ipl-logo

Causing Unrest In Shirley Jackson's The Lottery

596 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The lottery shirley jackson plot summary

What is causing increasing unrest in Puerto Rico? Puerto Rico is angry with the United States government because they are being overlooked in Congress. Residents of Puerto Rico are denied basic rights and aid due to the victimization and neglect of the United States government. Persecution is felt by all residents of Puerto Rico because of the mistreatment that they receive. Democracy does not stretch to Puerto Rico, as they have little to no representation in Congress. The process of becoming a state is long and difficult, making Puerto Rico's issues very challenging to change. Using the short story "The Lottery" by Shirley Jackson, Puerto Rico's challenges and unrest can be compared and more easily described. First, the residents in Puerto Rico are neglected and persecuted by the United States government. According to "US Policy toward its Territories: A Complex and Perhaps Intractable Problem", Puerto Ricans are considered full United States citizens, but they are denied the ability to vote in elections (Colón-Morera, 2017). Also, the federal government will not aid Puerto Rico in a crisis because it is not an independent nation (Colón-Morera, 2017). In "The Lottery", the individual being stoned holds her hands out desperately …show more content…

Even the locally elected leaders of Puerto Rico are subordinate to the greater federal courts (Colón-Morera, 2017). Conversely, one may argue that Puerto Rico is not a state and should not be able to participate in Congress. In "The Lottery", the villagers are in a similar position as Puerto Ricans because much like Puerto Rico does not have representation to defend themselves, the villagers do not have a system in place to cease the lottery (Jackson, 1948). Democracy is violated because all United State citizens should be able to voice their opinions, but Puerto Rico is unable to do

Show More
Related
594 Words | 3 Pages

Many Cubans defied this policy and control strategy because they saw it as a violation of their independence, but they felt obligated for cooperation because they relied on American sugar markets. The Spanish-American War led to Puerto Rico becoming a U.S. territory. The strategy towards Puerto Rico was different from Cuba's in that it implemented initiatives aimed at "Americanizing" Puerto Rico, such as encouraging the study of American culture and teaching English in education systems. As a result of Puerto Rico's status as an unincorporated territory of the United States, residents were still considered citizens of the country but lacked the same political freedoms as those residing on the US mainland.

Read More
548 Words | 3 Pages

This is hurting the island’s economy. For example, from 1993 to 2010 there was a $17 billion loss to the island’s economy because of the Jones Act. When hurricane Maria hit Puerto Rico, The Jones act still was in place. So, every boat that was made somewhere else, or was shipping from somewhere else to help had to

Read More
439 Words | 2 Pages

Puerto Rico received U.S. citizenship in 1917 and finally became a commonwealth in 1952. Puerto Rico is fully supported by the U.S. but the people do not have the same rights as the people from America, such as the voting right but they are allowed to fight in the U.S. military. Some of the pros of Puerto Rico becoming a U.S. state are that it would improve the quality of life for Puerto Ricans, most of them live under the

Read More
1146 Words | 5 Pages

“The Lottery” by Shirley Jackson, is a short story expressed through the theme of apathy, when the community feels no emotion for anyone, that a ritual is more important than a human being, mob mentality, and hypocrisy which is prevalent within the townspeople. It may help learning more about Shirley Jackson to better understand why she wrote such a horrific story like, “The Lottery.” Shirley Jackson moved into a small town, Bennington, Vermont, where she wasn’t accepted within her town which shows she was thinking how cruel people can be. Not being accepted is not the same as being stoned or killed, but it has the capacity for cruelty. Through this, Shirley Jackson is suggesting that we need to examine ourselves and our actions carefully and live our lives consciously instead of

Read More
682 Words | 3 Pages

Some may reason that by adding this 51st state, the United States may become accountable for Puerto Rico’s financial issues. Even though this may be a good point, the United States is actually more responsible for the territories, which Puerto Rico currently is, than the United States. The U.S. Constitution grants Congress total authority over territories. States are independent nations with rights and powers of their own, as stated in the article (“Puerto Rico Statehood”). This same article also refutes the argument that residents of Puerto Rico would be obligated to pay federal income tax.

Read More
1101 Words | 5 Pages

When the symbol of our nation cannot seem to cover all the nations it needs to it provides a sense of clear understanding that the government could not monitor all the nations at once. Questions about expansion, are still argued in modern society in relation to Puerto Rico and whether it should become the 51st state or remain as it is. Things have not changed as drastically as one may think in the past 100

Read More
896 Words | 4 Pages

Also there is a 13% unemployment rate on the island. Most people in Puerto Rico, speak only spanish with 95% of people speaking spanish. Many things

Read More
1273 Words | 6 Pages

In my opinion, this island has grown from where they started but are not fully ready to become an independent nation. The people may feel “whole” because they have built their culture from all of these different types of people that have taken over their island these past hundreds of years, but they still heavily lean on America’s government. Why would Puerto Rico choose to become independent anyway? People born on the island are automatically born as United States citizens and have all of the rights of a natural born, U.S. citizen. Puerto Rico is ruled by our government, has the same rights as Americans, and even use the U.S. dollar as their currency.

Read More
865 Words | 4 Pages

Puerto Rico’s economy is very poor and the government owes large amounts of debt which the US would have to absorb making the US national debt larger and the overall economy poorer. The US would also have to take control of and try to solve the social issues in Puerto Rico such as its high poverty and crime rates. Finally, the US would have to restructure Puerto Rico’s government and tackle its problem of corruption. Due to these responsibilities, it would not be beneficial for the US to make Puerto Rico a

Read More
653 Words | 3 Pages

For one, even though Cuba had intense difficulties in the past, it 's been able to provide for itself and sustain its own economy. However as for Puerto Rico, it 's recently had a large decline in its economy. Due to the decline, it 's had to rely on the United States in federal aid, and as a consequence Puerto Rico 's “unemployment rate swelled to about 16% compared to that of Cuba, which stands at only 2.4%”. In fact, these unemployment rates have again changed the view of the islands. Puerto Rico is now viewed as an island that 's close to falling apart.

Read More
881 Words | 4 Pages

Conclusion = Summary of important facts reviewed during the main points of the speech • Puerto Rico took a break from Spain in 1898 claiming some independence • United States did not hesitate to step in and kick Spain out • Years later the US and PR were engaged under the Jones Act making. No wedding date has been set. 8.

Read More
538 Words | 3 Pages

Puerto Rico Statehood Did you know that Hawaii and Alaska were both in poverty before they became states? Did you know that now they have poverty rates below the national average? At the moment, Puerto Rico is living in poverty and has been suffering since the drastic 2008 financial crisis. We, as a united people, can help Puerto Rico.

Read More
1008 Words | 5 Pages

Puerto Rico is suffering a major crisis of emigration and this not only affects the economy but the people too, Puerto

Read More
222 Words | 1 Pages

Nevertheless, Puerto Rico was granted some, but not all constitutional rights

Read More
1390 Words | 6 Pages

The Land of the Free… Well, Except Puerto Rico Whenever Americans think of Puerto Rico, they tend to think first of the beautiful Caribbean vacation destination. Whenever Puerto Ricans think of their island, they see the years of mistreatment and hardship that the island has endured. Puerto Rico has been the property of other countries for nearly five hundred years, but that does not give the United States a right to continue to ignore it. Puerto Rico’s status as a United States commonwealth keeps citizens from playing a part in fixing the political issues within the island. Without representation in the United States federal government nor political independence, Puerto Rico is powerless and silent.

Read More

More about Causing Unrest In Shirley Jackson's The Lottery

Related Topics

Open Document