ipl-logo

Case Study: Spinelli V. United States

519 Words3 Pages

The following essay will outline the variances of two case” Illinois v. Gates and Spinelli v. United States. It will discuss the Supreme Court requires to establish probable cause for a warrant. Illinois v. Gates In Illinois v. Gates, law enforcement received a letter (that was anonymous) stating that the Gate family was in the drug transporting business, and operating between the states of Florida and Illinois. Upon investigation, law enforcement discovered that Gates had made the purchase of an Air Line ticket, traveling to Florida. With surveillance, they observe that he meet with a person, and proceed to return to Illinois, via driving. Based on the anonymous tip and the observation of said events, matching in similarity to the information provided in the letter, the law enforcement obtained a search warrant. Duing the exection of the search warrant, a massive durg load was discovered in Gates car, he was subsequently arrested. The decision of the Trial Courts, made judgement that there was no probable cause, thus invalidating the search warrant, leaving the drugs found, inadmissible to the case. Gates counsel argued that law enforcement lack of sufficient probable cause for a warrant was a fourth amendment violation. The decision of the Trail Courts, was upheld by The Appellate Court. The court used the example of Spinelli v. United States, …show more content…

This decision was upheld by The Illinois Supreme Court affirmed. However, later the United Stated Supreme Court made a reversal and ruled that probable cause existed. This reversal lead to The US Supreme Court also making a reversal in their decision in the Spinelli case; it was determined that the” totality of the circumstances” should be considered when testing if probable cause,

Show More
Related

Case Study: Mcculloch Vs. Maryland

643 Words | 3 Pages

McCulloch vs Maryland Summary In case of McCulloch vs Maryland is a landmark case that questioned the extent of federal government 's separation of power from state government. A problem arose when the Second Bank of America was established. With the War of 1812 and it’s financial suffering in the past, the government sought to create a bank with the purpose of securing the ability to fund future wars and financial endeavors. Many states were disappointed with this new organization, one of them being Maryland.

Read More

Case Study: Welge V. Planter's Lifesavers

517 Words | 3 Pages

Read Case 10-2, Welge v. Planters Lifesavers, on page 243. What theory of liability did Justice Posner use in finding the defendant liable? Judge Posner used the strict product liability theory in finding the defendant liable (Herron, 2011). Under the strict product liability theory, K-Mart (seller) would be held liable for defects in their products even if those defects were not introduced by them; also for failing to discover them during production (Herron, 2011).

Read More

Riley Vs California Case Study

863 Words | 4 Pages

These function and information does not have enough effect to the law enforcement interests. In Riley’s case, the California Court of Appeal accept the case. The court maintained the original court’s decision. The reason is in the conduction that phone related to arrestee's person immediately, the Fourth Amendment permits a warrantless search of phone data incident to an arrest.

Read More

Cameron Awbrey's Argument Essay

703 Words | 3 Pages

United States, an officer arrested and searched the accused because the officer believed that there was a warrant out for the accused. The admissibility of the evidence was at question. However, the court ruled that evidence found is admissible if the officer is acting out in good faith on an erroneous warrant. In our case Officer West was acting in good faith because he was acting on an erroneous warrant. It will be argued that Officer West was negligent toward the facts that were on the warrant, the description of the weight.

Read More

Exclusionary Rule In The Weeks V. United States Case

475 Words | 2 Pages

The Weeks v United States case was the Supreme Court basis in determining to incorporate the Fourth Amendment into the Fourteenth Amendment due process clause and apply the exclusionary rule in state cases. In this essay, I am going to discuss the reason why the Supreme Court determine that the exclusionary rule should apply to the state police activity. Prior to the case of Weeks v United States, the state police activity “were not limited in their conduct by the Fourth Amendment” (Ingram p.81) and the exclusionary rule of Fourth Amendments illegal search and seizure only applies to federal law enforcement officers. Basically, it means that state law enforcement officials can illegally search and seized criminal activity evidence and court don’t prohibit the use of illegally obtained evidence in the trial court.

Read More

Supreme Court Cases: The Mapp V. Ohio Case

621 Words | 3 Pages

Police believed that Mapp was harboring a suspected bomber, and demanded entry. No suspect was found, but police discovered a trunk of obscene pictures in Mapp 's basement. Mapp was arrested for possessing the pictures, and was convicted in an Ohio court where she lost the case in fighting her for first amendment rights. Then, Mapp argued that her Fourth Amendment rights had been violated by the search of the officers and got her case taken to the U.S. Supreme Court where she won. At the time of the case, unlawfully seized evidence was banned from federal courts but not state courts, meaning that the evidence found in Mapp’s home was used against her in the Ohio court, but not the U.S. Supreme Court.

Read More

No Probable Cause To Arrest Hayes Essay

551 Words | 3 Pages

This is a criminal case, in which the Supreme Court ruled that there was no probable cause to arrest Hayes. Hayes did not give consent to be taken to the police station and be detained plus fingerprint. Therefore, Hayed Fourth Amendment rights were violated and the conviction was overturned. Fact of the case: In the 1980’s there was a series of rape and burglary that happened in Punta Gorda Florida.

Read More

Case Study: Moncrieffe V. Holder

1033 Words | 5 Pages

In 2013, the Supreme Court case Moncrieffe v. Holder refuses a Board of Immigration Appeals to removal from the United States of a lawful permanent resident based on a long term criminal conviction related to sole possession of small amounts of marijuana. The case finally made it all the way to the Supreme Court, which is considered a rather technical question of the interpretation of the U.S Immigration laws. Local police departments have long been accused of profiling Hispanic, African-Americans, and other minorities of race in law enforcement activities, including run of the mill traffic stop. Critics fear that immigration enforcement by state and local authorities will lead to increase of racism. Many Americans have shown concerns with the implementation of racist discrimination of the U.S immigration laws by state police agencies and local authorities.

Read More

A Brief Note On DLK Vs United States

752 Words | 4 Pages

Noah Pardi Mrs. Hansen Block 6 3/1/23 DLK vs. United States: Did the Government go too far? “Relying on the government to protect your privacy is like asking a peeping tom to install your window blinds,” said John Perry Barlow. To start, The Fourth Amendment is the amendment which protects the people and their property from unreasonable searches and seizures by the government. In the DLK vs United States case, DLK was growing marijuana plants in his house. The police suspected him of growing the marijuana plants.

Read More

Dk Dbq Analysis

742 Words | 3 Pages

According to Justice Scalia, the device was ‘not in general public use.’ (Doc F), Along with that, the areas the government scanned were not all in public view, as the inside of DLK’s home was generally inaccessible to the public. There are only four times when a search can be performed without a warrant: hot pursuit, public safety, danger of loss to evidence, and permission of the suspect. While some may argue that DLK could have packed up the marijuana or destroyed it, the chances of that are very slim, and it most likely could not be done in the time it takes the government to get a

Read More

Exclusionary Rule Pros And Cons

554 Words | 3 Pages

In an effort to enforce the legality of law enforcement conduct, the judiciary established the exclusionary rule to bar illegally or unconstitutionally obtained evidence in a criminal trial (Jurkowski, 2017). The rule's primary purpose is to deter law enforcement from violating laws and infringing on the constitutional rights of citizens. There are, however, several exceptions to this rule. One such exception is that of good faith, in which the officer involved did not knowingly or deliberately violate a law or an individual's constitutional right; this is often the result of an honest mistake or a clerical error. In the 1984 case United States v. Leon, the authorities executed a search warrant which was later found to be invalid due to insufficient

Read More

Attenuation Case Study

1840 Words | 8 Pages

In December 2006, local law enforcement received an anonymous phone call on a drug tip line regarding suspicious activity at a home in Salt Lake City. As a result, police officer David Fackrell surveilled the residence for approximately one week, witnessing several noticeably short visits conducive to drug activity. Officer Fackrell observed respondent Edward Strieff exit the home, followed him to a local convenience store, and stopped the man without articulable reasonable suspicion, a requirement of the Fourth Amendment. During this unlawful investigatory stop, Officer Fackrell requested that Strieff provide identification. Upon Strieff’s compliance, Officer Fackrell ran a warrants check and discovered that Strieff had an outstanding warrant

Read More

Essay On Exclusionary Rule

566 Words | 3 Pages

vs. Toscanino; the issue was the fact of him being kidnapped from a foreign country and the federal court acceptances of jurisdiction and that he was illegally kidnapped by force, interrogation and tortured. Toscanino did not question the evidence against him just the fact of how he was brought to the United States for trial, therefore, the government agents did not go through the lawful channels (Hall, D. 2105). The district court heavily relied on two court rulings; Ker v. Illinois, 119 U.S. 436, 7 S.Ct. 225, 229, 30 L.Ed. 421 (1888) and Frisbie v. Collins, 342 U.S. 519, 72 S.Ct. 509, 96 L.Ed.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On The Fourth Amendment

427 Words | 2 Pages

Back in 1975, there was a major case called, Payton V. New York. Theodore Payton was suspected of murdering a gas station manager, they found evidence within his home that connected him with the crime. What caused the problem was the fact New York had a law that allowed unwarranted searches if the person was a suspect. Based off the oral argument presented by Oyez, the police said it didn't count as the evidence because it was in public view when entering the home. It had to be appealed before it was determined as unconstitutional.

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Fourth Amendment

785 Words | 4 Pages

(How the) Without the rule non guilty parties convicted could be freed with reliable evidence. With having to have search warrants so that the evidence collected is considered “legal” only wastes

Read More

More about Case Study: Spinelli V. United States

Open Document