ipl-logo

Catcher In The Rye And Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

771 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Lord of the flies compare and contrast essay

Holden from the book “the Catcher in the Rye” and Ralph from “Lord of the Flies” have a lot of differences. Many of these dissimilar matters have to do with the fact that they are dealing with two completely unalike circumstances in their lives at the time. Some of the main things that make Holden and Ralph so mismatched are that Ralph takes a huge responsibility meanwhile Holden does not, they both are trying to survive, but two varying reasons, and about their futures. Since Ralph ends up being stuck on an island with a bunch of boys and no adults, he decides to take a big responsibility of becoming the leader. ““All right. Who wants Jack for chief?” With dreary obedience the choir raised their hands “Who wants me?”Every hand outside the choir except Piggy’s was raised… Ralph counted “I’m chief then.”” this quote from the book “Lord of the Flies” conveys that Ralph was voted for chief. On the other hand, Holden does not want anything that has to do with responsibility like actually trying to work hard in school. ““ We studied the Egyptians from November 4th to December 2nd,” he said “You chose to write about them for the optional essay question. Would you care to hear what you had to say?”... I had to sit …show more content…

Ralph is anxious for everyone on the island to get rescued. ““I’m chief,” said Ralph,” because you chose me. And we were going to keep the fire going. Now you run after food…”” this makes known that Ralph is attempting to get the others to visualize that he is still chief and he had said to keep the fire going so they could be saved. Nevertheless, holden does not even truly care for his future and basically is throwing it all away. “Oh, I have a few qualms, all right. Sure. . . but not too many. Not yet, anyway. I guess it hasn't really hit me yet. It takes things a while to hit me. All I'm doing right now is thinking about going home Wednesday. I'm a moron.”... “Do you

Show More
Related
1120 Words | 5 Pages

In America, we grow up in a society that grooms us to become a successful and happy adult. A society in which people are able to say and do what they want. This freedom that comes with growing up can be too much to handle. As we grow up we start to realize the flaws in our society and the flaws within ourselves. This pressure to remain happy can have various effects.

Read More
289 Words | 2 Pages

Although most of the time, Holden demonstrates his rebellious side, he actually still has fragile side. “What I was really hanging around for, I was trying to feel some kind of good-by”(7). “Good-by” is a word can brings a sense of sadness. Holden’s thoughts about “good-by” demonstrate he is a fragile boy who is like a piece of glass, easy to be broken. This shows that Holden is a person who has desire to love and care from others.

Read More
1471 Words | 6 Pages

While this novel does have profanity and sexual references, it still deserves to be taught in high school because Holden shows how having a negative attitude towards life does not get a person far. In the beginning of the novel Holden tells the reader that "[Pencey] kick[s] [him] out [of their school]" (6) because he "was [failing] four subjects and not applying [himself]" (6). However, he does not just notify the reader, he notifies them in a way of forgetting to mention that he is no longer going to be attending Pencey. Holden passes this off as some minor detail when in reality it is not just a minor detail. Later on, Holden reveals to the reader that this is not the first school where he has gotten expelled.

Read More
1025 Words | 5 Pages

Holden has the choice to either act like an adult or play like a child when he comes across a problem. But not surprisingly, he can’t choose which path to follow, so he stays stuck in the middle. This middle grey area of transitioning from childhood to adulthood for Holden is what is causing his problems and what is making his choices and decisions a lot harder. Holden 's past experiences have taken a toll on him and are starting to cause present issues for him. Holden was only thirteen when his younger brother passed away and it hit him hard.

Read More
652 Words | 3 Pages

Comparison essay There are a lot of similarity and deference's between The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger and Dead Poet's Society by Peter Weir. One of the most important is taking risks and pressuring the person, both the novel and the movie showed that taking risks and putting pressure on the people is bad because it affect both of the protagonist in a negative way. Taking risks and putting pressure on the both protagonist will affect their future, caring about education and they were reckless about their lifes Taking risks is bad and can affect the people in a negative way. In this case taking risks is effecting their future.

Read More
504 Words | 3 Pages

‘I’m Chief, I was chosen.’” (91) Again the order is threatened by Jack’s lust for power. Ralph, the chief, symbolizes the peace and stability of the island and Jack represents chaos and anarchy. Representing these qualities, he cannot be silenced for much longer.

Read More
656 Words | 3 Pages

Although others may say that Holden was successful on his journey, saying that he grew up he. Holden showed lots of immaturity throughout the novel and was the biggest phony of all.. Holden’s attitude throughout the novel was very immature and made constant poor decisions. While he was still at Pencey he put in no effort and had the attitude that nothing mattered. As he moves on from Pencey and goes to New York, he shows no care for anything as he blows lots of his money and doesn’t even take care of himself. He doesn’t clean himself up or get any sleep because of his attitude towards life.

Read More
1108 Words | 5 Pages

Ray Bradbury and William Golding have very similar themes in their books. All the way from human interaction and social conditioning. Lord of the Flies consists of a story due to the lack of social conditioning and Fahrenheit 451 portrays what it's like after too much too powerful social conditioning. Connecting the overlapping ideas of social conditioning, knowledge, identity, and truth in these two novels leads to a better understanding of human behavior.

Read More
111 Words | 1 Pages

Throughout the novel, Holden has a difficult teenage life, he is not responsible and can not face consequences that follow his irresponsibility. Holden can not let go of his childhood, and he has a tough time because he has to behave like an adult, now that he is 16. Holden is obsessed with his dead brother Allie, and his younger sister Phoebe because they are better than he is. Throughout the novel, Holden had many opportunities to get advice from the others that want to help. He refuses to go home and tell his parents he got kicked out of another school because he does not want to face the

Read More
1040 Words | 5 Pages

Often in literature, comparing stories will lead to revelations about human nature. Lord of the Flies and The Hunger Games both share a motif of being trapped and take human nature to another level. Lord of the Flies and The Hunger Games prove that working together and looking out for each other will give you a greater shot at victory. One very significant similarity is that in both books the characters are trapped on an island and fighting for their safety and survival. In Lord of the Flies, school boys, Ralph, Roger, Simeon, Piggy, Jack and along with other kids are trapped on an island and have to fight for survival, but, after a while of being on the island the civilization starts to die and so do the boys from violence and lack of communication.

Read More
1278 Words | 6 Pages

Golding suggests that Ralph represents leadership and democracy on the island. In Lord of the Flies, Ralph was elected chief because “there was his size, and attractive appearance” (22). Ralph represents leadership, and a properly civilized young man. He demonstrates common sense, and wants to do everything he can do to keep the island civilized, and not turn to savagery, until Jack rivals his command. Ralph seems genuinely interested in the welfare of the community on the island.

Read More
814 Words | 4 Pages

In The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger, the protagonist, Holden Caulfield is a rebellious boy similar to Igby in the movie Igby Goes down directed by Burr Steers. Both of these characters are very similar yet different in many ways. They both share the traits of phoniness and dysfunctionality while creating dishonest relationships by using sex to make them feel less alone. Applying oneself is to try to assimilate into society to become a functioning member. Though both characters are similar in many ways, I believe Holden will successfully become a functioning part of society and accept the reality.

Read More
779 Words | 4 Pages

Furthermore, Holden starts to hate all the adults or loses faith in them, calls them phony. Holden has a second thought of becoming an adult he loses hope in his future and it seems to him nothing in the world matters to him anymore. We can see that throughout the book. He smokes, gets drunk, and does daring acts like getting a prostitute in his room. He also tries to escape all this guilt and grief by wasting time with unnecessary people he calls phony.

Read More
837 Words | 4 Pages

Holden struggles with growing up and facing reality. There are many examples of Holden’s immaturity that are displayed in many forms such as facing responsibilities, his speech, his actions, and etc. Holden’s outlook on adult life is that it is superficial and brimming with phonies, but childhood was all about looking pleasing and innocent. He wants everything to stay the same and for time to stop. As Holden progresses in age, he will discover more about becoming mature in the

Read More
1433 Words | 6 Pages

Usually considered a controversial novel The Catcher in the Rye by J.D. Salinger can often express the feelings of being an outcast and the desire to find a meaning in the world. Holden Caulfield, the protagonist of the novel, though often complains of the phoniness of the world around him, has a way of creating a deeper meaning within the readers. While the truth may be that Salinger purposely set the story in such a way that the readers will be able to connect with Holden, not often do readers find it easy to do so. While Holden believes that everything around him are wicked and phony, there is part of him trying to protect the innocence of those not corrupted by such phoniness. Although Holden wants to protect and save the innocence of children, can he really do so if cannot protect himself and trust those around him.

Read More

More about Catcher In The Rye And Lord Of The Flies Comparison Essay

Related Topics

Open Document