ipl-logo

Christine Stevens Golden Rule Analysis

576 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Golden rule philosophy ethics

Throughout the ages, the Golden Rule has always remained: “Do unto others as you would have them do unto you.” Jesus spoke these words in Matthew 7:12, saying that this brief statement summed up the law. Usually interpreted as a mandate pertaining solely to human beings, Christine Stevens, an animal rights activist, took the Golden Rule a step further. She stated that the law not only applied to how people treat other humans, but to how people treat animals as well. Christine Stevens’ conclusion is flawed and inaccurate. She erroneously concluded that the biblical concept was meant to encompass all animal rights and humans’ treatment of them.
One reason why Christine Stevens’ conclusion is faulty is because, if the Golden Rule did apply to animals, it would prohibit us from clothing ourselves with their skins, using them as a source of food, and using them as a source of profit. It would be a sin to use a human being for any of these things, but it is the norm for animals. In the …show more content…

As stated before, God cares about the human race, more so than he does animals. He placed the animals on the earth to meet the needs of mankind, and if the Golden Rule applied to animals’ rights, then mankind wouldn’t be able to use them to meet their needs. This doesn’t mean that animals should be abused, though. Animals are still one of God’s beautiful creations, and he gave us dominion over the animals to protect them and to care for them. In the end, though, God still values human beings more than he does animals.
Christine Stevens’ conclusion is flawed and inaccurate. The Golden Rule does not apply to animal rights and humans’ treatment of them. The Golden Rule is a law that Jesus put in place because he cares for the human race. Although God also loves his other creations, humans are special. The Golden Rule only pertains to how people treat each

Show More
Related

A Rhetorical Analysis Of Factory Farming By Matthew Scully

1104 Words | 5 Pages

To begin, when talking about animals it can be a very sensitive subject mainly because the way animals are treated on farms, and how no one feels the need to question these actions. This is because many people feel this issue doesn’t concern them. In this essay Matthew Scully discusses the issue on how animals are treated and how they should be given more respect, and attention. Matthew Scully argues that animals in these factory farms are wrongfully treated, he uses biblical references and addresses the morals of humans to get conservatives to act on this matter.

Read More

Comparing The Night Thoreau Spent In Jail, By Ralph Waldo Emerson

480 Words | 2 Pages

The third maxim by Ralph Waldo Emerson is "Nothing is at last sacred but the integrity of your own mind. " Emerson is saying that one's open honesty is importantly treasured. One's honesty is more important than following other people's beliefs. The maxim embodies the theme that people respect others' honesty more than emotionless obedience to conventions set forth by someone else.

Read More

Animal Farm Why Does Napoleon Stay In Charge

690 Words | 3 Pages

This, he said, contained the essential principle of Animalism.”. Throughout the book the commandments are changed to fit the pigs lifestyle. Animalism was supposed to be used to keep one animal from having more, or less power than the others. One of the commandments states that “5. No animal shall drink alcohol.”.

Read More

Summary Of A Change Of Hearts On Animals

270 Words | 2 Pages

A life is a life, i think that every living organisms on this planet that are breathing are important and we all should treat others with respect and with love. Animals are like us, not physically, but they can feel pain and lonely when we mistreated them in some ways. I believe humanity has the ethical obligation to change their behavior towards animals. In the article, “ A change of Hearts on Animals” written by Jeremy Rifkin stated some of his key points that humans should focuses more on animals’ feelings.

Read More

Behaving Like Animals In Brad Watson's Water Dog God

1310 Words | 6 Pages

Humans like to think of themselves as moral, upstanding beings who cognitively and rationally function, but often they are accused of “behaving like animals.” This rationale is a social construct that encompasses the behaviors of people found as unacceptable and shameful to the average population. Although it appears demeaning to compare animals in such a critical manner, there is a clear separation between man and animal that places humans much higher on the scale of civilization. As illustrated in “Water Dog God” by Brad Watson, the lack of civilized presence among people damages the ability for one to understand proper conduct, leading to animal-like behaviors such as the absence of relationship boundaries, limited emotional availability, and no concept of hygiene or social norms. Further, the short story emphasizes the affects of various boundaries that humans cross easily and often due to their distorted nature.

Read More

Violence In Tom Franklin's 'Poachers'

1679 Words | 7 Pages

 It seems that many people do not comprehend that animals should be treated fair. In Poachers, Tom Franklin mentions certain act of truetl committed to animals.  These creatures were exposed to category of  mistreatment by certain citizens in the village.  The Gates brothers usually practice acts of violence to animal.  They hunt animals and later kill them.

Read More

Machan's Arguments Against Animal Rights

1408 Words | 6 Pages

One topic that many scholars are debating right now is the topic of animal rights. The questions are, on what basis are rights given, and do animals possess rights? Two prominent scholars, Tom Regan and Tibor Machan, each give compelling arguments about animal rights, Regan for them and Machan against them. Machan makes the sharp statement, “Animals have no rights need no liberation” (Machan, p. 480). This statement was made in direct opposition to Regan who says, “Reason compels us to recognize the equal inherent value of these animals and, with this, their equal right to be treated with respect” (Regan, p. 477).

Read More

Ethical Decisions In Kurt Wise's Devotional Biology

616 Words | 3 Pages

We are told to look out for the best in creation and understand how to protect them. In fact, Scripture tells us that we are to have dominion over the fish of the sea, birds of the air, and over every living thing that moves (Genesis 1:28). Furthermore, when God created man we see that He had the intention of man to have dominion over every “creeping thing” (Genesis 1:26). We know that we are obviously called to preserve animals and their life’s.

Read More

The Moral Sense Of Living In Mark Twain's The Mysterious Stranger

1146 Words | 5 Pages

Satan says that animals are off the hook because they no longer “tainted with the disease called the moral sense” (Twain 80a). Therefore, animals rarely wrong other animals because they lack

Read More

The Hunger Games: Collective Identity

848 Words | 4 Pages

But in the end, the leaders overthrow the seven commandments by themselves and dancing with human. In fact, the seven commandments is not very equal. “Animal Farm presents itself as a simple fable, but it raises profound questions about one of our most cherished political concepts, namely, equality. (Dwan

Read More

Pros And Cons Of The Golden Rule

728 Words | 3 Pages

There are different internal compasses that people utilize to point them towards the path of morality. The most common that probably still remains is The Golden Rule also referred to as the ethic of reciprocity. The Golden Rule stands for: “Treat others the way you want to be treated”. Some consider the Golden Rule to be the most universal of moral principles. Yet it does not always send a positive message.

Read More

Literary Analysis On Mercy

1068 Words | 5 Pages

We are also responsible to “fill the earth and subdue it.” (BibleGateway) Because we have been given dominion over all animals, we also have the responsibility to take care of them. If animals are not properly taken care of then we will not be able to fulfill the second part of God's command; “fill the earth and subdue it.” Animals provide vital nutrients and protein to us.

Read More

Kant's Theory As A Deontologist

1387 Words | 6 Pages

What sets animals aside from humans is that animals are not capable of intellectual capacity such that they lack the ability of intrinsic value and moral autonomy. Humans have the right to treat animals as objects as humans hold the position of a higher hierarchy in all organisms. Humans can treat animals as objects so long as they are not treated as a means of a tool. If a human being were to inflict unnecessary harm to an animal, it would reflect on the human’s character and create the ability for the human to inflict harm on its species. [Humans have a duty and responsibility to care for others whether it being, other people, non-humans, the environment or future generations.

Read More

Power And Corruption In Animal Farm

449 Words | 2 Pages

In Animal Farm, we see the sinister theme of abuse of power and corruption displayed throughout the story. The epitome on how the pigs abused the power was how they manipulated the 7 commandments to their own benefit. The 7 commandments were inscribed on the wall and they would form “an unalterable law by which all animals on Animal Farm must live for ever after”. Ironically, the 7 commandments were changed one by one to suit the benefit of the pigs. For example, when the pigs discovered a case of whiskey and got drunk, they got attracted to the taste of alcohol.

Read More

Wrong To Eat Animals

1800 Words | 8 Pages

They do not breed certain kinds of animals for their food. However, humans breed a certain kind of animals just for food and these animals are always enclosed in a small place. These actions deprive animals’ right and violate the

Read More

More about Christine Stevens Golden Rule Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document