ipl-logo

Brittany Navarra's Case Summary

1173 Words5 Pages

Imagine a situation in which a report came out that a 17-year-old was arrested for the killing of his next-door neighbor with the use of a shotgun. The video explains how adolescents from different age groups were sentenced to different types of crime. Juvenile criminal systems are different from adult criminal systems because innocent or guilty isn’t involved in that type of case as the juvenile is still a minor. For the adult criminal system, the criminal who is an adult has the option to bond and has a right to a jury trial as well. The proper age to be charged as an adult is 17 years old. This age is the proper age because at 17 years old the brain is already developed and the juvenile should know what is right and wrong. In other words, others would say …show more content…

This case supports the position because it shows how Brittany Navarra's brain should have been developed. Although she had problems in her life, it is still wrong for her to damage the life of Krista. This displays how jealousy and family are a big issue, yet the brain is already developed for a teenager like her to commit a menacing crime. This reveals how an individual's actions can affect others. Many will probably disagree with the assertion that 17 years old is the age where a juvenile should be responsible for the crime that is committed. Some may disagree because others would say 17 years old is too young for a teenager or juvenile to be facing time in prison. Some may disagree with the assertion by saying that placing a juvenile in prison is similar to keeping a child in prison as well. While it is true that 17 years old is too young for a juvenile to be in prison, it does not necessarily mean that the brain can’t function correctly. This is a serious issue because a similar case relates to this, when a teenage girl named Alyssa murdered her neighbor Elizabeth by strangling her and stabbing her to

Show More
Related

Summary Of The Steep Cost Of Keeping Juveniles In Adult Prisons

507 Words | 3 Pages

The article, “The Steep Costs of Keeping Juveniles in Adult Prisons” written by Jessica Lahey states, “Juveniles constitute 1,200 of the 1.5 million people housed in federal and state prisons in this country, and nearly 200,000 youth enter the adult criminal-justice system each year, most for non-violent crimes.” Minors should not be tried as adults because their brains are not developed, they may come from bad backgrounds, and they have their whole life ahead of them, and their life should not be determined by the mistakes they made as a child. Juveniles who are usually 14 or older who have committed serious crimes are tried as adults and are put into adult-state prisons. This is inhumane and unsafe for the child’s physical and mental health. One of the many reasons that minors should not be tried as adults is because their brains are not fully developed, so they cannot make good decisions until they are older, far into their twenties.

Read More

The 57 Bus Dashka Slater Character Analysis

988 Words | 4 Pages

In British Columbia, the juvenile justice system accepts offenders ages 12 and 18 because this system believes that since their brain is not fully developed, there is a good chance that they can learn from their mistakes and gain more awareness about the consequences and how they can affect you in the long term. In certain cases, if the crime committed is very serious, the judge can decide whether or not they should be tried as an adult, even if still a minor. For example, in this book the judge wanted Richard tried as an adult since Sasha was left in horrendous conditions. This example should have been laid out in a different way, no minor should be put in adult confinement no matter the crime since adult confinements are much more intense and violent than juvenile confinements. Teenagers and youth should not be introduced to the violence held in these confinements since it can create new bad habits that can more so affect their life and make it worse whether then rehabilitation which is the main focus in juveniles.

Read More

Nathaniel Abraham Research Paper

693 Words | 3 Pages

People argue that some juveniles are “too young and they don’t understand” but either way, they still broke the law and should be fairly punished. A fact stating “There are approximately 6,000 juveniles in adult jails and prisons in the United States” shows that people who have broken the law with felonies have been confined by law, no matter the age. People need to learn before they act in a similar manner, again. A similar case is a boy named Craig Price from Rhode Island who had committed multiple felonies, such as four murders and was charged as a minor, meaning he was arrested around age 16 and would get out and have his criminal record sealed at age 21. Because of this, a law was changed so that juveniles could be tried as adults with serious crimes.

Read More

Chapter 13 Powerpoint: The Juvenile Justice System

261 Words | 2 Pages

The Juvenile Justice system is the investigation, supervision, adjudication, carement, and confinement of the youth who are at or below the state’s juvenile court jurisdiction, while the adult criminal justice system is those who are above the age. Using the textbook, Crime Justice: A Brief Introduction 11th Edition, and slides 5-6 in the chapter 13 PowerPoint, multitudes of differences were found between the different systems. In the juvenile justice system, there is more prominence found in the child’s best interest, rather than with the legal issues in guilt and innocence as found on page 411. In the Adult court system though, it is mostly/completely focused on the criminality aspect and legal issues. In the juvenile justice system, there

Read More

Minors In The Juvenile Justice System

1878 Words | 8 Pages

The decision to try a juvenile as an adult varies drastically across the globe as each country or state has its own set of laws and principles regarding the approach taken to juveniles in the court system that differ from those of other countries (Juvenile Vs Adult). In countries like India and France, there are sometimes entirely separate courts (France’s being called Juvenile Assize) and certain amendments that allow for those aged 16-18 who have committed “heinous” offenses to be tried as adults (Singhl). Places such as Iran and the Middle East try everyone as though they are the same, so minors can receive equal trials and sentences as adults (Mostafaei). Considering there is a range of policy and court differences, and for the purposes

Read More

Juvenile Justice System In The 1800s

645 Words | 3 Pages

To begin with, the juvenile justice system is the area in criminal justice where one can’t be responsible for the crimes they commit due to their age. In most states, the cut off age for this system is 18 years old. One might say that the juvenile justice system has come a long way since the early 1800s. Back then, youth that committed criminal acts were treated the same as adults. There was no system to punish the youth properly.

Read More

The Role Of Juveniles In Adult Prisons

276 Words | 2 Pages

Juveniles may not be adults however; they should be punished the same as an adult if they committed a serious crime. Say a juvenile had murdered someone, they should be charged as an adult and not be given certain amount of years and then probation. These juveniles who commit serious crimes knew what they were doing and should deal with the consequence no matter the age. I am not saying that a a juvenile under the age of 18 should be put in adult prison, however they should be in a juvenile detention until he/ she is old enough to be transferred in to a prison.

Read More

Juveniles Should Be Tried As Adults Research Paper

1777 Words | 8 Pages

Children as young as 14 can be tried as an adult for a harsh crime . If a young adult commits a crime they should be tried as an adult

Read More

Difference Between Criminal Justice System Children And Adults

206 Words | 1 Pages

Few centuries ago, there was no clear distinction between the Youth Justice System and the adult Criminal Justice System children and adults were punished and treated the same in eyes of the law. The main clear distinction that was made between the systems started with the Youthful Offender Act 1854 and The Juvenile Offenders act 1847. The Juvenile Offenders Act 1847 was the first legislation to differentiate between adults and juveniles offenders. Children who were under the age of 14 whom were accused of theft could be tried immediately for the crimes that they have committed. Rather than being sent to prison to wait for their trials, immediate powers of convictions made the process of trials for children faster and more private under the

Read More

Should Juveniles Be Tried As Adults In Criminal Court?

1979 Words | 8 Pages

There are five ways in which a juvenile can be prosecuted in adult court. One way is through a judicial wavier, this is allowed in most states, where judges have the discretion to have a youth’s case tried in the adult criminal court. The second way is through statutory exclusion, twenty-nine states automatically require a juveniles’ case to be tried in the adult court based on the age of the youth and/or the alleged crime. The other three ways are allowed in fewer states and include direct file or “prosecutorial discretion” where juvenile court judges the decision to have a youth 's case tried in the adult criminal court. There also mandatory waivers in few states which require juvenile court judges to automatically transfer a youth 's case to adult criminal court for certain offenses or because of the age or prior record of the offender.

Read More

Children Should Not Be Tried As Adults Essay

1058 Words | 5 Pages

When children and teens commit a violent crime such as murder, courts convict them as adults. This means that children as young as eight have been tried as adults in court. Eventually, these convicts will be housed in jails with adults. Despite the federal law stating that juvenile and adult inmates must be separated, most states do not comply with these rules. Furthermore, a law that varies throughout the states is the age in which courts send the children to adult or juvenile prisons.

Read More

Juveniles Should Be Tried As Adults Essay

1291 Words | 6 Pages

In our society, crimes are being committed not only by adults but by juveniles as well. By law as soon as a person turns 18 they are considered to be an adult. So what if an adult and a juvenile were to commit the same crime yet were sentenced differently simply based on the fact that one is a child and one is an adult? Juveniles are committing violent crimes just as adults and should be given the equal treatment and sentencing as adults receive. Juveniles aren’t completely ignorant as everyone seems to think.

Read More

Juvenile Justice Argumentative Essay

1860 Words | 8 Pages

Juvenile Justice There is a great deal of controversy that exists in America today. The question is whether a juvenile who committed a heinous crime should be punished to the same extent as an adult. The growing trend in the United States is to “get tough” on juveniles who commit these crimes. This has resulted in a growing number of minors who trial as adults, and being sent to adult prisons. Many believe if that an adult crime is committed, then you should face consequences appropriate for adults, but what exactly is the appropriate age to be considered an adult?

Read More

Juveniles Should Not Be Treated The Same As Adults Essay

760 Words | 4 Pages

Can you imagine waking up behind closed walls and bars? Waking up to see your inmate who is a 45-year-old bank robber and you are a 14-year-old minor who made a big mistake. This is why minors who have committed crimes should not be treated the same as adults. Some reasons are because the consequences given to minors in adult court would impact a minor’s life in a negative way. If a minor is tried through a juvenile court, they have a greater chance of rehabilitation.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Teenage Brains

776 Words | 4 Pages

This shows that teenagers may act out on their fears and anxieties, which can lead to serious crimes, rather than being reasonable. Teenagers shouldn’t have to be punished as adults for one stupid decision that their underdeveloped brain

Read More

More about Brittany Navarra's Case Summary

Open Document