ipl-logo

Summary Of John Searle's Chinese Room Argument

2029 Words9 Pages

Supporters of computationalism and strong artificial intelligence claim that computers are capable of intelligence and other cognitive states if they are programed correctly. Therefore, computers can explain how human cognition performs. I contend that John Searle is correct in his claim that computers are incapable of understanding language and are, therefore, unable to explain human cognition. I begin the essay with Searle’s Chinese room argument, and explain how he uses it to prove that computers cannot understand language as they operate on syntax alone, where syntax is insufficient in producing understanding. Thereafter, I provide a description of the robot reply to the Chinese room argument, which states that a robot with a computer insert and sensory apparatus would be able to achieve understanding, a view which Searle argues is still insufficient. Moreover, I utilise my definitions of understanding and meaning, to explain that computers are incapable of both semantics and syntax. Where understanding regards syntax and meaning regards significance of which both are consciousness-dependent concepts. Lastly, I differentiate sensation from perception, where perception is the ability to interpret sensory information, in order to …show more content…

Thus, the CR proves that computers cannot understand language. Furthermore, my argument supports Searle’s (1980) claim that computers cannot explain human cognition, as they cannot attain knowledge for they are incapable of intelligence. It is impossible for a computer to explain human cognition when it is incapable of performing those very same abilities. Therefore, strong artificial intelligence is

Show More
Related

'Rhetorical Analysis Of Is Google Making USupid?'

989 Words | 4 Pages

Rhetorical Analysis Writer have different way of getting their point across, like in the article “Is Google Making Us Stupid? By Nicholas Carr. He makes an argument that google is a convenient tools and is making us less able to process deep information. He use ethos, pathos, logos and tone to prove his ideas. Carr want the audience to feel a connection to his article.

Read More

Grant And Lee's Argumentative Essay

64 Words | 1 Pages

For more than a month ,Grant and lee had been fighting almost daily. Grant had 1000000 men in his army to pound the confederate army to the ground but Lee 's men would not budge Both armies suffered extraordinary casitas . Grant had lost 60000 men and lee lost about half that.but Grant could afford casualties because he had more men than Lee’s army

Read More

Tex G. Hall's Argument

326 Words | 2 Pages

The author Tex G. Hall is explaining Native American team sports mascots are racist. He is testifying for many other people as well. He makes a very sensible are you and uses the motion and great facts facts. The way his argument is structured is very engaging. He first off thanks many people for bringing this controversy to everyone 's attention.

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

875 Words | 4 Pages

What this means is the things that are being continuously made are changing our critical thinking skills. Thompson central claim is that computers are not as smart as humans, but once you have been using them over a certain amount of time you seem to get better at working them and that’s what really makes you more efficient in using them. The point that I don’t agree with Carr on is “Their thoughts and actions fell scripped, as if they're following the steps of an algorithm (p.328.)” I don’t agree with Carr’s argument here because he’s emphasizing that human thoughts are being scripted and we don’t think about things critically, but not all of our thinking

Read More

Summary Of Is Google Making USupid By Nicholas Carr

428 Words | 2 Pages

Carr describes the way our brains have changed as a consequence of using media. He later reports that when new or improved technology enters our lives, we begin to take on the qualities of those technologies, because it changes our “intellectual technologies”. He also uses the analogy of a clock, presenting the idea that we eat, work, sleep, and rise based on what time of day it is, instead of listening to our own senses. Carr then uses the claim from a 1936 British mathematician named Alan Turing that computing systems are subsuming most of our other intellectual technologies such as our map and our clock, our printing press and our typewriter, our calculator and our telephone, and our radio and our television. Likewise, he explains how the internet assumes what we are thinking and injects its context with hyperlinks, blinking ads, headlines, and other propaganda.

Read More

Summary Of John Searle's Argument 'The Chinese Room'

76 Words | 1 Pages

Let us start with John Searle’s argument, or one could say counter-argument, with what he calls “strong AI.” The most famous of his arguments; “The Chinese Room.” In which you picture yourself as a monolingual English speaker “locked in a room, and given a large batch of Chinese writing “ as well as, “ a second batch of Chinese script” and “a set of rules” in English “for correlating the second batch with the first batch.”

Read More

Similarities Between William Lycan And John Searle

482 Words | 2 Pages

Searle’s beliefs are that strong artificial intelligence do not exist and that computers work off what was programmed into them. Searle defends this view by using the Chinese Room example, proving that computers only give out what they’ve already received. The Chinese Room analogy is a man sitting in a room being given a rulebook and dictionary and must translate Chinese messages and answer them which the man can do just like a computer. But the man was simply just manipulating symbols rather than truly understanding the messages or language in the

Read More

John Searle's Chinese Room Argument

175 Words | 1 Pages

The process artificial intelligence is slower we have initially hoped. Thus, the idea of the ability of conscious thinking in technology is still quite ambiguous. Hitherto, I believe that John Searle’s Chinese Room argument is the most cogent of the idea of intelligent machines. Indeed, the Chinese room argument shows that computers able to receive questions and give out answers properly because of functionalism. Yet, technological output surely way different than genuine minds based on the three mental states: physicalism, dualism, and idealism.

Read More

Fear Of The Unknown In Le Fanu's I, Robot

1177 Words | 5 Pages

The book consists of multiple short stories that center around robots and their interactions with humans. In this particular world, robots are a very recent invention, and humans are still getting used to their existence. The fear of the unknown in this case is the fear of what robots might be able to do and how their further impact on humanity in the future. The stories of Asimov present different aspects of this fear, for instance the fear of robots taking over human jobs, the fear of robots being dysfunctional and causing harm to humans, and also the fear of robots taking over humans, as their intelligence exceeds humans’.

Read More

Political Discourse Analysis Essay

1514 Words | 7 Pages

In doing so, language becomes a tool for constructing meaning to represent knowledge. Hence, human beings can interpret and represent the world for each other and for themselves (Matthiessen and Halliday, 1997. pp. 1-3). The following table (2-1) shows the three lines of meaning in the clause according to Halliday and Matthiessen

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of The Turing Test

1042 Words | 5 Pages

The Turing test has become the most widely accepted test of artificial intelligence and the most influential. There are also considerable arguments that the Turing test is not enough to confirm intelligence. Legg and Hutter (2007) cite Block (1981) and Searle (1980) as arguing that a machine may appear intelligent by using a very large set of

Read More

Sigmund Freud's Theory Of The Freudian Slips

1629 Words | 7 Pages

It is prima facie evidence of linguistic flexibility, proof of the great dexterity of the human mind. (Pincott,

Read More

Aesthetics: A Critical Review Of Galatea

1055 Words | 5 Pages

The “evolution of human-created technology” (2005, p. 7), according to Ray Kurzweil, will bring forth a posthuman society in which elaborate thinking machines will “enable our human-machine civilization to transcend the human brain’s limitations” (2005, p. 20). Indeed, many scholars agree that Galatea 2.2 highlights “fascinations and anxieties about the possibilities of computer technology to construct a human consciousness or mind” (Worthington, 2009, p. 111). While this may be the generic topic of Galatea 2.2, many scholars ignore not only the novel’s implicit emphasis on the disparity between artificial intelligence and human consciousness but also its underlying attention to the nature of (human) cognition. Especially, Katherine Hayles points out that Galatea 2.2 “hover[s] between two notational systems, referencing both the human and the posthuman” and suggests that “an unbridgeable gap separates the human woman from the posthuman computer” (1999, p. 263).

Read More

William James's Theory Of Perception

1689 Words | 7 Pages

This essay will discuss the statement by William James, “-whilst part of what we perceive comes through our senses but another part (and it may be the larger part) always comes out of our head.” (James, 1890). This excerpt relates to the topic of perception, which can be defined as the acquisition and processing of sensory information to see, hear, taste, or feel objects, whilst guiding an organism’s actions with respect to those objects (Sekuler & Blake, 2002). Every theory of perception begins with the question of what features of the surrounding environment can be apprehended through direct pickup (Runeson et al. 2000). Is it only vague elemental cues that are available, and development and expansion through cognitive processes is required

Read More

Statement Of Purpose For Artificial Intelligence

896 Words | 4 Pages

The attraction of artificial intelligence for me lies in its breadth of applicability, both as a method of problem solving in itself and in a symbiotic integration with other areas of computer science. A broad spectrum of applications exist within the artificial intelligence field, ranging from intelligent non-player controlled characters in computer game software to a ubiquitous computing solution that intelligently reacts to a variety of users. This diversity is one of the main reasons that I feel compelled to pursue artificial intelligence further. While I have striven to develop my understanding of artificial intelligence during my undergraduate education, the choreographed requirements of a bachelor's degree have restricted my research to only a minute sample of artificial intelligence’s applications. During my exposure to the field, I have often been unsatisfied with the level of interaction artificial intelligence displays in response to prompts of varying complexity.

Read More

More about Summary Of John Searle's Chinese Room Argument

Related Topics

Open Document