez V Westminster Case Study

1458 Words | 6 Pages

Title: Mendez v. Westminster (1946) Abstract: The Mendez v. Westminster (1946) was the stepping stone to ending school segregation in California. The lawsuit was led by Gonzalo Mendez and five other parents who were denied enrollment of their children in an Anglo school. This led them to protest and then file a class-action lawsuit against the Westminster School District of Orange County California. Accusing them of segregating Mexican and Latin decent students.

Read More

Racial Fault Lines Analysis

1871 Words | 8 Pages

In Racial Fault Lines: The Historical Origins of White Supremacy in California, Tomas Almaguer (2009) describes how race and racism coincides to facilitate the birth of white supremacy in California during the late nineteenth century. The idea of racial formation allowed groups to establish their power and privilege over defined racial lines. For each of the three racialized groups presented Chapter one combines the historical and sociological framework to describe the transformation of Mexican California. Through highlighting the historical accounts of racialized groups, fear of potential threats to white workers creates white supremacy. He continues by describing the peopling of Anglo-CA from 1848-1900 with the immigration of Irish, German,

Read More

A Brief Note On Pluralistic Society In The United States

1329 Words | 6 Pages

A Bumpy Ride on the Even Road: Still Separate and Unequal with Pluralistic and Two-tiered Pluralistic Society in the United States In order to illustrate the U.S. politics, especially in terms of racial and ethnic minority issues, many political models used as analytical tools to understand the political resources and opportunities of U.S. racial and ethnic groups in contemporary U.S. society had been proposed. Among these politically important models, two of the most fundamentally important are Pluralism and Two-tiered Pluralism (DeSipio, 2015: Week 2 Lectures; Shaw et. al., 2015).

Read More

Whiteness As Property Analysis

715 Words | 3 Pages

Fahad Albrahim Response 1: Review/Summary: “Whiteness as property” is an article written by Cheryl Harris, in which she addresses the subject of racial identity and property in the United States. Throughout the article, professor Harris attempts to explain how the concept of whiteness was initiated to become a form of racial identity, which evolved into a property widely protected in American law (page 1713). Harris tackles a number of facts that describe the roots of whiteness as property in American history at the expense of minorities such as Black and American natives (page 1709). Additionally, Harris describes how whiteness as property evolved to become seen as a racial privilege in which the whites gained more benefits, whether

Read More

Analysis Of Planting A Sequoia By Dana Gioia

1100 Words | 5 Pages

the

Read More

Civil Rights In The Late 19th And Early 20th Century

279 Words | 2 Pages

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, a large portion of Americans were restricted from civil and political rights. In American government in Black and White (Second ed.), Paula D. McClain and Steven C. Tauber and Vanna Gonzales’s power point slides, the politics of race and ethnicity is described by explaining the history of discrimination and civil rights progress for selective groups. Civil rights were retracted from African Americans and Asian Americans due to group designation, forms of inequality, and segregation. These restrictions were combatted by reforms such as the Thirteenth Amendment, the Fourteenth Amendment, the Fifteenth amendment, the Civil Rights Act of 1964, the Voting Rights Act of 1965, etc. Although civil and political

Read More

Essay On Health Care Disparity

989 Words | 4 Pages

The sexual orientation, race, age, etc., in the US deprived certain groups from receiving equal opportunity in the health care and the health care. Thus, making the disparities in the US health system an

Read More

Race Social Construction

1428 Words | 6 Pages

Throughout history social scientists have been trying to examine the different parameters of race in terms of phenotypic characteristics, and cultural behaviors regarding the different groups that society construct’s. legally judges have had different rulings regarding the categorization of different ethnicities and groups within the United States. Many philosophers such as Kwame Appiah, and Scientists such as Dr. James Watson have had opposing arguments on the topic of race and whether it exists or not. In order to do so we need to examine the different definitions of race, and analyze them in order to see how race is a social construct, where people’s notions of race and their interactions with different races determine the way they perceive

Read More

Essay On Mixed Race

1190 Words | 5 Pages

The majority of the general public has preconceived ideas as to what a person’s race is based solely on appearance. In general, it can be difficult to identify a person’s race just by looking at their skin color. In each race, there are many variations of skin color and to make it more complex and difficult, not to mention people who are of mixed race. Historically, race has been divided into four categories: black/African American, white, Asian/Pacific Islander, Native American/Alaskan Native.

Read More

More about Arguments Against Proposition 54

Related Topics

Open Document