ipl-logo

Black Death Theory

1581 Words7 Pages

The outbreak of the pandemic known as the Black Death in 1347 brought to Europe devastation unlike any other on record which demanded immediate action in both treating and preventing further spread of the disease. Firstly this essay will examine the causes and diagnoses of the disease. Following this, there will be an investigation of the precautions implemented in an attempt to stop the spread of infection, such as quarantine and the understanding of contagion. Furthermore, there will be an argument that the Black Death can be seen as a normal accident according to Normal Accident Theory. Finally there will be a discussion on how the Black Death’s implementation of quarantine relates to the precautionary principle and how we deal with epidemics …show more content…

While it is difficult to argue what exact system would have caused the Black Death, there are evidently many contributing factors that lead to its spread and devastation. If we take human society to be the system that contributed to the pandemic, then it is inarguably complex, involving countless interactions and potential failings that could lead to catastrophic disaster. As Perrow mentions, these systems are tightly coupled, meaning they leave little room for failures within the system without causing subsequent effects on the rest of the system (Perrow, 1984). These exact complex systems are the ones that Perrow argues lead to inevitable or normal accidents. In the case of the Black Death’s spread, the system is of human interaction being a long and unbreakable chain of actions, including overseas travel leading to further spreading of the infection. Once one person has been infected and come into contact with others, it is too late to prevent the others from further contacts, and by the time the disease was diagnosable the outbreak was already uncontrollable. In this sense, the pandemic can be seen as a normal accident, inevitable through a system that did not allow for any slack or quarantine measures, due to the absence of understanding when it came to the disease’s cause, treatment and nature of contraction from one …show more content…

(Fuller, 2013). If we look at this alongside the Black Death, we see that it would have been highly unlikely the disease could have been predicted to spread so quickly and cause so much death, but if they had developed the methods of quarantine in earlier stages it could have prevented substantial damage. As Fuller argues, risk taking is essential to the progress of humanity. (Fuller, 2013). This is certainly evident in the case of the Black Death, as the risk after the outbreaks was the total extinction of the human race, but more effective medicine and particularly the importance of quarantine and understanding of contagion were accelerated greatly by this risk that humanity might be wiped out. Of course, it is impossible to weigh the lives lost in the Black Death against the benefits to humanity that it produced, even if we consider how many lives were spared due to these early medical advancements. Thus produces the difficulty of the precautionary principle, which is the underlying question: is it acceptable to risk lives in order to possibly save others and advance humanities’ progress? It is impossible to know how quickly medicine would have advanced without the occurrence of the Black Death. Perhaps

Show More
Related
200 Words | 1 Pages

If war can eliminate people 's lives, so can a plague. The Black Death was the disastrous pandemic of mankind. This plague swiped over Europe and parts of Asia and Africa. Back then, insufficient of research of medical studies aided the spread of the Black Death. Variety of factors contributed to lack of research.

Read More
1303 Words | 6 Pages

During the thirteenth century, a disease known as the Black Death spread from Asia to Europe at an alarming speed. It travelled through the trade routes, in the form of infected fleas carried from town to town on rats causing catastrophic loses of population . The Black Death consisted of two forms of the disease; the pneumonic plague, and the bubonic plague . Since it was unknown as to what caused the disease at the time, their responses to the plague’s outbreak were almost entirely futile. Since religion was a big factor in nearly everybody’s lives, the records of the Black Death that we do have are heavily influenced by religion, and as such, their views strongly swayed things like treatments and medicine that were used against the plague.

Read More
995 Words | 4 Pages

All plagues strike by uprooting individual lives and society as a whole. Nevertheless, the particular circumstances regarding the government, and religious and cultural beliefs in the affected lands influence the specific results of the tragedy, as witnessed through the Black Death and smallpox. Although both diseases led to drastic economic changes, they caused different overturns of religious beliefs, and only the Black Death resulted in the creation of public health services and the marginalization of groups of people. A lack of labor precipitated alterations to the economy--the end of feudalism in the case of the Black Death and the creation of the Transatlantic Slave Trade in the case of smallpox.

Read More
1655 Words | 7 Pages

The Black Death and the World It Made”).

Read More
919 Words | 4 Pages

The Bubonic plague ended up being catastrophic, and so devastating to European society because it caused changes in attitude towards religion, changes in population, and an increase of antisemitism. The Black Death spread so quickly through Europe that people did not even have time to process what was going on. As seen in the map “The Bubonic Plague spreads through Europe,”

Read More
665 Words | 3 Pages

The Black Death contributed to the fall of trade between countries, and the halt of trade routes. Since many people were afraid of the Plague, they did not like to allow outsiders to enter their countries or trade with them. People still needed certain goods, so they ended up trading with infected people, for infected things. The Black Death shut down about three major trade routes, making it hard for disease long distance trade to occur. Trade ships were a large disease spreader, and made up about 20% of infection making it very easy for the Plague to spread to different countries.

Read More
731 Words | 3 Pages

The Black Death was caused by various reasons, non-religious and religious. The disease in Europe, was said to be caused by, miasma (impure air) carried by warm southern winds, the March 20, 1345, conjunction of Saturn, Jupiter, and Mars, excessive clothing or outrageous fashion, and in the near east, caused by, miasma due to wind carrying the stench of Mongol bodies from Crimea,

Read More
1480 Words | 6 Pages

The Black Death The Black Death: The Medieval black plague that ravaged Europe and killed a third of its population. It was due to the plague which is caused by a bacterium (Yersinia pestis) transmitted to humans from infected rats by the oriental rat flea. “By all accounts, the Black Death spread from France in the summer of 1348 to the port of Weymouth on the southern coast of England, from whence it travelled very rapidly to other ports in both directions along the coast. It progressed up through the Bristol Channel to Bristol before advancing along the Severn to Gloucester.

Read More
489 Words | 2 Pages

The Black Death was a disease that had a catastrophic impact on Europe. Reaching Europe in 1347, the plague killed an estimation of one-third of the population in the first wave. Each document varies with its reasons for the cause of the plague and how to deal with it. The first document Ordinances against the Spread of Plague seemed to blame Pisa and Lucca for the plague and thus, began to forbid contact with those places. It was forbidden for citizens of Pistoia to go to, or have contact with anyone or anything from Pisa or Lucca.

Read More
601 Words | 3 Pages

Often as a result of overpopulation, pandemics—like swine flu and ebola, for instance—have affected life on Earth for centuries; one of the most well-known, and possibly the most unforgiving epidemics was the Bubonic Plague, also known as the Black Death . Although the first symptoms of the Plague trace back to the Mongol Empire in 1331, the disease first struck Europe in Venice and Genoa during the winter of 1348. In the following years, the Bubonic Plague spread rapidly throughout Europe, killing roughly a third of its population. It is suggested that the rapid spread and extreme severity of the Black Death was partially due to the weakened immune system of the Europeans, which had been caused by the Great Famine, a period of food scarcity that affected Europe from 1315 to 1322. Additionally, the lack of knowledge about the spread of

Read More
1445 Words | 6 Pages

It is no wonder that the Europeans felt that their economic environment was vulnerable and uneasy, “European economy slowly improved, and agriculture and manufacturing production eventually reached pre-famine levels” (Nelson, Insert Year). The economy impact of the Black Death must start with the historical context that the economy was not as sturdy as other time periods or European history. For this reason, the set back, economically speaking, was an enormous strain on European life. With population decreasing drastically, and the economy barely trying to recover from the famine, the Europeans suffered in terms of having workers to produce into the economy--especially to create food for what was left of the population. For these reasons, the Black Death took a major toll on the economy of Europe and created relentless heart ache, “Many people touched by the plague moved away from medieval cities and towns to unaffected areas.

Read More
1668 Words | 7 Pages

It was the Spring of 1348, and the citizens of Europe were malnourished due to limited food supplies for such a large population. This made them more susceptible to the outbreak of the Black Death. The Black Death originated in Asia, then moved westward into Sicily. From Sicily, the plague crept its way up through Europe infecting millions of people, in total killing more than one third of Europe’s population. In fact, over fifty percent of the population of Siena died, along with fifty percent of Paris, eighty percent of Florence, and over two thirds of Venice.

Read More
592 Words | 3 Pages

Imperialism has affected the world in various ways. Imperialism has many benefits that we still use today. The world wouldn't be as advanced today if it weren't for spread of technology, healthcare, and language. One example is that health care got deadly diseases under control. With language spread, more cultures were influenced.

Read More
1497 Words | 6 Pages

Mexican Americans/Chicanx people in the United States throughout the 20th century have always had disadvantages in the United States. They been fighting oppression, discrimination and equal rights in this country. From establishing a colonial labor system, enforced immigration laws, LAPD police brutality, El Plan de Aztlán, El Plan de Santa Bárbara, and the 1968 walkouts. The history of Chicanx people in this country is huge but is still not really well known by many but thanks to all of the fighting for equal rights that Chicanx people fought for we now have ethnic classes that teaches us about our own history and empower us to keep on fighting for our rights. All the way back to the industrialization era in the United States, the economy grew and new opportunities of labor became available.

Read More
1524 Words | 7 Pages

Did the Black Death break the Malthusian Deadlock that was hanging over England in the 14th century? Did the people really create a better country after this horrendous plague? These exemplify some of the intriguing questions asked about the Black Death. The essay examined a variety of factors from population to the economic factors regarding the Black Death.

Read More

More about Black Death Theory

Related Topics

Open Document