ipl-logo

Buchat Vs Ravens Case Study

888 Words4 Pages

Case Citation: Bouchat v. Ravens, 2000, 241 F3d 350
Parties: Frederick Bouchat, Plaintiff-Appellee Baltimore Ravens and NFL Properties
Facts: Frederick Bouchat (Plaintiff-appellee) file suit before the United States Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit, seeking the payment of damages in the amount of $10,000,000. Bouchat alleges that Baltimore Ravens, Inc. and the National Football League Properties (defendants-appellants) had actually committed infringement of his three seperate drawings of his original work. Bouchat also alleged that several other drawings that he created during the concluding parts of 1995 has also been infringed upon. Additional facts showed that the other drawings were in fact created by Frederick Bouchat, …show more content…

Therefore, based on the strikingly similar doctrine, the issue of access is inconsequential in this case of infringement.
Issue 2: Rule of Law or Legal Principle Applied: In deciding the case, the Court relied broadly on Copyright Law, most specifically with respect to the basics of copyright protection. In addition, the Court also maintains the strikingly similar doctrine upheld in the case of …show more content…

Essentially, the strikingly similar doctrine permits an inference of access whenever two works are similar to one another, in essence, this negates the possibility of independent creation. As point out in a prior case, such striking similarity can lead one to believe that a work has certainly been copied from another. In this specific case, while it is true that Bouchat failed to bring forward sufficient evidence in relation to the defendant’s access of his drawings, the striking similarity between Bouchat’s works and the shield logo of the Ravens adequately shows copyright infringement. Given the aforementioned, the court additional states that it is of no moment that Bouchat did not prove that Modell (the official of the Ravens) actually saw the drawings. Instead, it was necessary to prove that the former was merely given the opportunity to view them. Bouchat’s act of send a fax copy of his drawings to the representatives of the Ravens is more than hypothetical and these acts support the Ravens infringement of Bouchat works. The court likewise sustained the fact that Bouchat drawing qualifies for copyright protection, however, the defendants argue that the drawings of Bouchat do not qualify for protection because it does not contain original elements. According to the court, while it is true that the

Show More
Related
331 Words | 2 Pages

The main issue from this case was to determine whether the NFL’s eligibility rule was exempt from the antitrust law. During this case, the NFL players union and the

Read More
213 Words | 1 Pages

Football DBQ The Ely Tigers versed the Dillard Panthers. They had an instant win at the end of their football game. They don’t know if it was a lucky catch or if it was a skilled catch. From reading through all of these documents from the story, they proved that Donnell Wilson caught the winning touchdown because it was a clean catch, didn’t have a penalty, and he caught it across the touchdown line.

Read More
700 Words | 3 Pages

Participation Portfolio 1 Asst 3: Henrietta Lacks Discussion Questions   Please answers each of the following questions, and be prepared to discuss in class   1. Please outline the history of Henrietta Lacks 's tissue cells. Who did what with the cells, when, where and for what purpose? Who benefited, scientifically, medically, and monetarily?

Read More
615 Words | 3 Pages

This trial is on Walt Disney Studios vs. Faden on the work Professor faden made to inform people on copyright, fair use and infringement. They are battling over copyright and fair use on this video. Walt Disney Studios claims that Faden’s work is copyrighted and is suing for infringement. But Professor Faden claims that he followed all the rules on copyright and he thinks it is fair use. “ Defendence you make take your stands,”The judge says in an assertive voice.

Read More
109 Words | 1 Pages

The football that we know today started in 1922 when the American Professional Football Association change its name to the National Football League. The team with the best regular season record was the champion. in 1960 a second national football league was started to compete with the NFL. Eventually it ended up the being two conferences to make up the NFL, the American Football Conference and the National Football Conference. The two implemented a system of playoff games and the champions of the two conferences went head to head in a game called the Superbowl.

Read More
1501 Words | 7 Pages

The arguments were based majorly on legal and moral considerations. The legal arguments, which opponents advanced, were stronger than those of proponents of the Act. Morally, the arguments seemed to be equally strong. However, upon consideration of the entire arguments, numerical strength favored those of opponents. Also, all the arguments by proponents, except one, were objectively controvertible while those of opponents were not.

Read More
1157 Words | 5 Pages

NFL Concerned with Health or Wealth Football is the most popular sport in the United States. It is a part of school and college life, and everyone wants to try it out. It is the most lucrative professional sport, with the day Super Bowl Sunday functioning as an unofficial holiday. NFL (National Football League) does provide entertainment, but it has a dark secret that the NFL does not want anyone to know. They deny having any connection with CTE.

Read More
390 Words | 2 Pages

The duty of any criminal prosecutor is to seek justice. A conviction is the end of justice being served prior to sentencing; however justice cannot be served if an innocent person is found guilty. Even though the prosecutor(s) are there to represent the public and has the duty to aggressively pursue offenders for violations of state and federal laws, they shall never lose sight or their own moral compass of their main purpose is to find the truth. In the pursuit of truth, the United States Supreme Court has developed or made rulings in reference to several principles of conduct which have to be followed by all prosecutors to assure that the accused person(s) are allowed the proper procedures and due process of the law granted by the 14th Amendment.

Read More
1506 Words | 7 Pages

The Pittsburgh Steelers have arguably the most passionate fan base in all of football, making them a marketing and business giant, however, these key strengths for the Steelers are somewhat counterweighted by their weaknesses. To the naked eye the Steelers really have no stand-out drawbacks, they sell out practically every game at Heinz Field, but when taking a closer in depth look at the organization it appears that the Steelers suffer from the same downfalls as the rest of the National Football League. NFL fans are some of the oldest fans in all of sports, these fans that are of old age will soon not be physically able to go to as many games as they once have, the Steelers have one of the oldest fan demographics. Season tickets are passed

Read More
972 Words | 4 Pages

Issue 6- Does the Act violate the Procedural Due Process? Conclusion 1.

Read More
1776 Words | 8 Pages

"Bratton turned the transit police into an organization focused on the smallest infractions, on the details of life underground." (Gladwell 154). Here, Gladwell writes about how a police chief finely tuned his tactics so that his officers would pay attention to the environment, and he was met with a rousing success. This really drives the point home that in both art and life, the environment adds its own influence. The same environmental impacts that affect society also affect the world of art, and once this is realized it becomes clear that many cases of plagiarism are actually the positive result of this contextual

Read More
686 Words | 3 Pages

The NFL is portrayed in the media show that the NFL players in their uniforms and portray them to be very happy and wealthy and enjoying their lives. The media also shows how NFL players get all the girls and show their high profile divorces or their criminal cases. The NFL shows young prospective player that in order to be a part of their league they must be the best of the best or go home. What that says about the NFL is that they are very competitive and it is not an easy journey to try to be a part of their team. The message it conveys to people is that if you get buff and you throw around a football you can be just like the NFL players and have all the money, cars and women.

Read More
721 Words | 3 Pages

Sports journalists from across the media spectrum had reacted to the Saints’ bounty scandal in a unified voice. Through JumboSearch, I dredged up their consensus: the New Orleans Saints had breached the ‘bounty-rule,’ a Constitutional clause that outlawed targeted, incentivized violence. In one report, the ‘bounty-rule’ supposedly outlined in the League Constitution was lifted verbatim from a policy piece I had read earlier. Using that piece as my guide, I scoured the Constitution for the ‘bounty-rule’. It did not

Read More
547 Words | 3 Pages

For many years has football has been considered the utmost dangerous sport in high school, but recently many new studies have been made to prove the exact opposite. High school football gives money to the school and improves the school. In high school sports when a team wins the championship the school gets money that can be used towards hiring new teachers, providing scholarships for students, buying new books, and overall improving the school itself. When a high school football team wins the championship the team's school gets $400,000 that can be spent on the school in many different forms.

Read More
2068 Words | 9 Pages

The court argued that Koon could have made the same statement without imitating Roger’s work. Koon had to pay compensation to Rodgers. CAN OR CANNOT PROTECT WORK AND

Read More

More about Buchat Vs Ravens Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document