ipl-logo

Athens Vs Rome Dbq Research Paper

900 Words4 Pages

Picture Athens buzzing with democracy and Rome towering with power, their clash echoing through history, shaping civilizations forever. The clash between these civilizations echoes throughout history and has shaped our world in countless ways. Citizenship started way back in these two city-states near the Mediterranean Sea. One of the ways it has shaped our world is that Rome and Athens both gave the gift of citizenship to their people. The notion of citizenship, whether in Athens or Rome, symbolized rights, and responsibilities within the society. If one had to choose between the two, it would be Rome’s concept of citizenship. The reason why Rome had the better system was because of its variety of people who could have citizenship and adjustments …show more content…

Considering the content and images presented in documents E and F, we can see that Rome’s structure and stability surpassed that of Athens. According to Document F, “members of the Senate (about 300 men) served for life”. This feature ensures that Rome’s Senate remains steady and consistent over time, offering long-term stability in its leadership. Based on Document E, “All of Athens’s 40,000 citizens were eligible to attend, though travel made that difficult. Six thousand were necessary for a quorum on important issues such as ostracism.”(Doc E). Out of the 40,000 citizens, only 6,000 people were needed to participate in important decisions. To have a meeting it was required to have full participation of its citizens in decision making. While, Rome’s Senate had a more manageable size of about 300 members, establishing efficiency and country governance. Others might say that Athens allowed participation from citizens to share all kinds of opinions and ideas. What needs to be taken into consideration is, that Rome’s Senate size was smaller, allowing for more efficient decision-making processes compared to Athens’ direct democracy. This categorization system was an essential part of Roman society, helping maintain order and allocate resources fairly. Without it, chaos would have ensued, and the city would not have been able to function properly. As such, we should recognize the crucial role that the censors played in the development of ancient Rome and its lasting impact on history. A brilliant move by the Roman leaders was their creative approach to granting citizenship to foreigners, by using unique methods. For example, Claudius, one of Rome's emperors says, “What was the ruin of Sparta and Athens, but this, that mighty as they were in war, they spurned [rejected] from them as aliens [foreigners] those whom they had conquered? Our founder

Show More
Related
791 Words | 4 Pages

D. Although Athens did have a few better ways of including citizens in government, it didn’t have many to involve more people like Rome did. Now let’s continue with

Read More
877 Words | 4 Pages

Even thousands of years later, the history of ancient Greek culture, the tales of legendary gods, the Spartan troops, and Athens' political system remain valuable and relevant to this day. There are even movies that continue to honor Spartan soldiers' bravery and Athens' democracy. This paper seeks to discuss how people in Athens and Sparta obtained the right to participate in public affairs, who held public office, and what rules governed the selection of public office holders, while also providing a glimpse into how the two city-states' governmental structures were similar and different at the same time. How did people in Athens and Sparta obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community? To have

Read More
1489 Words | 6 Pages

Every portion of the government directly represented its people - from the Council of 500 to the Ecclesia and the Court and Jury System - and citizens were payed and thus incentivized to participate in the system. They did their best to make an equitable system with the allocation of members through the 10 tribe system, the potential for scrutinization for any member of the government, and the randomization of jury members for trials. The Greeks were a tier above their Roman counterparts when it came to

Read More
962 Words | 4 Pages

Eventually, Athens became a true democracy. All could participate in government if they were a free Athens male citizen. Slaves, women, and foreigners were exempt from participating. The city was divided into different groups that made up the different voting blocs. Aristocrats still had plenty of power, due to being able to sway voters one way or another, but they were also not the only ones with power anymore.

Read More
755 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction Sparta and Athens were two big ancient Greek city-states, in this essay, we will discuss about how did the people of these two poleis obtain their political rights and participate in their public life. We will also illustrate who were the ones serving in public office and what were the rules that governed the selection process. Finally, we will compare the government structures of Sparta and the Athens, and analyze their similarities and differences. In Sparta, only the Sparta warriors enjoyed the political rights.

Read More
785 Words | 4 Pages

Athens and Sparta were two of the great powers of the Grecian peninsula during the classical period. The fact that both rose to power geographically close to one another with such different governments yet sharing in some similar ideals is intriguing. These ideals may have expressed themselves in different ways but served similar purposes. Examining these two city-states in regards to who participated in government and held office, the similarities of their systems, and their differences will allow us to have a better appreciation of each.

Read More
676 Words | 3 Pages

This paper will examine how the people in Athens and Sparta obtained the right to participate in public life, who held office, the rules governing the selection of public office holders, and similarities and differences between the two city-states in the governmental structures. Participation in public life In Athens, every male citizen who had completed his military training and was over 18 years old had the right to participate in the Athenian Assembly (Rothchild, 2007). The Athenian

Read More
640 Words | 3 Pages

Athens and Sparta were sociologically disparate across public life, public office, and government rules although similarities did exist. The right to participate in public life wasn’t available to commoners although decisions made in public office did effect communities. Consequently, public office positions within each city-state were obtainable under different rules, so different ideologies influenced civil servants managing government affairs. Furthermore, the regulations that governed the selection of public office holders also changed Athens and Sparta culture. Although the two city-states had distinct cultural ideologies, there were similarities in their governmental structure.

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

The Roman Empire had an estimated population of 45,000,000 people during 1 CE: about 15 percent of the world’s population. Athens had an estimated 300,000 people in their population during 400 BCE. The two empires are comparable to an elephant and a flea. Which empire had the best citizenship? The Roman Empire did.

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

Introduction The ancient Greek civilization was home to two of the most prominent city-states of their time: Athens and Sparta. While they shared a common language and culture, these two city-states differed significantly in their political systems. Athenians practiced democracy, while Spartans had an oligarchic system of government. I will mention in this assignment the differences and similarities between the government structures of Athens and Sparta, focusing on how people obtained the right to participate in public life, who held public office, and what rules governed the selection of public office holders. Participation in Public Life

Read More
699 Words | 3 Pages

HIST 1421 Greek and Roman Civilization Unit 1 Written Assignment Instructor - Jennifer Musgrave 12th April, 2023 Introduction I have learned about the Greek civilization in details from this week's reading materials, and there are so many interesting things, such as governmental processes and democratic systems of ancient Greek civilization. Now, I am going to mention them according to the given prompt questions from different scenarios by reflecting on the knowledge I have gained and the differences and similarities between the governmental structures of Athens and Sparta. How did people in Athens and Sparta obtain the right to participate in public life and make decisions affecting the community?

Read More
1014 Words | 5 Pages

Discussion These great states have various means by which a citizen can make contribution in the public domain, who can occupy the public office, and the rules governing their selection process. The Spartans were a military society which was been dominated by men who has the aristocratic bunch of superiority. Women were having control over the management of the household and they have no voting right.

Read More
1149 Words | 5 Pages

Sparta and Athens Introduction The purpose of my paper is to compare and contrast the ancient peoples of Athens and Sparta with respect to how their citizens obtained the right to participate in public life, which of their citizens were able to hold public office, and what rules governed their selection. I will also touch on how the governmental structures of the two city-states were similar and how they were different. Discussions Who could participate In both Athens and Sparta there were several qualities that were needed for one to be even considered for any kind of membership in any of the voting assemblies or as someone who held political office.

Read More
534 Words | 3 Pages

The magistrates and tribunes… were the only ones who could place legislation before the voters.” The small percent of citizens that actually did vote in Ancient Rome were spoon-fed their candidates by higher ups like the magistrates in

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

This system was designed to ensure that only the most capable and experienced citizens held public office. Similarities and Differences between Athens and Sparta Both Athens and Sparta had participatory forms of government, but they differed in several ways. Athens was a democracy, while Sparta was an oligarchy. Athens had a larger population than Sparta, and its citizens had more individual freedoms. In contrast, Sparta was more militaristic, and its citizens had fewer personal freedoms (Ober,2015).

Read More

More about Athens Vs Rome Dbq Research Paper

Open Document